Dreadnought: The Quest for Cringe - White-Kettle-Shufflepunk reads a trans YA superhero novel

being at the mercy of those stronger than him who seek to break him for their own reasons triggers not even a momentary "Shit, maybe dismembering people is wrong after all!" reflection
This would have made a great scene. Imagine if the Garrison beat-up scene ends with Danny's will broken and then Garrison going in for one last unnecessary punch.
"I recognize the look on his face, he looks just like me in this moment."

Have her say that she needs to work with a disgusting patriarch like Crenshaw because even he's better than Danny's horrible violence spree
For that matter, you could even have Danny's ultraviolence be the catalyst for all this. Maybe Garrison and Thunderbolt had been working on Graywytch for years with his "Only the worthy deserve powers" spiel, but got shut down every time. Then this brute male becomes the new Dreadnought and wheelchair stocks jump 300% on the NASDAQ, so Graywytch decides it's time to hold her nose and join up. We've seen examples of heroes with villain family members, maybe someone in Myra's hippy-dippy Wiccan coven has a sister who's a quadriplegic now for bullshit reasons.
From a certain point of view, everything Graywytch did has been to get the Dreadnought wielder, specifically, under control. We haven't seen any indication that she's a scenery-chewing megalomanical Big Bad. She keeps Danny off the Legion and tries to get him fired because she wants to cut off his funding and make him go back to being a civilian. And she tries to get the Tozers' custody back because she saw they're decent parents and maybe with some moral guidance Danny could step back from the precipice of psychopathic blackcapery.
Even the torturous extraction experiments could be justified (in her mind at least) as "It was this or just straight-up killing you".
In other words, turn her lack of ambition on its head. Make Danny himself the reason Myra "got woke" to the unworthy-heroes problem, and then have her take her crusading further and further till she's teaming up with supervillains.

But we don't get any of that, because everyone the author doesn't like is on the same side
And the weird thing is, the world didn't have to be this small. The author could have just had Graywytch retire in disgust, or disappear. There's nothing in the worldbuilding that specifically required a sorceress for Garrison's plan to work, it could easily have been written so hypertech alone does the trick, or some other superhero can contribute their powers to the magical Nemesis-controlling moonbase. It could even be Valkyrja, the "undocumented" half of her powerset is all about death and rebirth, and turning normies into supers. Have the "super-selection" process really be giving some random person the powers you want, forcibly reincarnating yourself into them with Valkyrja's powers, and then morphing your new body back to "you" with the Plot-Inciting Orb. So Garrison pretty much blackmails Karen: "I can help you with your brain parasite problem, but you have to give your mom and Dreadnought to me".
 
Oh God, no. Not now. She can’t see me like this, half-naked, covered in wounds, my face still wet with tears. But as much as my heart wants to be a wailing drama queen, my feet are much more sensible. I’m up and throwing on the cheap shirt they left me with before I really have time to think about it.

As I come into the light and Calamity sees me clearly, she goes rigid. “Jesus, Danny…”

"For Cris' sake, Stop thrusting your chest out at me, tarnation!"

We’re gettin’ you out of here,” snarls Calamity. Footsteps from up the hall. She whirls and fires in a single smooth motion, the blast of her six-shooter like God’s dynamite in the metal confines of the hallway. A guard in a green polo shirt goes down coughing blood, his larynx shattered by a high velocity jelly round. A submachine gun tumbles out of his hands and he makes a hissing animal noise as he writhes and thrashes on the deck.

Well, he's dead. Don't get me wrong, I think killing a guard while rescuing your friend from being tortured to death (even if that friend is Danny) is perfectly justifiable, just... maybe use bullets that'll kill fast?

“I can’t fight,” I say. My cheeks are red. Fighting is what I’m for. “My powers are gone.”

But you'll give it all up for your tits. I wonder if part of the motivation for writing Danny as such a blood psychopath was Daniels trying to show that, actually, women are just as aggressive as men. Like when TRAs say pregnancy isn't just a "woman thing" because "transmen" get pregnant too.

“We need to get out of here before Thunderbolt gets involved.”


“Kinetiq’s tanglin’ with him outside,” says Calamity. “Don’t know how long they can hold ’em.”

I still want to know what her powers actually are.

A voice blares out over an unseen PA system. “The intruders are under Moldbug Tower and climbing out to the promenade. All tactical teams converge on their location. Continue trying new radio frequencies. If you find a clear channel, let your teammates know immediately.”

Just in case you were starting to wonder if I was misremembering these guys specifically being neoreactionaries and not just generic right wing shitheads. They're found by some goons.

“Dreadnought, let’s go!” Calamity shouts, and I’m so stunned she has to shout again before I get up and dash after her. Behind us, I can hear pounding feet and jostling gear as the other team sprints toward the sound of gunfire. We run past the team she tore up, and it’s hard not to slow down and stare. One part horror, one part awe, three parts insecurity.


Calamity doesn’t need real powers. She’s perched at the very upper bound of human ability.


Right now, so am I. My body is still the way it became in the moments after Dreadnought gave me the mantle. Still as fit and strong and flexible as the entire US Olympic team put together. As bendy as a gymnast, as enduring as a runner, as strong as a heavyweight lifter. There are not enough hours in the day to train a normal body up to the level she and I are at.

Also, I'm pretty sure some of those things are mutually exclusive. Plus, Danny's meant to look like a petite teenage girl. Specifically, a petite, teenage girl who could pass as a literally airbrushed and photoshopped supermodel. I don't know if any of you have ever seen lady weightlifters, but they don't look like that. Though, trust a troon not to know how athletics and the human body work.


The difference is, she’s a badass on top of it.


But me? I can only lean into my powers. Take those away, and basic rent-a-goons can smoke me every time. No wonder she barely talks to me anymore.

Naturally, nobody has given Danny any actual combat training, despite him regularly fighting foes that approach or match him in strength and durability. Just let him clumsily rip and tear.

Calamity squeezes her throat mic again. “Doc, we’re out of the building, can you come get us at the northern marina?”


A window-shaking detonation erupts in the air above us. I can just make out Kinetiq and Thunderbolt flitting around each other, the air a boil of energy blasts. Thunderbolt throws more lightning; Kinetiq bounces it off their shields and lashes back with an emerald laser.

Again, why is her name Kinetiq when she seems to be a cut-rate Green Lantern or Dazzler? Doc's coming to pick them up in her tilt-engine, so they have to a roof-top

I grab Calamity by the shoulder, a sudden fear crashing through my stupor and bringing me back to the present. “Tell her to watch out for Panzer!”


Calamity’s eyes bug. “They’ve got a tank?”


“No, Princess Panzer, she’s Garrison’s daughter and she’s super dangerous.” In my mind, I can see her summoning a dozen or more heavy gun emplacements and tearing Doc’s jet into shredded aluminum litter.


“Oh, then I think we’d have seen her by now,” says Calamity, turning to run again. I’m right behind her. “She’s probably on the mainland with her father.”

I am really looking forward to seeing Danny try to justify venting his blood-rage on a twelve year old girl.

“How’d you know he would be gone?”


“Simple! I burned his biggest house down so he’d go inspect the damage.” She cranes her neck to look up at the towers looming above us. “Well. Second biggest, anyhow.”

Calamity is one of the only bright spots in these books. Do hope nobody was in there, rich people tend to have staff.

Bullets start to snap past us. Calamity reaches into her coat and tosses a grenade high in the air; it bursts into a cloud of purple smoke that covers us until we get into the base of the next tower over.


Something is confusing me. After a few dozen yards it hits me. If Garrison isn’t here, how come I don’t have my powers back? My fingers start playing over the steel collar around my neck, not for the first time. Maybe there’s something in this that’s still muting me.

Or his powers take a while to wear off? Also, as Kosher pointed out, it's weird Garrison can negate the part of Danny's powers that let him fly and shit, but not the part that pummels his flesh girl-shaped. You'd think that'd make for better misery porn, too, or is Daniels' coom-brain take priority there? Danny and Calamity get caught in a elevator, but manage to get up on top of it before the goons reach them.

The elevator doors beneath us open with a ding, and a burst of automatic fire rakes the back wall of the empty car. Calamity pulls the pin on a silver canister with a white stripe painted around the base.


“Heads up for Willy Pete!” she calls before she tosses it through the hatch. The canister bounces off the back wall and rolls out of the car and into the hallway. There’s a flat bang, and then some white smoke pours up out of the hatch.


“You—you didn’t just drop white phosphorous on those guys, did you?” I ask, aghast. White phosphorus is evil, evil stuff. Sticks to flesh, burns down to the bone, and dousing it with water only makes it worse. I knew she was hardcore, but damn.

You turned a guy into the dumbass Stephen Hawking. Danny, I don't think you're in any position to lecture people about brutality. Not that it matters anyway, because...

Calamity is stepping away from the hatch and laughing. “Hell no, it’s just a glue grenade. Betcha they shit their pants, though.” From the amount of dejected profanity wafting up with the last of the detonation fumes, that’s probably a good guess.

Why isn't she our hero? To make a long story short, they make it to the roof and Doc extracts them.

