Games you own or owed that's worth money today - Things you have, things you regret giving away

[Quijibo69]

Stuff I have today:

Stuff I have missing in another state: Another xbox copy of Futurama, SH 2,3,4, on PS2 and all game cases missing for handheld games.

 

[The Last Stand]

I had a copy of The Simpsons Game for Xbox 360. Price Charting says the complete copy with game, box and manual is worth about $50. I got it for $20 many years ago.

 

[The Evil Midnight Bomber]

Paper Mario TTYD sells for 200 bucks. That's still in my parents basement I'm sure. I even have the little booklet with it.

 

[Bionicle Enthusiast]

Pokemon Red, Blue, Yellow, Gold, Silver, Crystal, Ruby, Sapphire, Emerald, Diamond, Pearl, Platinum, Black, White, Black2, White2.

Fresh batteries too.

 

[The Fair Lady]

Both Haunting Ground and Rule of Rose are worth a fortune. Never selling them.

 

[Hellwalker]

I own 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand and The Simpsons Game both for PS3 but I bought those well after they became high priced. The only game I have that became valuable is Family Guy: Back to the Multiverse for PS3. Looking on Ebay shows that CIB's go for 60 dollars. Didn't think people cared too much for this game but I guess that's why is worth something.

 

[Quijibo69]

Both Haunting Ground and Rule of Rose are worth a fortune. Never selling them.

I have Haunting Ground too but it's back at home. I got it at a grocery store of all places.

 

[MrTroll]

I don't know if it's worth the most, but my favorite is my copy of the boxed PC version of Silent Hill 2, still with its big dumb "SUPER BUY: $5" clearance sticker on the front that I never bothered to peel off. Sure glad I didn't grab the other 20+ copies they had sitting there in a stack that day.

 

[The Last Stand]

Do collector's editions count? If so, Mafia III.

 

[Quijibo69]

It's just any game worth more or the same when it was new.

 

[Travis Touchdown (REAL)]

I'm away from home at the moment so I can't show pictures but I have a copies of Paper Mario TTYD, Fire Emblem Path of Radiance and Radiant Dawn and Killer7 for the Gamecube.

 

[Sundae]

I still have my copy of the GameCube game Cubivore. Used copies go for hundreds of dollars on eBay, and I've seen unopened ones go for almost 1000 bucks. Not planning on selling my copy, it's a hidden gem and is one of my favorite games.

I just wish I had grabbed a few more copies back in the day. At one point the local GameStop had 3 or 4 copies at a time on the shelf.

At one point I had a copy of Pokemon SoulSilver. As much as I enjoyed it, a few years after getting it I sold it for a bit of cash. If I had known then how much the DS Pokemon games would go up in price, I would have held on to it.

 

[Brahmin]

I have an unredeemed key for Poker Night 2.

 

[Sparkletor 2.0]

I had two copies of Suikoden IV (first one had a scratch) for PS2.

 

[That Guy Who Likes The Chili]

I'm not sure how on topic this is to the thread, but a month or so ago I realized I hadn't touched Team Fortress 2 in like 8 years, so I proceeded to go onto the Steam Marketplace and sell all my TF2 inventory and made over $200 for all the unopened loot boxes and random bullshit I had laying around from playing the game. I only put in like 196 hours so I can't even imagine the kind of gold mines that are laying around in some people's Steam accounts they aren't aware of.

Me and my cousin used to have the Blockbuster exclusive edition of Clay Fighters N64 Sculpter's Cut, and he may or may not actually still have it somewhere in his house or my aunt's house because we straight up stole it from Blockbuster (We called them and told them we broke it and paid the fee). But we tore the front label off of somehow and wrote "CLAY FIGHTERS" on it with permanent marker so I doubt its worth anything even if we did recover it. It's something that haunts me to this day when I see how much that is worth in mint condition.

 

[Dan of Steel]

I collect mainly big box PC games. In spite of being American, and being a le heckin child of the 90s, I never owned a console until I was an adult, and always played shit on PC. Started on the family computer then gradually was able to get into hardware acceleration. So, that's what most of my collection is, old PC games. But big box PC games are awesome, and if you have any passing interest in the golden era of of computer gaming (roughly 1989-early 2000s) Get some big boxes. A lot of them are still cheap.
Ones that I have that are expensive now are:
- Quake (no idea why it's expensive but it is if you look at ebay prices)
- All four of the mainline Mechwarrior games including the expansion packs
- LOOM, Monkey Island, Day of the Tentacle, Full Throttle, and other LucasArts adventure games.
- The Neverhood
- Blood and its expansions which are very rare.
- American Mcgee's Alice
- various Ultima games since Origin went all out with presentation
- The weird but cool Eidos trapezoidal boxes, like the Thief games and Tomb Raider games
- System Shock 2

I mostly look for expansion packs now since I have most of the games I want, and expansions are more rare and hard to find.

 

[Van Darkholme]

All the neo geo games I used to own. That whole scene is just retarded when it comes to prices.

Collection circa 2013. Probably not even all of it.

 

[mindlessobserver]

I have an unredeemed key for Poker Night 2.

Poker Night is great if you are into dated pop culture references and want to nostalgia for a time when pop culture was actually fun. Gameplay wise, once you figure out all the tells and how each of the AI's play the game you win every time.

Looking at my Steam Library off the top of my head, some good games are

Alice: The Madness Returns

Bioshock: Infinite

Divinity 2: Developers Cut (The Dragon Knight one, not Original Sin)

Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

and XCOM: Enemy Unknown

I also have a soft spot for Panzer Dragoon: Orta. What a fun game with surprisingly deep lore for an on rails SHMUP

 

[Squawking Macaw]

Pokemon HeartGold in its box with a fully-functioning Pokewalker. Sadly no Ho-Oh figure as I was too young to know what a preorder was.

Just a cartridge of this thing sells for 70€, the full package skyrockets to 200€. It's complete lunacy.

 

[Brahmin]

Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

Finally started a playthrough last week after figuring out how to get mods to work, really good, haven't been locked into an open world RPG like this in a while. Fuck bonewalkers, hated figuring out their nasty little gimmick.