Mukhrani
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2021
Not well. One of the Qing princes ended up pissing of a coalition of European powers during the Second Opium War so much that, in order to get revenge, they went to the Summer Palace and tore the entire thing to pieces and burnt all the gardens. This really was a tragedy because the palace was considered the height of architectural and landscape design for that era, and had a very interesting wing that was based on Western architecture, designed by the Jesuit artist Lang Shining. This palace was almost five times as large as the Forbidden City and it took thousands of troops days to destroy the whole thing.How did it end up working for them historically?
I can't really say that the West's impulses have worked well for us either. Our obsession with 'civilizing' other people has lead us to squander blood and treasure in countless stupid wars in shithole countries while our empires collapsed around us. I think that the Chinese getting their shit pushed in was an artifact of geopolitics and not due to an essential flaw within their system. Just look at Afghanistan and you can see that the Chinese approach is much more sane than ours: make deals with the stone age goatherders, slurp up their valuable mineral deposits, and use your influence with them to fuck with anyone else who threatens your interests. There's zero sense of 'yellow man's burden' involved, just cold, hard self-interest.
It's also true that the one thing which could have brought the Chinese up to speed and made them a civilizational threat to the West again was technological parity, and Western corporations handed them our IP on a silver platter in pursuit of the almighty dollar. China was set to remain closed off from the world; we insisted on opening them up in part because we held a belief just as delusional as those of the late Qing: that just by trading with us China would magically liberalize and become like the West, because our way of life was destined to win out and had some irresistible historical force behind it. Completely delusional idea, yet it's still very influential in the West.