RWBY - The Hindenburg on which Rooster Teeth rests its hopes, dreams and future

The problem with RWBY's world is that it's extremely one track and suffers from what I'd call "theological stiffness"
The other issue is that on top of the shaky foundations it's also a total "Kitchen Sink" setting. Just throw a bit of everything and the kitchen sink into it and hope for the best, it doesn't matter that none of these elements really mesh with one another and make the world feel bland and generic, if we put in more Stuff that will give us more things to do.
 
The other issue is that on top of the shaky foundations it's also a total "Kitchen Sink" setting. Just throw a bit of everything and the kitchen sink into it and hope for the best, it doesn't matter that none of these elements really mesh with one another and make the world feel bland and generic, if we put in more Stuff that will give us more things to do.
Even worse is how nothing interfaces with each other or works off one another in Remnant. "Onotological intertia" is what the nerds call it, or an adaptation to one's surroundings or whatever. While it tries to bring everything into its world, it fails to be itself. We get a world of magic where everything is powered by a magic system.... and suddenly robots? Not even Final Fantasy VII was this disjointed with its technological setting. Even something as barebones as Musashi: Samurai Legend had a carbon copy rip off of its predecessor's magic system, and that still had a lot more thought put into it than this shit.

Say, you know what would be really cool? Sembalances are the result of one's personal "Dust Within", and while can be replicated, are extremely unique to one's existence. As everyone is made of chemical elements, extremely complex organic components, magical energy/Aura and Dust in Remnant, there is no one exact Sembalance, and one's soul that generates Aura is believed to attract the kind of Dust one has affinity with.

"Dust Within" even builds upon itself! Dust Within, while it doesn't make external use of Dust obsolete, is a kind of "vital body" mysticism and magical science that is studied, ESPECIALLY BY HUNTERS, to unlock their inner potential and allows them use of a limited predetermined set but ever growing series of spells/powers with training, repeated applied use and realization to ensure they are not fully powerless against monsters like GRIMM IF THEY ARE UNARMED OR CAUGHT BY SURPRISE. EVEN BETTER, WHAT SEPARATES THESE POWERS FROM SEMBLANCES are that Dust Within powers utilize basic function and even specified usage of Dust within one's self, where Semblances requires Dust Within to work fully in unity to be activated. Holy fucking shit, I just bridged and fixed your magic system guys! Even Monty's giving me a pat on the back!

This makes way for Hunters who are straight up mages/magic users or even more different fighters than the series' typical hybrid magic fighters! Fuck, Dust can even have the same life force mechanic as the Lifestream and Mako if you wanted it to, making for summoned monsters and shit!

Back to robots, while they aren't certainly useless, they aren't very thought out either. Maybe robots are a way of doing things without attracting Grimm. The point is that tools are build by men out of a need, not out of a cheap want. Maybe every Hunter Team could have a super mech in the case of them encountering gargantuan threat Grimm, and that could also act as their storehouse for their flying arsenals. The other elephant in the room is that unless there's some super technology on the par of Megaman, and even then, robots have their weaknesses too. Metal has a tendency to warp, corrode, and consistently degrade if left in even the smallest of affecting conditions. Wear and tear definitely is an issue. Electrical components and power supplies are also not infallible. Electronics and robotics are also stupidly intricate for them to work, else they turn useless. Current tech is also consumption heavy, and then you also have to worry about if your robots will become cancer stations. Gee, THIS also would need some sort of technological explanation. Even in big mecha and tech heavy anime series, there's always a mechanical designer who also gives input and helps to explain how their technology works differently than real life.

OH I KNOW Dust Tech is used to create a sort of "organics system" to humanoid or organism based robots, giving them an inorganic skeletal and muscular system that allows them to overcome the fragility and intricacy of more basic joint systems that can seize and be more easily interfered with outside ordinance. Basically it's like the psionic android tech in Star Trek TNG or even Aliens, but more applied. Also, when a user pilots it, they have to "harmonize" with the mecha, which allows them to control it with nothing but their own action but piloting it is exhausting and they can feel anything the mecha does. I could also probably see how giant mechas could be extremely useful in going to ruins where they are incredibly large scale made by giants relics, but would require a vast amount of time to scale for a human.

I love kitchen sink settings. I loathe the hacks that use them when they are not developed and given the time to become more fleshed out and matured.
 
Last edited:
Did you know that Rooster Teeth is selling RWBY body pillows? I do now (I was looking for a nice RWBY t-shirt). Mousepad (lewd one) too!
000142.png
000143.png
000144.png
000145.png

One of the body pillows are even on sale now (as is the lewd mousepad)!
000146.png
000147.png

If you wanted to sleep with the Queen of Grimm, now's your chance!
 
It took me a second to figure out why they chose side characters for these. The main cast would objectively sell better, but the writers project so hard onto the main cast that the thought of sweaty weebs sleeping with the pillows makes them uncomfortable.
 
It took me a second to figure out why they chose side characters for these. The main cast would objectively sell better, but the writers project so hard onto the main cast that the thought of sweaty weebs sleeping with the pillows makes them uncomfortable.
I"ll be honest, I think it's more that these characters are adults older than time, and not teenagers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Juaco
So Batman without prep time?
I mean, it depends. Ruby would be worse, but someone like Yang would probably be stronger if less experienced. If Batman pulls a Neo on her, he’d win. Weiss is too reliant on her semblance, so maybe Blake? Iirc, she stopped spamming it after like vol 3 or something, but I may be misremembering
 
The other issue is that on top of the shaky foundations it's also a total "Kitchen Sink" setting. Just throw a bit of everything and the kitchen sink into it and hope for the best, it doesn't matter that none of these elements really mesh with one another and make the world feel bland and generic, if we put in more Stuff that will give us more things to do.
To add another one, besides being badly written. I think the RWBY setting has another very, very obvious practical issue I wish people pointed out more for their world building. Extreme Arrogance.

