Diseased Rowling Derangement Syndrome - "TERF/Woke Author Bad!!1"

But that doesn't mean the wizards hate each other too tho. I'm not even a fucking HP fan but these people are so retarded, that I feel the urge to defend that shit. Even if it's badly written.
Yeah, even if you don't like Rowling there's that little fact that most wizards try to live completely separate from their non-magical fellows and consider themselves basically their own community, as per Rowling's own words. Hence why so many of them are absolutely baffled by the most mundane and common of Muggle shit (Mr. Weasley not knowing how Muggle money worked, the ministry of magic needing a report written on firearms that have existed for 200+ years, etc.) and it's fairly likely that they don't give a shit about the spats between Muggles. So when the Muggles in the Balkans are killing each other over a guy who got a bottle broken in his ass, the wizards in the Balkans are probably just trying to stay the fuck out of the way and mind their own shit.

And Wizards absolutely have ways to keep you away from where they are. Hogwarts and the village of Hogsmeade, for instance, cannot be approached by Muggles without spells that compel them to find very good reasons not to go this way fucking with their heads. So a ton of them live away from their "countrymen" and do not read the regular newspaper.

And a great many of them simply blend in with the Muggles without interacting much with them. When you have apparition, invisibility cloaks, flue powder, and likely a dozen other ways to travel without needing to be seen leaving your front door, it's kinda easy to just be "That weird neighbor who minds his own business and we never see much." and apart from the community.

They're just reaching for reasons to call her a racist.
 
How is it racist to depict unity among wizards, ignoring borders and race alike, just going to the same schools happily and not caring about muggle ideology and nations. Wizards have their own racism and it started a war.

The racism argument is funny to me. Like how people give themselves away by saying the orcs in lotr are racist, but it's actually them who see an orc and think 'black man'.
 
It’s because troons are autistic retards who get hung up on the intricacies of ‘worldbuilding’ when it’s not that important in a light, pacy children’s book.
Normal people don’t have to make spergy diagrams to enjoy books.
Although obviously the trolls are supposed to represent trans women, because they’re hulking, smell bad and attack children in girl’s bathrooms.
 
It’s because troons are autistic retards who get hung up on the intricacies of ‘worldbuilding’ when it’s not that important in a light, pacy children’s book.
Normal people don’t have to make spergy diagrams to enjoy books.
Although obviously the trolls are supposed to represent trans women, because they’re hulking, smell bad and attack children in girl’s bathrooms.
How is it racist to depict unity among wizards, ignoring borders and race alike, just going to the same schools happily and not caring about muggle ideology and nations. Wizards have their own racism and it started a war.

The racism argument is funny to me. Like how people give themselves away by saying the orcs in lotr are racist, but it's actually them who see an orc and think 'black man'.
Yeah, even if you don't like Rowling there's that little fact that most wizards try to live completely separate from their non-magical fellows and consider themselves basically their own community, as per Rowling's own words. Hence why so many of them are absolutely baffled by the most mundane and common of Muggle shit (Mr. Weasley not knowing how Muggle money worked, the ministry of magic needing a report written on firearms that have existed for 200+ years, etc.) and it's fairly likely that they don't give a shit about the spats between Muggles. So when the Muggles in the Balkans are killing each other over a guy who got a bottle broken in his ass, the wizards in the Balkans are probably just trying to stay the fuck out of the way and mind their own shit.

And Wizards absolutely have ways to keep you away from where they are. Hogwarts and the village of Hogsmeade, for instance, cannot be approached by Muggles without spells that compel them to find very good reasons not to go this way fucking with their heads. So a ton of them live away from their "countrymen" and do not read the regular newspaper.

And a great many of them simply blend in with the Muggles without interacting much with them. When you have apparition, invisibility cloaks, flue powder, and likely a dozen other ways to travel without needing to be seen leaving your front door, it's kinda easy to just be "That weird neighbor who minds his own business and we never see much." and apart from the community.

They're just reaching for reasons to call her a racist.
I'd like to think that the world building can be tweaked a little bit to make it more coherent. But, is it possible?
 
Seems "racism" to SJWs means anything white people do, say, or think about race that doesn't follow The Narrative™. Or with Rowling, maybe even anything with her and race.*

*(because she's been declared "cancelled")
Don't be too sure. She's still very much in line with a majority of their narrative. It's just one that happened to tick her off, but they can nudge that under the rug.
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Reactions: ToroidalBoat
I'd like to think that the world building can be tweaked a little bit to make it more coherent. But, is it possible?
Absolutely. Rowling really didn't flesh a hell of a lot out about other areas of the world besides the one the books take place in. Most of the shit like that map are from outside sources that can always be retconned. I mean, they're screeching because she didn't flesh out areas of the world she never set stories in to their liking.