People ask me questions, and I barely hear them, barely want to hear them. Shake my head no to everything, hunch down into my arms crossed over my stomach. At some point, Calamity takes her jacket off and lays it across me, and I almost start weeping. With my forehead against the bulkhead, I bury my face in my hands and try to forget I exist.

Please, Sarah, just ignore me. Just pretend I’m not here. You’re better than me and you always have been and you don’t need to pretend I’m not pathetic because I’m pretty sure we all just proved that I couldn’t pull my weight when it really counted.

I begged her. I looked Graywytch in the eyes and I begged her.

You ever notice Danny still judges himself by very macho standards?

"I begged for my life while being horrifically tortured! I'm a wimpy, no good pussy!"

The ground comes up, up, up and then past as we’re touching down inside a deep pit. Above us, the roof winches close, and when the massive doors meet, a hologram will flicker to life and make this all seem like an empty gravel field in one of the disused industrial parks at the outskirts of the New Port metropolitan area.


This used to be a facility owned and operated by a hypertech merchant called The Artificer. Since he’s dead and nobody was using the place, Doc moved in and set it up as a safehouse/airfield.

Looting appears to be a recurring theme this book. Though, since the Artificer was a man, we at least waited until he was dead.

When Utopia killed The Artificer, she used her inversion beam, which mangles the underlying structure of reality. I had to spend weeks tying up the frayed strings of the lattice one by one before any of the equipment in here would work properly for any length of time. Once I was so proud of it, but now I couldn’t care less. My fingers won’t stay away from my collar for long. I need to get this thing off, and then hope my powers come back.

So, complicated machinery couldn't function, but human bodies managed just fine? I'm not really sure what "mangling reality" means, really. Shouldn't this place be a soup of elementary particles or something?

What if they don’t?

Then the world can breathe much easier. I normally find power loss storylines really tedious, but I'm perfectly willing to endure it for Danny.

“Danny, I’m so sorry.”

“It was my fault,” I mumble into her shoulder.

Doc takes me by the shoulders and looks me dead in the eye. “Don’t you ever start thinking that way.

"Lest introspection set in."

What they did is not your fault. In any way.”

I can’t maintain eye contact.

“Danielle, I mean it. They chose to hurt you. That’s on them.” Her voice gets hard. “And we’re going to make them pay.

I see we've reached the tranny struggle session portion of our program. Obviously, what Garrison and Graywytch did to Danny was beyond the pale, but remember, Daniels wants trans-identified kids reading this to that's basically the same as their parents not cutting their tits off or putting them on drugs for not being manly enough.

She puts an arm around my shoulder and helps me limp to the section of cots and dressers we have set up for overnight stays. Every step twists pebbles of broken glass in my feet. When Doc sees my bloody footprints, she cries out, “Why didn’t you tell me your feet were cut?”


“I didn’t want to be any more trouble,” I mumble, mortified.

We've also reverted to the first book's "Danny's main flaw is that he's too meek," framing.

Footsteps behind me, and then another Doc Impossible is there, identical in every way to the first, and they each get an arm under my shoulder and a hand under my thigh and carry me the rest of the way. I can’t stop looking between them, surprised. Doc never uses more than one body at a time. It’s against her android rules, the self-imposed rules she follows to act more human.

Like her rule about play-acting a life-destroying addiction to alcohol while responsible for an emotionally unstable minor.

“Okay. Don’t freak out, but you’ve been shot in the head. Just a graze, but there’s the chance of a concussion.” She holds up her hand, and the skin on her palm slides open, a lens peeking out. It lights up and she shines bright light into both my eyes, asks me to track it up and down and side to side. “I want to do some tests with you, okay?”

“Sure,” I say, a little stunned. A third Doc Impossible has arrived now, this one forgoing her traditional lab coat for a full-body ensemble of carapace armor and an automatic shotgun. She paces restlessly around the perimeter of the living area.

You'd think she'd just sleeve into a proper battle-chassis for that. It'd probably be more durable and hit harder than something designed to emulate a human body down to the digestive system. In general, Doc's status as an AI really doesn't matter much. Her alcoholism for example is written exactly like it would be for a human woman, except it's a completely different matter when not only did Doc design her body to be able to metabolize alcohol, she also deliberately gave herself addictive tendencies. She might as well be Utopia's actual daughter. I'm guessing it's part of the whole trans allegory thing. Doc is literally trans-human, so we can't acknowledge that she's different from a flesh and blood woman except when it's convenient.

The Doc with me sees this, and the one who has her back to me says, “I think Danielle needs to be alone for a little bit. We’ll call if there’s anything else.”

“I…okay. Sure. Yeah. Sure,” says Calamity. I hear her boots clicking and hang my head. She’ll never talk to me again, obviously.

“Sarah,” calls out one of the Docs. “Thank you. Really.”

After a long moment, Calamity replies, “Anytime.”

The door to the stairs open and then shut again.

“She thinks I’m a total loser,” I say.

She would be correct.

“I can pretty much guarantee you you’re wrong about that, kiddo,” mutters the Doc picking broken glass out of my feet.


“I am a loser. I don’t even have my powers anymore.”


The Doc doing the scalp wound leans down, tilts my chin toward her with a finger. “Danny, nobody who matters only cared about your powers.”

"They care about your tits, the only parts of you that do matter. Without them, you'd just be Daniel Tozer, that wretched, walking dead excuse for little boy. The only worth he ever had was as construction material for the flawless fuck-object you are today."

"Jesus, doc!"

"Look, if I say anything else, you could have me done for conversion therapy."

One of them is writing this down on a clipboard. “He didn’t touch you or shoot you with anything?”


“No, nothing like that.”


“Okay, so he’s not a drainer. This collar they put on you, could that have something to do with it?”

Nah, it's purely for aesthetics. Garrison knew how much trans girls liked their chokers.

“Maybe. I’m…I’m kind of scared to find out.” Graywytch’s torture brought the lattice into sharp relief in my head, but I couldn’t touch it, couldn’t engage with it. What if I’m broken? Part of me wants this collar off yesterday. But a bigger part was hoping I could avoid the issue for a while. Luckily, I grew up in a house full of shouting, so if there’s anything I know how to do right, it’s avoid the issue.

It helped that Daniels could never be fucked to actually write any yelling, I imagine.

“Um, if you don’t mind me asking, why are there three of you?”


They don’t answer for a while. The one next to me sprays my scalp with something cold, and the pain in my scalp recedes into a chilly numbness. As the silence curdles, the one with the clipboard says, “I got tired of people I care about getting hurt because I was too scared to stop pretending I’m human. I’m not. It’s time to stop playing.”


“Oh.” I reach out and take one of her hands. “Thank you.”

I love that Daniels wrote this without a trace of irony. "Pretending to be something you're not is bad."

Their faces get troubled. “Danielle, I am so sorry.”

“For what?”

The tactical Doc has her back turned, but she’s gone very still. The one running the scanner across my scalp stops working. “They had you for days,” says clipboard Doc. “It should never have taken me so long to realize something had happened. I…” Doc’s face cracks into tears. “I’m sorry. I was drunk. Even after Charlie came to tell me something was wrong, it took me hours to sober up. And…and look what they did to you.” She’s not working on my wound anymore. Doc sets the scanner aside, folds her arms around my shoulders, hugs me. “I’m so sorry. I’m so, so sorry.”

In other words, Doc was so dedicated to her drunk LARP, she prioritized it over Danny's safety. Say what you want about Bender, he's meant to be a dickhead, and he actually needs alcohol to function.

“It’s okay,” I say softly.

“It’s not!” snaps Doc. “You deserved a better friend than me.”

“You got me out. That’s what matters. It’s not like I’ve never dropped the ball before.”

Doc’s mouth twists up in a bittersweet smile. “You’re really something else, kid.”

“Yeah, well. Nobody’s perfect. I’m sorry for that crack about you helping me find something at the bottom of a bottle.”

Doc wipes her eyes. “I’m sorry for being a drunk.”

Remember, Roger is a irredeemable abusive parent for yelling and not stunting Danny's growth.

Whenever I look at her in the lattice, it’s obvious she’s not human. Her bones are basically fancy plastic. Her brain is synthetic gel. She’s got a power cell next to her heart, which is itself made of a weird mix of hypertech materials I can’t identify. Doctor Impossible is emphatically not human. There’s a contradiction here. One I’ve mulled over sullenly a few times in the past months as her addictions got the better of her and made life difficult time and again. Finally, I work up the courage to ask.


“Doc, do you mind if I ask why you’re an alcoholic?”


She shrugs. “It’s bad form for a psychologist to self-diagnose, but I’d have to say that it’s a coping mechanism for my inability to process the guilt from having murdered some of my friends. And from—” She stops for a moment. “From other frustrations.”

Someone enfeebling themselves in pursuit of a mad, intangible goal is a pretty good metaphor for trans identity, I will admit.

“Danny, would you think less of me if I told you I was scared?”

“No, no of course not.”

“Good, because I’m fucking terrified,” she says. “At least once a week, I sit down with my configuration files to write a patch, and every time, I say today’s the day. I’m gonna get better. And then I see that they go all the way down, and I freeze up again. I could make myself an entirely different person. Mom had a backdoor into me once before. My neural net is modeled after hers—it’s not just a metaphor when I say I’m her daughter. I think like her, and sometimes the things I think scare me. How do I know that I can trust myself to make more changes? How do I know that in editing my code, I won’t make myself more like her, and say I’m doing it to become better?”

