Unsolved Mysteries - WHY DID ROBERT STACK HAVE TO DIE

Out of every movie and TV show I've ever seen, Unsolved Mysteries is the only one that ever truly scared me. Growing up, I'd hear about the next door neighbor keeping the hall light on after Nightmare on Elm Street, or someone curling into a ball over Poltergeist or The Exorcist. None of that bothered me. At best, they were just gross.

But Unsolved Mysteries had that perfect combination of elements—the music, direction, and Robert Stack's narration—to scare the ever holy living piss out of me. Watching it in the dark was essential. After an hour of it, I'd get that creeping feeling that something unwanted was in the room with me. To this day, I still have memories of segments where ghosts materialize out of thin air, sending chills up my back. And there's no forgetting those murder reenactments.

These are the bits that stand out the most:
  • Tallman's Ghost, particularly the part where the little boy wakes up and the ghost is standing over his bed. By far my BIGGEST FEAR growing up was that I'd awaken to see someone/something that wasn't supposed to be there. Unsolved Mysteries brought that to horrifying life.
  • Whichever one had the guy found shot in the head in his room. It's the one where the murderer allegedly hid in the closet and came creeping out to surprise him. I didn't sleep the night that aired. If anybody can identify this one, you are Jesus.
  • The pedophile riddling Matthew McConaughey with shotgun blasts. That was McConaughey's first real acting job, and it's gut wrenching to watch. What a son of a bitch that monster was.
  • Ghost boy in the kitchen, the one who has that hideous face when he whips around.
  • The Devil's Backbone, mostly for the opening: ghost monk leering in the window while the camera zoom blasts on it, that tortured scream in the background.
  • Resurrection Mary - Just thinking about her darting out in front of the car gives me goosebumps. I'll never forget the bit where she's strolling along the roadside inNegative Face.
  • Creepy hitchhiker tries to jump the guy, later finds the driver's house and murders his mother in cold blood.
  • Arsonist home video footage. "Look at it, Omar."
  • The girl who got shock-induced amnesia after the supposed home invasion. Back in the day that was scary to watch; in recent years debate has struck up that she might have made up the whole thing. Regardless, it's a creep moment, sound of the two girls trashing the house while the two masked rapey guys guard her upstairs.
 
Last edited:
I've been watching this for the nostalgia feels on Prime every now and then.

I remember this show being the first time I heard of alien abductions, especially greys, and it scarred me when I was a kid.

Funny watching it now because it's pretty cheesy, especially with how obviously drunk Stack gets the more it goes as he doesn't try to conceal he's reading cue cards.
 
When I was a kid, the UFO abduction shit would scare the fuck out of me.

Same! The one that got me in particular was the Allagash Abductions. I think it was because the segment featured audio from the hypnosis sessions the alleged abductees underwent, along with drawings they made of the experience. For a couple of years after I saw it my secret fear was being abducted by aliens.

Arsonist home video footage. "Look at it, Omar."

I remember that one! But the worst case of arson and one of the worst segments ever, in my opinion, was about an older lady who operated a sanctuary for dogs in need of homes. At one point, someone came and shot a few of the dogs. And then one night, someone set the kennel on fire. In her interview the lady talks about how all she could do was stand there helplessly as she heard dozens of those poor, innocent dogs burn to death (I just looked it up, 59 dogs were killed). The police barely investigated the incident because in the 80s nobody really cared about animal cruelty. The lady and her dogs were terrorized again multiple times after the fire (with several of the dogs being injured or murdered). No suspects were ever charged and whoever terrorized that lady and her poor dogs got away with it.

I genuinely hope whoever did that got terminal cancer, suffered terribly, and is dead now.
 
Last edited:
God that title brings me back. Some good shit, I always loved the stories about the aliens and ghosts.
The dramatizations of the alien encounters gave me the spooks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cosmos
Same! The one that got me in particular was the Allagash Abductions. I think it was because the segment featured audio from the hypnosis sessions the alleged abductees underwent, along with drawings they made of the experience. For a couple of years after I saw it my secret fear was being abducted by aliens.

Yeah, that was the one. It was a combination of that and the movie Fire in the Sky, oh my fucking God the alien abduction scenes in that movie were fucking horrifying.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: Cosmos
On that note, anyone remember this bit from BASEketball?

Whenever I think of Robert Stack or remember Unsolved Mysteries this is always the first thing that pops into my head. Fuck, BASEketball was such a good movie. Unsolved Mysteries reboot when?
 
Back