- Joined
- Apr 25, 2019
So does anyone have a compilation of every Filoni Wars inconsistency with Legends? Im planning on attempting to reconcile them
Last edited:
Star Wars Griefing Thread (SPOILERS) - Safety off
- Thread starter CowReserach Inc.
- Start date
Berrakh
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jun 13, 2018
Rey should have been the fan theory that she was a reincarnation of Anakin. Keep that through-line going. And it would mean more to "the fans".
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2018
I think the biggest one to start with is Ryloth, first off it was orginally a tidally lock planet, with viscous predators and the Twi'lek were named because they lived within the twilight of the planet.
Then Filoni Wars came along and made Ryloth a genric rocky planet with a regular day and night cycle. If you can reconcile that than it wouldn't be too hard to reconcile other rectons, another one would of course being Darth maul being alive, and the pressence of Ahsoka Tano, which dosen't make sense watching Rots.
They also revived dead characthers, and prematurley killed off other like Evan Piel and Adi Galia.
I also suspect Shaak ti in the latest episode was killed off screen, so another big recton.
- Joined
- Dec 16, 2019
...another one would of course being Darth maul being alive...
I can never get past this one, then to make it worse he shows up in Rebels.
I can never get past this one, then to make it worse he shows up in Rebels.
- Joined
- Apr 25, 2019
Im fasmiliar with all those in fact I thinkl I know most if not all of them. I just want to be thorough
- Joined
- Oct 1, 2018
A big one is the Clones being compelled to perform Order 66 because of brainwashing chips implanted in their brain. This contradicts most previous portrayals of Order 66, and seems to simply be the case because Filoni needed an easy answer for why his beloved clones didn't join the jedi purge
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2018
He couldn't just have his clones be special or handwave it as Rex dosen't kill Ahsoka cause she's not a jedi anymore, he had to pull a huge asspull out of it.
I have to say at least most of Genndy Tarvosky's Clone Wars remains intact, though they never had the mission to Cato Nemodia, which should of happened according to Rots.
There's a lot to unpack from the last episode over all it's good, yet dosen't feel like it belongs in the same universe as George's films even though it tries to push it. Before I delve more into my overall thoughts these last four episodes are just Dave's Filoni's Power Fantasy, I expect Ahsoka and Rex riding wolves in the last episode.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2019
JJ and Swamp Thing? Haha
That's the worst combination ever. Especially, if they riff off of Alan Moore's take on the character...
- Joined
- Jun 27, 2014
I would be perfectly content with Star Wars getting vaulted and never touched again. Just so the hurting stops.
Thankfully Disney's utter collapse courtesy of the vicious whims of Corona-Chan seem to be pushing that way.
Thankfully Disney's utter collapse courtesy of the vicious whims of Corona-Chan seem to be pushing that way.
BR55
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- May 8, 2017
You don't understand, the chips make Order 66 tragic.
The poor Clones don't have a choice in the matter.
The Clones coldly and unwaveringly following the order without a moment's hesitation as they did in Ep3 is too dark for the kiddies you see.
With the chip in the brain they have a heartbreaking excuse.
Whoever said Filoni is incapable of letting his OC's do bad things or have bad things happen to them was on the money.
He's committed the worst sin imaginable for a writer.
He got attached.
Last edited:
RumblyTumbly
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2018
^^^
True. Its a shame too because he provided some great characters to SW. Ahsoka, the Clones, Ventress, Cad Bane, etc.
But he got a little too close to the personalities he created and that created problems down the road. The best example is Ahsoka, who worked out and became the heart of the CW show against all odds (potential to be annoying kid sidekick, potential to be a Mary Sue, etc.) and yet, when it came time to give her the hero's death, he just couldn't pull the trigger.
True. Its a shame too because he provided some great characters to SW. Ahsoka, the Clones, Ventress, Cad Bane, etc.
But he got a little too close to the personalities he created and that created problems down the road. The best example is Ahsoka, who worked out and became the heart of the CW show against all odds (potential to be annoying kid sidekick, potential to be a Mary Sue, etc.) and yet, when it came time to give her the hero's death, he just couldn't pull the trigger.
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2020
So just sat down and watched all of season 7 of the Clone Wars up to the most recent episode.
I really wish that Obi-wan/Anakin crystal arc had been chosen over the Martez sisters with Ahsoka arc. (Also fuck Disney for the obvious SJW inserts in the sisters. That horrible woke haircut shouldn't ever be in Star Wars.) The Obi/Anakin arc had some amazing character development and introspection between the two of them. Especially during those campfire scenes.
