I'm Writing a Series. - Posting this here is probably not a good idea, but oh well lol I need exposure.

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Clive Barker. I love him, but my worst Ex stole my first Edition Hellbound Heart and Book of Blood. I'm sad now.

Clive Barker also refers to bowels a lot. It is very noticeable. I do find it hilarious though.

Been a fan of Barker since I was 9 and saw Hellraiser. He's one of my horror gods whose work holds up. I didn't start reading his stuff until I was about 15 but the first three Books of Blood are a big reason why I got into writing. Him and Burroughs and Lautreamont.
 
Yeah, Barker was a huge influence on me too. The Books of Blood are fucking AMAZING. I also loved Candyman. I really need to read the sequel to the Hellbound Heart. I should re-buy all the stuff I lost.

Also, shame Midnight Meat Train was such fucking trash as a movie. That story was awesome.
 
I'm not trying to be an asshole but this is terrible. I don't know if the intent is to write something for the YA crowd or not. It comes off like it does and if so then ignore my advice because I find all YA material to be dog shit. Read something written by an actual writer. Anything. Edgar Allen Poe, Chuck Palahniuk, Bret Easton Ellis (specifically Less Than Zero in your case), Clive Barker, Ann Rice, William S. Burroughs, Hunter S. Thompson, Bukowski, fucking anyone. Take notes on how they compose a scene, introduce characters, set up the environment and the lore and all that. And then try writing again. I feel like I'm kicking a puppy but it's really bad.
I'll give my rushed, speed read take. I'm not commenting on the material, as that's a matter of taste, but just writing in general (for the sake of things I'm going to avoid spelling mistakes and grammatical errors):

1) You describe characters as if you're in a role-play session or something. Character descriptions are typically very limited (at least the way I like them). Also character descriptions should imply certain traits and let your reader imagine what they look like. Flowery prose around here is ok, especially if you want their look to convey emotion. Lots of authors also don't really describe their characters out this much. See Hermionie where she's barely even described out. Some characters aren't even describe racially. You're just left to infer from their actions and their language.

2) As others have said, don't tell. Especially when we're first meeting a character. To keep us interested, you need to draw traits out and build them up. Way too much telling of things that need to be built up.

3) Way, way too much description for the first two pages. You've got to nab your reader. The best way to do this is to hook them in with something exciting then keep them going. I'm just hit with this wall of text and my eyes sort of just glaze over.

4) Know your audience. Your language feels off for the material. If you're writing something bubbly and high-school like and not serious, try to soften your language up. I'm not telling you not to use big words or use dumb language, but don't use big words for the sake of using them. It really feels kind of cold and I know that's not the mood you're trying to portray.

5) Your character descriptions are interrupting the flow of action. Every time I'm getting invested and you introduce another character, there's a paragraph of description. I know I'm harping on this, but it is clear to me this is a problem.

6) Minor nitpick, but I don't know if you can do this on Google Docs, but any author's notes, quotations and citations typically go in the footnotes. Also try to avoid doing it unless you're making it a thing or cutesy fourth wall breaking. If you're not, don't do it. Alternatively, just have a character fuck up and think its the wrong day so you can convey this information to your reader without taking them out of the work. Always convey this information in the work itself. You want to do everything in your power to make your audience forget they're reading a book.



Great call. Definitely describe out your characters on your sheet. Put traits and background there, build them up. Even if you don't mention these events, its ok, they have no part of the story but they shape who the character is.



Clive Barker. I love him, but my worst Ex stole my first Edition Hellbound Heart and Book of Blood. I'm sad now. Clive Barker also refers to bowels a lot. It is very noticeable. I do find it hilarious though.

I think for the story though, its not really aiming to be any of those authors. But it doesn't hurt to adopt others. Brevity is the soul of wit. When you edit, you look for two things: Mistakes and cutting the fat. I always look back and go, "Is this too wordy? Does this convey what I want it to?"

EDIT:
I should add I fucking hate word for writing anything but essays or papers. I always end up with fifty fucking files. There are a lot of free writing programs out there that can keep all this in one place.
I just want to know, did you guys read the orginal version I published, or did you read the work in progress revision I've been doing, which starts here?
Version number 4.

Since I've begun to rewrite this beginning part, however, I started realising that the characterisation I initally had in mind for Waki, is not something I'm very fond to write about for the rest of the series, considering she's the protaginist, alongside Maeko.

I made her much more openly confident now, tell me if that works better.

Also, I made a greater attempt at "show, don't tell" here, but I might not be quite there yet.

“Oh, sorry!”


