YABookgate

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Okay I have a question for those of you are actually within the YA world in a respectable manner while secretly harboring rw views. Do you know any good developmental editors who are secretly or maybe not so secretly dissident? I don't want to hire a DE only to have them scold my book for being problematic. But I want to hire a professional.
I think even if you get someone who "is" leaning to the left and they do tell you that X View Is Problematic, that's still good info to have. You can decide whether to leave it on the page or make it more covert if you're thinking of getting into the normie/traditional publishing sphere.

Unless they are going absolutely extremist on their socials, there's more normies than out and out weirdos in editing. Anyone who is older (Gen X) is a safer bet.
 
Oooooooo! I saw this earlier in my twitter feed:
1705543462269.png

And was trying to figure out what the heck was going on. Thanks for filling it all in!
 
Is the full list available to read? Could do with a laugh.

Yes, if I screenshot it for you. Since she follows me the list is still available to me....it'll take awhile to screenshot everything though, as she is still adding to it, so tell me if you really want it and I'll see what I can do. After locking, she made another ongoing thread of books she likes.
 
Last edited:
Yes, if I screenshot it for you. Since she follows me the list is still available to me....it'll take awhile to screenshot everything though, as she is still adding to it, so tell me if you really want it and I'll see what I can do. After locking, she made another ongoing thread of books she likes.
Looks like the Twitter account is now completely gone, not just privated.

1705865663279.png .
 
Since we have people in YAspehere in here I figure I should reach out.

I'm reaching the ARC campaign phase of book release, I plan on sending ppl who provide substantial feedback / long-form reviews free hardcover copies if they're in the U.S., good idea, bad idea?

If you guys have any advice about YA publishing in general lmk.
 
I plan on sending ppl who provide substantial feedback / long-form reviews free hardcover copies if they're in the U.S., good idea, bad idea?
I'm not in the publishing industry, but if you can afford all the shipping, I don't see how this would ever be a bad idea. Giving a free book to a reader is like giving heroin to an addict, just without the downsides.

I've also heard you should give free copies to bookstore owners/the people who work there if the store sells your book. Word of mouth says just as good as the cover or the blurb on the back.

Edit: Almost forgot, Good luck!
 
Since we have people in YAspehere in here I figure I should reach out.

I'm reaching the ARC campaign phase of book release, I plan on sending ppl who provide substantial feedback / long-form reviews free hardcover copies if they're in the U.S., good idea, bad idea?

If you guys have any advice about YA publishing in general lmk.
Are you wanting to aim for wider support or are willing to flirt with the "right-wing" ghetto?
 
Since we have people in YAspehere in here I figure I should reach out.

I'm reaching the ARC campaign phase of book release, I plan on sending ppl who provide substantial feedback / long-form reviews free hardcover copies if they're in the U.S., good idea, bad idea?

If you guys have any advice about YA publishing in general lmk.

Yes, an ARC campaign is a good idea. It's more than a good idea, it's a must for the majority of authors starting out in the YA/NA world of publishing. There's a reason every single publisher has an ARC campaign for books in their release schedule: generate a little buzz months before your book releases and your first week sales will be better than what they otherwise would have been. A good resource for getting a ton of high visibility ARC reviews is NetGalley: https://www.netgalley.com/

Now, there is one part of your plan that I would advise against. You say that these ARC copies of yours will be sent to people who promise to give substantial feedback + leave a public review. The latter is good, thr former you should drop for two reasons:

1. The purpose of an ARC review is to gain pre-release visibility for your book on the net. It is not the same thing as a beta read or a critique partner. Once your book reaches its ARC stage, it should already be fully edited and ready to go. The time to weed out flaws in your manuscript is with your beta readers or developmental edit. Yes, it's nice to receive feedback for our work at any point in the writing process, but it is considered unprofessional to significantly alter your book after the ARC reviews are published - you might even anger the bloggers who told their readers your book contained some plot element that it doesn't have now.

2. There is a risk here in valuing "substantial" feedback over visibility. A book blogger with 10k active followers who will give your book a public review with only 200 words is much more valuable to your pre-sales than an anon with five followers making a review 2k words long.

