Among Phil's greatest hits with the Twitch tips rant was a statement that the tips are his and Twitch has no right to them. They have nothing to do with his streams.
Someone pointed out that he streams on their platform, so they could be entitled to a cut. Phil then said that, while true, they 'don't improve anything' and they would make a huge influx of money for doing absolutely nothing differently. Sound like the expectations of a certain streamer we know?
He also said that 'they already have subs and cheers, why do they need a percentage of tips'. I don't know, Phillip, but I notice you also have all three of those things on your leaderboard...
Additionally, Phil said that if Twitch wants money from streamers, they should just start charging to stream on the platform - a flat monthly fee, rather than some percentage of the streamer's income. He said that it wouldn't be fair to people who stream to small audiences who don't make much money, so a flat fee would be better.
1. Many of those small streamers are doing it as a hobby or side-gig and actually aren't counting their stacks of tips at the end of the night.
2. A percentage might actually screw them over less than a flat fee would if they have a small audience who don't contribute much - basic math would suggest that.
3. A percentage would hurt those 'million dollar streamers' (that Phil specified yesterday don't deserve contributions) the most.
Weird that a percentage based system would be so bad...
Except Phil just admitted what he is. He is a small-audience streamer who brings in a disproportionate amount of money, particularly via tips, that puts him in financial league with significantly bigger streamers. Phil is not one of 'the little guys', nor is he an underdog.
I don't even particularly think Twitch should do this, but I think they need to start purging some of the begging off their platform, and this would probably help. He'd probably just try to suddenly take an interest in Patreon again. That or we'd have a $300 tips goal every stream as Phil tries to tell us that Twitch taking 50% of his tips means that he needs to collect 3x as much to compensate.