Leanna was a 7/10 hottie on her worst day, grating voice aside. Leanna also had a personality. Seems like she's levelled up a lot since being DSP's child-bride, to boot. I don't think most people around the thread would say otherwise. Her face is nice enough. I'm sure she's got those sunken eyes people who wear glasses 24/7 since youth get, but you wouldn't notice it if she kept them on. Shape is alright and she keeps a healthy weight and a healthy diet, meaning she's unlikely to balloon up. She's got big eyes, big lips, and average cheeks. These are the three things most men look at first in a woman's face. So yeah, Panda is attractive. But she makes an effort to look good.
Panda wears her hair in flattering styles that emphasize her oval shape and big features, and even when she had it short or she's pulling it into a bun or ponytail for comfort, she chooses styles that make her look generally okay at worst. I'm pretty sure she does wear makeup, but you don't even notice it too much. Her body's easy on the eyes, too, she's kinda stacked and has wide hips. Never really looked at her ass much, but I figure she's got one, meaning some meat there.
Kat however, has the personality of a moist sock. Kat trying her best to be appealing is just like an autistic kid trying to be cool, best examples on her chaosrealm01 youtube channel. She's a slow thinker, a slow doer, and generally pretty bad company. She can't even pull off the whole cute and endearing thing a lot of girl streamers go for when they're below average at games, she's just bad and thinks she's quite good. Not to mention she's standoffish, likes to provoke trolls, and can't handle them at all.
As for her face, she's an eyebrowless wonder. Her eyes have a wonky shape, she's got small lips and boney cheeks that make her look like a B-film villain, a ghetto rat or a crack whore. While she does try to correct her small, slanty eyes with Homer's makeup shotgun, the one-two punch between her painted on eyebrows and the blackeye makeup is just shocking. Her makeup is impossible to not notice, she's painted like a clown. She wears her ratty, low quality hair in weird double-buns with a ribbon or something that only brings attention to how ABSOLUTELY MANLY her jawline is. Her shoulders are oddly broad and strong, too, which is fine, but it might be smarter to cover them up than show up in sleeveless outfits, specially when she wasn't straight up fit, just built weird. Next time we saw her, she was smarter about it and came with longer hair, some doordash pounds and a hat to obscure the top of her head. Still made up like a demon raccoon though. Thick Kat is probably better looking than Slim Kat, but her face is still a tragedy and her choice in clothing is still godawful.
The first time she came on stream she was wearing a negligee top and jeans. Kat's body is fairly unappealing for a woman. She's double-flat. No tits or ass to speak of. No thighs or shapely legs either. For whatever reason her choice in clothing doesn't bring out anything in her: Again, she's got no personality to speak of, so the dark, boring hoodies she wore on her streamer days are a good fit to say "Hi, I'm a bore" but not particularly attractive. When she was with Phil she was trying to look better, but failed miserably, presumably due to lack of knowledge.
Finally there's the whole "How they met Phil" argument, and while Panda may have been illegal/barely legal, at least she was a legit fan, she liked him more than he liked her, was cute, hot, ready for sex at the drop of a hat and generally concerned with helping Phil become his best self. Kat on the other hand met Phil while on the lookout for her next meal ticket, wooed him by claiming to LOVE to cook and clean, promptly dropped the soulmaid act and probably laughed her ass off at him for thinking she was ever gonna do any of that shit, make him put a ring on her, milked him for fun money, fed him baked potatoes and microwave dinners and is gonna stick around as long as he's still making good money.
Kat's not fucking Phil. They sleep on separate rooms. She's not being his housemaid, which he desperately craves. She's just there, probably doesn't even contribute to bills at all, keeps her money and has almost nothing to do with Phil. Phil's either a supreme cuck or a gay man happy with his beard arrangement. Most average guys who can opt to have a girlfriend at all can aim much, much higher than a benzo'd out gold digger who won't even fuck you. Even if they're completely cynical and only interested in transactional relationships, you can buy four hours of a hooker's time at around 120 bucks a month, and you're gonna be getting alright sex for much less money than Phil's giving Kat.
He's the one getting gutted and scammed in this relationship. He's got a degree, makes really good money and doesn't even want sex. Phil's a high value target in the gold digger community and if he just had the balls to be honest with himself, he could get his dream beard who'd keep his entire house clean and tidy and his meals ready and warm in exchange for tuition. Keeping Kat around just to be able to claim he's not an incel or closeted in front of the dentheads is fucking stupid when he could have a 20 year old Russian knockout living in the wakhando and lovingly making him tea and borchst every day. Again, the dude doesn't even want to fuck the sugar baby. What's the point in settling for such a trash tier one?
Whether you're all about modern dating and "What value does this person add to my life, that I may keep them around for my own benefit" or a more old fashioned, "I just want to be in love and share my life with this person I'm in love with" type, Kat and Phil's relationship is entirely pointless. Panda was a mess when she first appeared, sure, but she grew out of it and even at her worst it was easy to see that she really loved Phil. That alone would be reason enough for many people to stick it out with a partner who's not perfect. It was just as easy to see that Kat physically winced when Phil went in for some contact, so they're absolutely 100% not intimate in any way. I believe it's hard to build love without intimacy, so Kat probably doesn't love Phil at all, even if she does love the wakhando and the fun money. Phil and Kat aren't in love, they're not building a future together, and this is as good as it gets for them.
Just riding out the denthead whales in the wakhando on a slow burn to complete obscurity, no children, no trips, and nothing special, since that would cut into the gacha fund. Without plans, love, amazing sex, a great lifestyle, or even shared hobbies to keep them together, they're just roommates. It'll last until Kat gets tired. God knows Phil's too much of a fucking pussy to kick the gold digger to the curb and admit his mistake, and he's already put a ring on it. It's amusing as hell that Phil lives in a house riddled with filth, a dusty office, cat shit stacked from floor to ceiling in the garage in jumbo garbage bags until they can find time to go to the dump, and part-time worker Kat, his loving wife, can't even find the time or the will to clean up a little bit when Phil's making all the money and paying all the bills. But of course, Phil can't admit this, and Kat's grift has already succeeded. She can do whatever she likes now and Phil can only suck it up.
Panda at least had the backbone to leave, get herself out of debt, get a real job and bid Phil adieu in search of a better life while Kat has absolutely no interest in doing anything but riding out her meal ticket from the comfort of her Skyrim cave.