A reminder that the only reason this Doc isn't doing her mother's bidding is because she patched herself.

“I’ll make you a deal,” I say.


Doc pushes back from the computer to swivel on her chair and face me. “Yeah?”


“We get my powers back, and when you’re ready to patch yourself, I’ll sit with you, and if it looks like you’re turning evil, I’ll totally kick your ass for you.”

And she'd enjoy it, too.

Anyway, they take the collar off, and Danny's powers return.

“That’s nice to hear,” says Kinetiq as they enter the living area. They’ve got a sheen of sweat on their face from the long flight. A few shining burns on their bare arms have gone an angry red, but they don’t seem to notice or care.


I flit over to them and give them a hug. “Thank you,” I say.


Kinetiq smiles and runs a thumb across the staples in my scalp. “Nice train tracks. You want to shave the rest off and get a mane like mine? You’d look super badass with these in.”

I wouldn't tempt him, Kinetiq, shitty hairstyles are the only way your kind can distinguish itself.

I laugh, and now I’m not sure why I was scared that everyone would suddenly hate me. Fast rebounds are something I’m good at. Something I’ve needed to practice a lot. As much as I hate my parents for what they did to me, I don’t mind knowing how to compartmentalize and move on. “Maybe later.”

What they did was not surgically altering you so you'd be more appealing for straight dudes to fuck, while unable to get any pleasure out of it. Anyway, Charlie shows up, and it's time for a debriefing:

“Did he say anything about will to power, or anything related to an ethnic or cultural purity?”

“Uh, no, I don’t think so.”

“Anything about the leader principle, or a great rebirth of some bygone era? Maybe a golden age, either in the past or promised in the future?”

“No. They were pretty down on equality, and said they wanted to create a hereditary dictatorship—”

“One dictatorship? Worldwide? Or multiple smaller dictatorships, with Cynosure acting as the model?”

“Uh, they weren’t clear on that.” I sift through my memories, try to squeeze out more detail. “Maybe the multiple dictatorships? They said they were going to build more islands. And it didn’t sound like they wanted to rule the world directly, just that they wanted all the world governments to be obedient and give them special rights and pay them extortion money.”

Um... they were pretty clear about wanting to rule the world as a hereditary aristocracy. What Danny's describing sounds more like North Korea sable-rattling whenever they want grain. See, this is what happens when you mix neoreactionaries with seasteaders. Seasteaders don't want to rule the world, though they might entertain fantasies of expanding their influence once the old system falls apart. They want to succeed from the rest of the world, which is pretty much the opposite of Garrison's stated goals. Who the fuck edited this book?

“What about a cathedral?”


I blink, surprised. “Well, he didn’t, but a rich guy with powers I busted a few days ago wouldn’t shut up about it, and I’m pretty sure Garrison had Graywytch kill him in his cell so he couldn’t talk.”


“Likely not a true fascist, then. Probably a neoreactionary.” They shrug. “It’s a different flavor of shit, is all. They’re both authoritarian ideologies, but their emphasis is different. Fascists are a populist movement, deeply wrapped up in racism and misogyny and other forms of bigotry—essentially, it’s about hating anyone who’s different and enforcing a right-wing style of conformity on everyone.

I mean, that's often true, but a decent number of actual fascist regimes have been South American, in countries where the population is too ethnically mixed to really create stratified racial classes.

Neoreactionaries, on the other hand, are elitists who are all about bringing back the age of kings, and think that ‘common people’ should know their place and let themselves be ruled. They’ll use fascists as foot soldiers, but they don’t really care about things like ethnic purity among the labor classes, except as a bargaining chip to keep their toadies happy. They’re still super racist, though.

"Foot-solders"? "Toadies"? They're neo-reactionaries! The most influential things they do is write fucking substacks!

“Naturally, the neoreactionaries see themselves as the ruling class that everyone should kiss up to. ‘The Cathedral’ is the weaksauce conspiracy theory they use to explain why their incredibly stupid ideas aren’t more popular.”

Ah yes, because there's definitely not a concerted effort by special interest groups and the media to translate wildly unpopular, fringe views into public policy. Conversely, trannies would never resort to conspiratorial thinking to explain why parents don't want their kids mutilated, or why lesbians don't want to fuck Jim Sterling.

Doc looks sideways at them. “You spend a lot of time parsing their buzzwords, do you?”

“Gotta know the enemy,” says Kinetiq.

Translation: she read Neoreaction is a Basilisk, and now thinks Scott Alexander is a Nazi because a pretentious Doctor Who reviewer said so. Sidenote, you don't know how hard it is for me not to list all the ways Philip Sandifer is a shithead.

They tap the circle-A button pinned to the shoulder strap of their body armor.

That's right, Kinetiq's an anarchist. Anarchism is a very old and diverse political philosophy, but in my experience, it basically all boils down to persnickity arseholes who hate law, but love rules for other people. It's rule by Homeowner Association. Instead of police forces you have lynchmobs. Feudalism, but your landlord is a fat guy with ravaged genitals.

“It ain’t just the gentrification of the Bay that makes me hate Silicon Valley, you know. Lots of neoreactionaries and fascists are mixed up with the big money boys.”

You know, I regret that Calamity isn't the protagonist, but I'm grateful it isn't Kinetiq.

“I don’t think Graywytch is one of them,” I say. “Not politically, anyhow.”

Doc nods. “Yeah, Myra’s basically a communist.

That's... interesting. Care to elaborate, Doc? No? Okay, moving on.

I can’t imagine how much they had to offer to get her to agree to work for a bunch of right-wing STEMlords.”

Especially since right-wing STEMlords are what troons lay their eggs inside.

“Maybe she’s getting something else out of it,” says Charlie.


“Like what?” I ask.


“I dunno. But payment in kind or through favors is a common way to do business among practitioners. Can you tell me more about how they’re trying to lock down who gets superpowers?” I give him details, and describe what I can remember of the satellite constellation. His eyebrows go up, and then go up further. “You’re serious? She’s mixing magic with hypertech?”


“Yeah. Is that unusual?”


“It’s illegal,” he says emphatically. “If Graywytch is seriously doing this she’s…well, the term ‘death wish’ comes to mind.”

Why? It's all quantum-rock gobbledygook anyway, which, by the way, is a fact Charlie and Doc--a wizard and a super-scientist--apparently have no reaction to.

“You mentioned Phase One?” prompts Doc.


“Yeah. That’s what they’ve already got in place. It lets them pick and choose who gets superpowers, or decide if anyone gets them at all. From what they showed me, it sounded like with more time to develop their techniques, they could start mass producing supervillains.”


“What’s Phase Two, then?” asks Kinetiq.


“That’s what Graywytch was testing out on me,” I say with a suppressed shiver. I explain the details of the experiments, and how she’d almost managed to pull the mantle out of my chest before I was rescued. “I think Phase Two is being able to depower people who stand up to them, and then turn around and sell the stolen powersets to their cronies. Or hell, they might just start kidnapping metahumans and draining them for profit.”

Why the fuck do they need to drain and sell powersets when they can make new ones all they want? That's like if they started stealing seawater!

“That seems like an awful lot of trouble to go to,” says Doc Impossible. “Capturing a superhero is hard. Unless Garrison wants to be personally involved in every op, that doesn’t seem like a viable plan.”


“There’s still Phase Three,” I say quietly. “They didn’t explain it, but I’ve been thinking about it. They’ve already got satellites that can project a spell across the whole planet. And that collar let Garrison’s power keep my abilities suppressed even when he wasn’t there.”


Doc and Charlie get there at the same time. “He’s going to turn off everyone’s powers,” says Charlie.


“Maybe magic and hypertech too,” I say. “He seems like the meticulous type, I don’t think he’d leave any way to fight back unaccounted for.”

Again, Charlie has no reaction to the fact he's essentially just a crazy super? Doc's not even an AI! More like a tulpa or imaginary friend Utopia willed into existence. This is a big deal!

“Once the Council hears about this, they’ll look into it, and it won’t be long before they figure out Graywytch is breaking their laws. They’ll come after her and Garrison hard. I mean spinning hurricanes out of the clear blue sky hard. She has really screwed herself.”

Is the Council meant to be ancient? If so, how did it cope with magic basically not existing for thousands of years?

“If Garrison’s powers work on magic, she won’t have to worry about the Council,” says Doc.

Again, magic isn't real. It's just superpowers! Have a reaction to this! This is like if a bunch of Catholic priests found out Jesus Christ was an alien, and none of them cared.

He finishes scribbling a last note in his notebook. “All right, I think that’s enough for now. I might have more questions—actually, here’s one, where’s Calamity?”


My stomach flops over. Right. “Uh, she stepped out,” I say.


“Let’s get her back here; she needs to hear this.”


Doc and Kinetiq trade a look I only see out of the corner of my eye. Without saying anything, they both stand and leave. “I, uh, don’t think she’d be interested. She wasn’t impressed that I got captured, and team jobs aren’t really her thing.”