This was quite the common phrase for this particular girl, presently skating by a serene teenage couple beholding one another as they calmly moved along the side of the rink. In spite of the couple clearly being unconcerned with the rest of the world around them, the urge to apologize (often) was an unfortunate part of Waki’s behaviour. Still, the young lady kept up her brisk pace, effortlessly gliding through the small gathering of people that shared the rink with her, occasionally saying "sorry!" or "excuse me" to those she passed by. Her name was Waki Kurayami. 14 years old, her small, but athletic, build allowed her to weave through her fellow skaters easily and briskly. This was essential as it allowed the chill of the late fall to hit her, with the typical school clothing she wore, covered only by an unbuttoned, tight, sharp black cardigan, being unable to prevent the breezy rush her skin craved.


Following a few more minutes of speedy skatework, Waki glided to an empty part of the rink, twirled smoothly around, and began to skate backwards. She then cast her gaze to single out the set of eyes that was following her flight in the rink. Her gentle, bright, baby blue eyes quickly themselves on a happy brown pair, her confident skating not disappearing during this encounter.


“Heh, Youko, one day I need to teach you how to skate backwards!” This girl was casually leaning over the top of the rink's rigid wall, carelessly swinging her skates to and fro with her right hand. She was ready to depart for home, but decided to wait on Waki, who had desired to skate for a few minutes longer.


“Man, you’ve been so full of energy the last week or so.” leaning farther into the rink. “That because your momma’s coming back from her business trip today?”


Then, the graceful little skater, still backwards, made course for her friend. Another expert twirl later, and she had brought her flight to a stop, her smiling face a few feet from the relaxed Youko.


“He he...yep, that she is! I’ve missed her so much…” Waki began fidgeting with one of her cardigan’s buttons. “Sorry if I’ve been weird or anything lately…” With a tiny sigh, Youko stood herself up.


“Gosh, how often do I gotta tell you not to apologize all the time?” Youko said, slightly shaking her head left and right. Waki shrugged her shoulders a tiny bit, but was unable to respond before Youko resumed her questioning.


"You think, cause she was away on her trip, that she's gonna bring you something awesome back as a late birthday present?" Waki perked her head up, and brought her hands up to just below her chin.


"Oh my goodness! That would be so cool!” she chirped, jumping up, and struggling to keep balance once she landed back on the ice again. Unintentionally, her right arm, decorated with her custom black and white Zeeko watch, was brought up to close to her face. “Oh, I should get home and get things ready for her!" Thus, Waki rushed to the rink's exit, a few feet from Youko. Ungracefully power walking in her skates, she addressed a quick goodbye to Youko. "He he...see you on Monday, Youko…!" she said, almost falling over from the sudden stop she made.


A coy smile had formed on her friend’s face, and she whisperedly chuckled alongside answering back to Waki.


"See ya! Oh yeah, make sure you tell me everything that goes down, K?" she said, beginning to make her to the exit.


As she undoing her frosting white skate, she suddenly found her thoughts take on an introspective tone. She wondered why Youko was always so upset at her constant apologizing.


“It’s just the nice thing to say, is all. Besides, I’m usually in the right anyway.” She thought, as she passed from the warmth of the heated entrance way of the rink, to the soothing chill of the September weather.

Edit: Not that I don't apperciate the advice that you gave me.
 
I just want to know, did you guys read the orginal version I published, or did you read the work in progress revision I've been doing, which starts here?


Edit: Not that I don't apperciate the advice that you gave me.

A lot of the issues in the original persist in the rewrites. You've definitely lessened them, but they're still there and notable. The biggest thing you need to keep in mind, and have gotten a bit better about but still need to improve on, is Conservation of Detail and weaving that detail in a smooth way through your prose. Also less adverbs. Only use adverbs for important actions. Again, Conservation of Detail.
 
A lot of the issues in the original persist in the rewrites. You've definitely lessened them, but they're still there and notable. The biggest thing you need to keep in mind, and have gotten a bit better about but still need to improve on, is Conservation of Detail and weaving that detail in a smooth way through your prose. Also less adverbs. Only use adverbs for important actions. Again, Conservation of Detail.
Alright, good to know.

I will look back at them again.
 
I'm just going to drop this link right here. Hopefully some of the info on this site will help you. Check the sidebar for more writing tips.

Most of this is good advice, but I'm going to disagree when it comes to speech tags. While there's certainly a place for occasionally using whispered, 'said' is almost always your best choice. It comes down to what that say about trusting the reader and in almost all situations, context is going to inform the use of 'said' better than any other word. Additionally, depending on how many people are talking, you can sometimes throw out speech tags all together because it should be quite clear who's talking already if the characters have distinct enough personalities.
 
