Tim had Sean Fitzgerald, of
The Actual Justice Warrior YouTube channel, & John Nolte, a contributor for
Breitbart, as the guest.
Ian & Libby were co-hosts.
The panel ends up taking a distinctly pro-Israel turn, after setting aside the strike upon the World Central Kitchen convoy; with John, Libby, Sean, & Tim, all agreeing on the irrationality of Palestinians not accepting peace. Ian ends up coming out as the more balanced voice, saying that decades of blockades, settlement encroachments, & destabilisation efforts by Israel may have left fertile ground for the events of 7 October, as blowback on Israel: 4:32-58:57
Tim always talks about how he still gets ads, despite the efforts to cancel him. & how can he complain with ads on
Timcast, like this?
Clip Collection:
-Tim discusses the coming debate between Candace Owens & Ben Shapiro on Israel & the definition of anti-semitism:
-It is somewhat funny hearing John make similar arguments that Tim was, up until very recently. Also, Ian comes in with one of his verbal jabs, saying that the reason Israel may target aid convoys is to prevent food coming to the people they are trying to exterminate. Ian, also, notes that what happened to 7 October does not justify Israel flattening Gaza:
-I make these clips, as I watch, so sometimes I inadvertently predict things. But I was dead right about John using the same arguments as Tim, including a version of "What if the walls around Gaza were taken down, what happens?" but this time using disarmament:
-Ian is risking much by noticing these sorts of things, such as how Israel
helped to promote Hamas, & other Islamist groups to balance out
the secular Palestinian Liberation Organisation. John & Tim just ignore this point, & move to saying how irrational the Palestinians are for wanting their lost land back:
-Ian tries to bring up the right of return as a solution for giving Palestinians access to their old homes, only to be cut-off mid-sentence by Tim who argues that Gazans should do what the Indians did after losing their land in North America, build casinos:
-Ian argues that if someone stole his grandmother's home, he would still be angry about it. Sean asks if he would kill over it, to which Ian responds that if he were in Gaza-like conditions, then maybe.
Libby then makes what I can only describe as the most braindead take I could imagine. She argues that people should be "mad at Egypt" for not taking in Palestinian refugees, despite having a border with them. It is almost as if the Palestinians are not native to that land, or something.
Sean, not to be undone, one-ups this take by arguing that it is a conspiracy by Arab states to refuse Palestinians access to their nations to keep them stateless as a weapon against Israel. Then, he argues Israel ethnically cleansing Gaza of the Arab population is on the table, because historically that has happened. Ian tries to bring up the Geneva Convention to rebut this, to no avail:
-Tim says the argument for right of return are so muddied, that it is almost impossible to adjudicate. Ian retorts that the argument by Palestinians that they have a right to land in Israel is the same as that used by Jews to claim Israel, in the first place, in a land they had not inhabited for over 2000 years. Tim just cuts him off, declaring that he is "America First" & does not want anything to do with the dispute, with John blaming everyone in the region but Israel for the plight of the Palestinians:
-Ian the Anti-Lincolnite comes forth, where he argues that the 16th U.S. President seized unprecedented power to force the United States to remain a Union, against the wishes of some of its people, via tyrannical powers with "forced integration":
-A super-chatter spammed that Israel created Hamas, with Sean mentioning that Steven Bonnell has gone over this, claiming Israel was diverting funds that were being misappropriated by the PLO into new hands, not to boost Hamas. John mentions this as being similar to the United States backing Iran, then switching to Iraq after the 1979 Revolution to keep the now-enemy state off-balance: