Dreadnought: The Quest for Cringe - White-Kettle-Shufflepunk reads a trans YA superhero novel

To be fair, it seems like this plan failed because Panzer kicked the shit out Kinetiq, which I find very funny. Maybe there's a reason she doesn't have a steady hero gig.
I kinda hope that's the explanation behind her sudden absence. A tryhard non-binary anarchist beaten by a rich brat with superior firepower. Money prevails over ideals, that's the right message!

But this is written by Daniels, sadly. Non-binary anarchist checkbox is not allowed to lose. That would send the wrong message to the intended audience.
 
“Doc says she needs nurses,” shouts Calamity. “Who here is a combat medic?”


A few of the prisoners raise their hands, including one whose wrists are zip-tied together. Most of the prisoners and walking wounded were escorted over by Calamity and a bemused Codex, who looked incredibly uncomfortable to be holding a submachine gun. A few of the more serious injuries were strapped to stretchers so I could airlift them directly into the surgical bay.


One of these was Kinetiq. We found them collapsed on the steps of the mansion, bleeding heavily from the gut where one of Panzer’s bullets had gotten in under their armor.

See? One twelve year old girl with a load of guns who's honest about her sex trumps one handmaiden in denial of vague age and equally vague light themed powers. I suspect this is related to why kid Jon Kent is so much better than teen Jon Kent.

Just before they went under the anesthesia, they turned to me and said, “I can’t believe I got smoked by The Littlest Princess.”

But the fact you're "brown" and "non-binary" is totally why you haven't been given a full-time contract.

That’s how we came to organize an olly-olly-oxen-free for every Silver Mountain goon who hadn’t been taken out in the fighting. Calamity got on the PA and told them what was up and that they had ten minutes, and then she was going to personally shoot every goon she could find who hadn’t surrendered or fled.

I mean, I'm glad Calamity offered the goons mercy, but it kind of amuses me she phrased it like she was going to pull a Columbine if they didn't take it.

Further, she informed them that she’d run out of everything except plain old lead bullets. It turned out to be a powerful motivator.

"Oh, shit, a teenage girl is going to come and shoot us. We better surrender now, even though we outnumber her, know the lay of the land better, and are trained mercenaries and shit."

This would of course be even sillier if Garrison had remembered he could give anyone he liked whatever superpowers he wanted. At this point, I'm genuinely not sure why Daniels included that. It should be momentously important, but it's practically irrelevant to the plot. It's like if, in the latest Robert Galbraith novel, someone discovered a magic spell that resurrected the dead with no drawbacks whatsoever, and all they did was use it for insurance fraud.

Actually, no. It's dumber than that. At least the hypothetical warlock is actually using the spell, if for very petty purposes. If Garrison was that smart, he'd at least equip all his goons with Luke Cage powers. This is more like if the guy had this resurrection spell... and still went to the trouble of faking his dead the ordinary way.

Here, let's try to make this book less stupid. So, we have Garrison contact Danny with this amazing process he's invented that can give anyone--who can pay--superpowers, and he wants Danny to be his spokesperson for the program. Danny enthusiastically accepts, only to discover the truth later: Garrison can't produce new powers from thin air, only drain and transfer them between people. He's actually been kidnapping and draining super-powered civilians and maybe lesser known heroes and villains in order to sell their powers to the highest bidder.

This is where you'd get his spiel about how people who have power but not the iron will to use it don't deserve it, which would play into Danny's disbelief that anyone with superpowers would choose to lead quiet, humble lives. It'd also handily explain why Garrison doesn't just Zerg-rush everyone with an army of Dreadnought tier supers, because he can't!

The mercenaries who volunteered to be nurses file past us. Calamity snicks open a utility blade and cuts the zip ties off of one, then deftly slips the tip of the blade a little ways up his nostril, just far enough to get his attention.

“I want to remind you that both the Doctors Impossible shoot lasers out of their hands and that the fine young lady in blue over yonder is literally Dreadnought.

"And she's a crazed lunatic who literally sees her father's face on everyone she fights"

“We did it,” I say, wrapping my good arm around her shoulder. Dart in for a kiss on her cheek. “You did it.”

Without preamble, Sarah drops the Calamity voice and says, “We killed thirteen men today, Danny.”

My smile curdles. “Oh.”

Danny: Still haven't beaten my personal record!

It must be annoying being the only decent person in this story.

“I’m not naive. I know with how rough I play…” Sarah pulls away from me, leans up against a wall. “It’s different when I can’t pretend the ambulance will show up in time.”


“We didn’t have a choice. They forced this.”


“I know that!” she says, not angry, but urgent. Helpless. “But, I close my eyes and I see the bodies, and—I didn’t know it would feel this way.”


I step in close, slowly, and her posture opens, lets me in. “You’re a good person, Sarah,” I whisper. “I trust you. I love you.”

If Daniel Tozer told me that, I'd be terrified for my immortal soul.

Forehead to forehead, we stand for a moment, my fingers tracing through the hair behind her ear. The excitement of battle has faded, leaving us low. I’m glad that she lets me comfort her. It means I don’t have to think about myself.


Calamity pulls her bandanna mask down and kisses me, hard. My arm wraps around her neck and I return every ounce of it, low moans rising from the base of my throat. After hours, or seconds, she breaks away and searches my eyes.


“Did that help?” I ask.


“I don’t know.” She pulls the bandanna back up over her nose. “Let’s go check on Codex.”

I'd get myself checked for love spells, too.

“What’s the word, Codex?” asks Calamity as we enter.

He shakes his head. “My parents are going to kill me when we get home.”

“Are you kidding?” I ask. “You saved the world.”

“You don’t know my parents too well.”

"I mean, saving the world is one thing, but hanging out with you? Honestly, they'd be right to ground me."

The spells are stable, their powers are muted. They’re not going anywhere.”


“If the spell works by mimicking Garrison’s powers, then shouldn’t binding him make the other amulets not work?” I ask.


He shakes his head and returns his focus to his work. “No, that would violate recursive causality,” he says, as if that should mean something.

I swear to Christ, all Charlie's dialogue in this book is just "Actually, it turns out the inviolate laws of magic work out exactly in our favour, all the time, forever."

I don't even get this. The spell can't dampen Garrison's powers, because then the spell wouldn't work. So shouldn't it just... not?

“None of this will stick, you know,” says Garrison. With his hands and legs bound and his suit all ripped up, nah, I’m not calling him by his supranym anymore.


“Yeah, whatever, Dingus.”

Troons have this real thing about not using their enemies' "preferred names." Like when they call J.K Rowling "Joanne." Except, J.K Rowling isn't the sound that makes Joanne Rowling's soul sing or whatever, it's just her pen-name, one she originally adopted because her agent or publisher thought boys would be more willing to read a book they didn't think was written by a woman. When they call her "Joanne" the worst they're doing is being... overly familiar, I guess? It's literally them projecting their own neuroses onto the rest of humanity.

I guess it works a little better here, since "Sovereign" actually is Garrison's trumped up supervillain name, but then, why not actually call him Garrison--a mundane, boring name, most popularly associated with a sexually demented cartoon character?

“You stupid child, you still don’t understand—everything you’ve done today, I can undo with the stroke of a pen.” His smile is thin and cruel. “My attorneys will gut you and have your skull for an ash tray.”


“Pay him no mind, Dreadnought,” says Calamity with a warning in her tone. It hurts that she feels like she needs to keep a leash on me, but maybe I earned that.


Still, I can’t resist twisting the knife. With a reassuring squeeze of Calamity’s hand, I smile at Garrison. “And how are they going to do that when they’re deciding if it’s even worth keeping you out of prison? Whoever you had spying on me should have done a better job of reading my mail—my federal hero license finally came through.”


It was a close call. The license arrived while I was in jail, and Cecilia had to make some big promises—desperate promises, really—to keep it from getting instantly suspended until my trial was complete.

I really want to know what possible promises Cecilia could've made that would've convinced someone to give a murder suspect--who's been recorded breaking into a superheroine's home and making paranoid death threats--essentially a license to kill. Bet it was some Epstein-tier shit. If Cecilia ever goes to a hospital to give birth and comes back without her baby, now you know why.

Garrison’s face goes blank. I think he knows what’s coming, but it’s so fun spelling it out: “You’re about to get acquainted with my three favorite words in the world—civil asset forfeiture. When I was in the holding cell, Cecilia did an analysis of your public earning statements compared with the sort of costs that would be necessary to fund this operation, and it looks like your entire fortune is bound up in this scheme, isn’t it? That makes everything you own an accessory to kidnapping, murder, and terrorism. So we’re seizing it all. Every company you own, every account you hold, every last penny. I bet it’ll be hard to pay for lawyers when your money is all tied up in court. When you said you could make me a rich woman, you weren’t thinking you would do it this way, were you?”

Because as we all know, rich people always report all their earnings and assets with the most scrupulous honesty. Also, civil asset forfeiture is actually a really controversial thing--on both the left and the right, no less--so it's really funny seeing Daniels blithely wank to it.

“Nothing you can prove I’ve done is illegal,” he says, but with the way his skin has gone the color of sour milk, I don’t think anyone believes him. “Spectral evidence is inadmissible.

