Katholic Kiwi Kathedral (Catholocism General) - Byzantine? Ethnic? Roman? It doesn't matter. It's a place for Catholic Kiwis to discuss Catholicism and inquirers to inquire

Who is the best Catholic apologist alive today?

  • Bishop Robert Barron

    Votes: 42 47.7%
  • Fr. Mike Schmitz

    Votes: 39 44.3%
  • Trent Horn

    Votes: 23 26.1%
  • Jimmy Akin

    Votes: 14 15.9%
  • Joe Heschmeyer

    Votes: 2 2.3%
  • Matt Fradd

    Votes: 6 6.8%
  • Scott Hahn

    Votes: 13 14.8%
  • Brayden Cook - TheCatechumen

    Votes: 1 1.1%
  • Taylor Marshall

    Votes: 3 3.4%
  • Christian Fagner

    Votes: 3 3.4%
  • James White

    Votes: 7 8.0%

  • Total voters
    88
Brothers and Sisters, behold! The most cursed bastardization of the Blesssed Sacrament I've yet seen.

image0-60.webp
 
If memory serves me right, didn’t that sub get completely over ran with people saying “Jesus accepts transgender!” And stuff like that?

I’m not sure if I’m thinking of another
I think you're thinking of r/Christianity, which doesn't really contain actual Christians (the same situation is on r/TwoXChromosomes :smug:)
 
So nanna's Bible has afflicted me with nostalgia and I was considering going to visit the local parish church some upcoming Sunday to see if anything else clicks, but then I checked the diocese website (last updated for Easter this year very 90s style) and it turns out the priest who officiated all through when I used to get dragged there has retired and now they're all Nigerians. I'm not very TND minded normally but it is a bit off putting. Is there a trick to get over this (spiritually)?
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Hassou Tobi
So nanna's Bible has afflicted me with nostalgia and I was considering going to visit the local parish church some upcoming Sunday to see if anything else clicks, but then I checked the diocese website (last updated for Easter this year very 90s style) and it turns out the priest who officiated all through when I used to get dragged there has retired and now they're all Nigerians. I'm not very TND minded normally but it is a bit off putting. Is there a trick to get over this (spiritually)?
If they're a priest they are in communion with you, so you just love them as your brother. The way I think of it is you know a Nigerian priest probably wouldn't chimp out at you if you called him a nigger because he has a higher calling.
 
So nanna's Bible has afflicted me with nostalgia and I was considering going to visit the local parish church some upcoming Sunday to see if anything else clicks, but then I checked the diocese website (last updated for Easter this year very 90s style) and it turns out the priest who officiated all through when I used to get dragged there has retired and now they're all Nigerians. I'm not very TND minded normally but it is a bit off putting. Is there a trick to get over this (spiritually)?
Churches nowadays are mainly minority filled if you're in a place that doesn't have a long-lasting population of Catholics. The bigger churches where I'm at have maybe 60 to 50% Hispanic parishioners, and most of the white crowd are above the age of 50. I'm lucky enough to be in a large enough city with a thriving population of younger, homegrown Catholics, but I do understand how you feel. My advice would be to scout out a few parishes near you, celebrate mass, get a feel for whichever one speaks to you, and try it out.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Mound Dweller
You know what, I'm starting to love this Pope more and more. I believe he will repair the public image of Catholicism at least a little bit.
I appreciate the subtle contrasts between them. Francis' devotion to piety through poverty and service made him authentic, yet approachable, yet left others with a feeling of unseriousness. While I believe Leo XVI truly feels the weight of his duty, and that shows through his mannerisms. But maybe that's my American bias showing. That if they really wanted to see emotion, they would've went with an Italian.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Rango Dango
I attended a latin mass and confessional today for the first time. I'm honestly both incredibly happy and disappointed in myself, because it's something I've put off for a long time, yet it still was an incredible experience that I'm seriously considering further exploring. There's something profoundly humbling about a low mass that you don't often get in a Novus Ordo service: everyone is silent, while the priest and attendants perform their own service on the alter with careful attention to detail and prayer. I'm hoping that the traditionis custodes is lifted soon, because I believe every Catholic should attend at least one latin mass in their lives to see it for themselves.
 
I attended a latin mass and confessional today for the first time. I'm honestly both incredibly happy and disappointed in myself, because it's something I've put off for a long time, yet it still was an incredible experience that I'm seriously considering further exploring. There's something profoundly humbling about a low mass that you don't often get in a Novus Ordo service: everyone is silent, while the priest and attendants perform their own service on the alter with careful attention to detail and prayer. I'm hoping that the traditionis custodes is lifted soon, because I believe every Catholic should attend at least one latin mass in their lives to see it for themselves.
I'd like traditionis custodes to be lifted, but as a latin nerd, I attended that "one latin mass" and gotta say I wish priests were better at linguistics. For me, the latin mass isn't going to hear the "magical language" and be in awe of it, it's going to hear mass in another language I understand decently enough, but with a different form.

