What tactical mistake did he make? The Pizza Ship had a big gun that could blow up their ships, and with it gone, they could very slowly limp away from the enemy fleet. If it was still there, it'd have blown them out of space. The clunky expository dialogue of "it's a fleet killer" is evidence that destroying it was the right call.
If Poe hadn't made his "massive mistake" the entire Resistance would have been destroyed. This is the type of retard logic TLJ defenders use. It's fucking pathetic.
I don't think he got to pick and choose what resources he was assigned. If he did, then he's a dumbass for using stupid ships made out of explosives and paper, but the people who built those vehicles were even dumber anyway. Y-Wings had existed for 60 years by that point in the timeline, it's not like they're esoteric, impossibly advanced experimental craft.
You can only explain the movies logic with the standards it uses. And then you point out that doesnt make sense
So you want to justify something stupid with tard logic. The movie said he's bad, ergo he's bad, even though if you look at it factually, you can clearly see he's right. Also, those five planets that exploded were the whole Republic. Really. All of them.
www.google.com
If you take everything said at verbatim, you will never notice a discrepancy.
In a early draft he did and george came to the [correct] conclusion
So now you're saying the actions of Poe were entirely justified?
I never said they werent
What I've stated in passing before, and what I will now expound upon, is that the movie does not have an internal logic, or system of rules. It is a sequel, and therefore should be subject to the same rules of reality that the rest of the franchise is, but it does not obey these rules. People fly around in space for no reason. Hyperspace ramming is suddenly a viable tactic, despite the fact that it was never brought up before. Random children with brooms have mastered the Force. Rey is just as infallible as before, utterly raping the point that, no matter how much raw power someone has, they need at least some training before they can do things that are incredible. Things and people pop into and out of existence seemingly at random. It's like a five year old wrote it.
What internal rule is kept consistently? "Men bad"? "Purple hair good"? "Mary Sue Good"?
Are those storyboards real?
Was it MauLer or HFM or E;R, which one of those pointed out that you can string together any sequence of events in this movie, any sequence of lines, and demonstrate that it's what the movie's about, since it's so vapidly devoid of any actual theme. Just as Rey is devoid of character and must be projected upon to become compelling to the audience, so to is the plot void of character, and it too must be projected upon to become compelling to the audience.
