@Mayor Cody Travers the weird thing about Wonder Woman, is I have a very 180 take on the character from what you posted. I am sure more seasoned comic veterans can correct me, but I always thought of WW as more-or-less a hyper idealist with a child's view of how the world works. I think the WW movie did her pretty well in this regard.
Highly disagree, a big part of WW is how absolutely disconnected she is from the real world. She grew up on an isolated island of all women where the history of such reads like a Feminist Disney fairy-tale. Till Steve drops on that island, WW has never actually experienced the world around her, has not seen technology advance, hasn't even come into contact with the opposite sex.
The best Wonder Woman, in my view, is one that is in constant war between the Amazon dogma and the real world. I think she works best if she gets excitement about being a hero but cannot fully comprehend the wider complexities of what that actually means. She seems to have a very black & white worldview that ends up clashing with the League
The first WW movie did great in this aspect. She saw the war and suffering and immediately jumped to fight Ares. The only problem is, even after the big bad was defeated, the war still continued (I hate the third act for going against this scene). She couldn't comprehend why people still fight, it had to be Ares controlling them in her mind.
This aspect is also reflected in her relationship with Steve. Steve is a spy and a liar, the thing the Amazons see as being evil. WW takes huge stock in people being truthful, so she struggles to wrap her head around Steve being a genuinely good guy who did "bad" things because it was necessary.
When I think of how to describe the Trinity of DC, I think trust is a good measure for their characters. Superman is pretty all-trusting, willing to always give a second chance. Batman is someone who needs history to display trust, and even then, he always gets paranoid about worst outcomes. WW is in the middle. She displays a high amount of trust till backstabbed. She firmly believes everyone should be honest, which is why Batman being secretive and Superman being completely okay with secrets drives her up a wall.
Hawkgirl feels more memorable. She had a lot more of a personality, which is why I think people gravitated towards her more. The romance with John added a lot of levity to her where she can be more playful. Same with Flash, sort of hard to forget her joking around with him and playing wing-man for him and Fire. It felt like they took more chances with Hawkgirl to widen her past warrior, whereas WW only ever was strong women or Batman's sidepiece.
Will admit, she was pretty fun in the kids episode. There is a reason /co/ takes to loli WW more, past the obvious pedo bait. Wish they made that her default personality as her being able to play mom was a good fit.
A big aspect of DC heroes missing from WW is the family. If we are speaking on getting her a female audience, playing more into her being Wonder-Mom would be a plus. A huge draw of Batman, Superman, Flash and Arrow is the wider families they have, and it has been a complete missed opportunity to not dive into that for the premier female hero.
I think Wondy's extended family has potential but the issue is that they tend to occupy somewhat similar-ish roles in the dynamics of their own groups/teams. Maybe letting them work off Wondy when they're with her and be allowed to make mistakes and screw up as there's no pressure to live up to her. Donna's matured, sure. But Cassie? Artemis? Not really. It'd be interesting seeing them act in a sort of "they're not worried about living up to Diana's rep" kinda way. Add on Yara and Nubia too. Would be funny if Nubia was just running around acting like Artemis used to, but like twice as worse. A chip on her shoulder, anger issues, impetuousness, and an ego. It's leaning towards the "angry nigger" archetype but it could be interesting to see an Amazon go full on shoulder and think she's entitled to being treated like Diana is. Have it be a foil for Yara Flor, who's arguably in a weirder situation.
Wondy should also have been the one to fight Rao, the Kryptonian Sun God, and get washed for trying to do so. Hell, there should be a list of top tier threats that are mythical in nature and she should be the one that's first to fight and get slammed. Have her go on last stands while the rest of the heroes evacuate the place (Flash) or aren't there in time (most that aren't capable of high speed. but Wondy should have some sort of early warning system so she winds up in a place before the rest. )
I liked the DCAMU Doomsday event movie because it showed a classic lineup of JLA members. The world's top tier A-List heroes. GL, Captain Marvel, J'onn, Flash, Cyborg, Hawkman, etc. I also liked that Wondy herself was the one to last the
longest when fighting Doomsday. It was a good representation of what I think works for her. Have her be the "warrior" but give her a clear and likable personality. Give her good moments that are worthy. Hell, a part of that film was her giving Superman encouragement to share his secret with Lois.
I think it did a good job at showing the role Wondy should have without making her bland. A bit of maturity and a hell of a lot of willpower to be the last one standing.
Don't think there's been a good Wondy last stand moment in comics. Shame. It'd have been truly fun if they did it right. If Superman's heroic ideal is to be the leading paragon of everything and Batman's is to be the man that strives for his ideals in spite of his limitations, then Wondy could be a mix of old school chivalry (in an Amazon sense) while also being compassionate until backstabbed. Let her be a bit naive to the world of man's fuckery despite her age. It'd be good to show how screwed up normal people can be. Have Wondy get involved in a case where a woman's fake rape allegations led to a man's suicide. Etc.
Wasn't the first thing she wrote, after getting hired for complaining about fridging, a comic where a female character gets fridged?
That's because writers don't take them anywhere. The solution is to write more interesting stories for them, like what Timm already did with a few less popular villains he brought in for BTAS, not gender swap pre-existing characters (who you don't even give anything interesting to do anyway).
I'd assume there was some awkward CGI implementation somewhere, especially when a character is running.
Penguin, for the longest time, has been relegated to a crime boss with a sad childhood. But, to be fair, he seems to be somewhat respected within the DCU by others because he did his whole supercrime schtick against the timeline's original wave of heroes (the Silver Age guys).
I think a good way to utilize Penguin further would be him getting shit for not going head to head against the big guns on his own any more. Have him try to prove himself, but he escapes from Superman by the skin of his teeth. His rep gets restored because he slipped away.
Etc.
Wonder Woman’s sword and shield should be kept in the same locker as Bruce’s power armor and Clark’s murder eyes, only to be used when shit has hit the fan.
Everything Bruce Timm does, more and more shows that Paul Dini was the talent and Timm is nothing more than a hack fraud with a strong right hook, if you catch my drift.
Was Timm the artist? I think he was. Makes sense he's not the best writer.
Wondy's weaponry has been accessed in the past and she's always shown that she
can use all weapons due to her training.
Would be funny to see her train with Shining Knight in some story. Have all the really old heroes that have somehow survived for centuries meet somewhere for a sword and sorcery style adventure. But, because it'd be funny, have Oliver Queen get dragged along against his will. Get Shining Knight, Gilgamesh, Beowulf, and etc.
Hell, fucking drag in Vigilante. The original DC Cowboy superhero.
Make it a fun adventure with good art and fun dialogue. Ollie is way over his head and is surprised Vigilante isn't as tense. Make the adventure about something like. . . trying to retrieve Aquaman's trident from the dungeon-temple of QWSP.