Philosophy Tube / Oliver Lennard / Oliver "Olly" Thorn / Abigail Thorn - Breadtube's Patrick Bateman.

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
Reading some of the more sympathetic posts here has got me thinking...

Maybe I'm just heartless but I legitimately can't get myself to feel half the sympathy or at least pity that some posters here have shown for our trans princess Oliver, and I genuinely don't mean this in a bad way by the way, I firmly believe that finding the good in people and divining sympathy for them are good things that I never find to be anything short of respectable indicators of good character.

HOWEVER whenever I look at Oliver I legitimately can not overlook his narcissism, fetishism, and his self-assured smugness that betrays him as nothing short of an upper-class only-child douchebag with a comically and inexcusably exaggerated sense of self. He had this vibe before when he was trying to be BreadTube's super intellectual daddy-dom, posing naked with a snake slithering over his man-boobs as he explains to us why he's smarter than an actual best-selling college professor, and he has this vibe now when he's trying to be BreadTube's dainty and diligent trans princess, fighting leh evuhl terves and their crusade for.... women's rights...?

And don't get me wrong, I get that he's probably no worse or better than any other content creator on the cursed platform we call YouTube vis-a-vis narcissism and sick fuckery, but the straw that broke the camel's back is his complete and utter lack of originality or personality. Even ContraPoints is more innovative, creative and textured with his videos... and he uploads twice a year at best
 
Once your reproductive system has formed, that ship has sailed. Reproductive system growth happens in utero as your whole new human body is growing; trying to replicate this as an adult is as far-fetched as removing someone's adult brain and replacing it with a new brain growing from primitive pluripotent stem cells just like it formed in utero.
You really would need something on the level of a brain transplant to pull off a true sex change. Which makes me wonder if that one mad Italian surgeon trying to perform a head transplant would be willing to work with trannies.
 
This strikes me as deeply unethical.

Let’s talk sex work again.

Is the sex worker being raped? Cuz I would say she be rapin him.

(How the hell can u say he’s consenting)

The prostitute in this case is a tranny, and... yeah. Not a good look. Taking money from a man with Down's to do some kind of sexual activity, and he's obviously infatuated (because desperate and lonely) and wants to become trans to emulate his cross-dressing hooker. Clearly taking advantage of the poor guy.

So liberating and inclusive, am I right?
 
This strikes me as deeply unethical.

Let’s talk sex work again.

Is the sex worker being raped? Cuz I would say she be rapin him.

(How the hell can u say he’s consenting)
olly suc
I’ll say one thing / treatment or whatever it is for Downie’s seems waaaaay better now cos they are much more able- like on mass, they are doing a lot better then they were . Wether this is in utero drugs or just better treatment during young years or even maybe there was always the less effected ones, but nowadays you see a lot more capable Down syndrome people.

It’s pretty cool, and optimistic.

Weird that he was at a sex worker tho. You’d usually have a big enough group that they could find a partner of their own.
As an other side of’Ponder, you may not have seen this programme...

it was about a dating agency for all flavours of mentally disabled people.
 
As much as I'd love a Blaque and White youtube channel I sort of doubt this is gonna go anywhere. Kat Blaque has sort of a history of calling out woke people and it always ends with her white peers bowing their heads and going "so humbling, we have so much to learn" and then nothing happens.
It's a very strange space she exists in, essentially her role in Breadtube ends up being the token trans black girl who calls out the rest of the Breadtube community on being problematic on this or that and not really contributing much else. Everybody goes 'wow, thanks for speaking truth to power Kat! You are so noble and we will take your sage wisdom to heart' but nothing ever really happens. Like otherwise her videos are directionless gender identity vids that never really go anywhere or way, way too much information vids about how obsessed with BDSM she is. She may not like operating in this role but she can't really do much about it, its almost an unpleasant result of Breadtube being so woke and preoccupied with image and performance, I think she's slowly realized that perversely, their attempts to be ultra inclusive and elevate black voices or whatever has turned people like her into something of a caricature, not so much an individual person with her own thoughts and perspectives but a kind of inanimate idol that represents the holy word of the Trans Black experience, where every time she speaks they pay lip service back to her with incantations of how they will do better.
 
Last edited:
1000 years ago Ollie would be in a monastery colouring in books and preaching to his chasers in an ugly dress.