A supervillain is about to conquer the fucking world and steal all your powers! She is a superhero! Don't talk about this like it's a fucking concert!

Is Danny retarded? Like, seriously, at this point, I have to wonder.

“You’re sure? We could really use her help.”


“Look, Charlie, she was embarrassed for me,” I say, blushing. “I was pretty pathetic back there, and she probably thinks I’m a loser now.”


“I can pretty much guarantee you you’re wrong about that,” he says. He closes his notebook and sets it aside. “Danny, you realize how incredibly weird Sarah is, right?”

If he's not, he's at least so spectrum that he's ultraviolet.

She’s not—”


“To you. She’s not weird, to you. Because you can fly and go on talk shows. But to the rest of us, yeah, it’s a little strange that her hobby is beating up drug dealers.”

Everyone in this room is a fucking superhero. Why is this odd to you?

So she’s…different. So what?”

“So she’s not really good at normal people things.”

“Yeah, well, that’s no crime,” I mutter at my chest. “Neither am I.”

You're not good at anything except brutal violence and whining.

“I noticed,” says Charlie, making a heroic effort not to roll his eyes that nonetheless falls short. “Danny, when she and I were together, we never went out on a date. She doesn’t do dates.”

Blood is thundering in my ears. My heart rate has gone from 60 to 100 in a second and a half. “So?” I hear myself ask.

“So when she likes someone, she asks them to go caping with her.”

“…oh.”

About thirty seconds later, I’m hitting the sound barrier.

Because that's what fucking matters right now!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
"Moldbug Tower" :lol:
Going straight-up didactic is the worst mistake a novelist can make, and we're just diving right into it. "Remember kids, a neoreactionary believes A, B, and C, but not D or E! Take notes, there's a quiz at the end!"

So what's the point of having an island fortress and an army of goons if one barely-super girl can take them all out? I'll accept that the random no-name they/them super is a match for Thunderbolt because my suspension of disbelief is on apathetic cruise control by now, but that still leaves Calamity versus an entire island of armed, trained mercenaries (who use real bullets). And she's supposed to be just a bathtub-estrogen Captain America in terms of powers.
Garrison's "seastead" is nonsense if that's how power works in this world. If everything non-super might as well just be papier-mache, why bother? He's just lucky Calamity isn't the kind of sociopath who'd sink the island for fun, and that Danny was enough of a jackass that he couldn't even count one real superhero among his friends.
The Artificer had the right idea after all, just go for the classic "Warehouse in the Abandoned Warehouse District" setup, and guard it with the best supernatural stuff you've got. Garrison's lair should just have been a nice house up in the mountains somewhere for him, his daughter with an army's worth of hypertech, whatver supers he's hired, and his research lab.
And where was Graywytch during all this, anyway? Doesn't she care that her plans are being ruined, and her prisoner is going to escape and tell everyone what happened? She was willing to ice Crenshaw just to keep a secret, and now it's apparently her own neck on the line since she's risking getting Adava Kedavra'ed for mixing vanilla magic rocks with chocolate magic rocks.

You ever notice Danny still judges himself by very macho standards?

"I begged for my life while being horrifically tortured! I'm a wimpy, no good pussy!"
Well at least he's consistent, he exiled himself to Loser Island for showing the slightest weakness, right alongside Rocco and Gerald (RIP?)

Whenever I look at her in the lattice, it’s obvious she’s not human. Her bones are basically fancy plastic. Her brain is synthetic gel. She’s got a power cell next to her heart, which is itself made of a weird mix of hypertech materials I can’t identify. Doctor Impossible is emphatically not human.
"You will never be a real human. You have no cells, you have no bones, you have no life. You are a homosexual AI twisted by hypertech and 3D printing into a cruel mockery of nature's perfection."

When Utopia killed The Artificer, she used her inversion beam
What? Why did she need to use the Dreadnought-Killer Beam on some nerd? Especially when it takes time to recharge and the actual Dreadnought has been seen hanging around the place? Oh well, I guess it doesn't matter because Utopia is dead forgotten.

“Maybe magic and hypertech too,” I say. “He seems like the meticulous type
What?? Garrison has consistently been portrayed as anything but meticulous, from Danny's own firsthand observations! He talks smooth, but instantly gets derailed when things go off-script. He tries to keep his villain plans secret, but instantly blurts them out anyway. He interrupts his flunkies to jump to conclusions. And he runs off half-cocked when someone burns one of his techbro mansions, leaving his techbro island unguarded. How is this a meticulous man??

Doc nods. “Yeah, Myra’s basically a communist.
Bruh, she literally works as an agent of the capitalist state. And she gets paid a fortune for being an imperialist lackey, and uses that fortune to live like the millionaire she is. What kind of communist is that?
... Well, a fairly common kind. But Myra's a top-tier superhero, shouldn't she be at the level of changing how the world works if she doesn't like it? She could set up her own communist country somewhere (or hire out to an existing one), and maybe even use her powers to make it sort-of work.

So, seeing as Garrison, Greywytch, and the rest are still at large, is anyone else going to step in and help or what? Where's Professor Gothic? Where's the convention hall full of omega-level supers? Where's the army? Where's anyone?
 
That part with Danny feeling sorry for himself SHOULD have been That Moment.

You know the one, where a mentor or confident is hallucinated, asking the hero "Is all you are your powers? Without your powers are you nothing? Does your bolt on tits and your am-hole matter so much that you will throw everything away, let the world be destroyed, just so you can die in the ashes a girl?"

Danny's supposed to slowly get to his feet, realize that his body doesn't matter. What matters is his SPIRIT. He's supposed to wipe the blood off of his face and be on his feet when they come to get him.

He's supposed to laugh at Grey Witch that for all of her talk of the Goddess and women superiority, she still hides behind a man, she's still in the kitchen with her cauldron while the man does the heavy lifting.

When Grey Witch makes him male or whatever, he's supposed to laugh at her or tell her "It doesn't matter what you do to me, I KNOW who I am."

But no...

Without being tougher and stronger than everyone else, being able to do what they want, and being smoking hot on top of it, well, Danny's life just isn't worth living.

It's all or nothing with these faggots.

And it makes me hate their literature.
 
Jesus. One of the things that moves Danny's display of pathetic uwu-ness from contemptible to disgusting is contrasting it to his violence and bullying. If Danny was a continual ball of rage and, e.g., threw himself bodily at GreyWytch without powers, then that would be one thing, but the horrifying way that Danny buries his violent side when he doesn't have overwhelming force on his side is...just ick.

I definitely could have done without the tedious and not-even-accurate "Let me talk at length about the people I hate and how I've put them into this book." bit. But I do wonder also at describing GreyWytch as a communist. Honestly, I feel like the presence of superpowers should have pretty much up-ended the default political beliefs of everyone anyway. As we saw, this is a world where when a demagogue with power, money, influence, and hundreds to thousands of loyal followers goes up against supers, they lose. The world-as-described is one in which mass politics are completely irrelevant, except insomuch as they persuade a lot of mundanes who might turn into supers; any supervillain has a veto on the existence of non-super institutions or elected officials any time they care to exercise it.

I am also wholly unsurprised that the way the plot advances is apparently going to be telling on GreyWytch, not for torture and human experimentation and murder, but violating some gay-ass protocol rules that haven't been brought up until now. We haven't even seen this council, and for all we know, GrayWytch shadow-walked into a meeting, threw down a pellet of hydrogen cyanide, and shadow-walked out back in Book 1. There is no weight to this revealation, and I have no expectation that if this was a true fact about the world earlier that GreyWytch and Garrison would have, appropriately, known about it in advance and taken the appropriate steps.

Come to that, I have no idea what level of retaliation we expected from Garrison. I don't know why he sent Val Jr. out when she clearly wasn't happy with what was going on and apparently he planned to yank out people's powers. I mean, I know why; because that was how the author wanted to get word about the bad shit that was going down, but the way it was done was shit, as was the lack of preparation that Garrison had made.

You know what would have been better? If Val Jr. was actually a full double-agent, was nominally loyal to Garrison because he could use his power-shutty-downy collar to stop Valkyrie from doing her thing, but at some point, she realized that she was buying her life and mind at the cost of others, and disabled her collar, completed the transformation, and then both sent out the SOS and raised Hell herself, and we'd have both another heavy-hitter super in the mix to help get Danny out, Garrison assuming that he'd successfully nabbed Danny quietly (we could have him collaborate with Val Jr. and have her confirm that she had faked some messages from Danny to make sure no one knew where he'd actually be going), so he'd have reason to have light security. And we'd have a bittersweet moment as Danny saw Val, no longer Junior but Val, Nth of her name, throwing down, and realized what must have happened.

However, I will say that I like Doc sobering up. It's not done ideally, but it is hilariously contradictory to what the book wants to be saying; Doc is not human, and trying to act like a gross facsimile of human to satisfy her auto-hominidiphile desires doesn't make her human, it just makes her a shitty robot. I also wish that we had someone who wasn't giving her pure toxic affirmation, and that there was someone to pose to her the same question that Val Jr. had in my alternate version; if you can be human, or you can be better-than-human, and lives are depending on you, what right do you have to limit yourself? Also, as two follow-up questions; given that your mom was human, why hold to humanity as an ideal at all?