I finished reading Less Than Zero, @BrunoMattei.

I liked it, but I feel that the kinda of minimalist writing there won't really work for this.

The series is more fantasy based than what this first Episode would suggest.

Would this faster, minmalist writning style really work for this?

Also, I tried to cut down the "skating scene" even further, @Koresh, mostly through removal of adverbs. but also, some minor restructing through parts.

“Oh, sorry!”


This was a common phrase for Waki Kurayami, presently skating by a teenage couple holding one another as they moved along the side of the rink. In spite of the couple being unconcerned with the rest of the world around them, the urge to apologize (often) was an unfortunate part of Waki’s behaviour. Still, the young lady kept up her brisk pace, her small and athletic build allowing her to effortlessly glide through the small gathering of people that shared the rink with her, occasionally saying "sorry!" or "excuse me" to those she passed by. This was essential as it allowed the chill of the late fall to hit her, with the school clothing she wore, covered only by an unbuttoned, tight, black cardigan, being unable to prevent the breezy rush her skin craved.


Following a few more minutes of skatework, Waki glided to an empty part of the rink, twirled smoothly around, and began to skate backwards. She then found the single set of eyes that were following her in the rink. Her bright, blue eyes quickly set themselves on a brown pair, her confident skating not disappearing during this encounter.


“Heh, Youko, one day I need to teach you how to skate backwards!” This girl was leaning over the top of the rink's rigid wall, swinging her skates with her right hand. She was ready to depart for home, but decided to wait on Waki, who had desired to skate for a few minutes longer.


“Man, you’ve been so full of energy the last week or so.” leaning farther into the rink. “That because your momma’s coming back from her business trip today?”


Then Waki, still backwards, made course for her friend. Another twirl later, and she had brought her flight to a stop, her smiling face a few feet from Youko.


“He he...yep, that she is! I’ve missed her so much…” Waki began fidgeting with one of her cardigan’s buttons. “Sorry if I’ve been weird or anything lately…” With a tiny sigh, Youko stood herself up.


“Gosh, how often do I gotta tell you not to apologize all the time?” Youko said, slightly shaking her head left and right. Waki shrugged her shoulders a tiny bit, but was unable to respond before Youko resumed her questioning.


"You think, cause she was away on her trip, that she's gonna bring you something awesome back as a late birthday present?" Waki perked her head up, and brought her hands up to just below her chin.


"Oh my goodness! That would be so cool!” she chirped, jumping up, and struggling to keep balance once she landed back on the ice. Unintentionally, her right arm, decorated with her custom black and white Zeeko watch, was brought close to her face. “Oh, I should get home and get things ready for her!" Thus, Waki rushed to the rink's exit, a few feet from Youko. Ungracefully power walking in her skates, she addressed a quick goodbye to Youko. "He he...see you on Monday, Youko…!" she said, almost falling over from the sudden stop she made.


A smile had formed on her friend’s face, and she chuckled alongside answering back to Waki.


"See ya! Oh yeah, make sure you tell me everything that goes down, K?" she said, beginning to make her way to the exit.


As she removed her skates, she found her thoughts take on an introspective tone. She wondered why Youko was always so upset at her constant apologizing.


“It’s just the nice thing to say, is all. Besides, I’m usually in the right anyway.” She thought, as she passed from the warm entrance of the rink, to the soothing chill of the September winds.
 
The first 3 Books of Blood, Tortured Souls (very short novelette written for the toys), Imajica, The Thief of Always (children's book), Cabal.
 
The first 3 Books of Blood, Tortured Souls (very short novelette written for the toys), Imajica, The Thief of Always (children's book), Cabal.

"The book is a fable written for children, but intended to be read by adults as well "

Sounds exactly like what I intend for this series.

I'll check that one out first.
 
Here's a few good short stories online that might help. If you want, I can also go line by line of one of your revised chapters and comment on each thing, but only if you think that will help.

A Perfect Day for Banana Fish - A great example of how less is more. Salinger gets a lot of shit, but this short story is a work of art.

The Rememberer - It's on pages 3 to 5. A story with a very present narrator. Great example of Conservation of Detail and it establishes character very well with few words.

Sorry, I don't have a URL, but I do have it printed.

1.jpg3.jpg4.jpg2.jpg5.jpg

Here is the first page of the first chapter of Stephen King's Roadwork aka my second favorite novel. In just this single page, you already have a feel for the whole story.

roadwork.jpg

Here's the first actual story chapter of my favorite novel, Chuck Palahniuk's Lullaby.

chuck 1.png chuck 2.png

These all have very different prose styles, but one thing they all have in common is that in just a few pages or even words, they already portray a whole story and world. That's the key of less is more. A lot of times, more words and description, like you have, just robs the story of life since nothing is exaggerated and nothing is toned down. It's just a research paper. Show the reader what is valuable, show them what they need to focus on.
 
Last edited:
Here's a few good short stories online that might help. If you want, I can also go line by line of one of your revised chapters and comment on each thing, but only if you think that will help.
Honestly, if you wouldn't mind, this would be very helpful.

I'm a little too stupid sometimes to understand general advice.

I will get around to checking out your examples after I check out what @BrunoMattei suggested.
 
“Oh, sorry!”

This was a common phrase [This is telling, not showing. An important principle to remember is that the action you introduce your character with is the action we will forever associate with that character. First impressions are very real. If you introduced Waki as eating a cake, we'd think of her as the fatass. Since you introduce her apologizing, the readers automatically have the image of a character who apologizes a lot.] for Waki Kurayami, presently [When you say a character is doing something, that's already implied that it's happening in the present of the narrative. Reading is a linear narrative , the natural progression of a sentence and paragraph from left to right is already interpreted as the passing of time. You only need to state that something is happening in the present if you're breaking out of a flashback or flashforward or daydream or any other temporal weirdness.] skating by a teenage couple holding one another as they moved along the side of the rink. [Is this an important detail? Otherwise, the reader right now is following Waki's movement. Bringing up the movement of others will break the reader out of that. It's a frame of reference, sort of thing. Waki is faster than them, thus she's passing them, thus that's all that matters.] In spite of the couple being unconcerned with the rest of the world around them, the urge to apologize (often) was an unfortunate part of Waki’s behaviour. Still, the young lady kept up her brisk pace, her small and athletic build allowing her to effortlessly glide through the small gathering of people that shared the rink with her, occasionally saying "sorry!" or "excuse me" to those she passed by. [The prose here is pretty fine, it's just too many ideas in one sentence. A run on, in other words. I'd cut this up into three sentence of varying length.] This was essential [If the narrator is telling us that something is the case, then the reader will assume that it is essential. There is a trust relationship between the narrator and reader that the narrator will cut out all unnecessary details that don't build the world further.] as it allowed the chill of the late fall to hit her, with the school clothing she wore, covered only by an unbuttoned, tight, black cardigan, being unable to prevent the breezy rush her skin craved. [This suddenly jumps into passive voice which should always be used with careful intention. Active voice is "Waki drank tea." Passive voice is "The tea was drunk by Waki." Also the prose here is just a bit odd. Is it important that she's wearing a black cardigan? Is it important that it's unbuttoned? If it's a key character detail, then just a passing mention of the black cardigan like "the wind pierced her black cardigan" would be better than halting the action to describe it.]


Following a few more minutes of skatework,
[This falls back to that time thing I mentioned. Yes, you can do this, but it should be for unimportant actions like eating breakfast or walking down the street. It just seems weird to handwave the skating after setting it up. Also this is a great chance to show more of Waki's personality. If you want to express the passing of time without outright saying it and taking advantage to flex your literary muscles, spending a paragraph describing how she was skating, what she did, what more she noticed, will illustrate time and Waki herself. Longer paragraphs are read as more time passing, naturally.] Waki glided to an empty part of the rink, twirled smoothly around, and began to [Don't say a character began to or started to do anything unless you're trying to delay its occurrence in the narrative by a few seconds via that time thing I mentioned before or if they're going to be interrupted or stopped. In other words, only when it's important that they stop and don't complete the action or if there's a hesitance to it, or some other reason like that.] skate backwards. She then [Time thing again. You don't need to tell us that something is happening after the actions of the previous sentence. It's already assumed. There are circumstances when you should do this, but those are almost entirely flow reasons and flow is something that should be worked on in the final stages of editing.'] found the single set of eyes that were following her in the rink. [This isn't a big thing, but to me, the narration as been reading as limited within Waki's perception. It seems weird that she'd know that there was only one person watching her.] Her bright, blue eyes quickly set themselves on a brown pair, her confident skating not disappearing during this encounter. [This is just purple prose and it's honestly a bit nonsensical. Don't try to show off fancy word play, just say it how it is. You probably don't even need to tell us that she's still skating well, most people would assume that she's still presenting her pre-established trait of being a good skater. You usually only need to point out something like this if there is a change, like she startles but still skates well, or if she had an off-day skating the last chapter and can now skate well again.]


