Victor Mignogna v. Funimation Productions, LLC, et al. (2019) - Vic's lawsuit against Funimation, VAs, and others, for over a million dollars.

[Red Wizard]

Vic actually hasn't tweeted much about it at all. At cons when asked he's specifically said he doesn't want to talk about it. Ron and Monica on the other hand wouldn't shut their whore mouths and Casey had the memorable "I told him to stop" comment to Judge Chupp.

I think there was 2 or 3 tweets altogether. I think they're confusing him and Ron.

 

[Imperial Agent]

I think there was 2 or 3 tweets altogether. I think they're confusing him and Ron.

They aren’t confusing anything.

They are intentionally misrepresenting the facts.

 

[quickthrowaway]

How in the fuck is filing your TCPA on the day of the extended deadline "timely"?

 

[AcSK1LLies]

TLDR is "We filed in a timely manner, there's no ruling that says we can't turn in stuff late, Ty didn't do his homework, and, oh yeah, Vic is a public figure because we said so."

Maybe someone should inform Mein Kough of what the meaning of deadline is?

 

[PrinceofAllCucks]

J. Sean Lemoine filed a Response to the Motion to Strike the TCPA:

So basically, "the TCPA doesn't say we can't continue to supplement material after the deadline, thus we should be allowed to do it."

 

[Make Anime Illegal]

So basically, "the TCPA doesn't say we can't continue to supplement material after the deadline, thus we should be allowed to do it."

>Gets pulled over for going 40 over the speed limit.
>You see officer, it says the speed limit is 50, not that I cant go 90.

 

[TheClappening]

Even if Vic is declared some kind of public figure, MoRon are still nailed on actual malice, anyway.

Ron is on record believing everything on PULL without verification. Reckless disregard for the truth.

Monica says Vic assaulted. Vic says he did not assault her. According to TCPA, where evidence is ruled in favor of the plaintiff, Vic's story is considered the more credible one. And since Vic's story is considered true (for the TCPA), it means Monica's is false, which also means she has knowledge of the falsity (for purposes of the TCPA).

 

[Red Wizard]

IMO the only issue I can find in this trash heap is the issue concerning supplemental filings.

On one hand, BHBH contends that because there is a strict deadline, that supplemental filings should not be allowed, since that would defeat the purpose of a strict deadline.
On the other hand, Lemwhaaa???? argues that because the statute doesn't mention supplementals, that they should be allowed all the normal stuff you're allowed to do, including supplement.

Even if Vic is declared some kind of public figure, MoRon are still nailed on actual malice, anyway.

Ron is on record believing everything on PULL without verification. Reckless disregard for the truth.

Monica says Vic assaulted. Vic says he did not assault her. According to TCPA, where evidence is ruled in favor of the plaintiff, Vic's story is considered the more credible one. And since Vic's story is considered true (for the TCPA), it means Monica's is false, which also means she has knowledge of the falsity (for purposes of the TCPA).

Watching Racket's stream, he mentions that as long as it only involved two parties, Vic and Monica, simply stating the falsity of the accusation with clear and specific evidence (stating that the specific events didn't take place) is enough to satisfy the TCPA's need for a prima facie showing, AND it also satisfies the malice condition.

 

[MrRavellon]

1. Mr Jadolf claims that he can supplement his motion past the deadline because it was never ruled that he can't. He conveniently fails to mention that it was never ruled that he can do so either.
2. He keeps saying that the hearing can be heard up to 4 months after the motion is filed. He conveniently fails to mention that this is only the case when it was requested of the court to allow discovery as part of TCPA and the request was granted.
   Otherwise the limit is 90 days, and that's with extension. Without extension the limit is 60 days.
   And that's for hearing.
3. Mr Jadolf does not address Ty's argument at all, because Ty attacked Jadolf's and Funi's supplementary filings based on the deadline to file TCPA, not based on the deadline of when the hearing on TCPA must be set.
4. Mr Jadolf essentially argues to the judge that he is allowed to file supplements to the motions this judge must hold hearings on up to the day of the hearing, making the life of said judge much more difficult if you consider the fact that if Chupp allows it this time he will have to allow it forever from now on, for everyone.
   I don't think trying to make judge's life more difficult is a good plan. I think it's an awful plan.
5. Mr Jadolf's argument is constructed in a way as to suggest Ty's arguing the supplementation of TCPA motion should not be allowed.
   Ty's argument being that supplementation of TCPA motion must be done within the deadline for filing that motion necessarily implies that Ty is of the opinion that supplementation of TCPA motion should be allowed.
   Mr Jadolf's fight against a strawman is somewhat entertaining but I doubt Chupp will be very impressed by it.

