Some movie reviews of Axiom's End.
Merphy mentions how the novel starts out as a standard first contact movie. Later, Lindsay "comes into her own", and that really means "sci-fi devolves into monster boyfriend romance". Merphy points out Lindsay's repetitive writing, which makes sense because Axiom's End is really OC posted on Fanfiction.net. No editor gave it serious attention. Merphy also correctly notices how Cora is very passive and bratty, and that's because Cora is college dropout Bella Swan. For someone who shat on Stephanie Meyer so much, Lindsay really absorbed the former's work.
Rebecca does note Lindsay's interest in philosophical questions, but as other kiwis noted, Lindsay drops an idea rather than following through with it. Rebecca finds this impressive, and I guess it is, in a way. If you consume Independence Day and Transformers, Axiom's End looks profound in comparison.
Harman makes a point on how a woke alien is preachy, lame, and absurd. The writing style is very padded out as Harman notes, the potboiler NYT bestseller style as I mentioned before. And yes, the book is basically a fanfic that did not get thoroughly edited into a novel. And one hallmark of a fanfic is tons of world-building and character minutia (the aliens and Cora's daddy issues in this case) that are not fully integrated into the story's overall themes, character development, and plot.
Anyway, stating the obvious , Lindsay has a pathetic hateboner for Bush, like having him resign in the story - in 2007, late in his second presidency long after his worst policies were done. It's the most obvious sign (in this book) of Lindsay's political biases clouding her judgment.
"By the way, Lindsay, that's always what you're going to be known as, the Nostalgia Chick." Nice. The one thing Lindsay wants to erase from history so her toxic audience won't persecute her. Harman even mentions how Lindsay was his favorite contributor in The Guy With the Glasses, an opinion I share. Otherwise, Harman's review is this kiwi thread condensed into a YouTube video.
The Hank Green quote on the front cover is advertising for SJWs. If woke hierophant Hank Green likes it, you should do. Memodeth dunks on Cora for being so passive, including how Cora's education in linguistics does not come into play later in the book. Adding to her passivity is how Cora has no passion or desire for anything. A commenter made excuses by explaining how millennials are apathetic because of Bush and 9/11, which is bullshit. Even Adam Conover argued against the idea of millennials being cynical NEETs in a TED talk.
This even extends to Ampersand, as Memodeth complained how we are treated to tons of world-building, but we still get little of Ampersand as a "person", like if he had any personal relationships or attachments to other aliens or how a typical day in his home planet is like. Cora is not even curious about these aspects of Ampersand's life. This lack of a human touch (for lack of a better phrase) detracts from the world-building.
Rey points out the interesting philosophical ideas Lindsay had in mind when writing. Too bad she did not thoroughly explore those ideas but instead focused on SJW proselytizing and the monster boyfriend relationship, which are far less interesting. On the whole, the review is cunnilingus.
Luckily for us, fans made pozzed fanart of Ampersand, who looks like a fucking Pokemon.
View attachment 1536874
View attachment 1536875
View attachment 1536876
View attachment 1536877
View attachment 1536878
View attachment 1536879
View attachment 1536880