“Heh, Youko, one day I need to teach you how to skate backwards!” This girl was leaning over the top of the rink's rigid wall, [Passive voice again. Also Waki is the speaker of that dialogue. Rule of thumb is nearly always when a character says something and an action happens, if the speaker is performing the action, then you leave it in the same paragraph. That's an easy flow of idea and information for the reader. If the speaker says something and someone else performs an action in response, it should be a new paragraph since that symbolizes and reads as a break in the context/flow of info. For example:

"I'd like that!" Waki pointed at the bottle.


vs

"I'd like that!"

Waki pointed at the bottle.

The first one is pretty clear to read and understand. There is a physical connection on the page on being within the same paragraph. The second one is more ambiguous. The speaker might be Waki, or it might be someone else and Waki might be pointing at the bottle to clarify. Who knows.]


swinging her skates with her right hand. She was ready to depart for home, but decided to wait on Waki, who had desired to skate for a few minutes longer. [This is telling and not showing. You can show easily via expressing this in dialogue.]


“Man, you’ve been so full of energy the last week or so.” leaning farther into the rink. “That because your momma’s coming back from her business trip today?” [When doing a compound dialogue thing like this, commas are usually your friend. Of course, not always. If you want to illustrate a pause or an important end of the thought, then use a period. But here, you'd want a comma. Also the action of 'leaning farther into the rink' doesn't have a subject. I know it's Youko, but it's still jarring. The reader should never have to stop and figure out who or what the subject is. There's nothing wrong in framing this simply as '"... or so," Youko leaned further over the railing, "That because..." It's a lot simpler, but readers don't read to get flexed on or be wowed by prose work, they read for a story. The prose is just the tool to achieve that.]


Then [Time thing again. It's happening later on the page, thus it's happening later in the narrative.] Waki, still backwards, [You haven't made note of a change, thus she is still backwards in the narrative even without a note being made and most readers would still picture her as backwards.] made course for her friend. Another twirl later, and she had [This is the same thing as that "began to" and "started to" thing along with any other bridge words. Use them very intentionally.] brought her flight to a stop, her smiling face a [What you're doing here isn't always wrong, it's just weird here because it makes it seem like her face is seperate from her body. There's not really a reason to put emphasis on her face and her smile. Judging by their friendly dialogue, we can already assume that she's smiling or you can slide it into the next paragraph's speech tag.] few feet from Youko.


“He he...yep, that she is! I’ve missed her so much…” Waki began [Same thing as before. Also use ellipses sparingly. If there's an adverb or adjective to describe her speech pattern, use it. After a while, seeing ellipses over and over will make them fade into white noise and become meaningless to the reader. They should only be used for impact. Also most boomers text with too many ellipses and the last thing you want is people associating your YA fantasy with their dad texting about picking up gas for the mower.] fidgeting with one of her cardigan’s buttons. “Sorry if I’ve been weird or anything lately…” With a tiny sigh, Youko stood herself up. [It's that dialogue - action thing I mentioned before. This should be a new paragraph because it's a new thought.]


“Gosh, how often do I gotta tell you not to apologize all the time?” Youko said, slightly shaking her head left and right. [There is only one way to shake your head and that is left and right. Otherwise it is a nod or a seizure. Don't need to tell us that it's left and right.] Waki shrugged her shoulders a tiny bit, but was unable to respond before Youko resumed her questioning. [This is telling and not showing again. You can use that 'started to' thing here. Like 'Waki started to stammer a response" then immediately jump into the next paragraph of Youko's response.]


"You think, [cause with no apostrophe is like "this was the cause of the consequence". With an apostrophe is the shortened version of because. Apostrophes mark a contraction.] cause she was away on her trip, that she's gonna bring you something awesome back as a late birthday present?" Waki perked her head up, and brought her hands up to just below her chin. [Dialogue - action thing again.]


