- Joined
- Jul 30, 2017
Oh you should click on the link for the full effect. But here is the first quoted paragraph from Chuck in the article.If so, that is horribly vain, shallow, and self-serving. Winston Smith was practically a stand-in for the audience to get an idea of the world of 1984 and served as a walking info dump as much he did a character. Regardless, he still had his own motivations, goals, and feelings, and the story was no worse for him being his own person. You still were able to grasp the story moral and imagine what would be like in his shoes.
Turning a character into a lifeless cardboard cutout you project yourself on is generally fine in a role-playing game, because unless it's totally linear, it's up to you to determine how you will write their character with your actions. As part of a book, outside of the choose your own adventure genre, that's pretty boring, because that means you can draw nothing from the character once you put the story down, they have no unique experiences of their own that made the story interesting, they are a mere cipher you could switch out for anyone else with no changes.
“Let’s imagine that you are, as you are now, a straight white dude. Except, your world features one significant twist — the SFF pop culture you consume is almost never about you. The faces of the characters do not look like yours. The creators of this media look nothing like you, either. Your experiences are not represented. Your voice? Not there. There exist in these universes no straight white dudes. Okay, maybe one or two. Some thrown in to appease. Sidekicks and bad guys and walk-on parts. Token chips flipped to the center of the table just to make you feel like you get to play, too. Oh, all around you in the real world, you are well-represented. Your family, your friends, the city you live in, the job you work — it’s straight white dude faces up and down the block. But on screen? In books? Inside comic panels and as video game characters? Almost none. Too few. Never the main characters.”
I just also find it somewhat hilarious how Chuck is driving a lot of people to the position the Sad Puppies started at. Many of them tried to warn us all about where literature was going and how psychotic those people were, but nooooo, it was just a silly writing award, who really cared?Well now the Internet Archive and Star Wars burns. Sometimes ignoring the problem doesn't make it go away.