GraphicImageView_getContentStream.jpeg
 
I haven't heard of any buuuuut - meet Drag Syndrome.
As far as I know, they're drag queens, not trans a relative of mine has downs syndrome and I took her to one of their shows in Vogue Fabrics a few years ago
Re: Kat Blacque from upthread:

Mat/Kat leaked his JK Rowling debacle related Vaush DMs- almost made me warm to Mat but he gets close to peaking fairly often and then invariably doubles back down. I know he instinctively understands the tervern position - he wouldn’t want to be locked in a cell with Karen White any more than JK would.

He’d be 41%ing into transy-world social death to admit it though.

Screen shots of the DMs are here:


Wonder how Olly is spinning this in the privacy of his ladybrain? He’s gonna be more naturally sympathetic towards Vaush but will realise it’s better optics to publicly support Kat… but denouncing Vaush flys Olly dangerously close to the leftist-cancellation sun, seeing as he’s barely able to conceal his own misogynist prick-ness.

will his ego allow him to remain silent?
The thing that strikes me with the HR director in the tribunal and Vaush here is they're so... stupid? I don't just mean I think the logic behind their arguments is flawed, I mean they can't seem to grasp the logic of the arguments they're being presented with. They don't understand how analogies work. They can't conceptualise that someone understands the argument that trans women are women because they have a female gender identity and therefore this makes their bodies women's bodies and it's transphobic to gender a penis as male because that's a woman's penis - and yet disagree based on a materialist approach to the world. It's just ERROR DOES NOT COMPUTE.

I don't know if it's because they cognitive dissonanced themselves into thinking something that didn't feel right and now they can't see out of where they are, or if it's because they're literally dumb enough to not understand any arguments at all and just parrot what they're supposed to say from The People Who Are Right About Things.

Ollie is not a highly intelligent man, but he's at least got some facultive capability to deliberately misrepresent what people who disagree with him are saying and present bad faith arguments. "You're just pretending to care about women's safety, you secretly just hate trans people" is superficially more convincing than "I literally don't understand what gender criticals are saying but it's offensive to trans people so it must be wrong".
 
It's a very strange space she exists in, essentially her role in Breadtube ends up being the token trans black girl who calls out the rest of the Breadtube community on being problematic on this or that and not really contributing much else. Everybody goes 'wow, thanks for speaking truth to power Kat! You are so noble and we will take your sage wisdom to heart' but nothing ever really happens. Like otherwise her videos are directionless gender identity vids that never really go anywhere or way, way too much information vids about how obsessed with BDSM she is. She may not like operating in this role but she can't really do much about it, its almost an unpleasant result of Breadtube being so woke and preoccupied with image and performance, I think she's slowly realized that perversely, their attempts to be ultra inclusive and elevate black voices or whatever has turned people like her into something of a caricature, not so much an individual person with her own thoughts and perspectives but a kind of inanimate idol that represents the holy word of the Trans Black experience, where every time she speaks they pay lip service back to her with incantations of how they will do better.
not to turn this into a Kat Blaque thread but

Kat was on YouTube years before Breadtube was conceptualized as a community, and she'll be on YouTube, doing her own thing, long after the foundational Breadtubers flame out. She was lumped into that group not because she made an effort to join but because the fans grew uneasily self conscious about the snow whiteness of their stars. The actual content she produced was less relevant to them than her existence as a name they could drop into recommendation lists of nonwhite Breadtubers for others to watch. She was always a more natural fit with the early to mid 2010s pop feminists — marinashutup, chescaleigh, Laci Green, etc. — but that side of YouTube doesn't post much anymore, so Kat's on an island of her own now.

She's always been skeptical of her so-called "inclusion" in the Breadtube "community" and taken their lip service with a grain of salt. I like that about her. She has no patience for tokenization. She can be civil, play nice, mind her own business as long as she isn't getting hurt, but she has a pretty good sense of when people are approaching her as a symbol or a tool for their own advancement rather than a person in her own right, and she nopes the fuck out of that dynamic before they can pressure her into doing kindnesses without reciprocation. Good for her.