"Oh my goodness! That would be so cool!” she chirped, jumping up, and struggling to keep balance once she landed back on the ice. [That sentence should end at jumping up because that's the end of that action. The struggling to keep balance is a new action as a result of the previous one. Time has passed from her jumping and her landing and struggling. Also the time thing plays even more here. Right now her struggling is coming across as occurring before the landing. It's fine to play with time and cause and effect like this, but again very intentionally. I'd rephrase that whole "struggling to keep balance" part because it comes across as telling again. Say that her foot nearly slipped as she landed or that she wobbled as she landed. Don't need to tell us that she's on the ice unless she jumped over the railing onto the concrete.] Unintentionally, her right arm, decorated with her custom black and white Zeeko watch, was brought close to her face. [Passive voice again. Also how does one unintentionally bring their arm up to look at their watch? If you mean that she put her arm out to keep balance, then caught sight of her watch, then say that. Say that she grabbed onto the railing maybe. I get that the watch is important, but it's really shoved in here and it ruins the flow and pacing. I'd find a better way to weave it in.] .“Oh, I should get home and get things ready for her!" Thus, [It's logical that she would rush to leave after that statement. You don't need to point out that it's connected with a connection word. Thus is also a time word . We already knows that Waki leaving happens after her dialogue.] Waki rushed to the rink's exit, a few feet from Youko. Ungracefully power walking in her skates, she addressed a quick goodbye to Youko. [Telling not showing again. There is only one other actor in this scene and that's Youko, so we already know that she's talking to Youko. We know from the dialogue that it's a goodbye, so you don't need to tell us. The ellipses show up here again and that contradicts the quickly part of it. I think you can just say "...Youko!" she quickly said, nearly falling as she stopped suddenly." There's also passive voice in "sudden stop she made" so get rid of that. ] "He he...see you on Monday, Youko…!" she said, almost falling over from the sudden stop she made.


A smile had formed on her friend’s face, and she chuckled alongside answering back to Waki.
[Passive voice. Youko smiled as she chuckled. Bam. That's all you need. Then in the same paragraph, have her say her dialogue so it connects.]

"See ya! Oh yeah, make sure you tell me everything that goes down, K?" she said, beginning to make her way to the exit. [Who is this she? Is it Youko? Or Waki? Why are they saying goodbye if they're both going for the exit? Also K is the letter. 'Kay is the abbreviation of Okay. The beginning is fine here since the dialogue occurs within the start of the action. It works as framing.]


As she removed her skates, she found her thoughts take on an introspective tone. She wondered why Youko was always so upset at her constant apologizing.


“It’s just the nice thing to say, is all. Besides, I’m usually in the right anyway.”
[This is a non-sequitur. There's no logical reason why she would think of this now. You can easily fix this by having her apologize for leaving suddenly and ditching Youko then have Youko tell her not to say sorry, then this. Also "she found her thoughts take on an introspective tone" and "she wondered why" is telling and not showing. You can just say As Waki removed her skates, she sighed. Why did Youko always get upset about her apologizing?" And framing this with the "she thought' is weird because this chapter's narration is already limited within Waki. Limited narration rarely every needs a the focal character to have a thought tag. You can just write the thought in like I did before.] She thought, as she passed from the warm entrance of the rink, to the soothing chill of the September winds. [Earlier in the chapter you said she was hit by the Fall chill. But now she's inside in a warm rink? Just a consistency thing.]
 
“Oh, sorry!”

This was a common phrase [This is telling, not showing. An important principle to remember is that the action you introduce your character with is the action we will forever associate with that character. First impressions are very real. If you introduced Waki as eating a cake, we'd think of her as the fatass. Since you introduce her apologizing, the readers automatically have the image of a character who apologizes a lot.] for Waki Kurayami, presently [When you say a character is doing something, that's already implied that it's happening in the present of the narrative. Reading is a linear narrative , the natural progression of a sentence and paragraph from left to right is already interpreted as the passing of time. You only need to state that something is happening in the present if you're breaking out of a flashback or flashforward or daydream or any other temporal weirdness.] skating by a teenage couple holding one another as they moved along the side of the rink. [Is this an important detail? Otherwise, the reader right now is following Waki's movement. Bringing up the movement of others will break the reader out of that. It's a frame of reference, sort of thing. Waki is faster than them, thus she's passing them, thus that's all that matters.] In spite of the couple being unconcerned with the rest of the world around them, the urge to apologize (often) was an unfortunate part of Waki’s behaviour. Still, the young lady kept up her brisk pace, her small and athletic build allowing her to effortlessly glide through the small gathering of people that shared the rink with her, occasionally saying "sorry!" or "excuse me" to those she passed by. [The prose here is pretty fine, it's just too many ideas in one sentence. A run on, in other words. I'd cut this up into three sentence of varying length.] This was essential [If the narrator is telling us that something is the case, then the reader will assume that it is essential. There is a trust relationship between the narrator and reader that the narrator will cut out all unnecessary details that don't build the world further.] as it allowed the chill of the late fall to hit her, with the school clothing she wore, covered only by an unbuttoned, tight, black cardigan, being unable to prevent the breezy rush her skin craved. [This suddenly jumps into passive voice which should always be used with careful intention. Active voice is "Waki drank tea." Passive voice is "The tea was drunk by Waki." Also the prose here is just a bit odd. Is it important that she's wearing a black cardigan? Is it important that it's unbuttoned? If it's a key character detail, then just a passing mention of the black cardigan like "the wind pierced her black cardigan" would be better than halting the action to describe it.]