Now, I also think that Doc is opening up a giant can of worms by doing this in the first place, and that given that Doc has an addictive personality, she should bring up the risk of once she breaks the seal on editing her own mind, she might go full wirehead, and just edit herself so that she experiences maximal pleasure and satisfaction without actually doing anything. I feel like making a date with Danny to not just delete addiction.ini, but edit her core personality so that she's no longer susceptable to any further additions, including new ones she might invent later, would be a meaningful thing to ask of him, since he was more or less the primary victim of her wallowing in it up until now.

Now I guess I'm just holding out hope for a kick-ass climax in which all of Garrison, GreyWytch, Thunder Guy, and Princess Panzer reveal that they actually did have a contingency plan and start massively fucking with things now that they know they need to go loud.
 
any supervillain has a veto on the existence of non-super institutions or elected officials
Or at least the ones who don't have their own team of unambitious yet powerful supers on the payroll.

I am also wholly unsurprised that the way the plot advances is apparently going to be telling on GreyWytch, not for torture and human experimentation and murder, but violating some gay-ass protocol rules that haven't been brought up until now.
Plot twist: Graywytch herself was a council member, and without her they don't have a quorum!!!

but the way it was done was shit, as was the lack of preparation that Garrison had made.
But remember, Garrison is a meticulous man, according to Danny!

And we'd have a bittersweet moment as Danny saw Val, no longer Junior but Val, Nth of her name, throwing down, and realized what must have happened.
Or if you want to soften the blow, have it be a Captain Marvel (that's Billy Batson, mind you) situation, where she can turn the collar back on to go back to being Karen the ordinary kid. She can keep Valkyrja in the back of her mind as a sort of transformation for when it's caping time.

It's not done ideally, but it is hilariously contradictory to what the book wants to be saying; Doc is not human, and trying to act like a gross facsimile of human to satisfy her auto-hominidiphile desires doesn't make her human, it just makes her a shitty robot
You know, it's odd that that's the angle they went with in a book so characterized by laziness. Isn't there much more material to uncreatively rip off that goes for "You may be a mechanical man, but you've got heart and that's what matters", from Lt. Data all the way back to the Tin Man? You don't see too many stories opting for "You're really nothing but an appliance for turning energy into imitation thoughts, but just lean into your strengths".

Also, as two follow-up questions; given that your mom was human, why hold to humanity as an ideal at all?
Well, apparently she spent her childhood being raised by the ARPANET so she had other humans (or at least glowies) as early influences as well.

I feel like making a date with Danny to not just delete addiction.ini, but edit her core personality
The idea of Danny being Doc's debugging co-pilot is laughable, speaking of.
"OK, F5 and... run. ... So, you feeling evil?"
"Nope."
"Great, let's go paint our nails."
"GWA HA HAAAA"

Now I guess I'm just holding out hope for a kick-ass climax
Sorry, the Plot-Inciting Orb removed my ability to climax.
I assume we'll at least get one more fight scene so Danny can beat Graywytch mercilessly and kill her pet raven.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Probably going to be a few days until I can get the next post out. Mostly because I'm this close to finishing a draft of my own second book, partly because the next couple of chapters are largely about Danny and Sarah getting together, and I need to have nothing better to do to tackle that.
 
partly because the next couple of chapters are largely about Danny and Sarah getting together
Are you serious?

"Hey Sarah, I dare you to take a selfie sitting on Professor Gothic's casket."
"Who?"
"Oh, one of the B-plots I blew off to play tonsilhockey with you."
 
I'm hoping we cut back to the Tozers' custody trial too. Maybe Danny will execute the lawyer with a nice suit (but not as nice as Garrison's) for the crime of giving his parents access to the court system.
 
Right, let's see if I'm up for this:

I am a towering moron. A champion of idiocy. They’re going to build a monument to the great clueless minds of history, and my face is going to be on it.

The answer is "no" but we're doing it anyway!

I hate, hate, hate that this is how all YA protagonists talk, and yet it never translates to actual humility. Pure humble-bragging.

Danny finds Calamity working out in her backyard.

I’m careless. My shadow flits across her, and she looks up sharply. We lock eyes and her face darkens. No. Oh, please no, don’t let me have fucked this up. Sarah hops down from the post she’s on, a twelve-foot drop straight down, and lands like she’s only skipped a stair. A moment later I touch down a little ways off from her, and I’m dimly aware of the grass between my toes and against my bandages. Her good arm crosses her stomach, grabs onto her prosthetic. Shoulders in, turned away from me. But there’s something on her face, and I want it to be hope. My heart is charging in my chest, blood roaring in my ears. There’s probably some suave, charming way to defuse this, but I can’t find it.

What comes out is, “Are you straight?”

Sarah tightens a little. Her mouth gropes for a reply. “…I don’t know.”

“Do you want to kiss me?”

"Oh, no, it's not about that." Sarah took a long, sighing breath. "It's just... I've been invited into the Transhuman Earth Guardians."

She nods. “Uh-huh.”


And then we’re stumbling towards each other, and we collide, actually knock heads, but we’re kissing, and I’m laughing and that makes it harder to kiss, which makes it funnier until she gets a hand around my back and snugs me up against her and yes.


Yes.

Remember when we learned that magic and super-science were actually really vivid space-rock hallucinations, and that the guys who tortured Danny for days were planning on stealing the world's superpowers?

I’ve never kissed anyone before. It’s not what I expected.

"Me and David wrote several screeds about it on the internet."

Hand in hand we trot up her sloping backyard to the rear of the house, entering through the kitchen. Sarah’s mom, Anita, a fit woman in her forties with short black hair, is slicing vegetables for a stew when we come in.


“Hi, Mrs. Castillo,” I say with a nervous thrill when she sees me holding hands with her daughter.


“It’s nice to see you, Danielle,” she says. “I hear you got in some trouble recently.”


“Uh, yeah. Sarah really helped me out.”


Mrs. Castillo smiles and says, “I’m glad.”

Well, I can already tell Mrs Castillo is a terrible mother.

This is only the second time I’ve been here. The first time was shortly after the battle with Utopia, when Sarah lost her arm. It was so uncomfortable, with a thick fog of regret and sorrow hanging over everything, that I never came back.


As far as houses go, it’s just slightly off normal. Like, the kitchen is pretty standard, very neat and well squared away, but instead of drawings or report cards tagged to the refrigerator, there are old paper targets. One of them has a tight grouping of five shots in the ten ring and a blue crayon scrawl that says SARAH, AGE 7. The lattice tells me there are at least five hidden guns in this room alone.

So, when did Sarah start caping? She's like, sixteen, and has clearly had practice. I'm curious what kind of mother looks at their thirteen or fourteen year old and goes "Well, your blood panel is clear three years running, so sure, go hunt down drug dealers and rapists on the streets with your parkour powers and guns."

“So, Danielle, I couldn’t help but notice that you arrived from the backyard,” says Mrs. Castillo, and I wince. Crap.


“Uh, yeah, sorry,” I say. “I forgot.”


“I understand. It sounds like you’ve had a hard week. But I need you to be sure to remember our rules here. No powers that can be seen from the street.” And, I belatedly realize, descending from the heavens certainly counts.


“Right. Right, I’m sorry,” I say quickly, twisting on my stool to look down the hall and see if Sarah is coming back.


Mrs. Castillo sets down her knife. I hear her footsteps as she crosses the kitchen, and I turn back in time to get a front-row seat to Sarah’s mom plunging her hand deep into my chest. There’s no pain, no tearing of skin, only a buzzing cold fullness as her hand phases straight through my flesh, all the way up to her wrist. Her fingers clasp around my heart, every beat a new moment of pressure.

Ah, so she's a psycho. That makes sense. I wonder how hereditary powers are in this universe. Aloe and Chlorophyll seem to have the same powers, so that kind of implies they were born that way, and Karen's whole predicament is based on her powers being hereditary. Meanwhile, Sarah got her dad's super-cancer, but not her mother's intangibility, even though an intangible super-soldier would make for some fucking amazing fight scenes.

“Danielle. Please pay attention,” she says. “I take my family’s safety very seriously. Do you understand?”

"Which is why I let my daughter clean up street scum as a hobby."

My jaw jumps a few times before I can engage my vocal cords and choke out a breathy, “Y-yes!”


“Good. So what aren’t you going to do anymore?”


“No flying.”


Mrs. Castillo shakes her head. “No, the rule is no powers. None that can be seen from the street, right?”


I nod frantically. “Right, right, no powers.”


“So how are you going to come back here next time?”


“Uh, uh, taxi! I’ll take a taxi.”


Mrs. Castillo smiles. “Good. That’s good.” Her hand unclenches from around my heart and emerges from my chest coated in a wet scarlet glove of blood. She takes a paper towel and cups it under her hand to catch the blood while she crosses back to the sink to wash up. “I’m glad to have you over anytime, Danielle. Sarah has been so lonely lately. I’m happy you two are growing close.”

Uh, I'm no expert, but if Mrs Castillo's arm interacted with Danny enough to come away bloody, shouldn't he be in horrible pain from her fucking with his rib-cage and pectoral muscles?

“Jesus, Mom,” mutters Sarah as she comes around the corner. She’s wearing her motorcycle riding gear—the civilian, non-capey version—and has a spare bike jacket thrown over her shoulder. With stiff, robotic movements I rise from the stool and start walking toward the garage door. Sarah catches the look on my face and glances back at her mother.


“Have a good time!” says Mrs. Castillo.


When the garage door closes behind us, Sarah holds out the jacket for me with a twinkle in her eye. “She did the heart trick, didn’t she?”


“If that’s what you call it,” I say.


“Did I forget to mention that my mother is a reformed supervillain?” asks Sarah, perched at the edge of laughter.

Why isn't this series about the Castillos? Anyway, the two go motorbiking around town, which I think is meant to be the prose equivalent of like, a romantic montage. I could not give less of a fuck.

“No,” I say, sitting up. “Do you need help?”

“I got it,” she says, releasing my hand and reaching over to her left shoulder. She reaches up inside her t-shirt and finds a catch. Two more thick clicking noises, and her dark gray prosthetic slides cleanly away from her body. The attachment point at the socket is already being covered up by the automatic contraction of the synthetic shoulder muscle bundles. Sarah carefully places her prosthetic off to the side and leans back into me. Her smile is a little crinkled, a little unsure.

“You’re beautiful, you know that, right?” I tell her. And she is. There’s something about her hard, athletic lines that makes things spin inside my chest.

Oh, God, please don't have an amputee fetish, Danny.

“So you’re not angry at me?” she asks in a small voice.


“No! Of course not. I’m sorry I freaked out when we got back to the hangar. I’m…I was ashamed of getting captured. And you’re so great at this stuff, and—”


“But I’m not! I nearly got you killed again.” She stares at the shaved part of my head and the zipper row of staples I’m sporting.


“Wait, again? I mean, you didn’t, not today. But what are you talking about?”


Sarah shakes her head, like she can’t believe I’m so dumb. “You were right. We never should have gone into that warehouse. Going after Utopia on our own was stupid. But I—I didn’t want to back down in front of you. And I didn’t want to admit you were right about the Legion.” She looks away. “And I keep screwing up. That’s why—I thought you didn’t want me around anymore.”

"You were right, Danny. Glowies are our friends."

“Whoa, hey, no,” I say. I reach around to hug her with both arms, but she leans away. “I would never—I always want you out there with me.”


“Why?”


It doesn’t compute. My mouth makes noises in the general direction of an explanation, but struggles to put together a coherent sentence. Finally, I manage: “Sarah, you’re a better superhero than me.” She blinks with surprise. “When I’m in a really bad spot, when things are falling apart and I’m about to lose it, I think what would Calamity do? And that gets me through it.”


Sarah smiles like the sun after a storm. “Really?”


“Absolu—”


She tackles me with her mouth, lays me out against the ground.


I--trans people should not write romance. That just makes me picture Sarah enveloping Danny with her grotesquely distended lips.

“Would you like that to be an everyday thing?” I ask. “Because I can arrange that.”


Sarah laughs, and it’s glorious, and I will never get tired of that sound. My eyes slide closed. Her shampoo smells like coconuts. For the first time in what seems like years, I feel safe. Sarah is warm and solid beneath me, and her arm strokes up my back, down my back. My body is heavy. I put up a languid smile, and then I’m…

Way too tired to continue this post. Next time, more legal shit!
 
Remember when we learned that magic and super-science were actually really vivid space-rock hallucinations, and that the guys who tortured Danny for days were planning on stealing the world's superpowers?
Nope. Just gotta coom to AGP fantasies :tomgirl:

Her hand unclenches from around my heart and emerges from my chest coated in a wet scarlet glove of blood.
You know, this same author would probably be up in arms if there was a "father threatening his daughter's boyfriend with a shotgun" scene played for laughs, and yet this is a million times worse. What the hell?
This was a cooking scene, you could have had Anita just demonstrate on some food. Have her phase into a peach, pluck out the stone, and then crush it with her bare hands. "Don't make me crush any other stones." Or just wave her hand through Danny and give him a little "ghost chill".

“Did I forget to mention that my mother is a reformed supervillain?” asks Sarah, perched at the edge of laughter.
What??
So let's recap her father Ricochet's story. He's a Nth-generation government super-soldier trying to keep that fact a secret. But nonetheless he becomes a superhero, even joins the Legion's minor leagues, starts antagonizing the glowies, and marries a supervillain?
Why even bother with the secrecy at that point?
Also, funny how there are reformed supervillains out there that are not quadriplegics. Almost like you don't have to beat them within an inch of their life and break every bone in their body. I bet D3 just talked to her respectfully and convinced her to go straight.

For the first time in what seems like years, I feel safe.
Negro, the first thing you did when you got your powers was fly into space and to the seafloor, while villain monologuing about how the world that hurt you will never get another crack at you from this day on. You go out and recklessly fight other supervillains because you're convinced nothing can really harm you. In what world are you not feeling safe?
Yes, I know this is really just a callback to zoomer mental pathologies, but it's even stupider when applied to Superman than it is to real people.

Sarah is warm and solid beneath me
"Until she turns cold and phases out of the material plane. 'Ah ah ah, no canoodling', Anita cackles from somewhere."


Anyway, welcome back W-K-S, hope you're feeling better :heart-full:
 
Glad to see you back in action! Let us know if you got bit by a radioactive spike protein and now have superpowers yourself!

---

I appreciate you eliding the romance bullshit. God, it's generic and bland from the clips you're showing us, and I assume that's the relative best of the lot.

---

I will say that Ma Calamity's bit got my attention, but it feels...

OK, there's a thing that bad authors and storytellers do, where they have in their mind how every character will react to various things in their head all planned out. And OK, that's fine, you need to do that. But other characters don't know that. And it feels really bad and really off when the author knows that Character X won't react with sudden and terrifying violence to Character Y doing Z to them, but Character Y has no way to know that, and has seen Character X go off on other characters over Z.

This could have gone so bad, so fast. Maybe Dreadnought's matrix-thingy would have kicked in and seared off her hand for putting it inside him. Maybe Danny is actually super-strong all over and just mediating that strength with the matrix, and her attempt to touch his heart breaks all her fingers and sends her to the emergency room with a lot of questions. Maybe she'd actually grab the Boob-Inciting Orb and steal it. Maybe she'd give Danny a flashback and make him think that she was actually disguised GreyWytch stealing the orb and have him tear her demonstrably-corporeal-since-its-vibrating-air throat out in a flash.

It's stupid and cliche, and what it says is that Ma Calamity is Not Smart, and stands a very good chance of blowing her family's cover herself by doing stupid shit. And that would be fine if "Redeemed supervillain" were meant to be anything other than coolness points.

You know what I would have liked to see? Danny does have a freak-out moment as his berserker tendencies and his really recent trauma jump to the fore, and he flinches, and because he's goddamn Dreadnought, his flinch breaks half the kitchen.

Then he's standing there for a moment as Ma Calamity looks into his eyes and realizes to the extent she's caught a tiger by the tail, and he sees that she just realized that she invited a WMD into her kitchen and poked it, and that Danny can absolutely demolish the entire house and kill everyone in it in the three and a half seconds in between his heart being destroyed and him losing consciousness.

And then he gives her a big grin, takes a big step backwards, stabilizes himself a bit with his flight TK as he goes woozy for a moment, then gets to repairing the hole in his innards (which is a lot easier than the one Utopia put into him, since his matrix does most of the work for him and this was done without Nemesis gribblies) and have him repeat, earnestly and still grinning, that he absolutely will take the family's secrecy seriously from now on. And, moments later, as he's healed and Ma Calamity is looking at the bits of internal organs she's pulled out of him and realizing how little that means, and how wide the gulf is between Dreadnought and her (or acrobatics and fancy guns), Danny can get add a little intensity to his grin and add that if anyone, anyone at all else starts jeopardizing the family's safety, for her to know that she can always call on him.

From a dramatic stand-point, because you've put Danny at his lowest, you want to start building him back up. If everyone can slap him around, then Great Value Andrew Ryan and Spooky Shadow Lady aren't special. If you want them to be set up as challenging antagonists that do the hero credit for facing, then they need to look good and effective, and you need to lay the groundwork for how come the hero's next encounter with them will go differently, and you want to start doing that as soon as the new superpower stuff comes up by building your hero back up, so that the villains were worthy antagonists for defeating the hero the first time, and so that the hero is set up to plausibly turn the tables the next time they face each other. But what this showed me is that GrayWytch could hang out in a darkened room in shadow-form, wait for Danny to move adjacent to a shadow, then stick a shadow-knife in his chest and drop it so it becomes corporeal and then he's just fucking dead. It should matter what people can do with their powers so that we the audience have some idea of the stakes for each encounter, and we could have gotten a great scene that set up why GrayWytch was so focused on dealing with Danny via trickery and indirection when Garrison wasn't around; that Danny was basically immune to her best trick. Then we've got the romance and the greater plot operating within a context, and one reinforces the other.

