I'm so happy this thread was made because that Nexpo pedo video just made me lose any lingering interest I might've had in "horror youtube."
ARG's are fucking gay and I can't stand any youtuber that makes videos about ARG's going "ERH MA GAWD IS IT REAL OR NOT??? SO SPOOKY."
There are barely any good ARG's to begin with so seeing youtubers like Nexpo and Night Mind milk retarded shit like I Am Sophie, This Room Does Not Exist, HaUntEd TwiTtEr AcCouNtS or any crappy slenderman ripoff, etcetera, I just roll my eyes. Feels like literal content for little kids.
The only good ARG's I can think of from the top of my head are anything Wham City creates, Post Content and Local58, but even in those cases can you even call it an ARG? It feels more like just art projects with lots of hidden secrets for fans to enjoy deciphering. Everything else is already so tryhard and overdone, watching horror youtubers hype it up like it's some serious spooky stuff makes it even cringier.
I can't praise
Horror Stories enough, the guy gives no shits and gets straight to the point. If you wanna watch actual morbid stuff that somehow don't get booted off youtube, he's the one.
I don't care for stupid and obviously fake cliche 4chan creepypastas (don't get me started on shit like Erratas) so other than Horror Stories I just mainly watch Barely Sociable and blameitonjorge. They both have their spergy moments but I like that they don't pretend something is more than it actually is, and they actually prioritize giving real facts over dramatizing the story.
The Exploring Series is probably one of my favorite youtube channels. You might be put off at first if you're not already into SCP but give it a shot, it's worth it. The fact that he's not even pretending to be in character or doing spooky creepypasta narration and still manages to make legit horror content should say enough. I can't decide what video of his I like the most because they're all great but this is one of the top ones in my opinion