In other words, they just don’t have the budget. Rwby has 4 nations right? Plus Menagerie. Well I remember Last Airbender also had 4 nations and they still managed to make each very unique. In each nation people all dressed, and behaved differently. All had unique architectures too. All memorable.

Meanwhile RWBY had us go to a world tour and all the kingdoms look basically the same? Everyone dresses and acts pretty much the same, as modern humans? (Save for named anime waifus of course). All “new“ locations could have been in the starting city and nobody would have noticed a difference. Generic futuristic city, generic market, and generic beach to name a few.

I don’t even blame the bad writing on this one. I am sure the wiki surely has pages and pages on lore and how each kingdom is super special, and unique. But in the show? We got none of that.

It’s just obvious to me they simply didn’t have the money to pull it off. The animators barely deliver as it is, and last season they were crazy enough to try to pull of an Alice on Wonderland type of deal on top off it ? Wonderland alone is so complex to pull off you could do an entire movie/show based on it.

As a casual viewer, and without looking at the wiki try to even tell how the 4 kingdoms differ from each other? What makes them unique? Exactly.

It’s not even a bad idea to have 4 different kingdoms or even more. Last Airbender proves that. It’s just that it was extremely arrogant from Rooster Teeth to try it knowing they don’t even have half the resources of a kiddie show like Clone wars or Miraculous Lady bug. And even those recycle backgrounds a lot.

If they wanted their world building so badly, they should have waited for a video game or until they actually had money to pull it off.
 
Meanwhile RWBY had us go to a world tour and all the kingdoms look basically the same? Everyone dresses and acts pretty much the same, as modern humans? (Save for named anime waifus of course). All “new“ locations could have been in the starting city and nobody would have noticed a difference. Generic futuristic city, generic market, and generic beach to name a few.

I don’t even blame the bad writing on this one. I am sure the wiki surely has pages and pages on lore and how each kingdom is super special, and unique. But in the show? We got none of that.
To build off your A:TLA comparison, comparison, you make Remnant sound like The Legend of Korra if the show never left Republic City.
Miraculous Lady bug. And even those recycle backgrounds a lot.
Well, ML is just "the city of Paris" as a setting. Never watched, but it does seem like it's more entertaining than RWBY.


As a casual viewer, and without looking at the wiki try to even tell how the 4 kingdoms differ from each other? What makes them unique? Exactly.
Didn't the show first try to use the academy system to show the difference in kingdoms? Team RWBY didn't get out much in the first three volumes.


If they wanted their world building so badly, they should have waited for a video game or until they actually had money to pull it off.
I know Joon The King made his documentary on RT, and I'm not sure if they've ever disclosed finances, but I'm pretty sure when RWBY was started in 2013, that WAS the peak for RT. Even with the Fullscreen acquisition coming in 2015, the Red trailer was RT at the height of their power.

Also, RT did have a video game. It was RWBY: Grimm Eclipse.
 
To build off your A:TLA comparison, comparison, you make Remnant sound like The Legend of Korra if the show never left Republic City.

Well, ML is just "the city of Paris" as a setting. Never watched, but it does seem like it's more entertaining than RWBY.



Didn't the show first try to use the academy system to show the difference in kingdoms? Team RWBY didn't get out much in the first three volumes.



I know Joon The King made his documentary on RT, and I'm not sure if they've ever disclosed finances, but I'm pretty sure when RWBY was started in 2013, that WAS the peak for RT. Even with the Fullscreen acquisition coming in 2015, the Red trailer was RT at the height of their power.

Also, RT did have a video game. It was RWBY: Grimm Eclipse.

Actually that is very apt. RWBY is as if they never left republic city in The legend of Korra.

I will seize the chance to expand on my point. Yes, Remnant is in “theory” very complex and diverse. But in practice it is not.

Yes, we have seen different “backgrounds” Beaches, farms and roads etc. I don’t deny that.But, we haven’t Seen Diverse cultures, religions, or architecture enough to justify them being in a tour around the world.

The last airbender had 4 kingdoms and each of them was very unique. You can tell in an instant someone is from The fire nation or the earth kingdom. Meanwhile, in RWBY, people form Atlas or other kingdoms are virtually indistinguishable.

For example, we saw Atlas was a cold floating city. And that’s all there is to it.

I‘m sure there’s a lot of lore on why they are unique places. But in practice? We saw none of it.

As for the game? Yeah, I am aware Rooster Teeth has made several including some cash in mobile games. But my point is more along the lines that they would need the budget of an open world video game, like say Fallout to develop their 4 kingdoms properly if that’s what they wanted. Instead of trying to pretend some interchangeable 3D backgrounds in a low budget animated show is enough.
 
Also, RT did have a video game. It was RWBY: Grimm Eclipse
I actually got a chance to play the tech demo made by the one fan that loved RWBY enough to make everything from scratch. Was a good tech demo, and just like the early seasons of RWBY, you could tell there was passion behind it that was absent from full release.
For example, we saw Atlas was a cold floating city. And that’s all there is to it.
Imagine having a baked in ice area town, and not having any ideas on how you'd make it unique. The writers literally don't even try.
 
Back