I'm picturing something like Tranquility Lane from Fallout 3, but when the siren goes off it turns into a twisted hell world where the Scandi Prude neighbors are turned into various types of demon, Abstract Daddies on St Andrews crosses, little 9 year old girls with heads that are all hair like that chick from the Ring, that blow cocaine at him, walking Fleshlights, and Balldo Head stalking him relentlessly.
Nicks a deviant faggot though would probably enjoy the hell world. Hell for him would be like for any narc, just being ignored.