I watched the LSB restream of the first Daymare stream today and for all the garbage he said during the stream, something stood out to me. Someone asked about if he's ever been scared during a game, and he started talking about how he was only scared once during RE1 when the dogs break through the window, and that he doesn't really get scared at things like movies or games so much.
I've said something like this before, but I think that more and more pieces start falling into place to prove me right. I think Phil is too dumb to understand what makes things scary. His one example of being scared is a scene that involves loud noises, sudden movement, and aggressive animals. That's the horror that stuck with him.
This isn't going to turn into a "you need a really high IQ" rant, but this has made me think about the things myself and other people find scary compared to Darksy. I think Phil genuinely isn't scared by a lot of the horror game he plays because he can't comprehend weighty concepts. He strikes me as the kind of guy who doesn't find the Exorcist or The Thing scary because he misses the point entirely. I think this is reflected during his streams when he plays horror games because when the elements of really horrific stuff hits him, he just sort of blankly says what is happening, and then hiss or goat laughs.
Maybe too dumb isn't the right words. Too shallow. Can't think beyond the immediate. As shown by his spending habits, we know he doesn't have a good concept of long-term thinking or value of things. I think he genuinely lacks the depth of thought to appreciate anything. Not just horror, but anything. Guy probably doesn't laugh at something if the laugh track doesn't play, or the people (Kat and Jasper) he's watching with don't laugh either.
The irony to me is that the inability to be affected on an emotional level by anything could make for a pretty weighty horror story in my opinoin.