I'm ok with the madalore arc right now and I like how it appears we are going to see Order 66 in action again. My distinct hope is they show more of the major Jedi being killed and if we're lucky, more of the Jedi Temple during the sacking.
I really wish that Obi-wan/Anakin crystal arc had been chosen over the Martez sisters with Ahsoka arc. (Also fuck Disney for the obvious SJW inserts in the sisters. That horrible woke haircut shouldn't ever be in Star Wars.) The Obi/Anakin arc had some amazing character development and introspection between the two of them. Especially during those campfire scenes.
I'm ok with the madalore arc right now and I like how it appears we are going to see Order 66 in action again. My distinct hope is they show more of the major Jedi being killed and if we're lucky, more of the Jedi Temple during the sacking.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2014
The only Jedi Filoni will kill are those written by others, and he'll probably minimize it so he can preserve his own precious characters from being killers so I bet it's all off screen.
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2017
I love the death compilations of Shaak Ti. Dunno why, but it amuses me that she's the Kenny of Star Wars.
- Joined
- Dec 16, 2019
"I really wish that Obi-wan/Anakin crystal arc had been chosen over the Martez sisters with Ahsoka arc."
hahahaha an arc about actual real Star Wars characters we actually care about, not from this group.
They wouldn't have been. It was previously established some clones disregarded Order 66. The difference is he removed all nuance and agency from the clones. They went from being an extremely well structured clever trap to Palpatines retarded gambit that shouldn't have worked. How did the brainwashing not get discovered over three years? And when it wore off, wouldn't the clones have rebelled? Its stupid. The clones had to be on his side to uphold the new order and that doesn't work if they and the Jedi have a perfect relationship, if they weren't willing participants in Order 66. This retroactively ruins Revenge of the Sith and the prequels. Holy shit I just wrote something ruins the prequels...
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2017
The film effects can be handled like Coruscant was in ROTS. Who's important at Endor? The Emperor/Luke, Admiral Ackbar, Lando, and maybe Wedge and Admiral Piett (INTENSIFY FORWARD FIREPOWER). At Coruscant the important people are Obi-Wan, Anakin, and General Grievous (in his flagship). The battle follows those important people the entire time and has a few shots which gives the illusion of a larger battle. And in ROTJ the important part of the Battle of Endor is Luke confronting Vader and the Emperor on the Death Star II. The Rebel fleet is there to help the Emperor show Luke how hopeless things are. IMO the narrative would be even better if we have some adjutant shout out to the Emperor how [Grand] Admiral whoever's fleet has jumped in to finish the encirclement.
It seems clear the Rebels were really counting on Endor. And I think you can justify them raising a sizable fleet, since look at the end of ESB, they clearly have a big fleet there. For all we know, they're throwing everything they have into this just for the chance to take out the Emperor, Vader, and the new superweapon.
Very well? It's all in three dimensions over tens of thousands of cubic kilometers of space, they line up and shoot and cycle in and out as needed. It would be two clouds of ships colliding. TIE Fighters too.
It wasn't a theory, it was a fact, as mentioned in the Thrawn Trilogy and later books. I think that's a bit of a cop-out to explain why the Emperor doesn't bother to bring more ships there and presumably is actively dissuading a bunch of admirals and moffs from doing the same. Yeah, Sheev can do as he pleases, but if you're like the admirals on the first Death Star, you have no idea what your boss is rambling about when he says how unlimited the Force is. And it still doesn't preclude the Empire from stashing a few hundred ships in each system nearby as a reserve.
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2019
Exactly Bruce seems more than satisfying in defiling the DCAU with shit like Batman and Harley aka, the movie where Harley porks Nightwing and farts in the batmobile, to which Batman says it smells like discipline....who wrote that fuckness?
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2018
Alright I have gather my thoughts so I present to you my thoughts and pseudo review of the last episode. I'm happy to report overall the episode is pretty good, definitely the best of the season.
The episode starts with the Lucasfilm Ltd logo and instead of the typical Filoni Wars theme we get John Williams Fanfare. They are really trying to sell this as a film and get the memberberries going. I thought they were even going to do the long opening crawl as well, but they start with another news reel trying to remind us this is the definitive prequel to Episode 3.
General Grievous gets a new model and Damn he looks good, we could of had him in action with Son of Dathomir and Crystal Crisis, but no we had to have four episodes of Ahsoka and the dyke hairs.