Maybe it was just that priest who was particularly bad, but he sounded like a cross between a banjo and a fax machine. His intonation was odd and failed at carrying stressed vs. unstressed syllables correctly and he didn't understand how geminate consonants work, which meant whole sentences eventually "misaligned" and his speech just didn't scan correctly (kinda like how G-man in half life talks, but faster) and he was a southerner (and I am too, so I'm not knocking him for that) and you could hear every particularity of southern US english vowel mutation in his speech, which is very far from italianate ecclesiastical and classical, so it made a lot of words hard to understand, since vowel clarity is pretty necessary to parsing case endings in latin.

I felt bad for feeling so negative about the whole thing that it's made me not really want to go back, since I'd be worried I'd be more focused on how badly the latin is spoken than on the sacrifice of the mass.

EDIT: I'm not even trying to knock that priest. Priests have more important things to attend to than linguistics, like parish management and pastoral care, so while I had a negative experience, he's got more important stuff to do than appeal to language nerds.
 
Last edited:
Wait so does this guy just live forever or has he only done this recently? Also can he like train a successor? I really want to see this be like a longstanding thing in the Church.
STOP YOU'RE MAKING THEM LOOK COOL :(
I think I'd be too paranoid to post anything, anywhere if there was a chance that the pope would see it.
His Holiness definitely has a burner on here, and he is judging you. Repent.
Dude at a restaurant was talking to me about his failed marriage and I was giving my take from the religious POV. Dude said Jesus wasn't real and was invented by Constantine, so I just said Jesus was the most attested to guy in the ancient world and then he started threatening me. "Say Jesus again and I'm gonna beat the fuck out of you." So I just went full autism and started saying Jesus Christ is the way the truth and the life until he left. I was all full of adrenaline because I was sure bro was gonna just fuck me up.

Pray for that guy.
Wait so did you threaten him because he was badmouthing Jesus or did he threaten you because he didn't want to hear about Jesus?
Jesus would not autistically rile up someone who is already struggling. But He also wouldn't be on fucking kiwifarms so catch me throwing the first stone here.
Let's be real, if Jesus was around today He would definitely make Null one of His Apostles for the lols. All the iconography of St. Null would just be a retarded dog and it would be keno. In all seriousness though I don't think the other guy did anything wrong but I get your sentiment.
Has anyone here ever thought of attending or has have attended an Eastern/Non-Roman mass? I believe they're a good reminder that the Catholic Church is a universal institution that has many unique expressions of the faith, but all are united.
One time I went to an Anglican Ordinate Mass. You know, the kind for former Anglicans who jumped ship but still wanted to keep some of their old rites while being Catholic. Pretty ironic given how much I despise the Anglicans.
 
Wait so does this guy just live forever or has he only done this recently? Also can he like train a successor? I really want to see this be like a longstanding thing in the Church.
Maybe this is God telling you what his plans are for you, you've got to track him down and take up his mantle.

His Holiness definitely has a burner on here, and he is judging you. Repent.
Uh-oh.

He'd probably be one of the only people on this site who could shitpost in Latin though, so that's pretty cool.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Justice Tony
Dude had a seizure at Mass on Sunday. Usher called 911 for him because he was having breathing trouble. Seizure popped off right the paramedics arrived. Couldn't have had better timing.

Father stopped the Mass, grabbed the Last Rites oil, anointed him, then had everyone say a Hail Mary as they took him away.

Grim-humored as I am, I can't think of a better place to unexpectedly croak.

I told that to MeatDad (who's not Catholic) and he said, "then be glad you're not Pentecostal!"
 
I'd like traditionis custodes to be lifted, but as a latin nerd, I attended that "one latin mass" and gotta say I wish priests were better at linguistics. For me, the latin mass isn't going to hear the "magical language" and be in awe of it, it's going to hear mass in another language I understand decently enough, but with a different form.

Maybe it was just that priest who was particularly bad, but he sounded like a cross between a banjo and a fax machine. His intonation was odd and failed at carrying stressed vs. unstressed syllables correctly and he didn't understand how geminate consonants work, which meant whole sentences eventually "misaligned" and his speech just didn't scan correctly (kinda like how G-man in half life talks, but faster) and he was a southerner (and I am too, so I'm not knocking him for that) and you could hear every particularity of southern US english vowel mutation in his speech, which is very far from italianate ecclesiastical and classical, so it made a lot of words hard to understand, since vowel clarity is pretty necessary to parsing case endings in latin
Also a Latin nerd, also feel the same way. Have you ever heard how the British massacre Latin chant? I almost had a fit a first time I heard it, lol.
 
Also a Latin nerd, also feel the same way. Have you ever heard how the British massacre Latin chant? I almost had a fit a first time I heard it, lol.
I'd want not to lol. The british massacre calquing foreign words into their own language. I'd hate to hear how they fuck up speaking anyone else's directly. It must be the utmost horror.

I wanna hear a native romance speaker say the mass in latin. I'm sure I'd explode hearing a right proper rustic roman speak the language of all civilized people with all right sounds and pauses.
 
Back