She could just have regurgitated the stupid "talent freedom" nonsense without taking direct shots at a competitor, no matter how true or untrue something is, this kind of shit will only fan the flames of tribalfaggotry and get on the bad side of everyone who likes hololive
Those "shots" are pretty soft because all she says is that there is a difference and she didn't even say hololive's way was bad.
If folks have to "watch what they say or they'll get on the bad side of everyone who likes hololive" than the person making the statement isn't the one creating the tribalfaggotry, the hololive fans are. Though I don't disagree that there's a very strong tendency to lash out defensively on the part of a lot of holofans though to be fair that does come part in parcel with being the big name in town more fans means more people jumping up to defend you at a moments notice, hell it's half of what I'm seeing in this thread on this topic lol. But there's no real reason to take anything she said as offensive, she didn't frame it in a negative light, just that there can be alternatives to it because she doesn't think her general content would mesh with the idol-hololive image that pervaded the western vtuber sphere in 2020. (which I think even most people even here would agree that most if not all of the Vshojo girls content wouldn't work with restrictions that exist within hololive itself.
i would not defend this shit if it came from gura, vox or any other big names in the industry. Also, half her statement is bs, the only part which is even somewhat true is the relationship part.
You're right that it shouldn't matter who says something but nah I think what she said carries a lot more truth than you're willing to give credit for Certainly you recognize on the family side of her claim there's a difference between just being able to casually talk about any personal matter as you please and have family members drop into your stream is different than having to go through the managerial hoops to do so that happens in Hololive. Pekora's manager was a nervous wreck about the first pekomama stream. It's just a non issue within Vshojo and there are pros and cons to that. I'm certainly not saying the Vshojo way is better, and lord knows I watch far more hololive. I just don't know why folks get so kneejerk defensive over the comparison when they'd probably be a lot calmer if people were comparing something they like about hololive to something they aren't as fond of in Nijisanji. Also I'm sorry but that last bit is just laughable you can't even bring yourself to admit the relationship bit is entirely true. Nyanners streams with her boyfriend, 80% of hololive girls have to pretend they don't ever interact with men outside of hololive employees, family and viewers. all you need to do is ask "what would happen if Fauna fired up her stream with her BF the way Nyanners does with Aethel" to realize her point there is valid. But again, that's a matter of preference with pros and cons of it's own, but it's no big deal to just note the difference.
You know you fucked up when even reddit (who mostly sided with vshojo in the nux drama) is unanimously against your point, i do think it's a nothingburger but i don't think it's "well and good because she has a point".
putting aside the first part because I could give two shits less about reddit or trying to use reddit's opinion to validate an opinion just because it happens to agree with some parts of this thread for once when otherwise reddit agreeing on a point could just as readily be used here to say something is wrong just because reddit said it so it must be wrong.
I don't really think it's even about her being "well and good because she has a point" I think she just gave her point of view and opinion, that her opinion is benign and generally unoffensive so there's no much reason for folks to get defensive over it. and that there's nothing more to it than that, it's not about "who makes a better point" because she's just giving her opinion on a preference and saying she's happy with Vshojo's way of doing things you don't have to agree with that to just recognize it as a valid preference. It's just weird to me that as much as the folks here like to meme on the "talent freedom" line for being meaningless, the moment a vshojo member explains a facet in which they have more talent freedom, the response is so kneejerk and defensive "b-b-buh my favorite corpo can also do something somewhat like that with managerial approval so vshojo still bad" like ok, but not everyone wants to jump through beurocratic hoops to only do only end up doing something "sort of kind of similar to what they wanted to do" at the end of the day it's just her giving her preference and there's not much reason to take any preference that doesn't favor hololive as an attack on hololive or a slight against it.
It's all just weird to me, though this is probably a Connor situation where I'll just have to accept there's no sense trying to change anyone's mind on it because the hate runs too deep. (talking about the general sentiment of the thread not necessarily you in particular)