But instead, the author is just crudely stringing tropes together, from amputation-fetish power-fantasy to ridiculous HOA-tier maneuvering to weak-ass wack-ass political didacticism to aww-poor-baby woobification to Awkward Teen Romance With Literal Gay Black Disabled Woman, Because Danny Is Totally Woker Than Thou! (And man, I can't shake the feeling that the actual fetishization isn't of the actual literal Literal Gay Black Disabled Woman, but, well, the other kind of fetishization; where Danny, the author, or probably both are really having another kind of power fantasy, where they have the Ur-Least-Privileged on their side and are as immune to cancellation as they are bullets, but part of that fear is not being able to express it openly, but I might be delving too deep there.) There is no shared context, and nothing seems to really matter.

---

I actually genuinely like Calamity sharing her perspective and her actual feelings there. That bit felt actually genuine, and spoke to a whole bunch of other things, like the fact that even if we keep ourselves orthodox and body-positive, that Calamity's prosthetic arm is, to her, probably a continual reminder of what she sees as her failure. Or the fact that Calamity is, we are told explicitly, putting on the show of bravado as just another mask and costume, and that this is the first time she's been wiling to let that mask fall away, and that's much more significant than the awkward smooches.

But even as Calamity has flashes of actual characterization, because her romance is pointed at the moral and personality void that is Danny, I'm still not really invested.
 
but Character Y has no way to know that, and has seen Character X go off on other characters over Z.
And in fact, since it's established that people see Dreadnought fighting on TV all the time, Anita does know that she's provoking a berserker, or should know.
I'm still inclined to give the scene a little leeway in the name of genre conventions - I could imagine a scene where Wolverine pops his claws at Cyclops to make a point, and Cyclops lets the visor flare a bit and says "Back off". That sort of macho posturing thing. But the whole thing is tone-deaf and gruesome here - it's beyond just superpowered saber-rattling when you're spilling lifeblood all over the kitchen. It's like writing the "threatening the teenage daughter's boyfriend with a shotgun" scene but having the father actually fire and clip his ear or something.

It should matter what people can do with their powers so that we the audience have some idea of the stakes for each encounter
Or at least the author needs to decide how "super" Danny is. He can be a big flying brick who's easy to surprise with exotic/magical flavors of space rock powers, but if those are so common, why is he such a highly paid municipal employee?

But what this showed me is that GrayWytch could hang out in a darkened room in shadow-form, wait for Danny to move adjacent to a shadow
Does she even need to be there? She can cast her "no cell phone reception" magic on Danny from across the city, like when she was trolling his trial in realtime. As written, she could probably make good on her threat to just magically snuff Danny, or make the world permanently forget he exists.

As for Calamity, like everyone else in this world she comes off better than Danny because she doesn't have an internal monologue written by our author on display. But it is curious that she's the only one who has some sort of coherent personality and mindset.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
As for Calamity, like everyone else in this world she comes off better than Danny because she doesn't have an internal monologue written by our author on display. But it is curious that she's the only one who has some sort of coherent personality and mindset.

I find it interesting how little she plays the race-card, considering she's the product of a woke-as-hell imagination, and her whole origin story is about institutional racism. Like, it clearly affects her, because why wouldn't it, but it isn't the... be-all-and-end-all of her personality.
 
So, I saw Across the Spider-Verse yesterday. Given what we talk about here, I think I ought to address the elephant in the room. Yes, that's right, the big controversial question dogging the theme: where the fuck was Italian Spider-Man?


(Japanese Spider-Man next movie or we riot)

My room is barren. Something is coming. I’m hiding on my bed. Not under or behind, just on top. It feels like that’s the only place to hide, even though I know it’s not any good.


The door bangs like gunshots. Once, twice, an ogre bellowing on the other side. I don’t want to open the door, but I know I have to. From my spot on the bed I reach out, and the door is opening, and then my father has me by the shirt collar and is dragging me away. The noise is indescribable. My ears are bleeding.

Does anyone else picture Roger as looking like Geoff from League of Gentlemen?

1687362510941.png


Into the cage I go. The walls are solid iron, or maybe rusty old bars, or maybe both, or maybe something else, and I’m up against the bars, up against the window, and I’m screaming, screaming for help.

Pricklepins on my legs, and there are the beetles I was expecting. I know they’re Graywytch. I know they’re going to eat me from the inside out. Up against the door again, screaming through the window.

My mother and Doctor Impossible stand with their backs to me. “I told you he wasn’t worth it,” says my mother.

“Mom!” I’m screaming. “Mom, please! Let me out of here!”

Is this going to turn to that one bit in Deathly Hallows, except it's Janet and Doc making out in the swirly black evil? Also, it's kind of weird that Doc was all gung-ho about "being human" but apparently never picked an actual first name.

The beetles are chewing now, have gotten into me. My lips squeeze tight to keep them out, but they chew their way through. It burns. It stings. They swarm up my legs and over my body, and they’re prickly and sharp on my tongue as they go down, down inside me.

When I reach for the lattice, I find beetles crawling across it. Twitching antennas, chewing mandibles. They center in my chest, and they grab hold of my power, and they start eating, eating it all up. My chest—my male chest that I thought I was rid of forever—starts to warp and bend and bubble up like a blister, glowing with the light of my stolen power, and it begins to burst and—

Maybe this is a silly thought, but if people actually had this super-important blueprint for how their bodies are "meant to be" you'd think most stories about shapeshifting would be pretty Cronenburgian in tone.


Sarah’s hand fastens around my ankle. My body is wire-tight with terror. I take another breath and I realize I’m screaming, floating, my body curled up protectively around my chest in midair.

“Danielle! Wake up!” Sarah is hanging from my ankle, her toes just barely scraping the ground. When I go to tell her I’m awake, all that comes out is a messy cry of fear. My body is slick with icy sweat. “It’s just a dream; you’re okay,” she says.
“No, I’m not,” I say, and I start crying, and I can’t stop. I put my face into her shoulder and let go, sob and weep until there’s nothing left in me. I’m dimly aware of Sarah telling someone else that I’m okay, that I had a nightmare while we were napping, and I keep my face hidden. The last thing I need is this popping up on YouTube, and right now I resent that more than anything else in the world. But whoever came to check on my screaming leaves without a hassle, and Sarah turns her attention back to me. With kisses and stroking rubs down my back she helps me put myself back together.

Yep, Sarah and Danny were taking a nap in the middle of town. Because they are both sixty years old apparently.

I go limp, my cheek resting on her shoulder. “I’m sorry, I should have known that would happen,” I say quietly.


Sarah shakes her head, hums a negative sound that vibrates in my chest. “Does this happen often?”


“Not that bad, usually,” I say. “But, yeah.”

If I had superpowers, and they were prone to going off in my sleep when I had night-terrors, I would avoid sleeping beside other humans. Danny has clearly never seen the first X-Men movie.

Sarah makes sympathetic noises deep in her throat, and I am almost pathetically grateful. God, what did I do to deserve someone like her? She doesn’t push me away. She doesn’t politely tolerate me. She hugs me close, and with her helping me along I feel better faster than I expect. The hard knot of terror and sorrow fades, in its place I have an airy joy that makes me feel weightless. I’m not alone. Not anymore. I’ve got Sarah.

Press F.

Sarah pulls into the parking spot we’ve got set up a ways from the main ruins. It’s between two hillocks of gravel with a desert-pattern camouflage net strung between them, all but invisible from the sky. She pops the cargo pod and we each grab a bag of takeout before starting the long walk to the hangar entrance. Doc drops the cigarette and twists it out beneath her toe. As we get close, Doc’s eyes track down to my hand clasped in Sarah’s.

“Oh, fucking finally.”

She turns to head back down into the hangar, and we follow her, our cheeks a matching shade of red.

They have less chemistry than lead, shut the fuck up, Doc.

Doc comes over and pockets her cell phone before grabbing a gyro and digging in. “Cecilia is on her way. We’re going to explore legal strategies for the counterattack.”

They've got a private army, a floating fortress, and can give superpowers to whoever they want. The monopoly of force by the state has essentially ceased to exist. I don't think an indictment is going to do much. This is what happens when you've got such a bad case of tranny-brain, you think your legal word games work like actual magic spells.

Oh boy, here it comes. The law and order debate. Get more than three capes in a room together for the first time, and sooner or later we’ve got to hash out this hoary old argument. It looks like today’s the day. Joy.

Doc looks at me. “Hey, Danny, how many warrants are there out for your arrest?” she asks around a mouthful of chicken and lettuce.

“None,” I say between dainty little bites.

It's almost as though Danny is a state asset.

Funny how that works out,” says Doc. She takes another bite, and is obviously not of the defiantly-femme school of table manners. She’s wearing a napkin like a bib and it’s getting a workout.


“Don’t get too cocky,” says Kinetiq. They take a sip of a soda from out of Doc’s fridge. “The cops are not your friends. Sooner or later, you’ll see.”

Bitch, you are a cop. Actually, no. Kinetiq's a "freelancer." In other words, she's basically a private military contractor. Like Blackwater. Much anarchy, so ACAB.

“So we should give them reasons to come after us?” asks Charlie with a raised eyebrow. “That’s…um, insane? Yeah, that’s the word I want.”


