Business YouTube is cracking down on adblock users: pay or disable - this is reminder to install brave

YouTube has introduced an anti-adblock feature, which alerts users with pop-ups and interrupts the viewing experience. The adblocking community is already working on ways to defeat the feature, but YouTube seems to be changing its detection scripts constantly.

Users trying to view a YouTube video with an adblocker enabled are now greeted with a pop-up warning.

“Adblockers are not allowed on YouTube,” the warning reads. “You can go ad-free with YouTube Premium, and creators can still get paid from your subscription.”

The buttons below give users two options: either allow ads or choose a paid subscription. However, for now, closing the alert allows viewing the video.

Complaints about YouTube’s actions have started appearing on social media, as many people use adblockers for limiting trackers and other privacy-intruding scripts. Security researchers have been urging users to restrict exposure to ad networks for a while now because they’re often used to deliver spyware such as Pegasus.

“Awfully brave of YouTube to think I'm gonna stop using AdBlock before I stop using YouTube,” one X user shared.


Others encouraged resistance against YouTube’s new measure by leaving adblocking solutions enabled: “If you show Google that you are willing to forgo your adblocker for YouTube, they will make this new adblock ban a permanent change.”

An ad-free YouTube Premium subscription costs users $13.99 per month.

Adblocking community working on a workaround​

The adblocker provider AdBlock Plus says that YouTube’s wall is “particularly distressing to many of our users.” Some of them are unhappy that many ads on YouTube include “obvious scams” that stay afloat even after reporting them to Google.

For now, AdBlock Plus recommends that users keep their filter lists up to date so that any changes made by the filter list authors are applied to their extensions. They can also add YouTube to their allowlists, which will continue blocking ads elsewhere but allow them when watching the popular website.

The uBlockOrigin adblocker already has a workaround offered on its subreddit page. For that, users have to update the extension and its filter with quick fixes to the latest version.

The post also warns that stacking multiple adblockers or using old block lists won’t help.

“Disclaimer: YouTube changes their detection scripts twice a day, which means that even if you got a filter update earlier today, another one might be required soon. There's no way around this if you want to remain logged in,” the post reads.

Some X users also shared filters for the adblocker to turn off the new YouTube feature.

Ads are a significant attack vector​

Blocking malicious ads with adblocking software is an essential component of good cybersecurity hygiene and is recommended by the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA).

Malvertising is a significant vector for exploiting networks as it bypasses built-in browser settings to protect against pop-ups and website redirects. Malicious ads can generate a forced redirect or deliver a malicious payload.

“Adblocking software prevents different types of ads from displaying or removes them altogether, reducing the risk of receiving malicious advertisements or being redirected to malicious websites. A common adblocking technique uses web browser extensions that allow organizations to customize and control how online advertisements appear. CISA encourages organizations to evaluate solutions that would allow the ability to block a malicious advertisement,” the organization writes in its recommendations.

However, YouTube is not stepping back and insists that users will receive multiple notifications urging them to cease using the tools – or subscribe to YouTube Premium – before their viewing is disrupted, The Verge reported.

“We take disabling playback very seriously and will only disable playback if viewers ignore repeated requests to allow ads on YouTube,” Google spokesperson Oluwa Falodune’s mail to The Verge reads. “In cases when viewers feel they have been falsely flagged as using an adblocker, they can share this feedback by clicking on the link in the prompt.”

To find out more about DNS filtering solutions, you can check out this CyberNews experiment.



Over my dead body. Install brave or mozila i tested them both working , mozila had few days before they patched up and brave never had a bleep. Their blocking the adblock solution is now only workable on chrome . Also brave on mobile can play music in backround from youtube without paying shekels for premium. If youtube wants my money better let me view my downloaded videos without internet connection or demonitase and ban my favorite creators every time, or i dont know give me what i search for . Reminder to replace google with brave search engine or any non google based engine
 
"Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube"
Eat shit YouTube. I didn't ask your permission.
Besides, this is my emotional support ad blocker. You aren't allowed to tell me to stop using it, you ableist jerkwads.
I actually used their submit report button to tell them I refuse to stop using ad block and eat shit.
 
deleting my cookies and cleaning of catch seems to have fixed it. for now.

welp im bloacked again. tried to block element but after awhile, the video player would just vanish and there is only sound.

for now, im just gonna post a unlisted playlist on this site and play the videos from here.
This is exactly what is happening to me. I removed my filters, cleared cache, it seemed to work for one or two videos, now it's back to trying to block me, and if I block the element, the page ends up fucking up. Not sure what to do... do we just wait and hope the uBlock Origin autists make new filters?
 
I use Brave and now I get a warning from YT that Adblock is not allowed. If I wait a few seconds can ignore it but its annoying. Fuck Youtube I will never stop blocking ads!
 
I am very willing to buy youtube premium.
However I know that any money that I give youtube will go to gay purposes, therefore I cannot.
So the adblock and encouraging creators to move to odysneed will continue until the homosexuality improves.

What sense does it make to pay someone the money they need to lobby for you to lose your job?
 
I haven't had the popup yet. I use Brave and sometimes Safari (yeah yeah). The guy who makes the ad block I use for Safari (Wipr) has trooned out, and I'm not sure if that's good or bad for the future of my ad block.
 
It's inevitable. They'll make a $10 tier with ads, and a $20 tier without. And then raise them a buck or 2 each year. Everyone else is doing it now.

