- Joined
- Sep 29, 2022
As much as I enjoy the optimism in videos like this ("Oh there are plans to save Gary!"):
Urbanists still dance around the issue that some cities are unfixable without changing the demographics. There is no magic dirt/urbanism, you cannot simply plop down classical architecture and expect the entire city to suddenly become a good place to live.
Talking about the decline of blue-collar manufacturing is definitely one reason why Gary fell as hard as it did, but you can't really build manufacturing up like overnight (and urbanists mock people like Trump for trying). The riots are important part of why Gary died as well, even today, blacks will still claim they did nothing wrong when it came to riots and anyone moving out (whites, anyone with economic stability, etc.) was the problem.
Places like Gary are a stark reminder that vacant lots aren't the cause of freeways, it's just people leaving and abandoned buildings getting torn down or burned. The issue with places like Gary and the expansion of suburbs is that there's no accounting for leadership. Europe never had the corrupt political machines that made cities suck and no one want to live there.
So unless you get some extraordinary scenario where the existing government of Gary is functionally abolished and replaced with a system that roots out every problem that prevents people from wanting to live there, nothing will really change.
Last edited: