- Joined
- Sep 12, 2018
Any word on theatrical cuts of the OT from disney? I know I heard rumours about it. I'm really fucking stalty about my vhs' getting rect and not having the normal versions.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Hope everyone had a Merry Christmas, I've got more time than anything to write more of this stuff, so this double-whammy of Pts. 5 and Pts. 6 is my Xmas present to you all, written at work.
Here's what I still don't get. JJ is listed as an executive producer for TLJ. And since they were bought by Disney, Lucasfilm has repeatedly shown that they'll remove directors from projects if they're not satisfied with them. So JJ had to have known what Rian was doing before the film was finished and he could have advocated for his removal. But he didn't and now look what we got stuck with.
"Executive producer" is a very misleading term. If I recall correctly, it can mean anything from "does literally nothing," to "micromanaged the hell out of the director"
Hollywood uses it to trick you someone you recognize was heavily involved to sell tickets, but they might have done nothing at all.
Take Christopher Nolan for example. He was an "executive producer" in Batman V Superman, but he actually didn't do anything at all besides putting his name, and maybe collecting a check.
![]()
'Justice League' Credits Christopher Nolan as Executive Producer
As Justice League's release date gets closer and closer, we're seeing more and more official [...]comicbook.com
The one that actually had any power was K.K given she is the head of lucasfilm. J.J and Ryan were just contracted to do their directing jobs. I don't think they even qualify as employees.
If anything Ryan had more power than J.J, considering he was K.K personal bootlicker, and made TLJ to appeal to her poltical agenda, and J,J was just a big name director trying to profit of nostalgia.
Everything cool that happened involving the Emperor, the Empire, the force, or the prophecy have just retroactively been shat on and I just fucking hate it. The nu-Trilogy just makes everything meaningless in the end all for Ma-Rey Sue.From r/saltierthancrait:
![]()
According to the text it's not just a copy of an ISD, it's a copy of an ISD scaled up. I can't express in words how dumb that is. JJ pulled this same crap in NuTrek because he doesn't care about keeping spaceships at a consistent scale and/or just thinks that bigger=better. Although maybe here it's just an excuse they threw in to justify the death star lasers, I don't remember how big they looked in the film.
Stop expecting Disney to do it and look up the Despecialized Edition you consoomer.Any word on theatrical cuts of the OT from disney? I know I heard rumours about it. I'm really fucking stalty about my vhs' getting rect and not having the normal versions.
thisStop expecting Disney to do it and look up the Despecialized Edition you consoomer.
Maybe in the next trilogy, the main Star Wars character will be a troon Jedi?If falling in love is such a big deal for the jedi, and they lasted thousands of years on this principle. Why not just chemically castrate themselves at some point?
Forming attachments is forbidden, pump and dump is the true Jedi way!If falling in love is such a big deal for the jedi, and they lasted thousands of years on this principle. Why not just chemically castrate themselves at some point?
Lucas killed the franchise with the prequels, JJ took a shit on the corpse, and Rian Johnson just fucking raped it. Empire Strikes Back was a fluke that carried the movies.View attachment 1068971
cringe bro. Also nice ifunny logo.
Your friend is very intelligent because that's exactly the reason why these movies were shit. They want to rub their style of 'virtues' in our face. It's a deliberate rejection of the cultural values the original movies aspired to. You know there's a reason why the three main characters who had character arcs end up losers who reverse their personal growth and die anticlimactically. Lol Lando lives tho because he's black, but even he abandoned his daughter because it's not like he has connections or could summon an entire fleet to look for her. In the current year there can be no learning, personal growth, or redemption. You're less than your purported labels and values are.I had a very interesting discussion with an old friend of mine, a religious scholar, and she had a very interesting take on the ST. Her belief was one very different than proposals I've heard here as to why the ST was made the way it was, but there's parts of her theory that jumped out at me as chillingly accurate - so much so that I had to bring it up here.
At the core, her argument was that while Star Wars itself is for the most part non-secular, it teaches valuable lessons that are timeless, and, much like the Three Virtues in Ultima, can easily be used as the basis for a sense of morality - a good one - that goes beyond the movie itself. That's what makes these movies so enduring: the stories they cover and the underlying themes in them are so good. Every single major character in the OT (and even the PT) that has a coherent character arc also teaches lessons to the viewer in the process as part of the storytelling. By any accounting, there's absolutely nothing objectionable in any of this.