She's not fucking Robert E Howard who went into autistic detail about the various cultures in the world he created.
 
How is it racist to depict unity among wizards, ignoring borders and race alike, just going to the same schools happily and not caring about muggle ideology and nations. Wizards have their own racism and it started a war.

The racism argument is funny to me. Like how people give themselves away by saying the orcs in lotr are racist, but it's actually them who see an orc and think 'black man'.
Yeah it's better that the magical side stay in its own corner because trying to figure out about who's on which side in muggle wars and whether certain countries could be using wizards as special agents is a giant barrel of worms. This isn't a flaw, it's just how the setting works best. People who criticize it are the ones who watch hours-long "dark secret behind [children media] will ruin your childhood!" youtube essays.
 
Yeah it's better that the magical side stay in its own corner because trying to figure out about who's on which side in muggle wars and whether certain countries could be using wizards as special agents is a giant barrel of worms. This isn't a flaw, it's just how the setting works best. People who criticize it are the ones who watch hours-long "dark secret behind [children media] will ruin your childhood!" youtube essays.
That wizards were actually offering their services to either the Fourth Reich and the Allied Forces?

That would actually work.

If Rowling wasn't such a massive britbong.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: ASeabear8952
How is it racist to depict unity among wizards, ignoring borders and race alike, just going to the same schools happily and not caring about muggle ideology and nations.
But that doesn't mean the wizards hate each other too tho.
Listen, just because our governments are behaving like asses doesn't mean we have to. We're supposed to be scientists, not politicians.

- Heywood Floyd (Roy Scheider) in 2010: The Year We Make Contact (replace "scientists" with "wizards"?)
 
Last edited:
So, they love to oversimplify everything and pretend all people in the world lived in perfect harmony until the evil white men colonized them, like in this Ms Marvel scene
from-ms-marvel-v0-bloj808wqo891.jpg
but if Rowling gives them this magical reality through her books, she's a colonizer too. Got it.
 
The delusions of Hollywood and shitskins really grinds my gears.
The Pakistani state literally has rape prisons for Indian people, who are considered a war bounty. The nation of Pakistan is one of the most backwards, ontological evil and barbaric States on this planet. I dare anyone of those talentless writer cunts to travel there and just spend a day in public, without a man to protect you.
 
The delusions of Hollywood and shitskins really grinds my gears.
The Pakistani state literally has rape prisons for Indian people, who are considered a war bounty. The nation of Pakistan is one of the most backwards, ontological evil and barbaric States on this planet. I dare anyone of those talentless writer cunts to travel there and just spend a day in public, without a man to protect you.
You can pretty much blame the American education system and the media. It's bred a nation of idiots.
 
So, they love to oversimplify everything and pretend all people in the world lived in perfect harmony until the evil white men colonized them, like in this Ms Marvel scene
View attachment 5697853
but if Rowling gives them this magical reality through her books, she's a colonizer too. Got it.
Wasn't partition what the Muslims in British India wanted?

Partition with the migration and violence was a humanitarian disaster but imagine how much worse things would be if the British just quit and went "you guys figure it out." Doesn't get much worse than Civil War due to religion.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to think that the world building can be tweaked a little bit to make it more coherent. But, is it possible?
It’s possible, but it’s not necessary. Let’s not let autists define the benchmark for good literature. If you demand minute attention to the logical accuracy of a fictional world, then perhaps the light kid’s comedy adventure about wizard school isn’t the book for you. Go and read The Martian again. Stim appreciatively to the twelve page essay on potato horticulture.
Autists are basically robots. Letting them gatekeep art is why in ten years time the only entertainment available to us will be AI generated cartoons of blushing trans cat girls with twelve buttocks sitting on fascists.
I always thought Rowling included the stuff about wizards magicking away their shit to make fun of the hardcore fans.
 
I always thought Rowling included the stuff about wizards magicking away their shit to make fun of the hardcore fans.
I have worked with a lot of successful (not world star level) creatives from mainly the music industry and I can tell you: every single one of them, down to the last, has a deep contempt for their fanbase because the average hardcore fan is a fucking retard. I can seriously imagine her putting that in there as a joke only she is in on.
 
Back