I played 1 and 2 to completion on xbox 360 and once I got a non-potato pc, I played 2 again to completion. Across all platforms I had more than 200 hours on the series. I played a little of the presequel before chucking it, (much like 2k chucked the Australian studio that made it.) and Tales of didn't appeal to me at all.
I mean, if I were launching a reveal trailer I would want it to look great, not good, and again, I feel like there's not much there that couldn't be done on the older systems, and the borderlands 2 trailer was also in-game footage, so I don't think that's all that special. Given the environments they show off, you could have told me that this game was on the same planet as 1 or 2 and I would totally believe you. I sure as shit hope that isn't the case given the reveal at the end of 2, but who knows?
Now this, I can totally get behind you on. If you take any of the other characters and put them in silhouette, you can see the time and effort that went into their designs, much less their abilities to make them completely and wholly unique. When I look at this cast, I don't see much of anything that stands out except the Russian looking assassin guy.
I agree, if there's one game they won't fuck up, it's gonna be this one, I just don't see anything new in this trailer worth getting excited about, and everyone who is ranting about how amazing it is are basically saying this.