Which is funny, considering this is a world where magic is a publicly acknowledged fact.

“Once she’s done sewing up your men, the best hacker in the world is going to go have her way with your hard drives. There’s no security you can buy that will keep her out of a drive she has physical access to, and I will bet that she’ll find things you were trying to keep secret. When you get out of prison, you’re going to be a poor old man nobody remembers or cares about.”

"Well, an old man with high-level superpowers and the ability to negate the the superpowers of others, but that's a problem for Future-Us, as our fellow idiots often say."

“Why don’t you just leave us alone!” shouts Panzer. She’s at the edge of tears, and for a moment I feel bad about saying all that to her dad in front of her. “Because of you, the world’s going to keep drowning in poor people and losers!”

Welp. Never mind.

God forbid the little girl have internalised the bullshit her dad's been feeding her since birth, not like Danny, who apparently was shat from his mother's womb knowing everything his parents told him was unequivocally wrong.

We’re at the door when it happens. A deep thrum of power running right through my chest, shooting down to the soles of my boot and up to the top of my skull. The world seems to go pale and blue, and then I’m falling. My guts are a greasy knot pulled tight, painfully tight, spasms in my legs, my hands, flaring every injury into a fizzing scarlet beacon. Someone is moaning in agony, and as Calamity flips me over on my back I realize it’s me.


On the heels of that, I realize it’s Codex and Garrison too. A great wail of voices raised in misery drifts down the hallway from the triage point. The pain passes, and leaves in its wake a sense of profound disquiet. All my injuries seem worse, and I am so tired I can barely lift my head from the carpet.


Doc’s voice crackles in my earpiece. “What the fuck? Two of my patients just coded.”

So, as much as Daniels is probably incapable of actually executing any idea well, there was a ghost of a good premise with Garrison and company. Superpowered, self-appointed aristocrats who feel it is their right and duty to rule over the masses would be a great dark mirror for superheroes in the right hands. However, Daniels is a troon, and troons are physically incapable of thinking deeply about anything that isn't directly related to troons, so...

“The satellite system is active again,” he says after consulting his mirror for a moment. He pulls a crystal from one of his pockets and lets it dangle from a leather thong. It hangs for a moment and then rises up to point northwest. “It’s broadcasting a new spell that’s being bounced up from the surface. It’s probably coming from New Port.”

“But what’s she doing?” asks Calamity, voice tight with urgency.

Codex ignores her. “Doc, is everyone in the triage center down?”

“No, I’ve got two who didn’t feel it.”

“Do they happen to be women?” Codex and I make eye contact.

“…yes.”

No.

Oh God, please no.

That's right, Graywytch is trying to kill every man and boy in the entire world. Because that's what every woman who opposes TRA nonsense actually wants: to kill all the men. It's definitely not because any of them don't want to see their brothers, sons, and friends destroy themselves and hurt others pursuing an impossible dream, or because they don't approve of children being gaslit, drugged, and mutilated because they're a bit different. No, it's because they all just hate men.

Funny how that somehow includes "women" like Daniels, isn't it? Almost as though there's some overlap...
 
Last edited:
First, obviously, trying to impound Garrison's wealth is retarted troon-logic. Even given the asset-stores, Garrison put a network of fucking infinite-range magic-broadcasting sattelites in orbit. And while I appreciate the attempt for not-Superman to actually try to take away not-Lex-Luthor's sources of power, there simply isn't a legal justification for this, full stop. Danny, let's remember, is fucking paroled. Parole comes with conditions in every state I've looked at (which is like two, IANAL), and given that Danny, presumably, is about to have a whole shiny new set of charges lined up against him about the GreyWytch stuff as soon as he gets back, since "They're evil!" is not actually legal justification to break their possessions and their bones.

So, whatever troonshine Danny is trying to claim here would, if it were true, bounce back on him really fucking hard and fast. Also, speaking of which, how much hell could Garrison raise by mentioning that Doc and Danny brought a energy weapon into orbit and probably fucked with some very important non-proliferation treaties?

Of course, the actual answer is the same reason Danny got his heroing license. A world with supers like Danny is a world in which there is no rule of law. There is only power, and those who have it will forever trample over those who don't. The horrible dysfunction of the world of Dreadnought, brought about by authorial incompetence and impatience for the wish-fulfillment bits, have made a world that have done the impossible; they've turned a neoreactionary's motives comprehensible and made them actually be a reasonable response to the world around them.

What would have been better, and punchier, would have been for Garrison to have fucking exploded mid-jurisdictional argument, Team Dread (and Jesus, that name has become fully non-ironic) to quickly look and see which of them did it, and then the gendercide spell hit, and left it up to implication that GreyWytch has just taken out the one person with an off-button to her power before doing her main ritual.

"Actually, it turns out the inviolate laws of magic work out exactly in our favour, all the time, forever."
And not just magic. Magic and law and finance and hypertech drugs, which work always for Team Dread and never against them. They're weak crutches, and the fact that they need to be given to the Strongest Hero Eva!!! just makes Danny look weaker.

And the fact that it keeps happening robs the setting of so much of its impact. How the hell can waving a crystal around detect a magic radio broadcast?

I mean, actually, now that I mention it, quartz being piezoelectric actually does make it interact with radio waves and crystal radios were an early thing, so that's not the stupidest thing I've heard, but the point is that there is no set-up for it. There's no underlying metaphysics that makes it reasonable or not reasonable that Codex can detect "Hey, GreyWytch is doing the thing she clearly wanted to do since Book 1.", so there's no weight to it. When you can't predict what will happen at all, when you can't even exclude entire classes of events as unreasonable, then you don't increase tension, you murder it. When anything can happen, the fact that any specific thing did happen isn't interesting.

And I will give the author a pass on GreyWytch being a literal "Kill all men." radical feminist. That was her position before, and it's not really that uncommon a position in internet-posturing land. And when you have Magic Bullshit and can make yourself immune to scarcity and independent of global manufacturing, transportation, medicine, defense, and everything else that men do, then I absolutely buy that a crazy magic ideologue would murder half the world to bring about their supposed utopia. Hell, you could probably get a good what-if story about how fucked everyone without GreyWytch-level superpowers would be, when the gender revolution comes.

There exist non-batshit-misandrist feminists, even specifically trans-exclusive ones, and there will probably be more as $CURRENT_YEAR continues and more people start Noticing. But GreyWytch, explicitly and textually, is not one of them.

I also don't care enough to go back to GreyWytch's speech in the first book, but damn if she didn't have Danny's number when she said he had nothing but male violence in his repertoire, didn't she? Why the hell would you write that, as an author?

...Hell, I really actually can't contemptuously mock this book enough, can I? Isn't this entire second book more or less an explicit statement of the author to GreyWytch's online, real-life counterparts of "Yes, I am the brutal and violence monster you claim me to be, and there's nothing you can do about it, because I am strong enough to hurt you, and I will be given praise and approval for doing so, and so I revel in your screams of outrage."? Is there a single conflict in this book that Danny doesn't solve (or attempt to solve) with overwhelming, injurious violence?
 
See? One twelve year old girl with a load of guns who's honest about her sex trumps one handmaiden in denial of vague age and equally vague light themed powers.
Holy shit, no way! Daniels, you've got some balls to allow a non-binary anarchist PoC checkbox get defeated off-screen like a total bitch.

My hats off to Panzer. A strange villain, but one who has killed Doc's spare body and left Kinetiq for dead. This makes Panzer the most effective baddie in this shitty book thus far.

Your baddies suck, Daniels.

“We did it,” I say, wrapping my good arm around her shoulder. Dart in for a kiss on her cheek. “You did it.”

Without preamble, Sarah drops the Calamity voice and says, “We killed thirteen men today, Danny.”

My smile grows. “Nice.”
Fixed it for you, Daniels. Gotta stay consistent with your characters' personality, it's important!

"Actually, it turns out the inviolate laws of magic work out exactly in our favour, all the time, forever."
"It's magic, I ain't gotta explain shit."

“You stupid child, you still don’t understand—everything you’ve done today, I can undo with the stroke of a pen.” His smile is thin and cruel. “My attorneys will gut you and have your skull for an ash tray.”
And so Danny tore out Garrison's remaining eye.

Where is Garrison's bravado coming from?

Seriously. Last time we saw Garrison he was half-dead, brutalized, rendered powerless, and begging his daughter to stand down to save her life.

So how do we get from that to Garrison casually threatening the sadistic psychopath right in front of him? What's with the massive shift in his attitude? Am I missing something?

“You’re about to get acquainted with my three favorite words in the world—civil asset forfeiture."
And Danny is about to get acquainted with Garrison's three favorite words in the world - Swiss bank accounts.

“Once she’s done sewing up your men, the best hacker in the world is going to go have her way with your hard drives. There’s no security you can buy that will keep her out of a drive she has physical access to."
You better hope Doc won't get infected by whatever security booby trap Garrison has on his hard drives. Last time Doc got compromised she kinda wiped out half the characters of the previous book.

“Why don’t you just leave us alone!” shouts Panzer. She’s at the edge of tears, and for a moment I feel bad about saying all that to her dad in front of her. “Because of you, the world’s going to keep drowning in poor people and losers!”

Welp. Never mind.
Danny, rub it in more! Tell her she will never see her dad again. Tell her she and her daddy will be locked in small containers for the rest of their lives. She will never use her powers again, nor will she see the light of day.

Actually, how do they intend to deal with her? Will they throw her in one of the anti-super cells, stab her with needles and feed her by tubes?

That's right, Graywytch is trying to kill every man and boy in the entire world.
But who will fix the door to her apartment then...?

Allow me an alternate, more plot/character accurate explanation:

Graywytch is scared shitless of Danny.

Her magic does not work on him and he keeps threatening her, breaking into her home, beating her, strangling her, and accusing her of being a black cape. And this motherfucker just got his federal hero license. Not even the law can keep him on a leash anymore.

And she knows he will be after her now, she knows he will slowly strangle her to death - if he's merciful, that is.

Out of options, Graywytch uses the satelites to drop a magical nuke that kills all men in the world.

She will kill all men to stop one man. Danny.

She is so terrified of him she resorts to extreme measures just to save herself from a sadistic, sociopathic monster.

Danny is to blame for the entire situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Where is Garrison's bravado coming from?

Seriously. Last time we saw Garrison he was half-dead, brutalized, rendered powerless, and begging his daughter to stand down to save her life.

So how do we get from that to Garrison casually threatening the sadistic psychopath right in front of him? What's with the massive shift in his attitude? Am I missing something?
How else is he gonna set up Danny for an epic legal verbal takedown!?

“Once she’s done sewing up your men, the best hacker in the world is going to go have her way with your hard drives. There’s no security you can buy that will keep her out of a drive she has physical access to."
Better hope Garrison has no contingency to erase incriminating files or burry his involvement behind third party shell operations or has hidden a super lawyer super power. As we know, these Lex Luthor character types are terrible at finding loopholes or having back up plans to keep their association hidden.
 
Another silly thought I had: Earth-10 Dreadnought. For those not in the know, Earth-10 is one of the DC alternate realities, one in which Kal-El's escape pod crash-lands in the occupied Sudetenland in 1938, leading to the Germans conquering the world with reverse-engineered Kryptonian technology. In this timeline, Superman is called Overman, and he leads a team of Axis superheroes. (Nazi Flash is a thing. He's basically the same, except he has two lightning bolts on his chest instead of one.)

Anyway, I've been thinking of how much better the book would be if it were set in a knockoff Earth-10 with a protagonist to match. Danny would be a swarthy mutt or mischling collaborator who got turned into a 6'2" blond-haired blue-eyed Übermensch by Das Orben der Plotincitinwiffelschaft. The backstory would presumably be the same but inverted, with the German hero Kriegsschiff winning WW2 for Germany, and it being passed down through the decades. Danny's dad hates him because Danny sympathizes with the German overlords or something. Greywytch is replaced with the Doctor von Sieg guy who gets a brief mention in the Dreadnought exposition. He's a very old-fashioned Himmlerite who believes that just because Danny is now physically Aryan doesn't make him spiritually so.
 
Last edited:
This has been a trip, and I'm looking forward to the end. Is there still no news about a third book? I noticed this hack has a wikipedo page (trans privilege) that mentions it's a trilogy. Wonder if the coof-shot ended up making the author even more braindead.

Weirdly this has all left me a little inspired. I know that I'm a terrible writer, but shit you're telling me all I need to do is put on a wig and shit out some shlock? I don't know anything about capeshit, but it seems like that's not a prerequisite.
 
Maybe they'll process her into an Aiden.
"Inside every natal female is a trans man trying to get out out!"

Another silly thought I had: Earth-10 Dreadnought. For those not in the know, Earth-10 is one of the DC alternate realities, one in which Kal-El's escape pod crash-lands in the occupied Sudetenland in 1938, leading to the Germans conquering the world with reverse-engineered Kryptonian technology. In this timeline, Superman is called Overman, and he leads a team of Axis superheroes. (Nazi Flash is a thing. He's basically the same, except he has two lightning bolts on his chest instead of one.)

Anyway, I've been thinking of how much better the book would be if it were set in a knockoff Earth-10 with a protagonist to match. Danny would be a swarthy mutt or mischling collaborator who got turned into a 6'2" blond-haired blue-eyed Übermensch by Das Orben der Plotincitinwiffelschaft. The backstory would presumably be the same but inverted, with the German hero Kriegsschiff winning WW2 for Germany, and it being passed down through the decades. Danny's dad hates him because Danny sympathizes with the German overlords or something. Greywytch is replaced with the Doctor von Sieg guy who gets a brief mention in the Dreadnought exposition. He's a very old-fashioned Himmlerite who believes that just because Danny is now physically Aryan doesn't make him spiritually so.
Impressive how a crappy book can produce ideas that are silly, over the top, and most importantly, entertaining.

Danny lives in the Sudetenland, with his dad being a Sudeten German farmer who returned a crippled man from the war. As such, the dad cannot do much of the difficult work at the farmstead and the land falls into disrepair.

The same lazy faggot as in the original book, Danny gives his father crap for it, but rather than helping, he skips work on the farm by attending Hitlerjugend and huffing national socialism.

Danny hates his mother for being a Sudeten Czech and is constantly at odds with his father for marrying her. "Love has no right to exist when it comes to racial purity," Danny seethes over dinner, "You shouldn't have married a filthy, inferior Schwein. She makes us look bad! Different bloods should not mix!"

Like in the original book, Danny's parents hope he grows out of it.

Danny is an outcast at school, alongside his best friend, David. David is a Mischling of the second degree, his grandmother was Jewish. Later in the book, after becoming Kriegsschiff, Danny wants to erase this mistake of a friendship. He accuses David of tearing down a propaganda poster. "His grandmother was a Jew. Obviously it shows." David disappears after this.
 
Danny lives in the Sudetenland, with his dad being a Sudeten German farmer who returned a crippled man from the war. As such, the dad cannot do much of the difficult work at the farmstead and the land falls into disrepair.
That's even better than what I had in mind, which was more a straight copy of the plot of Dreadnought with the names and themes switched out. Like in the Man in the High Castle Timeline, the US is partitioned between the Axis powers. I'm imagining that not!Portland is a Free City jointly administered by Germany and Japan, which lets us throw in some Grorious Nippon flavor to break up the Nazi-themed capes, and handwave why the local government hasn't gone full Nuremberg Laws. The local A-List team could be called something like the Aryan Brotherhood, and would consist of Kriegsschiff, Doctor von Sieg (Doctor Strange but Nazi), Valkyrja (pretty much unchanged), Ardito (the token wop), Ronin (so called because he has been disavowed by the IJN, they just don't have enough pull in the Free City to get a major hero disbarred), and Uncle Sam (occupier propaganda edition).

Sarah/Calamity is now the granddaughter of a Klan leader who was a cape, and she fights under the name White Rider. She opposes the Powers What Is because she's a believer in the traditional American school of extreme racism and doesn't much care for this new-fangled German nonsense.
 
Sarah/Calamity is now the granddaughter of a Klan leader who was a cape, and she fights under the name White Rider. She opposes the Powers What Is because she's a believer in the traditional American school of extreme racism and doesn't much care for this new-fangled German nonsense.
This in particular is just brilliant.

Imagine the first meeting between Danny and the Aryan Brotherhood.

Doctor von Sieg: "Daniel, as I am sure you have noti--"

Danny: "Kriegsschiff. My name is Kriegsschiff."

Doctor von Sieg: "As I am sure you have noticed, Daniel, it is highly unusual for the Aryan Brotherhood to accept someone of mixed blood."

Danny: "Kriegsschiff, I am Kriegsschiff! And I am a pure blooded Aryan, I have always been! A pure Aryan born in the wrong body!"

Doctor von Sieg: "Insecurity about one's race. How typical of lesser creatures."

Lemme add some 'baddies'.

Monarch - Garrison in this setting. Kinda like Tony Stark with a touch of magic. American industrialist and brilliant engineer who actively collaborates with the nazis to accumulate both wealth and influence. His plan is to combine state of art tech with Doctor von Sieg's occult arts to liberate the US, Make America Great Again, and rule as its king.

Princess Howitzer - Monarch's little daughter, sporting a pink, child-sized power armor equipped with enough firepower to challenge the whole Reich. Deadliest character in the second book.

After Monarch dies at Danny's hands, Doctor von Sieg uses Monarch's technology to amplify a spell to kill all who have a drop of lesser blood in their veins in a desperate bid to kill Danny. The spell backfires as unbeknownst to Doctor von Sieg, one of his ancestors boned a gypsy witch.
 
This in particular is just brilliant.

Imagine the first meeting between Danny and the Aryan Brotherhood.



Lemme add some 'baddies'.

Monarch - Garrison in this setting. Kinda like Tony Stark with a touch of magic. American industrialist and brilliant engineer who actively collaborates with the nazis to accumulate both wealth and influence. His plan is to combine state of art tech with Doctor von Sieg's occult arts to liberate the US, Make America Great Again, and rule as its king.

Princess Howitzer - Monarch's little daughter, sporting a pink, child-sized power armor equipped with enough firepower to challenge the whole Reich. Deadliest character in the second book.

