Where Gone Home unironically deserves credit is it's recreation of a house circa 1995, they really captured a lot of details, sometimes real subtle ones, that brought back memories myself.
It was done realistically rather than in a cheaper nostalgia way, like for example the fact that the sister owns a SNES, which is what I was playing in 1995, than a then brand new PlayStation which would have been a lot less likely.
And some of the general atmosphere was neat, like the storm warning on the TV.
As soon as I realized where the story was going though I was meh on that though and I never played any of the other walking simulators because the novelty wore off fast.