I think there’s a non zero chance that with the amount of dialogue, reading, and early game speed bumps he might pull a Stalker; wander around the map for 30 minutes doing nothing before judging the game as not fun and too slow and sending it to Banworld.
That’s on top of the potential chance for him to 1) get wiped so often in the first area that he pusses out and uninstalls or 2) choose game journalist difficulty (to own the haters who want to see him fail, of course).
There's so many ways this can go wrong.
Is there a name for the phenomenon that Dave displays when he lies constantly and compulsively for sometimes little to no gain but simultaneously and pardoxically shows restraint in that he tries very hard in his lies to keep some semantic 'truth' and always leave himself an out and will not tell an outright bald faced whopper he has to own unless under great pressure.?
Just narcissistic self-preservation. By carefully selecting his lies, or lying by omission, or by not specifically lying but letting the listener jump to his preferred conclusion without correcting them (I have bills to pay! where "bills" refers to anything with a receipt including his WWE Champions micro-transactions), he protects his fragile ego. It's also convenient for someone as lazy as him to have an excuse he can prefix with "I didn't say
X, I said
Y" to avoid doing the work he represented he was going to do (I didn't say I was going to reboot Project 7, I said I was going to make a Project 7 reboot
trailer; I didn't say I didn't get a cat, I've
already had a cat). This puts the person pointing out his lie in the position where they have to look up the truth to prove him wrong, which instantly makes them a mentally ill obsessed detractor. He's comfortable telling big lies when he can make the person questioning them look like a bad person (I lied to protect my family and if you point that out you must want my family to die) or if he thinks he can successfully gaslight them (Come to me for the honest truth, don't listen to detractors, but if you ask me about my financial situation, even just the most cursory details, you need serious mental help).
Since today is the start of Divinity 2, I'll go ahead and say right away that I'm more interested in how his character will turn out rather than what character he'll make in the beginning. I bet he'll go back to a garbage balanced build that he utilizes in any other RPG of that type (look at CyberPunk2077, hell look at his Dark Souls and Nioh builds). Any kind of freedom is the bane of Dave's existence because he doesn't know how to play vidya so he doesn't know what strengths he should focus on (cuz he has none) so he ends up with a character who can only utilize all the skills and options the game has on offer poorly.
My understanding is that if you're playing on anything but game journalist difficulty, spreading skill points too thin will leave your characters really underpowered. If he tries to round out his mages with combat skills or vice versa I think he'll be ill-equipped to make much progress. Even something as simple as having two party members with the same hydrosophy spells leaves you tactically open to things you could prevent if you diversified more. And yeah, he can respec as much as he wants, but I don't think he has enough brain cells to do this properly across his entire party (because party balance is very important), and it's possible to lose access to your character's current skills if their new specializations don't support them, so you can bet on that happening.
I recently started watching GOOD lets players... one of then was playing blind RE2RE and he begged viewers not to spoil it for him. He said many times that if you dont like watching a streamer getting stuck on the puzzles and you wanna backseat him, why you watch it?
At one time he pretended to stuck at chess piece puzzle for 10mins... He said he wanted to know which viewers wanted to backseat him. He said these people are "special" and they need "special care".
The difference is night and day.
The streamer Tomato—who I've watched maybe one or two streams of, but has over 100,000 followers—is insanely adamant about backseating, and will straight up ban for it. Besides the generic "don't be a dick" chat rules, backseating is the only act specifically called out as bannable. I wish DSP had a mod that was willing to time out or ban backseat chatters. DSP not being able to have his chat play the game for him while he does nothing, and rakes in more money for gambling, would be the icing on the cake.