Magicicada_septendecula
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2021
To a lot of people, the first Dune is the only one worth reading. I think this is actually a bit harsh, it's more that after reading the first, you're expecting a lot that later books in the series just can't deliver. Next to most other science fiction, they're really good. I thought God Emperor of Dune comes closest to the greatness of the original. Towards the end of the lockdowns, I started rereading it because a big part of the plot is the Emperor restricting his subjects' freedom to travel among other things to destroy the empire's stagnant feudal system when people scatter to new worlds upon his death.I actually quite enjoyed HA and similar books by Delicious Tacos, while Houellebecq (God, what a name) did nothing for me. Mika Ma and DT are kinda self-ironic and not too serious, while Houellebecq left a bitter taste in my mouth. Eh, maybe I am too much of a pussy for that sigma mindset stuff.
On another note, I'm currently reading Dune and want to read all five books. I read the first one many years ago and maybe second one, too.
I'm not a fan of Mentats and other similar stuff in the setting thought. You know, this stuff that was popular years ago about how our brains only work at 65% of their capacity, so if you unlock your true brain power (preferably with some hard drugs) you can literally become a supercomputer or a psychic. It's so 60's. Ugh, don't know why but I don't like when sci-fi writers do this shit. But I'll give Dune a pass, since it's probably the best example of this trope in all of sci-fi.
Also, why books by Frank's son are so hated? Say, I want to know more about Dune setting. Is it worth reading them? Or it's better to just browse Dune wiki?
As for the works of Frank's son, I have never actually read them, but I have read summaries and reviews. Just based on that, they didn't even seem worth giving a try. Many details of the Butlerian Jihad were far different from what you would expect after having read anything from Frank Herbert, so it's not really in the same universe. They also just seem like mediocre fan fiction.