Yup, Cable TV used to have almost no ads in the early 80s, I can recall my father watching MTV in the mid 80s and it was only announcements for other shows and things like that in 'breaks'. Also recall Nickelodeon being this way well into the 80s, as I had a recording of 'David the Gnome' done on a Betamax tape in that era and it was just 'coming up next' or other 'ads' for shows that were coming on later that day.

Funny now I don't even remember the slow drip of ads on cable, it must have gone so slow I didn't notice because I don't remember bitching about them. Went from none to like they were always there.
 
This is exactly what is happening to me. I removed my filters, cleared cache, it seemed to work for one or two videos, now it's back to trying to block me, and if I block the element, the page ends up fucking up. Not sure what to do... do we just wait and hope the uBlock Origin autists make new filters?
YouTube's latest effort to detect ad-blockers was defeated by uBlock Origin several hours ago, so.....

1. Make sure you're not using any other ad-blocker, including extensions that don't have the primary purpose of blocking ads but block them anyway, such as some of the "YouTube enhancement" extensions that are out there.

2. Disable your custom filters temporarily if any of them block things on YouTube.

3. In the filter lists in uBO, click "Purge all caches", then "Update now".

4. Restart your browser.

Manually blocking the pop-up itself does nothing, because that's just a cosmetic thing; YouTube is still detecting that you're using an ad-blocker, but you just can't see the pop-up telling you.

YouTube have been updating their detection methods a couple of times per day up to now. Here is a list of the updates they've done, with the newest at the bottom: -


So, at the time of writing this, we're currently on "7a13cbe7", which has been defeated by uBO.

When YouTube update their detection methods, a new entry will be added at the bottom of that web page, the uBO guys will have to come up with code that defeats it (which so far has taken less than 30 minutes each time), then you'll have to update your "uBlock filters - Quick fixes" filter list and restart your browser and you're good to go again.
 
NewPipe has been pretty good. A bit annoying to search on but if you use the exact title of what you want to watch you can find pretty much everything.

I'm trying that NewPipe+SponsorBlock fork someone posted earlier in the thread.

I've noticed that it doesn't seem to be very good at displaying live or archived livestreams though.

I noticed some channels were livestreaming on YT in Brave browser, but when I tried to find them in NewPipe, they wouldn't show up in What's New or Channel pages.

I could only find them by chance in the Recommended sections while watching other videos.
 
Yup, Cable TV used to have almost no ads in the early 80s, I can recall my father watching MTV in the mid 80s and it was only announcements for other shows and things like that in 'breaks'. Also recall Nickelodeon being this way well into the 80s, as I had a recording of 'David the Gnome' done on a Betamax tape in that era and it was just 'coming up next' or other 'ads' for shows that were coming on later that day.

Funny now I don't even remember the slow drip of ads on cable, it must have gone so slow I didn't notice because I don't remember bitching about them. Went from none to like they were always there.
Apparently Nick was ad-free from 1979 to 1984 but it was also a pay-to-watch channel, so that was probably the trade-off.
Funny, I didn't even think the channel had been around that long.
 
  • Like
Reactions: make_it_so
I've noticed that it doesn't seem to be very good at displaying live or archived livestreams though.
That is the biggest negative I've found with it. If you've got a url to a livestream, you can open it in a browser and share it via the android share menu with newpipe, but that's a very clunky workaround.
For those unfamiliar with the android share function, here's some pictures:
It's button at the top that looks like an arrow.
one.jpg
After you click that, it will bring up the share menu.
two.jpg
Click the newpipe app and choose video player.
three.jpg
I did notice the Grayjay app (thread) (site) from Louis Rossman's group works well with livestreams after some testing earlier.
 
Yup, Cable TV used to have almost no ads in the early 80s, I can recall my father watching MTV in the mid 80s and it was only announcements for other shows and things like that in 'breaks'. Also recall Nickelodeon being this way well into the 80s, as I had a recording of 'David the Gnome' done on a Betamax tape in that era and it was just 'coming up next' or other 'ads' for shows that were coming on later that day.

Funny now I don't even remember the slow drip of ads on cable, it must have gone so slow I didn't notice because I don't remember bitching about them. Went from none to like they were always there.
Now the streaming services like Netflix, Hulu, and Disney+ are doing it, like cable but worse because you have to look for everything on separate services instead of one nice guide with everything on it. And now YouTube wants to be cable TV too.
 
I know why they're doing this, and greed only accounts for part of it.

A common contention is that Google doesn't make money on Youtube -that it's a loss leader. This is a lie. While the actual profit from ads is low, it's pure profit to Youtube, and the real money that Youtube makes is selling user data and trends. They let you use the service essentially for free because Youtube considers you the actual product. An actual product that Youtube made a record-breaking profit on for several years running.

The problem is that this is about to end, and end hard. Youtube is chock full of employees like this, who mostly get paid for doing nothing but show up. Unfortunately this - and the other poltiically-motivated horse-shit Youtube's been cause repeatedly at over the last few years - are fair-weather-only ideologies. And right now, everyone's getting an economic cornholing.

The second that the pinch hits Google, the sooner they have to shed a fuck of a lot of dead weight in order to make targets, and if they dip too low, the Shareholders will eat them alive. The ad-supported model of the Internet has been dying a slow death of a thousand cuts for a very long time. Google knows once that particular pilot light goes out, they lose one of the biggest things giving them market share goes with it. They don't really have an answer to it, either. All they can do at this point is stem the tide.
 
Someone needs to start a religion that states it is against their beliefs to be sold anything that they don't naturally desire from god, making ads a violation of their religious freedom.

I'd join.

I even get sold to now while I am pumping the gas with a talking fucking gas pump. I am buying their fucking gas, and they still scream at me.
 
Back