So basically, it's good if your ARC reviewers give you personal feedback in addition to their public review, but keep in mind that the review itself is more important than the feedback. If you feel that your manuscript needs substantial feedback, then you are not ready to enter your ARC phase. Find beta readers, those people love giving feedback.

One last thing, everything I outlined above is under the assumption that you are trying to enter the mainstream YA/NA world. But @Flexo raises a good question. If you ARE trying to enter the "right-wing" ghetto, then all the advice I gave above about ARC reviews is not for your book. NetGalley is irrelevant in that sphere. I have published one book in the right-wing area of publishing twitter before leaving it for the mainstream, but if you want to enter the right-wing writing ghetto, then really all that matters is having a Twitter account and ingratiating yourself with the key players in that bubble.
 
Last edited:
One last thing, everything I outlined above is under the assumption that you are trying to enter the mainstream YA/NA world. But @Flexo raises a good question. If you ARE trying to enter the "right-wing" ghetto, then all the advice I gave above about ARC reviews is not for your book. NetGalley is irrelevant in that sphere. I have published one book in the right-wing area of publishing twitter before leaving it for the mainstream, but if you want to enter the right-wing writing ghetto, then really all that matters is having a Twitter account and ingratiating yourself with the key players in that bubble.
It does annoy me that there is a ghetto. I would only quibble that it's less about "entering" it and more about getting shoved into it. But that would get us side tracked into broader cultural trends and this old man saw a particular cloud he wants to yell at...
 
You say that these ARC copies of yours will be sent to people who promise to give substantial feedback + leave a public review.

Not necessarily "promise".

My plan is to do it through BookSprout (unless you have a recommendation), expecting nothing from any individual beyond a simple rating submission on amazon/goodreads. If a person by their own volition makes a more thought-out, in-depth review I would reach out to see if they want a free hardcover copy.

Right now I'm only waiting for the cover and wrap for the book to be finalized because people are more likely to be interested in an ARC campaign if they like the cover. I plan to leave sign-ups open for maybe a month (this is based on absolutely nothing, if you have any advice on deadlines let me know) and then distribute an e-reader copy. I think maybe allowing people another month to read and submit their rating/review also sounds reasonable so the project would take multiple months from beginning to end.

If you feel that your manuscript needs substantial feedback, then you are not ready to enter your ARC phase.

I have never in my life felt that a project was "finished". I will always find something I want to change each time I do a full manuscript review, so usually I just say "good enough" and move on. Perfect being the enemy of good, as they say.
 
Oooooooo! I saw this earlier in my twitter feed:
View attachment 5643470

And was trying to figure out what the heck was going on. Thanks for filling it all in!

This is an important distinction, even for mainstreamers, centrists and "cryptos" (people flying under the radar). If you try to lean into any kind of overt virtue signalling or cringe-level diversity just for the sake of attempting SJW credits, you'll be treated to a harsher standard. Larry and Sarah are right-wing writers, they stay in their lane, they don't try to sell themselves as moral compasses (they know they live lifestyles and hold views that are not universal).

The GOTCHA tactic of woke-trolling doesn't work on them, because there's no gotcha to be had.

Since we have people in YAspehere in here I figure I should reach out.

I'm reaching the ARC campaign phase of book release, I plan on sending ppl who provide substantial feedback / long-form reviews free hardcover copies if they're in the U.S., good idea, bad idea?

If you guys have any advice about YA publishing in general lmk.

It'll be tough if you are doing indie/self publishing as getting people to read ARC's is sometimes a fucking commitment. (Me apologising to the authors I was supposed to do it for last year but ugh, never got around to it.