Following a few more minutes of skatework, [This falls back to that time thing I mentioned. Yes, you can do this, but it should be for unimportant actions like eating breakfast or walking down the street. It just seems weird to handwave the skating after setting it up. Also this is a great chance to show more of Waki's personality. If you want to express the passing of time without outright saying it and taking advantage to flex your literary muscles, spending a paragraph describing how she was skating, what she did, what more she noticed, will illustrate time and Waki herself. Longer paragraphs are read as more time passing, naturally.] Waki glided to an empty part of the rink, twirled smoothly around, and began to [Don't say a character began to or started to do anything unless you're trying to delay its occurrence in the narrative by a few seconds via that time thing I mentioned before or if they're going to be interrupted or stopped. In other words, only when it's important that they stop and don't complete the action or if there's a hesitance to it, or some other reason like that.] skate backwards. She then [Time thing again. You don't need to tell us that something is happening after the actions of the previous sentence. It's already assumed. There are circumstances when you should do this, but those are almost entirely flow reasons and flow is something that should be worked on in the final stages of editing.'] found the single set of eyes that were following her in the rink. [This isn't a big thing, but to me, the narration as been reading as limited within Waki's perception. It seems weird that she'd know that there was only one person watching her.] Her bright, blue eyes quickly set themselves on a brown pair, her confident skating not disappearing during this encounter. [This is just purple prose and it's honestly a bit nonsensical. Don't try to show off fancy word play, just say it how it is. You probably don't even need to tell us that she's still skating well, most people would assume that she's still presenting her pre-established trait of being a good skater. You usually only need to point out something like this if there is a change, like she startles but still skates well, or if she had an off-day skating the last chapter and can now skate well again.]


“Heh, Youko, one day I need to teach you how to skate backwards!” This girl was leaning over the top of the rink's rigid wall, [Passive voice again. Also Waki is the speaker of that dialogue. Rule of thumb is nearly always when a character says something and an action happens, if the speaker is performing the action, then you leave it in the same paragraph. That's an easy flow of idea and information for the reader. If the speaker says something and someone else performs an action in response, it should be a new paragraph since that symbolizes and reads as a break in the context/flow of info. For example:

"I'd like that!" Waki pointed at the bottle.


vs

"I'd like that!"

Waki pointed at the bottle.

The first one is pretty clear to read and understand. There is a physical connection on the page on being within the same paragraph. The second one is more ambiguous. The speaker might be Waki, or it might be someone else and Waki might be pointing at the bottle to clarify. Who knows.]


swinging her skates with her right hand. She was ready to depart for home, but decided to wait on Waki, who had desired to skate for a few minutes longer. [This is telling and not showing. You can show easily via expressing this in dialogue.]


“Man, you’ve been so full of energy the last week or so.” leaning farther into the rink. “That because your momma’s coming back from her business trip today?” [When doing a compound dialogue thing like this, commas are usually your friend. Of course, not always. If you want to illustrate a pause or an important end of the thought, then use a period. But here, you'd want a comma. Also the action of 'leaning farther into the rink' doesn't have a subject. I know it's Youko, but it's still jarring. The reader should never have to stop and figure out who or what the subject is. There's nothing wrong in framing this simply as '"... or so," Youko leaned further over the railing, "That because..." It's a lot simpler, but readers don't read to get flexed on or be wowed by prose work, they read for a story. The prose is just the tool to achieve that.]


Then [Time thing again. It's happening later on the page, thus it's happening later in the narrative.] Waki, still backwards, [You haven't made note of a change, thus she is still backwards in the narrative even without a note being made and most readers would still picture her as backwards.] made course for her friend. Another twirl later, and she had [This is the same thing as that "began to" and "started to" thing along with any other bridge words. Use them very intentionally.] brought her flight to a stop, her smiling face a [What you're doing here isn't always wrong, it's just weird here because it makes it seem like her face is seperate from her body. There's not really a reason to put emphasis on her face and her smile. Judging by their friendly dialogue, we can already assume that she's smiling or you can slide it into the next paragraph's speech tag.] few feet from Youko.


“He he...yep, that she is! I’ve missed her so much…” Waki began [Same thing as before. Also use ellipses sparingly. If there's an adverb or adjective to describe her speech pattern, use it. After a while, seeing ellipses over and over will make them fade into white noise and become meaningless to the reader. They should only be used for impact. Also most boomers text with too many ellipses and the last thing you want is people associating your YA fantasy with their dad texting about picking up gas for the mower.] fidgeting with one of her cardigan’s buttons. “Sorry if I’ve been weird or anything lately…” With a tiny sigh, Youko stood herself up. [It's that dialogue - action thing I mentioned before. This should be a new paragraph because it's a new thought.]