After Monarch dies at Danny's hands, Doctor von Sieg uses Monarch's technology to amplify a spell to kill all who have a drop of lesser blood in their veins in a desperate bid to kill Danny. The spell backfires as unbeknownst to Doctor von Sieg, one of his ancestors boned a gypsy witch.
If we want to combine it with some ideas that were floated about to fix the first book upthread, we can work in how most of the Aryan Brotherhood are down with the new Kriegsschiff, and it's just Doctor von Sieg who's the lone dissenter. Ronin doesn't particularly care about autistic racial purity, Ardito is mostly concerned with preserving the legacy of Die Kriegsschiffe (he and Kriegsschiff 3 fought Red Steel above Stalingrad or w/e) and as far as Vakyrja is concerned, Aryan is as Aryan does.

I do like the idea of Monarch as a supervillain. Since the Business Plot was a thing in the US in real life, having a cape themed after it in Nazi-occupied America would make perfect sense.
 
Last edited:
If we want to combine it with some ideas that were floated about to fix the first book upthread, we can work in how most of the Aryan Brotherhood are down with the new Kriegsschiff, and it's just Doctor von Sieg who's the lone dissenter. Ronin doesn't particularly care about autistic racial purity, Ardito is mostly concerned with preserving the legacy of Die Kriegsschiffe (he and Kriegsschiff 3 fought Red Steel above Stalingrad or w/e) and as far as Vakyrja is concerned, Aryan is as Aryan does.

I do like the idea of Monarch as a supervillain. Since the Business Plot was a thing in the US in real life, having a cape themed after it in Nazi-occupied America would make perfect sense.
Nice! Really shows how much the far-left mindset kills creativity.

And since, unlike Daniels, I can use my creative autism to make interesting shit, here is Malice/Utopia's replacement. Like every villain in Daniels' books, Malice was pretty boring, so I am making her entertaining.

Elohim - Benevolent Jewish version of Deathshead from Wolfenstein. Old scientist/researcher used by the nazis for his intellect and breakthrough discoveries in robotics. Responsible for artificial limbs and organs supplied to wounded Axis soldiers. Also invents autonomous robot surgeons (think semi-Terminator-looking, serial produced version of Doc Impossible). Actually improves people's lives with his inventions.

A genius mind trapped in an ageing body, he decides to cheat death by removing his brain, preserving it in a jar, and hooking it to a supercomputer so humanity can continue to benefit from his genius. The procedure works. Technically, at least.

He emerges as an insane robot-god calling itself Elohim, and wants nothing less than to remove everyone's brain and put it into a machine to create a deathless robot utopia with himself as its eternal overseer. His robot creations and everyone supplied with robotic limbs go berserk. This could include Danny's dad.

Elohim wages a short, brutal war against humanity until Danny/Kriegsschiff smashes Elohim's jar and stomps the brain several times.

countless Daniels-esque paragraphs describing Danny's sadistic joy over getting Jewish brain matter all over his combat boots
 
I kind of hate the way Dreadnought makes me think about certain things. For instance, Charlie's family. If I read a normal book where one of the supporting characters was a black lad with a doctor for a father and a homemaker for a mother, I wouldn't think much of it. In a book like Dreadnought, meanwhile, I can't help but notice he's the only one with a functioning nuclear family.
 
Right, let's get this shit done. When we last left April Daniels, he was recreating the climax of X2 but with misandry instead of mutants. Yes, Graywytch not only hates troons, but all men. This of course didn't stop her from apparently working just fine for years with male superheroes, to the point where she enjoyed the benefit of the doubt of both the city government and the wider superhero community.

We open with Danny flying fill tilt towards Legion Tower, as all the expected carnage from all the men in the world starting to die at once unfolds beneath him.

At my top speed, I can cover the distance from Cynosure to New Port in a little over twenty minutes. I never thought that would feel slow. Another pulse of the spell sweeps over me, and I grit my teeth and put myself on an upward trajectory before it becomes too much. Once again the spell makes me lose my grip, but I’m on a ballistic trajectory now and keep going up. I peak and begin the long, uncontrolled descent into a forest. At the last instant, I’m able to catch myself and get back in the air before I go smashing through the trees.


A small cabin in the woods is on fire as I pass. A woman is pulling a limp man out of the burning building. That’s all I have time to see before I’m thousands of feet beyond her.

So, clearly the spell is straight up knocking men out as it kills them. Remember that.

She did it. She really did it. Graywytch told me this was coming, and I didn’t realize what she meant. When she had me strapped down to that table in the dungeon below Cynosure, she said women can only be pushed so far before they push back. And of course, her definitions of man, woman, and push are all so fucked up it could have meant anything.

Oh, yeah, who could possibly know what Myra meant by the word woman? Crazy bitch could be talking about a squirrel for all any of us know. And push? Danny just burst into her home and threatened to kill her because his parents had legal representation and his lawyer's mobile-reception was spotty. Real snowflake, am I right?

It could have meant anything, but it meant this:


The flat-out murder of half the human population.


All the signs were there, and I missed it. Her neglect of her superhero duties. Her strained alliance with Garrison. The shoddy magic she performed for him—almost as if her real concern was somewhere else, on a different project.

Yeah, all those things totally add up to "kill all men." It's all so obvious.

Now that it’s happening, I can see how they all fit together: if her definition of what makes a man and what makes a woman isn’t respected anymore, she’ll simply remove men from the discussion. “Men” like me.

I love the scare quotes around "men" when we're talking about a teenage boy who used the powers of the universe to remold himself into a woman-shaped fuck-object with no uterus.

Like anyone with a Y chromosome, I bet.

Yeah, that's a pretty good definition. Shame about the women with androgen insensitivity syndrome, but still, a description that fits 99.99% of any given group is better than most.

More than three-and-a-half billion people, all dead, and then a mad scramble to figure out how to keep the species going.

So, has Graywytch considered that at all? I know Daniels is clearly writing her as a mad-dog bitch, but I can't imagine she wants her ideal all-lady civilisation to die out after one generation. When Akasha came up with basically the same plan in Queen of the Damned, she at least specified she'd be keeping one man alive for every hundred women.

I feel like the more I tell you good readers about my taste in books, the less you'll trust my opinions.

They’ve radioed ahead to tell the NPPD to arrest Graywytch, but if the highways and towns I’ve been flying over are any indication, downtown New Port will be such a mess it will be amazing if the cops can even get to Legion Tower on foot, much less with enough firepower to do anything about this.

Why? I mean, obviously arresting Graywytch would be a good idea, but why do the police believe them now? I mean, I could see them going by what I assume are many misandrist comments she's made in the past, but those didn't seem to matter before. Again, Daniels doesn't seem to realise his characters are meant to have "existed" before the start of the story.

“Codex, are you still with us?”


His voice is weak and raspy over the radio. “Yeah. I’m here.”


I have to fight down another surge of nausea to get my next sentence out. “What do I do?”


“Find her. Stop her.”

Helpful. Also, how is Codex still conscious? I can (begrudgingly) accept Danny being more resistant to the spell because he's a tough bastard, but he's just a kid who knows some spells.

“I don’t see her. What do I look for?” And now I do vomit, a half-mouthful of acid and bile. There’s nothing left in me, but I still can’t get right. My ears are ringing, my lips are numb.


“Can’t even begin to guess,” says Codex.


“Dreadnought, she’ll be in her library if she’s anywhere,” says Doctor Impossible. “That’s where she always disappeared to when she needed to work something big.”

Luckily, Myra didn't think it might be a good idea to do her genocide ritual anywhere except the first place anyone who knew anything about her would check.

With an effort that makes my head swim I push myself back to my feet and try to get over to the elevator. Between one step and the next I forget how to walk and end up sprawled cheek-down on the floor.


The floor that I now realize is shaking with ponderous footsteps. I roll to look back over my shoulder. A twelve-foot-tall golem of concrete and rebar looks down at me, eyes like two burning points of green fire. The monster stares down at me, cocks its head. Knives edged in green-white fire begin to push themselves up out of the concrete. I can feel the heat radiating off the blades even from down on the floor.


“Oh, come on!” I shout. “That’s not even close to fair!”

Yes, it is unfair that Graywytch only starts getting halfway creative with her limitless magical power near the end. Danny asks Doc how to kill the thing, and her advice is this:

Seawater,” says Doc.


“What?”


“Seawater always blocked her. Abort the mission, get out of there.” Doctor Impossible sounds like she hates herself right now. “Once you’re under the ocean, her magic should have trouble reaching you. You’ll be safe.”


“No.”


“You just need to hold your breath for twelve hours, I can get to you!” She’s at the edge of pleading.


“Can’t do that, Doc. All those people will die.”


“We can clone more sperm, and the species will go on. There’s no reason to throw your life away!”

God, can you imagine, an entire world descended from Danny. I'd rather scour the ocean for the bits of those poor people on that sub a few weeks back.

Does it make me a bad person that I like hearing her say these things? I don’t know. I don’t care. If I’m going to die, I’m happy to die listening to someone trying to trade half of humanity for me. But quitting isn’t an option, and she knows it.

Trust Danny to even make a heroic sacrifice weird and gross.
“Sarah, are you there?” I ask.


“I am,” she says.


