The Penguin 2024 - Colin Ferrell in a fat suit.

I'd probably give it around a 7 overall but it's nowhere close to the truly great series - The Sopranos, Breaking Bad, The Wire
A series like this would always be weighed down by its to adherence to its comic book roots; a lunatic in a bat costume running around on rooftops and driving a batmobile exists in this universe.

Penguin at this point is irredeemable to me and I will feel it distasteful to see him triumph
That's an odd way of watching a series like this. I mean, how do you find watching The Sopranos?

I'm okay with the Penguin being a self-serving sociopathic character but killing Vic made no sense, why kill a useful henchman?
 
That's an odd way of watching a series like this. I mean, how do you find watching The Sopranos?
I've never seen it. Generally I watch very little in the way of TV shows. I tried Penguin on the strength of Reeve's Batman movie which I liked the tone and style of a lot; and stuck with it a bit mainly on the strength of Colin Farrell's performance and Sofia Falcone. But she became significantly less interesting as a character as time went on and whilst Penguin started off as a bad person you could like due to redeeming characteristics and background, the show ended up with him being someone I simply found unpleasant.

I'm guessing your Sopranos show is an example of a show with villainous viewpoint characters but are they as repugnant as Penguin? E.g. Mother-son incest vibes and murdering his kid brother out of jealousy of his mother's affection as a young child. If so, there's a good chance I wouldn't enjoy Sopranos, either. You can certainly do "bad" view point characters but typically you need to do that in one of three ways:
  • Tragedy: The villain through some fatal flaw or fate was doomed to their role. Be that Macbeth, Arcane's Silko or (ironically) Oedipus.
  • Social Bad rather than Personal Bad. E.g. your bad person is not bad due to how they treat those close to them or being ignoble, but because they're on the "wrong" side. So you can do some hagiography of some Rommel like figure or some WWII Japanese war hero and make the audience admire him for his determination, loyalty or skill, even if he's a "villain" in the wider sense.
  • Sheer fucking charisma and bravado. The Don Giovanni approach - he might be reprehensible and he might get dragged down to Hell by his victim's ghost. But he'll do it refusing to repent all the way. Milton's Satan with his "What though the field be lost?" attitude probably counts.
Penguin in this show never had the former. He had the latter a little for a while with his poor neighbourhood background and seeing of hoodlums as neighbourhood heroes. And he had the third one thanks to Farrell's performance. But one was proven to be a lie by later episodes and the other just couldn't stand up in the face of just how unpleasant his deeds actually made him to a viewer.

Ultimately, the show was flawed, despite good casting and some nice touches.
 
Seen a fair few superhero movie spinoff-series and they always suffer from the same shit: Instead of running on the side to the primary movie or the main character's continued behavior, at best you get a cameo the last 2 minutes of the season finale. We didn't even fucking get that: We got a bat symbol.

Likewise they all want to be Rogue One; making a contained story that doesn't affect anything. A whole season just to be like "- and that's how penguin became a mob boss" or "now batman is the dark knight". It was 100% obvious that Victor was gonna die, else he'd have to grow into either an established goon of Penguin's or be written into new material, leading to this whole ordeal of having to carry over characters. These mini-series try to tell a story that doesn't push anything that wouldn't just be fine being untold. "The whole fucking city blew up, leaving a vacuum and penguin rose from goon status". Done.
 
Penguin in this show never had the former
They toyed with making him somewhat tragedic. They just didn't commit to it, which was a missed opportunity. He is an ugly crippled from a poor neighborhood in the most corrupt city in the world. It would have really helped to make him more understandable. But if they did that, they would have to actually try in their goal to make him hateable, which they did not want to do. Sofia = good, Oz = evil.
Seen a fair few superhero movie spinoff-series and they always suffer from the same shit: Instead of running on the side to the primary movie or the main character's continued behavior, at best you get a cameo the last 2 minutes of the season finale. We didn't even fucking get that: We got a bat symbol.
The show would've really benefited from Batman easter eggs, and perhaps even an interrogation by him. There was probably a dogma in the writing room "this is a Sofia Fal- sorry, Penguin show. Do not mention Batman at all!" that really harmed the worldbuilding of Gotham. I understand Pattinson is expensive but you really can't get Oz to say "and make sure that Bat-Freak doesn't fuck this up!"?
 
They toyed with making him somewhat tragedic. They just didn't commit to it, which was a missed opportunity. He is an ugly crippled from a poor neighborhood in the most corrupt city in the world. It would have really helped to make him more understandable. But if they did that, they would have to actually try in their goal to make him hateable, which they did not want to do. Sofia = good, Oz = evil.
You know it never even crossed my mind that his disability would be a reason for him being a tragic figure. People can read into that not occurring to me how they like. But it wasn't until you brought up his foot that the connection with his relationship with his mother occurred to me. A certain Tom Lehrer song begins to play in my mind...

Honestly, if that was deliberate it makes me like the show even less.

I really feel that a lot of current day writing doesn't really understand myth. They copy it and emulate it but they don't get it. I feel the same about Neil Gaiman whose work I actively despise.

