It's not people, it's corporations, shills, and twitter arguers. That's why they had to make public voting count for 10%, and judges vote count for 90%.
Likewise, GOTY is exactly that. Game of the year. It's not a list of the best game to ever exist. Yet people keep treating it like it is. This was a shitty year for games, and it looks even worse once you cut out games like Halldivers 2 and Palworld. ie. Games people actually like but are considered "problematic" to the corpos, shills, and leftie culture war people.
There's also the simple fact that games aren't just released now, but are constantly updated. The argument could be made that one of the nominations for GOTY should be the Half-Life 2 20th anniversary update.
Strongly disagree. The kids today aren't playing dogshit, that's why it's failing. There was a survey or study that said the vast majority of young people are playing games more than 10 years old. This sent AAA into a panic. We can argue about the specifics (lots of people did at the time) but I'm of the opinion that modern AAA slop will be remembered the same way we talk about shit like Rise of the Robots and Superman 64.
I don't necessarily agree. No one in their right mind would consider Palworld to be a goty contender. If they did, it would only further prove my point: That I am alienated from what people seem to expect and be satisfied with. The game is not finished. Early access has been a blight on the industry ever since it reared its ugly head, and yet people keep buying these unfinished piles of shit, so developers keep letting people play their games when they are in their shittiest, most unfinished forms. It has been normalized with a thousand different cope arguments. For every instance of a game actually improved by early access feedback, there are ten instances of Dead Cells - a confused tale of schizophrenic development as the studio flip flops on what incredible "community ideas" they should implement (almost none of them are good). I don't want to play an unfinished buggy version of pokemon with guns, I want to play pokemon with guns.
But contrast this with the other game you mentioned that also had massive problems which turned me off of even playing it (I did pirate Palworld). The Helldivers 2 team is seemingly almost as retarded as the teams who want you to play their early access shitpile. Starting with bizarre region blocking due to SNOY's meddling, and from what I've heard from people I trust, the balancing and general management cannot hope to compare to something like Deep Rock Galactic (which actually is goty material and a masterpiece). Not to mention performance issues and the like.
But I don't think we have to go past the first point - the region blocking. Why are people still playing this game, when the developer's parent company just treats everyone like shit? Why do people just accept SNOY's unacceptable premise that they shouldn't be allowed to play this game with people from countries who don't have PSN? It's because the standard has been set that low, and people see it as completely justifiable, or not worth caring about. It makes no sense for a PC game, distributed on Steam to be region blocked just because SNOY doesn't offer their wondrous and benevolent Faggotstation network services in those countries. 30 thousand peak players on steam today. Disgusting. Game of the year? Nah.
None of this occurs to the average person that plays these games. They just slop them up and never question any of it. Whether you're playing early access garbage or "finished" games with massive design issues and straight up riddled with bugs, the standard is in the toilet, and I am alienated from it.
I do have hope that the industry will crash soon, and we will witness another golden age rebith, like with the NES in the 80s. I have been hoping that for a good while now. But I can only hope beyond hope that more people come to the realization that the original Resident Evil 4 completely shits on the remake, which is trash and made me feel ripped off for even wasting bandwidth and time pirating it.