I close my eyes and savor the sound of her voice. “I’m sorry I waited so long.”


“It’s okay. I should have said something.” Her voice is wavering, but she’s holding it together. It makes me happy to know she’ll be okay. “I love you. Die proud.”

But most importantly, die.

My fist tightens. One way or the other, this will be quick. Take a deep breath—


The tip of a sword bursts from the creature’s forehead with a screech of steel on stone. With a screaming shower of sparks, the sword forces its way through the golem from forehead to groin. The golem crashes to the ground in two twitching halves.


Karen stands behind it, dressed in steel armor, her wings unfurled. No, wait. That’s not Karen. She’s wearing Valkyrja’s armor, holding Valkyrja’s sword. She carries herself with Valkyrja’s posture, and when I look into her eyes there is no mistaking the ancient intelligence gazing back at me.


But Karen?


Karen is gone.


“You killed her.” I’m dimly surprised at myself. Karen betrayed me, abandoned me to be tortured to death, and still, I am outraged. Nobody deserves to be eaten from the inside out like that. Nobody.


Valkyrja shakes Karen’s head. “No. I embraced my nature. It is the way of things.”

So, Danny being born in a healthy male body like billions of other people was a great cosmic injustice, but Karen's soul being drowned out by the voice of a thousand ancestors is just 'the way of things'? Still, more selfless than anything Danny has ever done. Might've been a bit more effective if we'd seen Karen at all since the first quarter of the book, but still, points to her for trying.

“You going to kill me too, now?”

...Why would you think that? Valkyrja liked you!

A troubled look passes over her stolen face. “I have much to atone for. Please, let me begin.”


“This is another trick.”


“You are too weak to fight me. Graywytch has nearly won, and I could kill you without effort. Were I working with her, there would be no possible motive for deception,” says Valkyrja. She steps to a clear place on the floor and begins cutting a pattern in the carpet with the tip of her sword. “She has secreted her ritual away in another realm. It is a strategy I have seen her use before. I must open the way for you.”

I mean, I can't see why Valkyja would work with Graywytch. If there's no men, how would she produce new bodies for to steal?

Valkyrja looks up, eyes flashing. “I’m not dead, Danielle! This was my choice! Now is not the time to speak of it.” She steps back from the design, and with a hard thrust she stabs her sword through the barrier between worlds—the blade disappears into thin air, a silver mist billowing from the wound. Gripping her sword with both hands, she pulls the blade up and around until she has cut a rough oval in midair. Beyond it lies grass and trees and a night sky that is lit by a brilliant purple nebula.


“Win your battle,” says Valkyrja. “We will speak later.”


“I’m in no shape to fight. You want to atone? Go do it yourself.”

I love the idea of Danny trying to palm off killing Graywytch to someone else. It's unintentionally the most accurate depiction of troon work-ethic ever.

“I cannot open the way from the other side, nor keep the door clear once I leave it. I must stay here.”

“You could seal me in there.”

She nods. “I could. I won’t.”

You should.

I don’t trust her. I don’t trust this. But what choice do I have? Half-limping, half-floating, I cross into another world, and hope I’m not too late.

The wind on the other side is cool, crisp. The stars spill across a dark sky, and a luminous purple ribbon of nebular gases reaches from horizon to horizon. A glowing fog hugs the landscape in the distance. Flecks of light like campfire embers rise in swirling funnel clouds from the center of the fog bank. That had better be Graywytch’s ritual. The silver-edged portal dwindles rapidly behind me.

"Hah, sucker."

Also, if Grawytch can cast global genocide spells from another dimension, why did she have to be personally present for... anything?

There, the ritual site is just ahead, in a clearing under a full, red moon. There’s no time for subtlety, no time to check for traps or defenses. No time to find Graywytch and take her out first. I put everything I’ve got left into one headlong dive. It’s another Stonehenge wannabe. I aim myself at the biggest arch of stones in the center and get my good arm up to shield myself. In the instant before I hit, I see Graywytch lying in the grass, her robes stained with drying vomit.

Judging from the many groans I can hear in the distance, I'm guessing most of you have already guessed the next twist.

When I come to stand over her, she gets a look on her face. A look I’ll never forget. I can tell the exact moment she comes to the same realization that I have. That we’re alone. Truly alone in a way most people never experience.

It’s just her.

And me.

And no witnesses.

I'm shocked Danny's cock didn't just grow back.

So we come back to that tired old cliché: who you are in the dark is who you really are. If I go home, they will believe anything I tell them. I could say it was self-defense. I could say there was no other way. Nobody would know.

"See? If I mention it's a cliche, than it's actually clever!"

“I don’t remember when my father started screaming at me,” I tell her, and I’m as surprised as she is that this is coming out now. “But I know that by the time I was in kindergarten I was already afraid of him.”


Graywytch licks her lips. “What are—”
Shut up, or I will kill you.” She closes her mouth, and I keep going.

Danny, towering over a prone foe, giving a bitter speech about unrelated foes. Sane behaviour if I ever saw it.

He used to sit me on the couch and scream himself hoarse at me. Over any little thing. Not always the same things. Sometimes, forgetting to clean my room wasn’t a big deal. Sometimes it was a huge deal. It hurt. A lot. But nobody would help me. My mom abandoned me every time it happened. Grandma and Grandpa refused to get involved before they died. I think Mom was telling them I was exaggerating. I told a cop once, and he said to buzz off. So I grew up scared. I didn’t talk to people at school, more or less, because I didn’t know if I’d say something that would make them angry at me. And it got worse when I realized I wasn’t like the other boys. It got so much worse because this was something that I knew I couldn’t show. And I was terrified, all the time, every day, that I’d be found out. So I hid myself. All the time, on reflex. I would disappear, and when I couldn’t disappear I would try to be forgotten.

In other words, Danny is bitter he wasn't placed into foster-care... because his dad was a shouty dick. Words fail me.

“Dreadnought died. He gave me his powers. The Legion came to collect me. And for a few minutes there, you know, I thought I’d finally be safe. But then I met you.”


My jaw clenches. I have to force the words out, wet and raw. “And you took that from me. You did everything you could to make sure I wouldn’t have any place to be safe. For no reason. Why?”

"Safe"? You were being asked to join a superhero team! That's the opposite of safe! And technically speaking, Myra didn't actually "take" the Legion away from you, you refused to join, then Doc killed and maimed most of them because she forgot to update her antivirus software and didn't tell anyone.

She’s silent for a long moment. “Because—”


“I never cared that you don’t think I’m a girl, Myra!”

Bullshit. Troons can't even brook people privately doubting their bullshit.

I shout, and she flinches. If possible, she goes even paler than she normally is. “And I never wanted to be in your club. I just wanted there to be one place in the world where I wasn’t scared anymore. Where I didn’t have to hide myself.
So, Danny didn't really want to join the Legion, he just wanted it to be a safe-safe for him, at the expense of one of its present members.

Troons, man.
Would it have killed you to just keep your mouth shut?”

"Shut up, woman."

Graywytch stays silent. She’s petrified, and maybe I should feel bad or good or something about that, but I don’t. I rock back on my heels and land heavily on my butt, my knees drawn up protectively in front of me. All those years of pain, all those memories of tight fear and blaring terror, they’re all coming back. It’s like he’s here again, screaming at me until I want to die just so it can be over. Other kids’ dads teach them to fish or to play catch. Mine taught me I was too weak to defend myself. That it was always my fault. That nobody would ever love me.

If you showed someone this paragraph in isolation, I bet they'd assume Roger beat the sheet out of Dan, or at least have engaged in like... verbal abuse outside of summaries.

Also, notice that--rather than have Danny actually confront his father about all this--Daniels just has him take his frustration out at the woman cowering at her feet.

I tremble and my throat clenches up. I’ll never be free of it. What he did will haunt me for the rest of my life.


And I hated Graywytch for letting me know that so soon.

Way too much media for young people today basically has the message "you are permanently reduced by every shitty thing that happens to you."

But I don’t cry. Not because I’m ashamed or anything—with Graywytch half-dead from her own magic, I finally realize I have no reason whatsoever to give a shit what she thinks about me.

Troons know they're lying, and the only way they can pretend to themselves they aren't is if they get everyone to lie too.

I don’t cry because I realize I don’t need to. Because they gave me their worst, and I’m still here. Dad doesn’t get to choose if I’m happy, and neither does Graywytch.

"But if someone tweets something I don't like, they should be exiled from all public life."

Graywytch lies there, statue-still. Eyes locked to me. We stare at each other for a long time. She’s got dried vomit all over her chest. I make a sweeping gesture toward the mess. “Let me guess: your spell was targeted to the Y chromosome, but you’ve never had a karyotype test.”


It’s such a left-field question that it startles an answer from her. “What?”


“Your chromosomes. You never had them tested, did you?”

So, you know the hoary old trope of every homophobe being a closeted gay? Well, waste not, want not:

Her brow furrows, and the first emotion that isn’t fear works its way onto her face. Disgust. “Don’t lump me in with you. I’m a woman. I menstruate.”


“So? Sex is just as fuzzy as gender is.

No, it really isn't. Actually, I don't think "gender" is all that fuzzy either, so maybe it is.

You might not be trans, but you could be intersex.

Troons are so jealous of intersex people, which is a bit like being jealous of people with type-one diabetes. People who have developmental sex disorders are still either male or female. In fact, most if not all types of intersex disorders specifically occur in either men or woman, boys or girls. The idea their existence somehow casts "the sexual binary" into doubt is like thinking amputees means human beings aren't bipedal. It's kind of telling that the most common effect of intersex disorders is infertility. Having a broken arm doesn't make you double-jointed.

Most importantly, even if there were genuine hermaphrodites among the human race, Danny was never intersex. He was just a teenage boy who clearly thought he should've been born a girl because he didn't fit masculine stereotypes. Well, aside from the ones about men being violent brutes, obviously.

If you’d just looked it up you’d see there are women with Y chromosomes who can give birth. It’s not common, but it happens.”

I actually know of one case of this. Basically, there was a woman with androgen insensitivity syndrome who was lucky enough to have an underdeveloped womb. With some hormone therapy, she was later able to have a baby. However, she still didn't have any ovaries, so the eggs were from a donor. Obviously, this would've been impossible without substantial medical intervention. If anyone knows of any actually fertile, anatomically female people with a Y chromosome--who weren't like, genetic chimeras who ate a twin brother in the womb--I'd be happy to hear about them. Still wouldn't make Danny any more of a woman.

She huffs. Graywytch seems so much less impressive now. “No. Magic is dangerous. I miscalculated, is all. Standing this close to the center, it could have gotten anyone.”


I get to my feet. “Maybe. I’m sure you’ll have plenty of time to think about it in prison. I bet they’d even run a blood test for you, if you asked.”

"I mean, you'll probably be too drugged to the gills to remember, but you could."

er. “Get up. I don’t think I’m strong enough to carry you safely yet, so we’ve got to hike out of here.”

She looks at my hand, wary for a trick.

“For fuck’s sake, Graywytch, I’d just kill you if I was going to.”

Because if there's one thing Danny Tozer isn't known for, it's flying into out of control, berserk rages.

“We’re going to hike back to New Port so you can get arrested.That’s all that’s going to happen, I promise.”

She still doesn’t believe me; it’s etched in her face. “Why? Why spare me?”

I smile. “Isn’t it obvious? I’m better than you.”

So, Danny's not showing Graywytch mercy because of the inherent value of human life or anything, he just wants to rub her face in shit. Charming.

I don’t end up retiring after all.

Fuck.

Things can’t keep going on this way, but if I’m honest with myself, I don’t have it in me to quit. I like the power. I like the action. I love the look on people’s faces when they realize I’m there to save them. But I’ve got anger issues, and those are going to get somebody killed if I can’t figure out how to control them. That moment under the water with Sovereign, when he stopped fighting—I was so proud. Now it makes me feel uneasy to think about it. It’s just luck that Panzer was there to save him. So I’m taking a break. I’ll keep patrolling long enough for Kinetiq to get out of the hospital and take over my contract, and then I’m putting away the cape for at least six months.

Doc knows a therapist who specializes in the treatment of superheroes. We’re going to have appointments twice a week at first. Hopefully I’ll get better.

Poor therapist. Can't even begin to address the elephant in the room, or its massive, rope-like cock.

The break isn’t only for my health. Cecilia says I need to get out of the public eye for a while until the dust settles. My arrest and arraignment did a lot of damage to my reputation, and that will take time to fix. And, to be honest, she just doesn’t have enough hours in the day to be my publicist and my lawyer right now. Whatever remaining anger she had at me for breaking into Graywytch’s apartment evaporated when she got a look at just how much money we seized from Garrison. Uncle Sam took the lion’s share of it, of course, but Cecilia managed to snag ownership of Cynosure and what looks like enough money to cover the repairs as well. The rest of Sovereign Industries will be parceled out in court to Garrison’s business partners, and likely will be subject to ongoing legal disputes for years, if not decades. Cecilia says we can’t take it all for ourselves, but we can be damn sure that Garrison won’t get any of it back, either.

Wait, superheroes are allowed to claim the spoils of their vanquished foes? I'm sure this doesn't lead to any perverse incentives at all!

Speaking of lawyers, when Doc cracked Garrison’s hard drive (his password was password2), she unleashed a legal apocalypse. It turns out he had more than fifty judges and prosecutors on his payroll in one of the largest law enforcement corruption scandals in American history. That’s how he arranged to have me arrested for murder, among other things. He figured that Cynosure was safely under his control, and so he kept meticulous records of a whole range of illegal financial maneuvers, political bribery, and the occasional murder for hire.

How fucking convenient.

Graywytch is dead. I didn’t kill her, but she’s dead. They found her in her cell the morning after her arrest, without even a mark on her body. People are outraged. They wanted justice, and it’s been stolen from them. I’m frustrated too. I wanted her to see the world turn its back on her. I wanted my choice to spare her to mean something.

Oh, she wishes.

For more than fifty years, Mistress Malice was the heavyweight champion of supervillains, with over a quarter-million confirmed deaths during a six-month rampage. Graywytch made Malice’s crimes look like a liquor store robbery. They’re still counting the dead, but it’s easily the worst supervillain attack in history. The global death toll might top three million, mostly men, but hundreds of thousands of women died as well.
Not just trans women and intersex women, but cisgender women too; nearly ten thousand airliners crashed when their (overwhelmingly male) flight crews were disabled by her spell. Not to mention women who were on the operating table with male surgeons who collapsed, who were killed in traffic accidents and building fires, or any number of collisions caused by half the human species falling over all at once. Graywytch killed some of every kind of person that exists.


There were cries for justice, for punishment. Since people died in every country on the planet, there was going to be a huge fight over who got to put her on trial for mass murder, but all of that’s been stumped by the simple fact that she’s dead.


Except that I’m not sure that she is.

In other words, this entire book was so April Daniels could make a TERF the greatest terrorist in history.

Meanwhile, Charlie's been given a "full-ride scholarship and apprenticeship" by the Council of Avalon, whatever that means. Not sure how you can have a unified curriculum for magic when it's all just delusions made real by space-rocks. Shouldn't every mage operates under their own rules?

Congress has already passed a sweeping new anti-magic law in the wake of Graywytch’s attack, and they’re hoping he’ll be safer out of the country until the paranoia about magic users dies down. If it ever does.

So, nobody thought to legislate about magic shit before?

A question that has been running around in my mind pops out of my mouth: “So do you know what happened to Graywytch?”


Charlie freezes, and Sarah looks up from the pile of books she’s sorting.


“Not for sure,” he says.


“But you’ve got a suspicion.”


“Yeah.”


“Are you going to tell us?” asks Sarah.


Charlie crosses his room and shuts the door. “Look, you cannot repeat this, okay?”


Sarah and I trade a look. “Go on,” I say.


“I think the Council of Avalon added her to their Library,” says Charlie quietly.


“What does that mean?”


“It means they tore her soul from her body and bound it to service for all eternity. She’s as good as dead, except when somebody wakes her up to ask a question. That’s all anyone outside the Council knows about the Library, and I shouldn’t even be saying that much.”


Sarah sums up my feelings: “Holy shit.”

So, in other words, Danny sparing Graywytch meant nothing, and in fact only set her up for an even worse fate. I know from a Watsonian perspective, Danny had nothing to do with that, but clearly Daniels wants to have his cake and eat it too. It's like a way scummier version of the Margaret Thatcher scene in Miracleman.

Valkyrja-in-Karen's body is going to rejoin the Legion, but first:

There is…a kindness I must ask from you. I have a task I must complete, and I have put it off too long. It will take time, and then I will return to you.”

“What kind of task?”

“A…ritual. A family tradition. I must secure my mother’s legacy. Until then, I cannot indulge distractions.”

“How long will it take?”

Valkyrja’s wings curl protectively around her. “About nine months.”

Oh.

“Are you sure you want to do that?” I ask. The other part of the question is left unspoken: do you want to do that to your daughter?

That's right, not only has Karen been drowned in her own head, now her body will be used to breed a future host for the parasite that did it.

“It is the way of things. It will bring me solace.”

Remember when Doc was comparing herself to a rape victim? Also, I really hope Karen and Charlie never got further than making out.

The one thing that everybody agrees on is that those damn satellites need to go. Nobody should have the power to cast a spell over the entire planet ever again. I boost up into orbit again and start knocking them down. Red Steel sends me another email, congratulating me on my victory, and stating that because his employer turned out to be a criminal and the satellites were weapons of mass destruction, that he has generously decided he will not be seeking vengeance upon me for defying his warning. I send him a fluffy cat picture in reply.

What, are you telling me Red Steel doesn't usually work for criminals?

So have you thought about who you’re going to give the money to?” Kinetiq asks me. It’s a topic that’s been hanging over our heads. They’re clearly unhappy with the sudden influx of wealth. We nearly died taking down the guy I took this money off of. We’d be well within our rights to keep it. Kinetiq hasn’t been shy about how much they disagree, and I guess now is as good a time as any for us to decide not to avoid the issue any longer.


I shrug, and regurgitate a line I heard from Cecilia: “Until the asset forfeiture case is settled, it would be premature to spend any of it.”