“Gosh, how often do I gotta tell you not to apologize all the time?” Youko said, slightly shaking her head left and right. [There is only one way to shake your head and that is left and right. Otherwise it is a nod or a seizure. Don't need to tell us that it's left and right.] Waki shrugged her shoulders a tiny bit, but was unable to respond before Youko resumed her questioning. [This is telling and not showing again. You can use that 'started to' thing here. Like 'Waki started to stammer a response" then immediately jump into the next paragraph of Youko's response.]


"You think, [cause with no apostrophe is like "this was the cause of the consequence". With an apostrophe is the shortened version of because. Apostrophes mark a contraction.] cause she was away on her trip, that she's gonna bring you something awesome back as a late birthday present?" Waki perked her head up, and brought her hands up to just below her chin. [Dialogue - action thing again.]


"Oh my goodness! That would be so cool!” she chirped, jumping up, and struggling to keep balance once she landed back on the ice. [That sentence should end at jumping up because that's the end of that action. The struggling to keep balance is a new action as a result of the previous one. Time has passed from her jumping and her landing and struggling. Also the time thing plays even more here. Right now her struggling is coming across as occurring before the landing. It's fine to play with time and cause and effect like this, but again very intentionally. I'd rephrase that whole "struggling to keep balance" part because it comes across as telling again. Say that her foot nearly slipped as she landed or that she wobbled as she landed. Don't need to tell us that she's on the ice unless she jumped over the railing onto the concrete.] Unintentionally, her right arm, decorated with her custom black and white Zeeko watch, was brought close to her face. [Passive voice again. Also how does one unintentionally bring their arm up to look at their watch? If you mean that she put her arm out to keep balance, then caught sight of her watch, then say that. Say that she grabbed onto the railing maybe. I get that the watch is important, but it's really shoved in here and it ruins the flow and pacing. I'd find a better way to weave it in.] .“Oh, I should get home and get things ready for her!" Thus, [It's logical that she would rush to leave after that statement. You don't need to point out that it's connected with a connection word. Thus is also a time word . We already knows that Waki leaving happens after her dialogue.] Waki rushed to the rink's exit, a few feet from Youko. Ungracefully power walking in her skates, she addressed a quick goodbye to Youko. [Telling not showing again. There is only one other actor in this scene and that's Youko, so we already know that she's talking to Youko. We know from the dialogue that it's a goodbye, so you don't need to tell us. The ellipses show up here again and that contradicts the quickly part of it. I think you can just say "...Youko!" she quickly said, nearly falling as she stopped suddenly." There's also passive voice in "sudden stop she made" so get rid of that. ] "He he...see you on Monday, Youko…!" she said, almost falling over from the sudden stop she made.


A smile had formed on her friend’s face, and she chuckled alongside answering back to Waki.
[Passive voice. Youko smiled as she chuckled. Bam. That's all you need. Then in the same paragraph, have her say her dialogue so it connects.]

"See ya! Oh yeah, make sure you tell me everything that goes down, K?" she said, beginning to make her way to the exit. [Who is this she? Is it Youko? Or Waki? Why are they saying goodbye if they're both going for the exit? Also K is the letter. 'Kay is the abbreviation of Okay. The beginning is fine here since the dialogue occurs within the start of the action. It works as framing.]


As she removed her skates, she found her thoughts take on an introspective tone. She wondered why Youko was always so upset at her constant apologizing.


“It’s just the nice thing to say, is all. Besides, I’m usually in the right anyway.”
[This is a non-sequitur. There's no logical reason why she would think of this now. You can easily fix this by having her apologize for leaving suddenly and ditching Youko then have Youko tell her not to say sorry, then this. Also "she found her thoughts take on an introspective tone" and "she wondered why" is telling and not showing. You can just say As Waki removed her skates, she sighed. Why did Youko always get upset about her apologizing?" And framing this with the "she thought' is weird because this chapter's narration is already limited within Waki. Limited narration rarely every needs a the focal character to have a thought tag. You can just write the thought in like I did before.] She thought, as she passed from the warm entrance of the rink, to the soothing chill of the September winds. [Earlier in the chapter you said she was hit by the Fall chill. But now she's inside in a warm rink? Just a consistency thing.]
About to go to sleep, I will read over all this later.
 
Sorry, @Koresh, I had no time today to read over your thing.

I will get on it when I can tomorrow.
 
Back
Top Bottom