 

[LuNaS]

Talking about deadlines, isn't there a standard that you need to file a document like the one Useless Car filed with some time before any hearings or is it different because it's a response?

 

[Mr. Zed da Robot Poon Fed]

Why are they still harping on the twins story so much?

Also, Lemon Fuhrer, Vic did say that they were in the hotel room and that he asked for sex. Unbelievable that this shit is actually being considered an offense. And is Vic even suing for what the twins said about him, or for what Monica said?

 

[MrRavellon]

Twins part of the filing is irrelevant. It's a transparent attempt to prejudice the judge.

 

[RodgerDodger]

J. Sean Lemoine filed a Response to the Motion to Strike the TCPA:

Do Lemonhead’s filings make anybody else’s head hurt? They feel like they are arrogantly lecturing the Judge.

They dont come right and say it, but they basically are saying Vic is a public figure because he is engaging publicly with a matter of public concern over an incident they started. Which is not how public figure law works at all. You dont get to start a public shitstorm and then claim your target is a public figure because he is trying to clean all the shit off himself.

It seemingly works for the Washington Post, sadly...

 

[Sheryl Nome]

It seemingly works for the Washington Post, sadly...

No, thats not why that case got dismissed. Shut up.

 

[TheClappening]

Why are they still harping on the twins story so much?

View attachment 912782

Also, Lemon Fuhrer, Vic did say that they were in the hotel room and that he asked for sex. Unbelievable that this shit is actually being considered an offense. And is Vic even suing for what the twins said about him, or for what Monica said?

View attachment 912792

The twins haven't made any public statements as far as I know, and court documents are protected against defamation.

 

[NotaLolyer]

J. Sean Lemoine filed a Response to the Motion to Strike the TCPA:

Immediately A 2 is bullshit unless Lemonfuhrer means they planned to engage in only receiving Vic’s discovery he should fucking realize there’s still a pending motion to compel BECAUSE these fuckwits played discovery games and still haven’t provided jack shit of what was requested in their interrogatories.

Is this guy an idiot or does he think Chupp is a playful little puppet? “In the legion of decision over 370 not one has ever determined that a movant cannot amend or supplement a timely filed motion to dismiss”

That would be because not one had had a supplementary challenge and I can bet all of those 370 have never attempted supplement past the deadlines in the first place.


What a panicked little shit, trying to fuck up the courts time and dockets with unnecessary research.

You’re gonna get dunked on Lemonfuhrer, you better hope your clients can afford that appeal and that conflict of interest doesn’t result in you getting paid ZERO and face disbarment.


The little shit is actually trying to retroactively apply the changes made earlier this year to the TCPA... this guy is a fucking clown.

 

[Iron Hamster]

Do Lemonhead’s filings make anybody else’s head hurt? They feel like they are arrogantly lecturing the Judge.

Because he's a TCPA expert doncha know. Allegedly. He'll even tell you so!

 

[5t3n0g0ph3r]

Do Lemonhead’s filings make anybody else’s head hurt? They feel like they are arrogantly lecturing the Judge.

That'll go well for them. It certainly went well for Kevin Landau.

 

[ES 195]

Because he's a TCPA expert doncha know. Allegedly. He'll even tell you so!

Mein Kough could be an expert at this point considering most people learn from their mistakes and failing every TCPA you've done is quite a lot of them.

 

[RodgerDodger]

Because he's a TCPA expert doncha know. Allegedly. He'll even tell you so!

He’s so much of an expert that he has failed to convince a Judge in every case he’s brought. I mean I know failure is educational and all, but I don’t think I really want to be paying somebody to learn in that way.