....Unless you're a progressive utopian trying to usher in the glorious superior future, that is.
Many of the re-occurring themes in Star Wars are very straightforward: Don't take the easy way, because you'll suffer for it. Hard work and perseverance will carry you farther than you'd ever think. You can help people become better than they were just by being their friend and rubbing off on them. It's important to be brave. If you lose yourself in anger or fear, you'll lose sight of what's important. You can become more than what you were before, if you will yourself to it. Even the brightest prodigy may have a dark spot they are not proud of, and even most despicable person may be redeemable. Sometimes a little hope can go a long way.
Now note how these are directly the opposite of Progressive orthodoxy: The easy way is good. Hard work is for suckers. Fuck everyone else, you're the important one. You should be angry and afraid all the time, of everything, and ready to go completely off the chain based upon that anger and fear. You have no meaningful agency in your own life, so give up and revel in helplessness. Anyone guilty of original sin is forevermore guilty and irredeemably evil, except for those at the top of the progressive stack, who can do no wrong. We are all fucked if you don't do exactly what we want.
Her argument is thus that the ST was specifically intended to undermine and destroy Star Wars entirely because these simple values pose an existential threat to the Progressive world-view, which is already on the decline. It certainly explains their hatred of the fandom. If they'd just made terrible movies, but didn't do what they did in The Last Jedi and The Rise of Skywalker, they'd just be one more piece of shitty Star Wars content in an ongoing landfill, ignored by the fandom entirely. The franchise endured worse in the past. That's not what they did. They went out of their way to unmake the previous movies. To destroy the messages and characters of old. You can't have someone who essentially became a hero from nothing and accomplished things on his own merits in current year, especially when the hero that accomplished this was a white male. Ergo, they turn one of the most optimistic, idealistic, beloved characters in a generation into a grumpy, vicious, murderous old hobo and without any payoff, and then gave him a meaningless death.
Kathleen Kennedy has made zero bones about her fucking hatred of the original fandom, as well as her progressive bonafides on Social Media, and if there's anything more autistic than the House of Mouse, it's the progressives and the entire pathological need for vindication. While I don't know if I fully buy it, this theory does, if truthful, makes a great deal of sense.
This concept art looks amazing, and -- quite honestly -- like something one would expect to see in any sort of Star Wars media. It's a real shame this was nixed by the highers-up in favor of something for more bland and unimpressive.Also to further show case that the designers aren't the problem but rather the higher ups, here is concept art of Canto Bight, then known only as "Casino Planet".
I like this idea. TLJ could have started with Luke being brought up to speed by Rey with what's happened in his absence. Realizing that he can no longer afford to sit and watch from the sidelines, he decides it's time to act. Although he can't take time to methodically train Rey as Yoda did with him in ESB, he could see her raw skill and teach her a few quick items to help her be more prepared for what's going to be a big showdown later on where the pair team together to take on Kylo and company. Heck, if Yoda still needs ot make a cameo here, have him appear briefly and comment how Luke has actually heeded Yoda's words in passing Jedi knowledge to Rey.Ruining Luke is what it all comes down to for me, that's just so unbelievably shitty the way they treated his character, that's my biggest bone to pick, even beyond Rey being a Mary Sue.
Because what would have been so bad about having your Mary Sue character team up and kick some ass with a beloved older character? I thought that was part of the appeal of a Mary Sue character was vicariously spending time with characters you love, not shitting on them?
Fear not, Flexible 'Farmer. With the way this thread has blown up in the past week, it's a challenge to keep up with any of it, let alone try to remember who posted what and when.Sorry I was late on the story. I did a search of the board and didn't see any sign of it.
Your friend is very intelligent because that's exactly the reason why these movies were shit. They want to rub their style of 'virtues' in our face. It's a deliberate rejection of the cultural values the original movies aspired to. You know there's a reason why the three main characters who had character arcs end up losers who reverse their personal growth and die anticlimactically. Lol Lando lives tho because he's black, but even he abandoned his daughter because it's not like he has connections or could summon an entire fleet to look for her. In the current year there can be no learning, personal growth, or redemption. You're less than your purported labels and values are.
It's why disney is intentionally poisoning the well on star wars. Everything new has no soul and is a warped simulacrum of things done better being carefully erased for being "on the wrong side of history."