The Breadtube crowd is actually split down the middle on this drama — not treating her like an idol at all, because she isn't in fact an idol to them. They like her when she politely props up their faves and when she issues nonspecific criticisms of the culture (but no person in particular, of course). They turn against her the minute she threatens the standing of someone they truly love. Vaush — God help us — is loved by many, controversial as he is even among online left influencers. So opinions on Twitter and Reddit are mixed, with plenty of people defending/crucifying both Vaush and Kat, mostly depending on how much they like Vaush and (to a somewhat lesser degree) how much they like Contra, who took Kat's side. If Contra didn't side with Kat, I guarantee you that fewer people would have come to Kat's defense. Arguments like "X is bad but I said it ironically and the target deserved it and I was defending Our Team" are massively appealing within a tribe. Vaush could have gotten away with this one if it weren't for pushback from a personality with even more passionate fans.

All of this is just proof that Kat's instincts were correct, and she was right to do her own thing with no regard for how Breadtube would receive it. None of these people actually care about her as anything more than 1) an idpol obsessed misandrist harpy for Vaush to rightfully own or 2) a hammer to drop on the head of the most insufferable egotistical debate bro on their timelines.

Where Kat went 100% wrong was sexting Vaush. VAUSH. I'm revolted but sadly not surprised. This would have been around the same time she was thirsting after Olly. Her taste in men is terrible.

Screen Shot 2022-03-17 at 3.49.37 AM.png


Remember when he jammed an irrelevant scene into a video to show that Rich White Cis Woman Bad? Well, she's back. I won't bother to guess what this has to do with transhumanism because precedent suggests there will only be the loosest of ties.
 
Where Kat went 100% wrong was sexting Vaush. VAUSH. I'm revolted but sadly not surprised. This would have been around the same time she was thirsting after Olly. Her taste in men is terrible.
I mean it's kind of understandable. I generally dislike Kat (the recent fiasco being an exception) but it's pretty much known that most transwomen out there don't have a particularly easy dating life or a particularly wide dating pool, so it's either A) other trans people or B) bisexual chaser dudes. Even attractive ones like Blaire White end up with.... interesting personalities like Joey.

A white, internet-famous dude who doesn't say no to she/her dick must've been a big turn on for Kat, so there's that. Probably the same thought process that led Kat to find soon-to-be trans princess Oliver attractive.
 
The thing that strikes me with the HR director in the tribunal and Vaush here is they're so... stupid? I don't just mean I think the logic behind their arguments is flawed, I mean they can't seem to grasp the logic of the arguments they're being presented with. They don't understand how analogies work. They can't conceptualise that someone understands the argument that trans women are women because they have a female gender identity and therefore this makes their bodies women's bodies and it's transphobic to gender a penis as male because that's a woman's penis - and yet disagree based on a materialist approach to the world. It's just ERROR DOES NOT COMPUTE.

Yep. I really think Hate-y-Katy-Colin Montgomery needs a dedicated thread because he is the absolutely best at missing the fucking point. So much so that I can’t quite decide if he is being disingenuous or not - surely no one who can read and type is THAT STUPID?

(also, he is really fucking HUGE in real life and I have lots of early transition photos saved)
Remember when he jammed an irrelevant scene into a video to show that Rich White Cis Woman Bad? Well, she's back. I won't bother to guess what this has to do with transhumanism because precedent suggests there will only be the loosest of ties.

This will almost definitely be an attempt at humiliating Jennifer Bilek. Bilek’s metaphorical balls are way bigger than Olly’s shrunken estrogen nuts so Bilek is unlikely to care.
A white, internet-famous dude who doesn't say no to she/her dick must've been a big turn on for Kat, so there's that. Probably the same thought process that led Kat to find soon-to-be trans princess Oliver attractive.

I listened to a bit of the Vaush-is-angry-at-Kat-and-Contra stream last night and holy shit, the DARVO is off the scale. If I were Kat I would be looking into some kind of restraining order against Vaush because he turns JK’s line against Vaush (sounding like an abuser) against Kat (who definitely doesn’t) and says he feels sorry for anyone in a relationship with Kat because Kat is clearly a terrible person and they must be in danger.

he also bans anyone from chat who even mildly sticks up for Kat or Contra, even just to suggest that there might be a misunderstanding. It‘s proper batshit and pretty much proves JK right, Vaush does exhibit a veritable village-fete’s worth of red flag bunting 🚩🚩🚩🚩

 
1647534444201.png
Was there something between K/Mat and Olly??????????? "Choices" makes it sound like it wasn't only Vaush he was sexting. Now I'm dying to know if Contra wasn't the first/only troon Olly was interested in back in like 2018 or w/e. It's funny seeing both Mat and Nyk express embarrassment over being attracted to Olly now that he has trooned out. PennyAni you were right.
 