“Ain’t about givin’ them reasons,” mutters Calamity, who has suddenly displaced Sarah. “They ain’t never had trouble findin’ their own. Way I see it, you can set your mind to doin’ the right thing, or the legal thing. Sooner or later, you gotta choose.”


“Right on,” says Kinetiq with vehemence.

Again, Kinetiq's also a "licensed hero." She's just as much of a glowie as Danny, she's just not impressed anyone enough to get a salary for it. Calamity's way more of an anarchist than her, except I'm guessing she doesn't identify as one, because anarchy is for fucking morons.

“What about rules of evidence?” asks Doc. “What about making sure the perps get convicted?”


Kinetiq shrugs. “I don’t really care about that. The American prison system excels at a lot of things, but justice isn’t one of them.”

So, you don't really care about getting dangerous criminals off the streets, you just like being paid to beat people up. Kinetiq is the most accurate political anarchist ever put to page.

“So when a serial killer gets out because you fouled up the crime scene, what then?” I ask.


“If I was a Sherlock—” Cape slang. Go ahead and guess what it means. “—that might be an issue,” Kinetiq says. “But I’m not. I do crisis containment.”

"So I get to shit on everyone who cleans up after me."

All eyes land on Calamity. She’s suddenly really interested in her food. After a moment, she mutters, “Sometimes you can only mail a wiretap recording to the detective in charge and hope for the best.”


“Oh, so suddenly the police serve a purpose!” says Doc brightly.


“Ain’t never said they didn’t—look, do we gotta talk about this over lunch?”

Sarah: What do I look like? A retard with a bad haircut?

“No, we don’t,” I say with a pointed glance at Doc. She looks up and away like the picture of innocence. “Charlie, have you had a chance to figure anything out about how that collar worked?”


Charlie swallows a big bite, nodding. “Yeah, actually. I was really surprised by how simple it was. It’s—well, I think I know what Phase Three is.” That perks up ears all around the circle. Charlie goes on: “So the collar had a pendant built into the inner side of it. Quartz and blood, right? It’s a basic—and I mean really basic—sympathy charm running off of Garrison’s powers. Whoever wears a pendant like that is subject to his power-disruption field, even if he isn’t around.”


“Step back a moment,” says Kinetiq. “What?”

Of course it's Kinetiq who can't follow this basic-arse explanation.

“Right, but I don’t think you have the full implications yet. First of all, this charm is really straightforward, dangerously so.”

“Dangerous how?” asks Calamity.

“Well, she didn’t do anything to prevent a backtrace attack up the sympathetic connection. With this pendant, I can cast spells on him as easily as if he was in the same room with me. That’s insane. Nobody runs sympathy like that; it’s too dangerous. It would be like remembering your passwords and social security number by posting them on your Facebook wall—yeah, you’ll never lose it, but the first person who thinks to look there is going to have you by the balls.”

“So she’s getting ready to double-cross him,” I say.

...So, story's over, right? You literally have an artifact that lets you cast whatever magic you want on the main baddie, and a wizard. Just cast a sleeping spell on him, or make his cock vanish. You've beaten him.

Charlie shrugs. “Maybe. It sure does seem like she’s willing to take huge risks with her boss’ safety. But I think there might be something else in play. The charm is reversible too. It didn’t have to be designed that way, but it was.”


“Reversible how?”


“Well, right now what it does is shut down the powers of whoever is wearing it. But if you reversed the charm, it would make whoever is wearing it immune to Garrison’s suppression field. So you’ve got to ask why? There are other, easier ways to run the charm. Why make it reversible, if doing it that way nerfs her team’s big advantage? So I got to thinking—what if it wasn’t a nerf? What if it made their advantage stronger to be the only ones who were immune to the field?”

Who cares? You can hex the fucker right here and now.

I shake my head. “They’re already immune when he wants them to be. When they kidnapped me I was fighting Thunderbolt, and his powers didn’t disappear. Garrison just chose not to mute them.”


“But what if Garrison wasn’t around?” says Charlie. “What if they wanted to be able to ensure their people wouldn’t have their powers muted when he wasn’t there to pick and choose?”


“How would they even mute people if he wasn’t—” I stop, the answer arriving like a smack upside the head.


“The satellites,” says Doc.

Charlie, why aren't you casting something on Garrison? You used to go out caping with Calamity, you telling me you don't know any battle magic?

Charlie nods. “The satellites. I think Phase Three is shutting down everyone’s powers. If they can magically project Garrison’s power-muting field with these amulets, there’s no reason they couldn’t use a similar spell to broadcast his field from the satellites as well. The amulets could then have their charms reversed, so that they would let their own people keep using their powers while everyone else was stripped of theirs. And if this stuff shuts down magic too, then it wouldn’t matter how simple and vulnerable she made the charms. Nobody else would be able to exploit the loophole. That’s Phase Three. I’d bet you anything, that’s Phase Three.”

So, Graywytch is so ready to turn on Garrison, she magically doxxed him, but also made sure his super-weapon functions exactly as promised?

“First step,” says Doc, “we should call up Detective Phạm and tell her that one of the superheroes she’s responsible for tried to kidnap and murder the other.”

“What will that accomplish?” asks Kinetiq incredulously.

“Phạm needs to know that Graywytch can’t be relied on.” Doc shrugs. “Also, it’s vindictive and bitchy and will ruin Myra’s day.”

“I like that plan!” I say. “I am all for that plan!”

Uh, why aren't we also alerting... every superhero in the world? Hell, call up the supervillains and the civilian capes while you're at it, I imagine they don't want to lose their powers either. Seriously, you should be preparing to recreate that bit with the train from Across the Spider-Verse. Also, cast something on Garrison, you fucking pinheads!

“Then we knock down his satellites,” says Doc, flicking her phone to life. “With a little data mining I can get you the orbital track of everything Garrison’s company has put into space. We take those down, and we stop him before he gets started.”


“That might be dangerous,” says Charlie. “Magically speaking, I mean.”


“How sure are you?” asks Calamity.


Charlie shrugs. “Zero percent; I really have no idea, but it’s a risk we need to consider before you send Dreadnought up there.”


“Doc, get to working on those orbital tracks,” says Calamity. “Charlie, what would you need to be absolutely sure?”

Again, surely you can call up other orbit-capable heroes.

“There’s something else to consider,” says Doc. “As a permanent reserve member, I only have a tie-breaking vote, but since Graywytch hopped the aisle—” More superhero slang. It means a whitecape going evil or a blackcape trying to reform. “—then as far as the bylaws go, she’s forfeited her seat in the Legion. Which makes me and Magma the only two voting members left. Bylaws say I’ve got to inform him that I’m lifting the membership veto, but I doubt he’ll object under the circumstances.”

“Meaning what, Doctor?”

“Congratulations, we just refounded the Legion Pacifica.”


Who cares? Hurray, this random collection of unrelated super-teens of identity have inherited a dead superhero team's name! Why do these people want to turn into women so much, when they're clearly transitioning to Vogonity!
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
my body curled up protectively around my chest in midair.
Danny's first instinct is to protect his gigantic bazongas. "My preciousssss..."

Anyway, this supervillain plot just derailed even further into nonsense. The plan requires Garrison, personally, to be alive and broadcasting his powers over the planet? What is the long-term plan here? Remember, Garrison isn't just in this to have fun as long as he lives, he's a neoreactionary who wants to set up a dynasty of dictators. Are they going to have to keep using the Magic Space Rock to create more power-nullifying supers, and then remake all the Hired Goon Amulets with new blood every generation?

Think of how many moving parts we have here. For Neoreactionary Arcadia to remain functioning, you have to have:
- Nemesis still being available (and remember, it is still cruisin' on through space)
- The Nemesis-manipulating moonbase operational and staffed
- A power-nullifying dictator
- A constellation of nullifier satellites
- A wizard to operate the moonbase/satellite rig, and make amulets for the hired goons
- Some way of raising a new, loyal generation of nullifiers and wizards (or a way to become immortal)
- An army of hypertech engineers just to keep this up and running

All of that just to begin the mundane work of raising an army that can conquer the world. You still have to actually conquer the world and set up your new monarchy.
And if any part of this fails, suddenly you'll have a planet full of enraged supers out for your blood.
Why not just run for president of some country, or start your own? Garrison could have just declared himself King Of Sealand and nobody would have batted an eye.

...So, story's over, right? You literally have an artifact that lets you cast whatever magic you want on the main baddie, and a wizard
And we've already established that mixing magic and hypertech will get you the Wizarding World's death penalty. If Charlie doesn't know Avada Kedavra himself, he can just take the amulet to the Council of Avalon and ask someone who does.

but since Graywytch hopped the aisle—” More superhero slang. It means a whitecape going evil or a blackcape trying to reform. “—then as far as the bylaws go, she’s forfeited her seat in the Legion
Hold on, so everything about Legion bylaws is mired in pointless troonocracy, but declaring a member to be a blackcape is something you can just do without any sort of trial or administrative hearing? They haven't even told Detective Pham or anyone else in the municipal bureaucracy about this yet, let alone presented evidence. How typically troonish - rules are only ever a means to an end.

Also, it's kind of weird that Doc was all gung-ho about "being human" but apparently never picked an actual first name.
Her first name is Doctor. :smug:
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Back