We're "arguing" because people take offense to the fact that I don't think Phil is that bad
In my opinion, all of this compounds to make Phil more tolerable than most cows. It's why people meme the "pigroach is unkillable" shit. He's never done anything irrevocably horrible that would make all negatives that happen in his life something worth celebrating, and his A-Logs do stupid shit like false DMCAs, run autistic illuminatis, and call in to his bankruptcy hearing, which just seems to go beyond what Phil is worth. If he was an actual monster than yeah, his life getting fucked with would be funny, but he's just some financially illiterate boomer streamer who says stupid shit. It makes his "detractors" look worse when they go that far to fuck with him. As a result he's just less laughable than he otherwise would be.
I agree, which is why I've kept an eye on him for years. Tevin probably does it the best because he's good at pointing out the nuances and hypocrisy.