Even publishers throw in bribes like chocolates and candles and other items. YA marketing in social media works if you can provide some design elements yourself to kick off the "provision of content". Booktok and Bookstagram reviewers need to produce content, and they MAY NOT be reading every book, so if you can provide a blurb and synopsis with the ARC package (don't just rely on the book blurb) and perhaps commission some artwork (stay away from AI... its cheap and easy but can be a poisoned chalice right now) or do some art/swag of your own, you're more likely for them to feature a photo of your book cover on their socials. That's kind of all you want at the moment, a wide reach, and the reviews will come naturally.
 
perhaps commission some artwork (stay away from AI... its cheap and easy but can be a poisoned chalice right now)
Oh yeah, I commissioned the cover from an artist I liked on Twitter (ye i know), and it was a pleasantly drama-free experience. I can probably contact them to get some character portraits for stickers or something.

I do use AI for shitty little flash fiction stories I write in one sitting as part of my daily practice. It's mostly for ME though. I like having a little cover and other auxiliary materials that don't cost an arm and a leg.
 
I do use AI for shitty little flash fiction stories I write in one sitting as part of my daily practice. It's mostly for ME though. I like having a little cover and other auxiliary materials that don't cost an arm and a leg.
And here I was told AI art was going to ruin artists forever by an endless parade of twitter hacks. Its almost as if AI is just another tool in a creative's tool box and not some harbinger of the apocalypse.
 
George is having a sook on his blog that he's getting old and his entire world view from consuming X and MSNBC content is causing him to be depressed and therefore not write Winds.

Dark Days


January 29, 2024

In years past, I would often do a Not A Blog post on or about New Year’s, looking back over the year that was ending and ahead to the year to come. This year, though, as I reflected on the year we had just lived through, I found I had no appetite for living through any of that again. 2023 was a nightmare of a year, for the world and the nation and for me and mine, both professionally and personally. I am very glad that it is over.

Unfortunately, so far 2024 looks to be even worse.

There is war everywhere. Ukraine and Gaza dominate the news, but there is a war in Myanmar as well that our western media just ignores, things are heating up in Yemen and the Red Sea, North Korea has nukes and is testing missiles and rattling sabres, Venezuela is threatening to annex three quarters of neighboring Guyana.

Meanwhile the US grows more polarized every day. Hate is rising, democracy is under threat, millions of Americans have swallowed the lie that the 2020 election was stolen. Newspeak has taken over political discourse, cancel culture is destroying lives and careers, and we have a disgraced, indicted, venomous ex-president winning primaries despite openly declaring that he will be a dictator on day one and will govern on a platform of “retribution,” when he is not busy grabbing women by the pussy. His last attempt to overthrow the government failed on January 6, but some of his more ardent supporters are now saying that “next time” they will bring more guns. There are actually folks out there wanting civil war.

It is hard to escape the feeling that we are living in the Weimar Republic.

I am famous and I am wealthy and, supposedly, I have a “big platform.” Whatever that is. But I have grown more and more cynical about this supposed “power” that people keep telling me I have. Has anything I have ever written here ever changed a single mind, a single vote? I see no evidence of that. The era of rational discourse seems to have ended.
And death is everywhere. Howard Waldrop was the latest, and his passing has hit me very very hard, but before him we lost Michael Bishop, Terry Bisson, David Drake… from my Wild Cards team, Victor Milan, John Jos. Miller, Edward Bryant, Steve Perrin… I still miss Gardner Dozois and Phyllis Eisenstein and my amazing agent Kay McCauley… Len Wein is gone, Vonda McIntyre, and Harlan Ellison… Greg Bear too, and… oh, I could go on. I look around, and it seems as though my entire generation of SF and fantasy writers is gone or going. Only a handful of us remain… and for how long, I wonder? I know I have forgotten people in the list above, and maybe that is the destiny that awaits all of us… to be forgotten.
For that matter, the entire human race may be forgotten. If climate change does not get us, war will. Too many countries have nukes.

Sigh.

Well, I take solace where I can. In chocolate thrones, if nowhere else. In books. In films and television shows… though even there, toxicity is growing. It used to be fun talking about our favorite books and films, and having spirited debates with fans who saw things different… but somehow in this age of social media, it is no longer enough to say “I did not like book X or film Y, and here’s why.” Now social media is ruled by anti-fans who would rather talk about the stuff they hate than the stuff they love, and delight in dancing on the graves of anyone whose film has flopped.