“Don’t dodge the question, Dreadnought.” Kinetiq leans on their cane and pivots to face me. “Who are you giving the money to?”


Getting angry isn’t going to help. More and more I’m trying to rein in my temper. “I’m thinking that we’ll keep it.” Technically, it’s going to be a group decision, but everyone has been looking to me to make a proposal. I tried to pawn the responsibility off on Calamity, and she literally laughed in my face.


“You don’t want to do that,” says Kinetiq. “Money changes people, and never for the better. Besides that, no fortune that large can exist without the exploitation of the working class—it’s stolen money, Dreadnought. Blood money. You have a moral duty to return it to the people. How you do that, what charity you choose, that’s your choice, but you can’t keep it.”

The idea that a self-professed anarchist would turn down billions of dollars and immediately fight to the death to keep it is the funniest joke in this book. Like, have you seen how defensive Alan Moore can be about his property? I'm not saying he doesn't have every right to be (though, he has screwed over his collaborators in the process, people forget that) but these people often seem to care a lot about private property when it's their own.

“It’s not go-crazy money, okay? Most of the cash got hoovered up by the Feds. We’ve only got enough to repair Cynosure, and maybe a couple million left over after that.”


“Why repair it? Bust that damn thing up for scrap.”


“What good would that do anyone?”


“What good would it do anyone to keep it?” they reply, almost before I’m done speaking.


“I was thinking we’d put up a free clinic that provides the full range of transition services to anyone who asks. Or a halfway house for queer runaways who need to start a new life away from their family.” I very carefully do not look at them when I say that last part.


“Oh,” says Kinetiq quietly.

That's right, Danny's turning the seastead into a private island refuge for "queer kids" and it'll be run by an AFAB enby. In other words, he's created a floating Tranch, but instead of alpacas, it's confused human children. I'm not sure if I want to read that Kiwi thread or not.

“I was thinking, though. It might be good to have one of us stay on the island to make sure all the kids are okay. You could see to it that it’s just not another way of throwing them into the system.”

They snort. “Lay off. You made your point.”

“So you’re okay with this?”

“Yeah. I think so. I think I’d like that.”

A reminder that Danny thinks the United States foster-care system would be better than living with his middle class family.

Professor Gothic lands in New Port after almost a month spent in hiding—it’s the first flight into town since the biggest disaster the airline industry ever suffered. The Nemesis is not quite public knowledge yet, but we think it’s only a matter of time until word leaks. Most of the world’s governments already know, and are scrambling to decide what—if anything—to do about it. The Nemesis sits on the other side of the moon, watched by Garrison’s remote cameras. Cameras Doc Impossible has taken full control over, along with every other piece of his surviving outer space infrastructure.

So now Danny's chief handmaiden controls the world's source of superpowers. Swell.

Gothic wants to send Nemesis away, which will eventually lead to all comic book bullshit leaving the world like it's the end of Lord of the Rings. Doc and Danny don't agree, because, well, Doc would literally cease to exist and Danny values power above all else.

“And after what happened last month,” I say, “I don’t think the world would be better if the only kind of power was money. Right now, most people just have to go along with whatever the rich and their pet governments tell them. Maybe if everyone could do the things that I could do, things would be better.”

Danny's basically a minarchist: the government should only exist to enforce his delusions upon people with working brains.

“Or they could become catastrophically worse,” says Gothic thinly.


“We already have supervillains,” says Doc. “And even without them, we’d still have existential threats that we’d have to confront—only we’d be doing so with vastly reduced capabilities. Climate change doesn’t get easier just because we all go back down to the baseline. If things get too hot, we can move the rock to the L-point on the other side of the sun.”

This might be more convincing if we hadn't already established any "solution" a super-scientist comes up with is basically voodoo bullshit liable to explode if left alone for any length of time.

Doc at least finally stops LARPing being an alcoholic.

“My parents dropped their objection to my emancipation papers. So I’ve signed them and I’m free.”
Probably wise.
Doc’s jaw drops with open delight. “Kickass! What do you want to do to celebrate?”

Oh man, I hadn’t even thought about that. My tongue fumbles for something to say as I focus on not tripping while I cross the room. “Oh, uh, I wasn’t—probably not much, it’s just a formality. But um. I did have Cecilia draw up some other papers; I was wondering if maybe you’d take a look at them? I mean, if you want to.” I set the folder down on the counter next to her.

Doc wipes her hands on a paper napkin while she regards me with curiosity. “Sure, okay.” She opens the folder and starts to read, and I try to keep my heart beating. Every twitch and flick on her face seems to shout. Curiosity. Surprise. Understanding.

“These are adoption papers,” she says quietly.

Rip off the ending of Matilda, got it.

“Yeah, well. I mean, if you don’t—look, it’s not that big a deal and, I was just thinking, so, you know—”

Doc’s face falls, and so does my stomach. “Danny, I’d…I’m honored, really. But I’m not human. I don’t have a birth certificate or a social security number or anything. I’ve got incorporation papers, and that’s it. Corporations can’t adopt people. I’m sorry.”

You'd think there'd already be laws regarding people-equivalent beings who aren't human.

“Oh.” My face feels numb. My chest is filled with lead. In between the space between hearing and understanding, between understanding and despair, I make one last grasp at it: “Can you hire me?”

Doc’s composure stumbles, quickly covered by a tremulous smile. “Yeah,” she says weakly. “I can hire you.” She sets the papers aside and opens her arms. “Hey, bring it in, kiddo, come here.”

Replacing a parent-child relationship with a corporate relationship with a piece of software is troony as fuck.

And then I’m hugging my mother and she’s hugging me back, tight and protective, and finally, finally I’m home. After a while something occurs to me.

“Hey, Doc. What’s your first name?”

She looks at me blankly. “You didn’t know? It’s—”

Okay, that's kind of funny. Post your answers in the comments. The book proper ends with Danny and Sarah professing their love for each other during an orbital pleasure flight. I'm going to spare you that horror, and instead move straight to the book's acknowledgements section:

Thank you to my agent, Saritza Hernandez, who fought for these books and helped me get my feet wet as a professional writer.

Aspiring writers who might be reading this, always remember, April Daniels has an agent, and we don't.

Thank you to Grace Li, who provided invaluable sensitivity reader services.

Sometime, I should tell you all about my brush with a would-be sensitivity reader. Bit of a redpill.

Many friends listened to me spitball ideas or answer gut-check questions. They listened to me whine and moan when I was stuck, and also to my wildly optimistic bragging when things were going well. Many friends also read early versions of my manuscripts and gave me their honest and valuable feedback. Special thanks to Erica, Autumn, Clarissa, Tor, Devin, Sara, and Cal.

Just a parade of troon names. Also, I refuse to believe these books had multiple drafts.

Thank you those special teachers who, from kindergarten on up, kindly tolerated my habit of ignoring them to read instead.

A curse be upon their names.

Thank you to my mother, who raised me, among other feats of endurance.

Okay, that one's a surprise.

So, that's Sovereign. I could write a little mini-essay about all the reasons I chose to review these shitty books, but I'd rather give you some recommendations for better stuff:

  • If you want a fun YA series involving (mostly evil) super-people, I enjoyed Brian Sanderson's Reckoners trilogy. Danny would actually make a pretty good Epic, now that I think about it.
  • If you want a good superhero-adjacent thing with a trans character (God knows why) check out Kieron Gillen's The Wicked+The Divine, which I still think is one of the best comics I've ever read. Even if he'd be utterly scandalized about it being recomended here of all places.
  • If you want to read good comics about young people with superpowers, try Tomasi's Super-Sons, the stone-cold classic, Louise Simonson's Power Pack.
  • If you want a good superhero prose novel, look for It's Superman! by Tom De Haven, which is a fun period-piece about Superman in 1930s New York City.
  • If you want a good superhero prose superhero about kids with powers, um, ask about my manuscript I guess, we're getting pretty niche at this point.
I really enjoyed doing this thread and chatting with all you good readers, and I'd like to do it again. I don't know if we'll ever get the last Dreadnought book, but I promise, I'll be doing it the fucking week it drops. In the meantime, feel free to suggest a new book for me to read for your amusement. I'm looking for anything in the fantastical genres, that's either entertainingly bad or interestingly flawed, and is woke-poisoned, or at least aiming for some kind of social message. I'll take left-wing, right-wing, radical centrist, whatever's dumb enough.

Also, vampires. Vampires would be nice.
 
I'm looking for anything in the fantastical genres, that's either entertainingly bad or interestingly flawed, and is woke-poisoned, or at least aiming for some kind of social message. I'll take left-wing, right-wing, radical centrist, whatever's dumb enough.
It might not be exactly what you're looking for, but I've heard of a sci-fi libertarian polemic called The Probability Broach, which deals primarily with a timeline where the Constitution of the United States never replaces the Articles of Confederation. This leads to the "North American Confederation" becoming an sci-fi utopia by the present day.
The Articles of Confederation, drafted during the Revolution, established the first proper government of the fledgling republic. The system established was infamously weak, with the central government having almost no power over the states. After two armed rebellions that the federal government was incapable of suppressing, it became the popular opinion that a greater degree of centralization was needed, which led to the drafting of the Constitution.

If that's not something you want to do, I might take a crack at it myself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Let's rip right into this one last time!

