- Joined
- Aug 4, 2022
Assuming the story is true, that wasn't disdain and judgement in the operator's tone, it was shock and disbelief. That weight at that age?
For context, I looked up the average height of an 11 year old male (I presume this is for the U.S. population, no idea of the source data), and it's 135 cm (4'5"). Assuming the child weighed 118 kg (260 lbs.) -- which may be a charitable underestimate of >250lbs. that means he had a BMI of 64.7. I know BMI isn't supposed to be used for children because it doesn't really apply because they're not proportioned like adults, but still, there's no worry here about mistaking muscle for fat. That's hugely, impossibly fat. But sure, the fatphobia is the problem here, not letting your child eat in such a disordered fashion that they become a behemoth whose body collapses in on itself before puberty.
For context, I looked up the average height of an 11 year old male (I presume this is for the U.S. population, no idea of the source data), and it's 135 cm (4'5"). Assuming the child weighed 118 kg (260 lbs.) -- which may be a charitable underestimate of >250lbs. that means he had a BMI of 64.7. I know BMI isn't supposed to be used for children because it doesn't really apply because they're not proportioned like adults, but still, there's no worry here about mistaking muscle for fat. That's hugely, impossibly fat. But sure, the fatphobia is the problem here, not letting your child eat in such a disordered fashion that they become a behemoth whose body collapses in on itself before puberty.