The show would've really benefited from Batman easter eggs, and perhaps even an interrogation by him. There was probably a dogma in the writing room "this is a Sofia Fal- sorry, Penguin show. Do not mention Batman at all!" that really harmed the worldbuilding of Gotham. I understand Pattinson is expensive but you really can't get Oz to say "and make sure that Bat-Freak doesn't fuck this up!"?
100% this. I think we just chalk this up as another piece of comic book media being terrified of being associated with comic books.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Nothingness
I love that it had no Batman in it and I love how batshit and irredeemable penguin is. It really makes him a worthy mainline villain. Only part that pissed me off was a little too much slow burn at times and the stupid shit where she somehow burns down an entire mansion using fucking ever clear. The pozzed argument also falls to shit when the strong woman gets sent back to poo poo pee pee rape dungeon and the nigger gets thrown in the river. It’s impressive considering how shit the Batman movie it’s spun off was
 
The show would've really benefited from Batman easter eggs, and perhaps even an interrogation by him. There was probably a dogma in the writing room "this is a Sofia Fal- sorry, Penguin show. Do not mention Batman at all!" that really harmed the worldbuilding of Gotham. I understand Pattinson is expensive but you really can't get Oz to say "and make sure that Bat-Freak doesn't fuck this up!"?
I watched Agents of SHIELD and they constantly referenced the mainline heroes which was kinda useless since you'd never see them, but at least it kinda made it feel connected. The entire Vulture part of Spiderman in which he makes money cleaning up old war debris would be a cool ass series in comparison. Then they had Mr Niggerman Fury show up for a single seated scene in the end of season 1. Not sure what they did for the next 50 season finales though.

It was just nuts how they literally didn't talk of Batman once. Dude almost killed Ozzie. It was cool building an entire series on the watergates being blown but like.. one mention of "that freak" who did it?
 
  • Agree
Reactions: AFAB
I'm okay with the Penguin being a self-serving sociopathic character but killing Vic made no sense, why kill a useful henchman?
Its mainly because Vic knew too much of Penguin's personal life and he didn't want to risk someone like Batman to interrogate him. That and when I first saw the episode, thought he did it so he wouldn't risk someone else having ambitions to take over.
 
but are they as repugnant as Penguin?
Yes. Probably a lot more so.

Its mainly because Vic knew too much of Penguin's personal life and he didn't want to risk someone like Batman to interrogate him. That and when I first saw the episode, thought he did it so he wouldn't risk someone else having ambitions to take over.
I guess that's a fair enough explanation but watching the final scenes it feels more forced as it tries to punch above it's weight.
 
Its mainly because Vic knew too much of Penguin's personal life and he didn't want to risk someone like Batman to interrogate him. That and when I first saw the episode, thought he did it so he wouldn't risk someone else having ambitions to take over.
I'd also argue it's because he was too attached to Vic at that point. He had just seen his mother used against him and needed to excise another potential soft spot.
 
Killing vic is also the full blown mask off moment for how truly evil he is. Obviously we see the shit with his brothers as a kid, but up until then it’s still somewhat unclear just how irredeemable oz is. It’s effective because it comes right after he gives his speech about giving the people who’ve been passed over their whole lives a chance. It’s a one two punch of making you kind of root for him and then ripping the rug out from under you. Simple but a television series is always gonna be kind of cheap if you look at it too close
 
At episode 5 now. I'm overall enjoying it, but mostly due to Farrell doing a great job as the Penguin. Between the make up and the acting I truly forget it's him and totally buy him as the Penguin. It reminds me of Uncut Gems in a way, him just constantly fucking over everyone just to stay barely above water. Him climbing up the ranks to take over from the traditional mob crime families and becoming the Batman villain we know is fun.
Sofia is also alright, but only if you really just accept it as a comic book show rather than the realistic take it's trying to be. It's what drags it down because a lot of it is comical.
A lot of Sopranos comparisons are made but just compare the way how they constantly have to worry about wiretaps and the like in the Sopranos to how everyone just does whatever in the Penguin. I get that Gotham is a corrupt shithole but police and laws might as well not exist.
The writing is just not great at times. A lot of the plans wouldn't work in a million years, his 9000 IQ plan was seriously to douse that guy in gasoline and hope that somehow no one would notice for example. (Also he must have blasted out his eardrums playing music so loud he didn't notice the gunshots. Obvious Californian noguns writing)

The pozzed shit is so fucking tiresome though. Sofia's story would have been fine without all the retarded patriarchy aspects. The Iranian mobsters with the lung cancer mother. As a sidenote I'm so sick of seeing that woman in everything. She has an unique voice. It was amusing the first 3 times, I don't need to see her in literally everything, It just takes me out of it every time.
The most hilarious part to me is probably Vic and his wholesome POC family, his black hoodrat girlfriend who might as well be a saint. Who's the bad guy in this poor neighborhood? Why it's that filthy white guy pushing drugs!
If you still don't notice this propaganda you must be braindead. I truly don't see how one could not pick up on this overt shit.
 
I think Sofia is hot, I like crazy chicks.
Kinda cute too at times.
1000043332.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chunky Salsa
I tried watching the penguin and I couldn't shake the feeling that I was watching the down syndrome version of the sopranos the entire time. When people call this show "good" they should really qualify "when compared to the average garbage comic book media shits out".

If its aspiring to be a serious crime drama ala breaking bad/the sopranos/the wire, but its just the cargo cult version of those mimicing common tropes without much thought or consideration as to why the tropes exist.

Watching Colin Farrell in a fat suit and his pet nigger run around pretending to be gangsters is amusing for 3 minutes but loses its luster real fast and the show doesn't really have anything to offer you other than an inferior version of already existing tropes.

Also, I jest but it really feels like his pet, he picked some stray off the street that tried to scrap his car and trusts it more than every single other friend he's made in the bussiness over his entire career and they're best friends now? Get the fuck outa here.

This right after he shots someone for disrespecting him? Supposedly he's impulsive enough to shot his boss for making fun of him but someone stable enough to be a trusted lieutenant in the family, ok lmao.

Sorry this isn't a crime drama, this is a marvel show that skinned a crime drama and is wearing its skin over its head playing pretend. Half this shit wouldn't fly in a real script.

Am I supposed to judge this as a marvel show or a crime drama? Yes its an above average marvel show, no its not a good crime drama.

The fact we already know how this shit ends (i.e. it doesn't, because he's a batman villain) also doesn't help.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingNothing
Back