Like anyone with a Y chromosome, I bet.
Oddly specific way to program your spell. Can't just say 'men'! No, it must be programmed in a weird way that allows you to technically commit a suicide by your own ritual.

it will be amazing if the cops can even get to Legion Tower on foot, much less with enough firepower to do anything about this.
Yeah, if only you had more firepower on your side.

Poor Danny has to do it all alone. If only there was a character who flies and wields a 'tank platoon’s worth of firepower' and, unlike Danny, is not affected by the spell. A character who would save the world to save her dad. Would make for a decent redempti-- hah, kidding.

There is no redemption for those who oppose the tranny overlords.

I hate wasted potential for character development. (:_(

God, can you imagine, an entire world descended from Danny.
I bet Daniels wrote this one handed.

I love the idea of Danny trying to palm off killing Graywytch to someone else. It's unintentionally the most accurate depiction of troon work-ethic ever.
“You just need to hold your breath for twelve hours, I can get to you!” She’s at the edge of pleading.


“Can’t do that, Doc. All those people will die.”
“Win your battle,” says Valkyrja. “We will speak later.”


“I’m in no shape to fight. You want to atone? Go do it yourself.”
I cannot wait this out in safety. People would die. Hey, Valkyrja! Wanna, like, do my job while I dip myself underwater and wait this out?

Graywytch told me this was coming, and I didn’t realize what she meant.
All the signs were there, and I missed it.
“You going to kill me too, now?”
I don’t trust her. I don’t trust this.
Danny is seeing things that aren't there, making connections that don't exist. Adding paranoia among Danny's qualities, alongside sadism and sociopathy.

Because Graywytch was totally dropping hints and Valkyrja has to be working with her because... Danny does not approve of her being reborn in Karen's body.

“I don’t remember when my father started screaming at me,” I tell her, and I’m as surprised as she is that this is coming out now. “But I know that by the time I was in kindergarten I was already afraid of him.”


Graywytch licks her lips. “What are—”
Holy shit, I know we established he is a psychopath, but for fuck's sake, tone it down, Daniels. This is sadistic serial killer behavior. Psychological torture of his victims before he gets physical.

She’s silent for a long moment. “Because—”

“I never cared that you don’t think I’m a girl, Myra!”
He sure threw many fits over it for someone who never cared.

The global death toll might top three million
Three... million? That is nothing in superhero stories. That is barely enough for people to notice. A fucking doomsday spell to kill all men and it only kills three million people. Graywytch's magic sucked ass.

Congress has already passed a sweeping new anti-magic law in the wake of Graywytch’s attack, and they’re hoping he’ll be safer out of the country until the paranoia about magic users dies down. If it ever does.
So, nobody thought to legislate about magic shit before?
And how do they plan to enforce this...? Might as well make black-capes illegal!

So, in other words, Danny sparing Graywytch meant nothing, and in fact only set her up for an even worse fate.
Same with Garrison. Daniels doesn't want his villains to just die, he wants them physically broken, their life ruined, their accomplishments reduced to nothing, their families torn apart, their fucking souls suffering for eternity.

What, are you telling me Red Steel doesn't usually work for criminals?
Communism is wholesome, it just keeps getting sabotaged by the wrong people in charge! Red Steel dindu nuffin, blame the rich guy!

"Oh, I didn't know my boss was a criminal, I only followed orders!"

Gothic wants to send Nemesis away, which will eventually lead to all comic book bullshit leaving the world like it's the end of Lord of the Rings. Doc and Danny don't agree, because, well, Doc would literally cease to exist and Danny values power above all else.
Power and tits. Don't forget the boobas.

“I don’t think the world would be better if the only kind of power was money. Right now, most people just have to go along with whatever the rich and their pet governments tell them. Maybe if everyone could do the things that I could do, things would be better.”
Yes, let's give everyone superpowers. That will definitely end well. Can't wait for Super Fags to parade their "All Powers are Equal" signs while those who win the superpower lottery rule the world as they see fit.

And then I’m hugging my mother and she’s hugging me back, tight and protective, and finally, finally I’m home.
Eternal mommy who won't age and will always validate Danny and do the laundry.

Is it just me or is it creepy how he calls a machine 'my mother'? Because Danny does have a loving mother. A mother whose only crime was not blind validation.

“Hey, Doc. What’s your first name?”

She looks at me blankly. “You didn’t know? It’s—”
T-800.

I'm still open to suggestions, but how would you guys feel about a vampire book written by a yaoi fangirl who later went full Aiden?
If it's a steaming pile of bad writing, I'll have it.

Many thanks for chewing through this, man. It's been a wild ride.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
We've finished! Hurrah! And the book has finished...well, if not strong, then on-brand!

No final fight scene, because the end conflict is an expression of principles. Specifically the principle that Danny's feelings are the most important thing in the world, that TERFs are just jealous, that mercy is only and always for you to look good for your public and nothing else.

But, to give the devil his due, the story does at least give lip-service to the idea that Danny is fucked-up. I certainly don't care for the fake-medicalization of therapy, and the way that it's used as an excuse and not a long-term credible signal that someone is trying to improve, but hey, it's there. And I think that there's actually some interesting points to be made about the Valkyrie. The person you are at 10 is not the person you are at 40, even though you-at-40 contains everything that is in you-at-10, by definition. But the neat thing is that you get a good story in either case; either Valkyrie is an independent psychic parasitoid, or she really is just an accumulation of people over the centuries. In one case, Valkyrie-Junior chose to risk herself and discovered that her fear was unfounded, that she was still herself and now more besides. And in the other case, she chose to sacrifice her life so that another could live in her place, because the world needed Valkyrie more than it needed her in that moment, and that's a powerful story too.

I am, of course, wholly unsurprised that the actual novel didn't get past "Well, this has nothing to do with stroking my ego, so we're just going to slide on past it now that I got what I needed from this character!"

Of course, with those few nuggets of not-the-worst do we get a whole lot of actually-the-worst, in no particular order:

How long until someone either in government or just another blackcape busts Garrison out for him to do Sattelite Boogaloo, Round 2? All he needs is a mage, apparently, and mages are not particularly rare on the ground. And now he can build himself a space suit and put the damn things in orbit himself, if he ever gets out.

Man, the Council of Avalon sucks. They apparently have the power to kill GreyWytch only after she's crippled herself from casting a world-affecting spell for the first time, and not stop her from doing so, or raise any sort of alarm to anyone as to what she was doing in the first place which was apparently super-forbidden.

Again, Civil Asset Forfeiture Does Not Work That Way (except in the sadly ironic sense of it's people with power taking your stuff and the state pretending that it's OK because they don't want the slap-fight that denying it would cause). As pointed out above, this is not supposed to be a novel thing in-universe; there is no reason Garrison hasn't squirreled away both cash and actual superpowered assets elsewhere as a contingency, especially after the first time his house got burned down.

No one asks "Hey, what was the actual chain of custody on those records that Doc pulled up? Given that Doc's not legally a person and can't be sworn in or give deposition, what evidence exists that Doc didn't just make them up wholesale?"

Apparently GreyWytch's magic pocket dimension has fucking Wi-Fi. How is the signal going from there to the satellites again? Hell, I mean, we heard the answer already; 'magic' is just 'I, the author, don't care enough to pretend that this makes sense, so it just does what is convenient for my characters always and forever'.

Man, fuck off Kinetiq. I mean, fuck off that whole bit, but a particular fuck-off to that useless genderspecial whose sole contribution to the plot was burning books. And extra fuck-off to "See, money is great if it's being used by people like us, to do the things we want! Anarchism just means no government for the bad people, and lots of government for us, and by us!" And double-extra-fuck-off-with-a-cherry-on-top for the absolute inverted moral. Money and influence didn't kill 3.3 million people; superpowers did. Specifically, a novel combination of superpowers. Hell, a better novel would have Garrison already speaking out and saying that this will happen if powers are not controlled, and will happen more and more as Nemesis approaches. And the fact that the book didn't ever set up that the magic satellites were hard-constrained by something like physical Nemesis fragments (if I recall correctly) means that all it takes is someone re-turning the groundwork for, I dunno, 5G, and whoops, you've got the same shit happening again.

Danny getting adopted by Doc is fucked-up as has been pointed out above, but it's not at all unrealistic in the story as presented.

Danny being inconsistent enough to give a schizophrenic whiplash has also been pointed out above, but that's also entirely in-character for Danny, so I'm fine with him saying contradictory things to Valkyrie and Doc, because Danny just makes mouth-noises that make him feel superior and get him what he wants.

Apparently being on a fucking floating island isn't enough seawater to fuck with GreyWytch's magic. Why did Doc not recommend a Faraday cage? Hell, why not say the same thing, but because the deep ocean will block the satellite signal? Why bring in an extra random element for no goddamn reason, practical or thematic?

---

As for what is to come next, I say sure, let's go for some messed-up vampire romance. I mean, you're the one who is going to be slogging through it, so I say pick something that will keep you looking either for nuggets of interest, or near enough to your own interests to keep you reading to point out all the specific ways it fucks up.

But regardless of your choice, congratulations! You've made it through these books, and shared the journey with all of us!
 
Back