The first wave of dipshits arrived with AOL, during the waning days of Usenet. Web culture was totally alien to them and they had trouble assimilating with the clipped verbiage and frank obscenity of the average IRC or BBS user. Most dipshits used to hang out on ICQ or AIM and email each other with AOL or Yahoo accounts. Newsgroups were on their way out, but forums were still reasonably healthy. This encompasses the period from the late 90s to the mid-2000s.
There was something of a brief cultural renaissance in this period, with flash animations and games being a big deal and enjoying a strong indie scene. The internet was still intimidating for the vast majority of normal people around this time. Then, along came Facebook, MySpace, and LiveJournal to fuck things up. The real death knell of intelligent conversation on the internet was sometime around 2009. Smartphones had taken off, and with them, instant access to the internet for every drooling dipshit.
Sites started dumbing down their content rating systems, which were originally implemented to get rid of spammy posts like "I agree" and "+1" and the unnecessary database overhead they represented. 1 to 10 ratings became 1 to 5 stars. 1 to 5 stars morphed into likes and dislikes. Some sites eventually dropped dislikes entirely, not wanting people to pitch shitfits over negrates (like Nexus Mods). Forum systems started introducing likes for individual posts and, in the case of Gawker’s ludicrous Kinja system, comment systems started prioritizing content based on how many good-boy stars it got, ostensibly with the aim of eliminating trolls and encouraging civil discourse. The net result of this was the gamification of the internet. Now, rather than saying controversial things, like telling someone they disagree with to lick their sweaty taint, people say whatever they think will give them the biggest dopamine high from the greatest quantity of popular approval. The internet's decline into a vast popularity contest slash beauty pageant had finally begun.
Many news outlets eliminated comment systems entirely because they didn’t like people complaining about the Lugenpresse and their dumb-as-shit prolefeed. Obama legalized the use of propaganda against Americans with the Smith-Mundt Act, and thereafter, all news outlets went from being mildly propagandistic to extremely propagandistic. With the rise of SJWs, first on LJ and Tumblr and quickly spreading to infect the whole goddamn internet, the web was Balkanized and bifurcated into two general domains; the one with the angelic progressives who fart butterflies and rainbows and can do no wrong, and the one with the right-wing doo-doo heads who apparently want to lynch melanated folk and queers. These two groups of people never talk to each other except in screamed invective.
A kind of extreme tribalism has taken root, centered not on fun things, like the jolly good rivalry of the Console Wars, but on an increasingly hostile populace that has been forced to ask some very basic questions about the kind of society that they wish to live in, finding that the reality falls far short of their expectations. The state of the internet has increasingly come to reflect the utterly deranged and hyper-polarized nature of our politics. The new generation has grown up with recessions, unpaid tuition debts, and terrible job prospects. Home ownership - and with it, some semblance of normalcy - always seems to shimmer and vanish into the horizon, like a mirage. In many developed countries, younger people's share of their respective nations' wealth is shrinking to nothing. They're bitter and hostile about it, so naturally, they look for an outlet for that hostility, taking it out on total strangers.
People are gaslighted by our governments and our media. Advertisers have gone out of their way to try and restrict a lot of the edgier content that defined the early internet and its culture, withholding ad support for sites that fall out of compliance with an increasingly corporatized and homogenized web. All manner of limitations on free speech have been exercised, partly to avoid offending groups on the basis of race, gender, or religion, but also to put a leash on internet culture itself. W
hy is this happening? To put it bluntly, governments and corporations were scared as shit over the web in its old incarnation. Wikileaks and other whistleblowers scraped back the layer of shellac that they’d rubbed onto the polished turds that were their foreign and domestic policies. Bloggers and independent journalists were going outside the limits of the controlled media and revealing ugly truths about the way our societies are actually run. Governments would love it if they could blast a megaphone over all of this and drown out rational conversation by any means necessary.
China has literal armies of trolls who manipulate narratives online. So does every other intelligence agency on Earth. They all have a vested interest in controlling what you think and believe, and so do the big media corporations and advertisers who are upset over the increasing obsolescence of their business model. Armies of fact-checkers, propagandists, and professional shit-disturbers have all but obliterated meaningful online discourse except in the most obscene corners of the web where their influence cannot easily penetrate. People are accused of peddling conspiracy theories even when they have clear evidence of collusion, conspiracy, and racketeering stretching all the way from Silicon Valley to DC and back. Independent investigators found that there was a revolving door between Alphabet and the Obama administration, for fuck's sake.
In short, the most powerful people on Earth were shit-scared of the old, unadulterated internet, as it used to be. So, they got together with the corpos and conjured up new cyber-divisions of their intelligence agencies, and they deliberately shitted it up. When you ask banks why they've debanked you, and when you ask advertisers why they've deplatformed you, they offer platitudes and excuses. They insist they're just following regulations.
It's not us, they say.
It's the government. We're just following the rules.
At this point, we really have to ask ourselves if the increasing consolidation of the internet and the concentration of the power over our communications in the hands of a few tech oligarchs is something we want to continue, or if we want to do things differently, and put the power back in the hands of the people.
Fun and banter is based around pushing boundaries and being offensive. The rise of CancelCulture out of California has pushed most of society into a subdued state of being afraid to say things and those places that remain free are terrified of that culture spreading to their own spaces. Places relatively free of cancel culture react to the world around them by being edgy on purpose to the point of being painful, or by trying to make everything about their great struggle.
Kiwifarms is one of a few places where banter and fun survives, but the forces of California and Social conservatism have infiltrators waiting for their chance.
*End of Prologue*
A certain level of edginess is a good filter. It keeps the pro-censorship shit-eaters out.