Agreed. What Phil and a lot of "content creators" don't seem to understand is that YouTube and Google are the people that took a gamble with something that wasn't profitable. Hosting video is
expensive. Especially back in the day when Phil first started, hosting video was
really, really fucking expensive.
YouTube isn't even actually profitable to this very day. Every day they run that website, they basically throw money out the window and fuck around with algorithms to see what works. A big part of that has been experimenting with monetization and seeing how advertising might work for independent content creators, which is why in the early days YouTube was a massively profitable enterprise for someone to upload their videos on.
If you look historically at almost any similar project and the concept of monetization the early days are when people make easy money, but once the marketplace fills up with shit and people trying to abuse the system by uploading 10 times a day, that's when the money starts drying up. Advertisers don't want to have their shit on every fuckers videos when they can pick more premium content to focus on.
One of the big reasons, as you said, behind their algorithms isn't just advertisers or search results but its making sure that a user on their website gets a nice, friendly experience. Most people who subscribe to a channel will probably not watch every single video uploaded (on average) and if you allow people who upload 40 times a day to spam their inboxes, they won't get angry at the uploader, they'll get angry at the website.
To give an idea of this, I have email addresses from ages ago which are signed up on various services. I no longer use any of these email addresses, but I still get emails (and I have to check them regularly for "important" accounts).
This is what YouTube sends me:
View attachment 410268
The emails are
annoying as fuck but do you think I get frustrated at the person whose channel I subscribed to? No, I get frustrated at Google for sending me an email every fucking week. I'd sooner stop using YouTube than stop subscribing to any channel.
I've had more than 200 of those fucking emails, but because they're sent once a week I'm not frustrated enough to actually go and turn them off. Imagine if YouTube sent me an email or notification every fucking time DSP uploaded a video? I'd probably delete my account entirely.