Last edited:
View attachment 3080517
Was there something between K/Mat and Olly??????????? "Choices" makes it sound like it wasn't only Vaush he was sexting. Now I'm dying to know if Contra wasn't the first/only troon Olly was interested in back in like 2018 or w/e. It's funny seeing both Mat and Nyk express embarrassment over being attracted to Olly now that he has trooned out. PennyAni you were right.

Well, I guess there are a few bearded leftist YouTubers who most people would be ashamed to have sexted. On the other hand, it's already established she liked Olly. Did Contra ever openly express embarrassment, or have we just inferred that from some unspecific shady comments?

The thing that strikes me with the HR director in the tribunal and Vaush here is they're so... stupid? I don't just mean I think the logic behind their arguments is flawed, I mean they can't seem to grasp the logic of the arguments they're being presented with. They don't understand how analogies work. They can't conceptualise that someone understands the argument that trans women are women because they have a female gender identity and therefore this makes their bodies women's bodies and it's transphobic to gender a penis as male because that's a woman's penis - and yet disagree based on a materialist approach to the world. It's just ERROR DOES NOT COMPUTE.

I don't know if it's because they cognitive dissonanced themselves into thinking something that didn't feel right and now they can't see out of where they are, or if it's because they're literally dumb enough to not understand any arguments at all and just parrot what they're supposed to say from The People Who Are Right About Things.

Ollie is not a highly intelligent man, but he's at least got some facultive capability to deliberately misrepresent what people who disagree with him are saying and present bad faith arguments. "You're just pretending to care about women's safety, you secretly just hate trans people" is superficially more convincing than "I literally don't understand what gender criticals are saying but it's offensive to trans people so it must be wrong".

They have a pseudo-religious worldview consisting of saintly troons being martyred by evil TERFs and transphobes. GC arguments are just so many heresies to be purged. To even consider them as valid is giving in.
 
not to turn this into a Kat Blaque thread but

Kat was on YouTube years before Breadtube was conceptualized as a community, and she'll be on YouTube, doing her own thing, long after the foundational Breadtubers flame out. She was lumped into that group not because she made an effort to join but because the fans grew uneasily self conscious about the snow whiteness of their stars. The actual content she produced was less relevant to them than her existence as a name they could drop into recommendation lists of nonwhite Breadtubers for others to watch. She was always a more natural fit with the early to mid 2010s pop feminists — marinashutup, chescaleigh, Laci Green, etc. — but that side of YouTube doesn't post much anymore, so Kat's on an island of her own now.

She's always been skeptical of her so-called "inclusion" in the Breadtube "community" and taken their lip service with a grain of salt. I like that about her. She has no patience for tokenization. She can be civil, play nice, mind her own business as long as she isn't getting hurt, but she has a pretty good sense of when people are approaching her as a symbol or a tool for their own advancement rather than a person in her own right, and she nopes the fuck out of that dynamic before they can pressure her into doing kindnesses without reciprocation. Good for her.

The Breadtube crowd is actually split down the middle on this drama — not treating her like an idol at all, because she isn't in fact an idol to them. They like her when she politely props up their faves and when she issues nonspecific criticisms of the culture (but no person in particular, of course). They turn against her the minute she threatens the standing of someone they truly love. Vaush — God help us — is loved by many, controversial as he is even among online left influencers. So opinions on Twitter and Reddit are mixed, with plenty of people defending/crucifying both Vaush and Kat, mostly depending on how much they like Vaush and (to a somewhat lesser degree) how much they like Contra, who took Kat's side. If Contra didn't side with Kat, I guarantee you that fewer people would have come to Kat's defense. Arguments like "X is bad but I said it ironically and the target deserved it and I was defending Our Team" are massively appealing within a tribe. Vaush could have gotten away with this one if it weren't for pushback from a personality with even more passionate fans.

All of this is just proof that Kat's instincts were correct, and she was right to do her own thing with no regard for how Breadtube would receive it. None of these people actually care about her as anything more than 1) an idpol obsessed misandrist harpy for Vaush to rightfully own or 2) a hammer to drop on the head of the most insufferable egotistical debate bro on their timelines.

Where Kat went 100% wrong was sexting Vaush. VAUSH. I'm revolted but sadly not surprised. This would have been around the same time she was thirsting after Olly. Her taste in men is terrible.

View attachment 3079597

Remember when he jammed an irrelevant scene into a video to show that Rich White Cis Woman Bad? Well, she's back. I won't bother to guess what this has to do with transhumanism because precedent suggests there will only be the loosest of ties.
To be frank, its hard for me to have much respect for Blaque or see her as somehow roped into Breadtube unwillingly when she constantly seems to get well involved out of her own volition and then act above it all when it inevitably goes sour. We already know that she was gagging for Oliver's Philosophy Tube for ages before he transitioned, and right now she's quite literally talking about the size of Vaush's dick from personal experience, I mean have a bit of self respect Kat, come on!

She wants it both ways, reaping the benefits of connections and viewership that comes with being thick as thieves with the likes of Contrapoints and pre-troon Philosophy Tube while also being able to disown the whole phenomenon when something idiotic happens like the current beef going down with Vaush.
 
View attachment 3080517
Was there something between K/Mat and Olly??????????? "Choices" makes it sound like it wasn't only Vaush he was sexting. Now I'm dying to know if Contra wasn't the first/only troon Olly was interested in back in like 2018 or w/e. It's funny seeing both Mat and Nyk express embarrassment over being attracted to Olly now that he has trooned out. PennyAni you were right.
I think "choices" could very well include what Kat did publicly: make a fool of herself in Olly's replies.
All I’ve got on Kat is that she used to thirstpost about Olly with a fierceness.

1647536242559.png
1647536249494.png

1647536256967.png
1647536262663.png
1647536271336.png


Then he transitioned and Kat went mute. She was one of the very few Breadtubers who, like Contra, declined to offer congratulations. Because Kat is an HSTS who’s been burned many times by GAMPs who chase her only to later come out as trans. And it unsettles Kat to learn that men she saw as men — masculine men who wanted her “as a woman,” whatever that means — have now declared themselves women as well, as if they are and were always the same, as if the “heterosexual” dynamics of their previous encounters were never real, and as if she wasn’t an object of desire to them so much as a prop in their self discovery. Sucks to be used.

1647536281492.png
1647536287817.png


I feel bad for Kat on a human level because fuck people who treat lovers like ego props rather than people deserving of dignity and respect, but man, does the thirsting after OLLY of all people make me want to slap some sense into her. His self obsession leaps off the screen. How could anyone not see it? If you have a history of being burned by AGPs, a narcissist who praises the mouthfeel of girldick should send alarms blazing through your brain. Kat’s picker is broken beyond repair.
The tweets I screenshotted last November are now gone, but I don't think Kat sought them out for deletion; she just wiped her old tweets. Probably for the better. She tweets too much.

I doubt the flirting was ever more than one sided because Olly has made his preferences crystal clear. He's been involved with three people that we know of, and all three were blonde when he was with them. Now he won't shut up about BLONDE AMERICAN GIRLS on his podcast as if we won't notice — or it isn't crass of him to admit — that blonde is shorthand for unambiguously white.

It's painfully obvious that Olly is the kind of guy who sings the praises of Audre Lorde and Angela Davis and Frantz Fanon and Sara Ahmed to score woke points only to flash his high score into the eyes of white girls to dazzle them with his worldliness. All of these ideas are hypothetical to him, nothing but currency in a game for a certain kind of prestige. You see this type everywhere. Like John Mayer said infamously to Playboy, he's got a Benetton heart and a David Duke cock. Except even the Benetton heart is questionable because who knows if Olly believes his progressive mantras deep down — he certainly doesn't deliver them with naturalism.

To be frank, its hard for me to have much respect for Blaque or see her as somehow roped into Breadtube unwillingly when she constantly seems to get well involved out of her own volition and then act above it all when it inevitably goes sour. We already know that she was gagging for Oliver's Philosophy Tube for ages before he transitioned, and right now she's quite literally talking about the size of Vaush's dick from personal experience, I mean have a bit of self respect Kat, come on!

