- Joined
- Dec 17, 2019
Yeah and two of the Coronaviruses in the antibody study cause the common cold.
>Common Cold Coronaviruses are giving us antibodies that trick the test into thinking they are COVID-19 antibodies!You think there will be immunity from a different Coronavirus, a much more mild one? There's not even good evidence that you develop antibodies from Covid-19, with reports of people contracting it twice (although those reports could be false)
>You think those antibodies which are structurally similar to COVID-19 antibodies might work like COVID-19 antibodies?
>Akachually we might not even get antibodies from COVID-19!
Fucking Galaxy-Brained take right there!
I don't claim to know, or even think one way or the other, but its certainly a realistic possibility. Keep in mind Cowpox, the Vaccina virus derived from Cowpox and Smallpox are all in the same family (though not the same genus); and the former two provide antibodies to protect against the latter. Fun Fact: it was the observation that Cowpox conferred immunity to its cousin Smallpox that gave us the first vaccine (everyone else feel free to use this fact to dunk on Karens & Soyjacks that claim herd immunity is somehow anti-vaxxer pseudoscience). Further, its worth pointing out that these two other "common cold" coronaviruses are in the same genus (Betacornavirus) as COVID, SARS-1 and MERS; meaning that they are closer related and more akin to one another than Cowpox, Vaccina and Smallpox are.
Its certainly possible, and if we are to believe the other two betacoronavirus species are close enough to COVID-19 to trick an antibody test then its not far-fetched to entertain the idea that these other betacoronavirus antibodies might transfer some level of immunity/resistance to their close cousin.
Furthermore, the hypothesis that COVID-19 is regulated moreso by T-Cells recognizing and destroying infected cells has been accepted by multiple peer-reviewed studies (just like its cousins, who'd have thought?). Antibodies are merely one factor of a host's immune response. The 5,000 IQ take that no antibodies = no resistance falls flat when you realize the body can just make more antibodies. The genetic memory of your immune system ins't just going to "forget" how to cook up an antibody to fight off a coronavirus or "lose the recipe" to the antibody, its going to have that information stored for quite some time. The T-cells will also be primed for quite some time to recognize a coronavirus infected and act accordingly.
As far as "muh reinfection" goes, I (among others) have provided sources time and time again debunking that angle. Simple case math can tell us that out of over 14 million recovered cases worldwide we have a handful of "well maybe it was a reinfection", that its clearly not very possible and likely statistically insignificant even in extremely rare cases where it does happen (i.e. someone with an immune disorder where their body actually does fail to produce antibodies, T-cells forget, etc.)