The episode has Anakin and Obi-wan on not Cato Nemodia, not Nelvann, with terrible battle droid humor and of course they are win despite the odds being stacked against them, because Filoni is adverse to having the separatist ever be victorious on screen. So they receive a transmission from Ahsoka and Bo-katan. Ahsoka now goes by Fulcrum, which retcons the Ahsoka book, its minor but just remember Dave Filoni is still doing retcons, They want help from the Republic and Anakin already had the Orange Face reunion ready for her, and is about to give her lighstabers which are blue now. I don't know how Lighsabers colors work now, another retcon of the Ahsoka novel.
Also Shaak Ti doesn't appear at all in this episode but is mentioned protecting the Chancellor but has gone missing, or died off screen. I predicted she would at least appear in the background, but nope she gets shafted and I'm guessing the deleted scene where Grievous impales is what happened to her in the Filoni verse.
Then we have Obi Wan Kenobi saying they have to go to Coruscant to protect it, and like in one of those Sjw comics Ahsoka lectures them that they don't care about the common people and they should go with her to protect Mandalore, because according to her they only want to help for politics. If we didn't waste time with Martez sisters, maybe I could understand her point more and why she's gets along so well with Bo-Katan, but she just comes across as snooty and full of herself, the episode portrays her as more mature and wise than Anakin.
So Ahsoka gets half the 501st, and right away they go to Mandalore with Ahsoka teaming up with Bo-katan and it becomes total Ahsoka power fantasy she disposes many death watch members casually, we have characters from both Son of Dathomir and Space Aladin show up on mandalore. The Show ends on a cliff hanger with Darth Maul ready to fight Ahsoka, I thought it would at least take two episodes to lead up to that but oh well.
Anakin feels off like he usually dose in Filoni Wars, Ahsoka is good at everything, The Battle of Corusant like in Genndy wars happen almost the same way, except instead of being Tentacled Raped by cables, Shaak ti got
More Proof Hidalgo is full of shit, and Filoni Wars exist in it's own continuity, I can't really imagine all the Siege of Mandalore stuff happening during episode 3, overall I really liked this episode, but it felt rushed at parts.
The episode starts with the Lucasfilm Ltd logo and instead of the typical Filoni Wars theme we get John Williams Fanfare. They are really trying to sell this as a film and get the memberberries going. I thought they were even going to do the long opening crawl as well, but they start with another news reel trying to remind us this is the definitive prequel to Episode 3.
General Grievous gets a new model and Damn he looks good, we could of had him in action with Son of Dathomir and Crystal Crisis, but no we had to have four episodes of Ahsoka and the dyke hairs.
The episode has Anakin and Obi-wan on not Cato Nemodia, not Nelvann, with terrible battle droid humor and of course they are win despite the odds being stacked against them, because Filoni is adverse to having the separatist ever be victorious on screen. So they receive a transmission from Ahsoka and Bo-katan. Ahsoka now goes by Fulcrum, which retcons the Ahsoka book, its minor but just remember Dave Filoni is still doing retcons, They want help from the Republic and Anakin already had the Orange Face reunion ready for her, and is about to give her lighstabers which are blue now. I don't know how Lighsabers colors work now, another retcon of the Ahsoka novel.
Also Shaak Ti doesn't appear at all in this episode but is mentioned protecting the Chancellor but has gone missing, or died off screen. I predicted she would at least appear in the background, but nope she gets shafted and I'm guessing the deleted scene where Grievous impales is what happened to her in the Filoni verse.
Then we have Obi Wan Kenobi saying they have to go to Coruscant to protect it, and like in one of those Sjw comics Ahsoka lectures them that they don't care about the common people and they should go with her to protect Mandalore, because according to her they only want to help for politics. If we didn't waste time with Martez sisters, maybe I could understand her point more and why she's gets along so well with Bo-Katan, but she just comes across as snooty and full of herself, the episode portrays her as more mature and wise than Anakin.
So Ahsoka gets half the 501st, and right away they go to Mandalore with Ahsoka teaming up with Bo-katan and it becomes total Ahsoka power fantasy she disposes many death watch members casually, we have characters from both Son of Dathomir and Space Aladin show up on mandalore. The Show ends on a cliff hanger with Darth Maul ready to fight Ahsoka, I thought it would at least take two episodes to lead up to that but oh well.
Anakin feels off like he usually dose in Filoni Wars, Ahsoka is good at everything, The Battle of Corusant like in Genndy wars happen almost the same way, except instead of being Tentacled Raped by cables, Shaak ti got
More Proof Hidalgo is full of shit, and Filoni Wars exist in it's own continuity, I can't really imagine all the Siege of Mandalore stuff happening during episode 3, overall I really liked this episode, but it felt rushed at parts.
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2019
Why does SW has a fetish with killing my alien waifu? (unlike Feloni's, mine is actually of legal age)