She wants it both ways, reaping the benefits of connections and viewership that comes with being thick as thieves with the likes of Contrapoints and pre-troon Philosophy Tube while also being able to disown the whole phenomenon when something idiotic happens like the current beef going down with Vaush.
She's very online and constantly overshares. That's her thing. The tweets about Vaush and PT are deeply embarrassing but no more so than her tweets about various actors and Kpop idols. The sheer volume of her tweets is insane — or was before she deleted them. Not a day goes by on my Twitter feed without a Kat Blaque thread several dozen tweets long followed by like fifteen threaded quote retweets of replies.

The onlineness of it all doesn't speak well of her mental health and life satisfaction, but it does mean she isn't as cozy with Breadtube as a few tweets, or even a lot of tweets, might suggest. Kat interacts with everyone. Breadtube is obsessed with trans issues, so of course there's some overlap. It's easy to see how Kat's interactions with Breadtube might seem minimal to her — they comprise a small percentage of her total interactions — while striking outside observers as extensive because she tweets so much in general.

Anyway, I think we can agree that Twitter is poison and many regular users are profoundly broken for choosing to consume it. Not that we're speaking from a place of spiritual elevation here on Kiwi Farms.

Screen Shot 2022-03-17 at 2.48.18 PM.png


lol PT has noticed the drama
 
I think the questionable life choices and horrible, horrible taste in men (and the subsequent humour about it) make Kat one of the more likable trans women/TIMs out there. Watching a TIM be ironic and sardonically remorseful about sexting a small dicked dude like Vaush of all fucking people is so far removed and detached from the grandiose narcissism of Contra or even trans princess Oliver that I can't help but find it amusing and slightly endearing. Is that just me?

I'd literally pay to hear Kat's opinions about Olly becoming a dainty trans princess. Unfiltered opinions expressed without fear of cancellation or career death, to be sure.

Let's hope trans princess Oliver does or says something stupid that pushes Kat into conflict with him followed by a full exposé like the one Kat did with Vaush :optimistic::optimistic::optimistic:
 
I think the questionable life choices and horrible, horrible taste in men (and the subsequent humour about it) make Kat one of the more likable trans women/TIMs out there. Watching a TIM be ironic and sardonically remorseful about sexting a small dicked dude like Vaush of all fucking people is so far removed and detached from the grandiose narcissism of Contra or even trans princess Oliver that I can't help but find it amusing and slightly endearing. Is that just me?

I'd literally pay to hear Kat's opinions about Olly becoming a dainty trans princess. Unfiltered opinions expressed without fear of cancellation or career death, to be sure.

Let's hope trans princess Oliver does or says something stupid that pushes Kat into conflict with him followed by a full exposé like the one Kat did with Vaush :optimistic::optimistic::optimistic:

It's not just you. I have a little bit of a soft spot for Kat and I would LOVE to hear her uncensored thoughts on Abi-era Olly.
 
We already know that she was gagging for Oliver's Philosophy Tube for ages before he transitioned, and right now she's quite literally talking about the size of Vaush's dick from personal experience, I mean have a bit of self respect Kat, come on!
Real talk: does this mean Vaush will troon out next?

@fax machine
Now he won't shut up about BLONDE AMERICAN GIRLS on his podcast as if we won't notice — or it isn't crass of him to admit — that blonde is shorthand for unambiguously white.
He's going to have to keep saying it about American girls: British women are too normal, slavs are too conservative and wouldn't put up with his troon shit, and girls are the younger more gullible version of women. If I heard Oliver was coming to visit America I'd insists all the blonde female friends I have had an experimental week of hair dying, or however long he's here.
It's not just you. I have a little bit of a soft spot for Kat and I would LOVE to hear her uncensored thoughts on Abi-era Olly.
We're probably going to have to wait a long time on that since even a Black Trans woman would get shat on for saying shit about Oli.
 
Real talk: does this mean Vaush will troon out next?
I do wonder if some people in the ultra-woke sphere have a big red 'go trans' emergency button if they are dangerously close to having their progressive credentials permanently ruined or getting canceled to the moon, but its a big commitment if you want to do it even vaguely convincingly. This might apply to Olly but I'm not sure personally, the best example I can think of is Charles Clymer, now Charlotte.
 
Back