Jesus, Freddy could speed up his talking rate. 6 hours of slow ponderous talking could be cut down to 2.5 hours playing it at double speed, which is what Null did I think. I still think he has a good narrating voice but it being slow is something you don't notice when the vid is only 15 - 20 minutes long. With it being 6 hours, you really do notice it. Another caption highlights an article and you know a minute of your life is going to be wasted by him reading it.
Regarding the content, it is well thought out and timelined into segments but again I feel as if you could chapter it in a way like Mandalore's really early review of Eve and not have such a bloated run time. The two hour mark has you cover the early section of CCP, the initial development, the early economy and faction wars, the council and the introduction of Plex. That's two whole hours. I think you could edit that down and speed freddy up to cover that in just over an hour.
Multiple times at the end of segments, he'd make a claim like "The game was going to change in an unexpected way." No, bad Freddy. Cut that. Each time you do that you're adding to runtime with sequiturs that arn't needed. Just flash a chapter card and go straight into it.
One of the things I'll say about Eve is it's fascinating how the Goonswarm went against the Band of Brothers because they were legit cheaters, then The Mittani turned them into a mustache twirling villian to keep the game going and generate player interest. It's also nice to see neutral corps like Eve University and Signal Cartel actually help new players or provide a way for people who don't want to engage with PvP but still want to play the game. Taking a look at their K/D ratio though,
Signal have killed a thousand ships and lost 42k of their own. It must suck to be a herbivore.
The real money trading issue. As an MMO, you need someway to have an income and it's usually through subscriptions or making the game free to play and offering cosmetics or other shit. There's always going to be someone to do such a thing but to leverage that proceeds from gambling into paying the mercs to go to war for you. Now that's some 14th century city state thinking.
As the developer, I don't know what you can do other than trying to ineffectively play whack a mole with them or lose the entire plex side of the economy but that would kill your revenue stream.
Then we get to the Citadel systems. These changed the game to be way more static. Being able to house titans, large defensive bonuses. The PvP map probably wouldn't change all that much with just how many fortifications there are.
A comparison would be Sins of a Solar Empire vs the Vasari. They can build 2 mobile starbases in a system, call in reserve black fleet ships and drop a Phase Stabaliser node to transport their entire fleet from one side of their empire to another. It makes cracking them a lost cause for you because you'd lose more ships than they would. Loss aversion is a core part of EVE, so everyone would want a Citadel, especially if they can house Titans that they can just pull out of storage during an invasion.
This also allowed for Titans, which were a rare ship, to be massed on such a scale that smaller corps like Rooks & Kings could no longer use tactics when raiding because instead of a few escorts and maybe a battleship, they'd send out a titan instead and the sheer size of it would be enough to ward off most ships.
Finally fucking finished. The music was kinda not needed to be honest and there are a lot of "female" names at the end, with two dedications that you know could be troons that offed themselves.
Overall this could have been a massively shortened video if he only stuck to the timeline of Eve, which is far more interesting than tangents of WoD and Dust 514 which both died anyway. He doesn't even give an ending to the game, just stating that another war is brewing and EVE is eternal, which is unlike his other vids.
Should have been 2 - 3 hours max going over the timeline/6 hours of me speeding up his slow narration to drag out run time. So a 5/10.