And don’t get me started on immigration. We are a nation of immigrants, yet millions of us have now decided we hate immigrants… refugees dreaming of a better life who are no better or worse or different than our own ancestors.

It is all so sad.

Now that I have made you all as depressed and angry as I am, let me close with something nice. When word of Howard’s death got out, I got a lot of texts and emails of condolence from mutual friends and fans. One of them was from Steven Paul Judd, the amazingly talented screenwriter and director who worked with us on the adaptation of MARY-MARGARET ROAD GRADER that will be going out on the film festival circuit Real Soon Now (more on that in a later blog post).

Steve wrote:

“Oh, no. I’m so sorry. My heart is heavy for your loss… In my tribe (Kiowa) in the old beliefs, they said we would go ‘west’ when we walked on into the spirit world. Who knows if that’s true, but if it is, then Howard is on his journey west now, going to the place where the fields are filled with buffalo and the grass is green even in winter — and when he gets there he can tell all his wonderful stories to those around the campfire.”
Howard would like nothing better, I think.

Current Mood:
depressed
depressed

The lazy cunt needs to get over his TDS and finish the series he promised. He's been fucking around for 20 odd years and needs a good kick in the arse by his publishers. Even those redditors on r/asoiaf are telling him to get over it, that Trump isn't that big of a deal (and those saying he is is getting downvoted), to read a history book on Wiemar Germany (lol) and get on with the work.

Just suck in that ego of yours, George, and get a couple of good writers to help you sort out this shit heap of a mess you've written into your story and you'll feel a lot better about your legacy. Also, finish your Dunk and Egg series before you die.
 
This blog is 854 words long. A Dance with Dragons, the last book published in the A Song of Ice and Fire series was published July 12, 2011. It has been 12 years, 6 months, and 17 days; or 4,584 days since A Dance with Dragons came out in the US. If Martin had written the equivalent of this blog post every day for that time span, he would have a word count of 3,914,736 words. Which is 2.2 times more words than is in the published works of A Song of Ice and Fire. If he only wrote 1/4 (213.5 words) of this blog post every day for 4,584 days. He would have a word count of 978,684 words, or little over half the current word count of the published books. He could have written these last two books several times over and even if they were below average, he would have gone down as one of the greatest fantasy writers of all time. This man is an abject disgrace.
 
Goddamnit Martin. Can't finish his book because he's too stressed out by the possibility of a war between Venezuela and Guyana.

Vonda McIntyre
Odd person to include alongside household name greats. Didn't she write a couple of glorified Star Trek fanfics and a book about teenage snake sex? (ETA nope I suck cocks she wrote a bunch of other shit I've never heard of (ETA2 surely he didn't include her so he couldn't be criticized for complaining about the loss of Old White Men from sci-fi right?)).
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile the US grows more polarized every day. Hate is rising, democracy is under threat, millions of Americans have swallowed the lie that the 2020 election was stolen. Newspeak has taken over political discourse, cancel culture is destroying lives and careers, and we have a disgraced, indicted, venomous ex-president winning primaries despite openly declaring that he will be a dictator on day one and will govern on a platform of “retribution,” when he is not busy grabbing women by the pussy. His last attempt to overthrow the government failed on January 6, but some of his more ardent supporters are now saying that “next time” they will bring more guns. There are actually folks out there wanting civil war.
Well, I take solace where I can. In chocolate thrones, if nowhere else. In books. In films and television shows… though even there, toxicity is growing. It used to be fun talking about our favorite books and films, and having spirited debates with fans who saw things different… but somehow in this age of social media, it is no longer enough to say “I did not like book X or film Y, and here’s why.” Now social media is ruled by anti-fans who would rather talk about the stuff they hate than the stuff they love, and delight in dancing on the graves of anyone whose film has flopped.
I love George can't even stop a moment and think about how he contributed to all of this. Do you remember NO-AWARD, George???

Here, let me sum up GRRM's entire blog post:
1706621792154.png

Congrats, idiot! You broke things and now you don't like the mess.

Don't write again unless its an apology.
 
Back
Top Bottom