The story seething from Lorefags is kinda funny, but I can understand it. The basic story was interesting enough. The Tarnished is effectively just a tie-breaker in the event someone doesn’t win.
Prior to the DLC the story is effectively this:
The whole story starts with Godwyn’s assassination by a pact between the Carian’s and the Eternal Cities
sanctioned by Marika in order to prevent Ranni’s apotheosis. For a while there is no actual war after Marika shatters the Elden Ring.
The War probably starts when Godrick and the Golden Lineage claim their right to be Elden Lord as the descendants of Godwyn. Godefroy leads a proper attack with Godrick undermining the defenses from within. The other Demi-Gods beat Godricks forces back and Godrick flees the city the Stormveil.
Morgott basically shuts the city to the other Demi-gods. Ranni is trying to find a way to sever her fate, Rykard knew of the plan, and Radahn holds the stars/ fate to give her time. Miquella investigates Godwyn’s corpse and abandons the Golden Order due to the inability of the Order to cure him and his sister. Godrick builds his own forces.
Miquella and Melania then start going on the offensive. A civil war erupts in Liurnia either due to Renalla being viewed as a depressed sad sack or due to encouraging by other factions. The March goes from Liurnia to Caelid. Godrick is subjected by Melana.
Battle of Aeonia has Malenia and Radahn battle. Maybe to cause an Eclipse so Miquella can kill Godwyn’s corpse and stop the Deathblight spread, but it’s not really stated. Radahn and Melania fight to a stalemate and forces her to do a suicide attack that fails to put down Radahn.
After this, Rykard is attacked by Morgott’s forces and the Shaded Manor. Feeds himself to a snake in desperation. Mogh kidnaps Miquella. Godrick goes back to grafting. Radahn’s boys try to put him down.
The player character and other tarnished are revived from the dead and sent back to the lands between in order to choose a winner.
Post DLC
Miquella wanted his bussy SMASHED AND SLAMMED by Radahn who said “No Way, fag”. After the battle he doesn’t help Melania recover, he lobotomizes a Radmane and gets kidnapped by Mogh because Mogh somehow can access the Shadow Realm because he bought enough Black Wings
.
Miquella’s entire plan involves being murdered by Mogh in order to use Mogh’s lifeless corpse to serve as a vessel for Radahn’s soul. His entire plan revolves around you killing Radahn and Mogh for whatever reason.
Like the DLC turns it from desperation driving action to literal Game of Thrones Yaoi fanfic.