Extra Credits - leftie gaming channel that had two of its members accused of "misconduct" in only 2 months

When I saw this thread I was taken aback, EC was a decent watch... about four or more years ago. It's like (hypothetically) seeing They Might Be Giants listed as lolcows.

But now that I can barely be bothered to watch any of their new content, I can see that this thread was warranted.
same my dude
 
I remember looking at their videos way back then. It started like a simple "why is not every game a nintendo game" kind of videos. Good luck applying the same criteria to outside of the mainstream genres. Not every game can be an intuitive action game. You won't get an easy tutorial in a proper sim ie Steel Beasts or strategic wargame ie Fleet Command etc.
 
Why has their artstyle been copied by nearly every historical Youtuber now? It's eerie. It's like they're the modern-day Carl Sagan for every Reddit-tier "smart guy" on the internet.
It does depend on the historical YouTuber, I don't see that on The Great War channel or C&Rsenal. The ones with more serious credibility are fine.
 
It does depend on the historical YouTuber, I don't see that on The Great War channel or C&Rsenal. The ones with more serious credibility are fine.
If you want to talk about someone with a good and unique art style (and that's about it), I would say Feature History has a good style, even though he's become increasingly more boring and normie.
 
Why has their artstyle been copied by nearly every historical Youtuber now? It's eerie. It's like they're the modern-day Carl Sagan for every Reddit-tier "smart guy" on the internet.
It's simple and it's easy to teach others. All the characters are very simple shapes - circular heads, generally rectangular torsos, simple faces, and since EC in particular uses that Rayman-esque style of floating hands/feet/heads that's even more lazy and ugly time-efficient. It's easy to keep on-model because the model is so simple and because of that it's easy to cut and paste - every single humanoid on the channel is basically a recolor just with different hair/clothes. I believe that EC uses multiple artists/has had different artists that have come and gone and they want to keep things consistent. I don't know if it's fair to say that the style is popular - it's kind of a chicken or egg debate: is everyone using the style because the market is speaking and this style is what people want, or is it popular because it's the only thing that's coming out and your options are consume it or consume nothing (I think it's probably the latter, but I don't want to put words in people's mouths). As such, it's an appealing bandwagon for uncreative people to jump on - it's easy to get a large number of panels drawn fast so faster and more frequent uploads (which the YouTube algorithm loves), stuff with the style still gets views despite how oversaturated the style is, plus there's the fact that it's taught at a lot of big US animation schools, most notably Cal Arts (again, because it's easy to teach), so it's also got some clout. Basically the only channels I see that don't use that sort of style (at least of the stuff that use their own illustrations) are the weebs using that kawaii chibi style, which is a whole 'nother can of worms.
 
It's simple and it's easy to teach others. All the characters are very simple shapes - circular heads, generally rectangular torsos, simple faces, and since EC in particular uses that Rayman-esque style of floating hands/feet/heads that's even more lazy and ugly time-efficient. It's easy to keep on-model because the model is so simple and because of that it's easy to cut and paste - every single humanoid on the channel is basically a recolor just with different hair/clothes. I believe that EC uses multiple artists/has had different artists that have come and gone and they want to keep things consistent. I don't know if it's fair to say that the style is popular - it's kind of a chicken or egg debate: is everyone using the style because the market is speaking and this style is what people want, or is it popular because it's the only thing that's coming out and your options are consume it or consume nothing (I think it's probably the latter, but I don't want to put words in people's mouths). As such, it's an appealing bandwagon for uncreative people to jump on - it's easy to get a large number of panels drawn fast so faster and more frequent uploads (which the YouTube algorithm loves), stuff with the style still gets views despite how oversaturated the style is, plus there's the fact that it's taught at a lot of big US animation schools, most notably Cal Arts (again, because it's easy to teach), so it's also got some clout. Basically the only channels I see that don't use that sort of style (at least of the stuff that use their own illustrations) are the weebs using that kawaii chibi style, which is a whole 'nother can of worms.
Of course none of those theories are mutually exclusive so it could also be an "all of the above" answer as well.
 
I'm a couple of weeks late, but if you lads remember there was that wonderful deleted scene from Captain Marvel where she assaults and robs a guy for flirting with her. I believe the director tried to explain it as a (clumsy, tone-blind) homage of the bar scene from Terminator 2.

Cue this idiot, Legal Eagle, who unironically argued with glowing eyes thunk emoji that it was in self defense, because him gently touching the map and bending it to see her constituted as assaulting her.
 
Legal Eagle is a moron that the normies of youtube treat like a supreme court justice. Really needs some dissenting legal voices on the site because he may as well be Attorney General of Youtube the way he is taken as gospel.

Speaking of dumbass animated history channels, do Overly Sarcastic Productions must be close to deserving a thread. Blue presents such a ridiculous leftiest bias in all his videos, europe bad, all other racea good. His india videos praise the Mughals as bastions of tolerance while he ignores the Mughal persecution of the Sikhs. Red is the same, has full on trump derangement syndrome (the video of her crying when Trump was elected was a highlight) and did a huge lovecraft video where she predictably moaned about racism the whole time.
 
Legal Eagle is a moron that the normies of youtube treat like a supreme court justice. Really needs some dissenting legal voices on the site because he may as well be Attorney General of Youtube the way he is taken as gospel.
Oh viva frei has taken shots at legal eagle more than once, as well as other law-tubers.
 
Figured you guys would like this

There's petition to stop the sale of the game Six Days in Fallujah and Matthew Krol, the guy that dose the voice work for Extra Credit, supports it.

Screenshot (38).png
(L) (A)

Screenshot (41).png
(A)

Screenshot (40).png
Decision makers.jpg
(L)(A)

Normally this wouldn't be a big deal but back in 2012 extra credits made a video defending the games creation.

 

Attachments

  • Facing Controversy - How to Stand Up for Games as a Medium - Extra Credits.mp4
    33 MB
Last edited:
Figured you guys would like this

There's petition to stop the sale of the game Six Days in Fallujah and Matthew Krol, the guy that dose the voice work for Extra Credit, supports it.

View attachment 2029520 (L) (A)

View attachment 2029522 (A)

View attachment 2029552 View attachment 2029570(L)(A)

Normally this wouldn't be a big deal but back in 2012 extra credits made a video defending the games creation.

This goes to show that they've completely rejected their past, now. I don't know how you can do a 180 this hard.

Do they really believe that the US government, still promoting wars in the ME, is going to ban a game that's like call of duty but based on a real event? What the fuck would the UN even have to do with this either?
 
Back