You can make one game of execptional quality magic into existince - What game do you pick?

A first person Splatterhouse, with combat inspired by Dark Messiah and Condemned. Get Jim Cummings back for the Terror Mask, *Insert up and coming VA's here* for Rick and Jennifer, and shit tons of gore and series references. Bam, instant hit, plus it'll provide some competition for Doom on "Which series does the killing demons in increasingly brutal ways".
 
Crustyguy said:
That dream elder scrolls game I wanted with ridiculous amounts of detail, where every playstyle is fun, every skill has something game-changing, player choice is encouraged, followers are actually characters, and the lore isn't shat upon.
Click to expand...
So Daggerfall Unity modded to le tits.

Also, Wayward Realms if it gets made.
 
I'd love to see mass effect 3, but without the shitty writing

If it has to be a new game bloodborne 2
 
Last edited:
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Bumblino
A fantasy first person VR rpg. So taking skyrim VR but improving the gameplay further and adding more stuff. Weapon variety like d&d, way more spells, add in attributes, more action style combat, larger world, more variety of monsters/enemies, and just more stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bumblino
A new Silent Hill game by the old crew that gave us 2 and 3, same continuity as those games.

That's literally one of the things I want most out of life, it always broke my heart that we never got just one more game on the level of quality of 2 and 3, it just feels wrong that it never happened, it's sickening the way Konami mishandled that talent.

Silent Hill, especially 3, really resonated with me on a deep, personal level.

"We were put here on this Earth, put here to feel joy"
 
  • Like
  • Feels
Reactions: Aaa0aaa0 and Sundae
Superhero/villain turn-based sandbox rpg with great character creator and seasonal events popping up to keep it alive. There's permadeath and your beginning power is randomly rolled but with achievements/challenges in your run you can weight the scales further to one power or another (or get 3 choices per roll etc unlocked as you go). There would also be some civilian stuff in the mix but nothing boring and grindy, maybe just social links and activities that help out your attributes ala persona. It'd also would have to have some sort of house customization because I love that stuff. Maybe clothing too. OH also you can choose whether to roll a new character in the previous world (your previous characters would've altered the timeline somewhat so the world would reflect that in some manner) or just roll a new world and begin anew.
 
Aside from the previously mentioned Banjo-Kazooie 3, at this point all I want is a proper Rayman 4, with the same level of quality as Rayman 2. Could even have elements from the canceled Rayman 4 from a few years back.


Sadly, between Michel Ancel retiring from the gaming industry and the current state of Ubisoft, I doubt we'll ever get a high quality 3D Rayman game again.

And on the subject of cancelled games, I wouldn't mind seeing the cancelled Sabreman and Donkey Kong Racing games get a second chance at release.
 
I had commented that I would make Star Wars 1313 a while ago. For a non-SW suggestion, I would suggest Batman: Arkham Knight.

The Arkham Knight would now be an older Damian Wayne leading the League of Shadows. He would be hunting down Batman to avenge Talia's death.

The armored Batsuit would be replaced with the Batman Beyond suit. I also would have added to the gliding mechanics through the use of the Beyond suit's jet-boots.

The story would take inspiration from The Dark Knight Returns since it would have an older Bruce come out of retirement for one last night. This would allow for a satisfying conclusion to the series as it would be a subtle nod to this being the last game in the Arkham series. This would add more emotional weight to the story.

The Scarecrow would be one of the main villains, but not the main villains. While he is an interesting villain with a lot of setup throughout Arkham City, I don't think he can carry the game by himself.

I would also bring back Hush as one of the villains so that he could take over Wayne Enterprises, but in a more interesting way than just trying to steal money.

The Joker segments wouldn't start as early into the game. I'm okay with him being involved, but have it as the Scarecrow gas driving Batman insane rather than literally turning into the Joker. Use it as a way for the player to be unsure about Batman since he would become an unreliable narrator/POV. I would keep some of the Joker scenes (The Killing Joke/Jason flashbacks).

I would have the game end with Batman dying and/or officially giving the role to Azrael so that AK would wrap up that plot thread a bit better.

Nightwing's appearance and story would be similar to how it plays out. Unfortunately, they didn't do much with him in the previous games.

Tim would be a lot less of a beta male. His only job in AK is to get captured and whine to/about Batman.

Oracle was fine, I liked her portrayal in AK. I would have had her kidnapping happen later in the game, though.

Jason coming back from the dead would have been a side story that emulated the Red Hood story. It would have been a nice diversion from the main story.

That's all I have for story ideas at the moment, so I'll leave one more major change: Only keep 25% or less of the Batmobile sections. I want to play as BATMAN, not the friggin car.

Sorry for my long post, I've had many thoughts regarding what I wanted from this game versus what we actually got. It has a lot of good elements (the combat, visuals, voice acting, alternate suits, etc.), but the missteps are very unfortunate.
 
Last edited:
  • Winner
Reactions: Aaa0aaa0
a game with dialogue comparable to fallout nv , gunplay of eft , and the world of life after people but set like 5 years into the apocalypse , main threats are a mix of the clickers and raiders and it takes place in a abandoned american city.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: DeadwastePrime
James Roancrest said:
Sorry for my long post, I've had many thoughts regarding what I wanted from this game versus what we actually got. It has a lot of good elements (the combat, visuals, voice acting, alternate suits, etc.), but the missteps are very unfortunate.
Click to expand...
I feel the exact same and love what you came up with, this kicks ass. Dammit rocksteady :(
 
  • Feels
Reactions: James Roancrest
Planetside 3. Big fuckoff battles in early Planetside 2 were some of the most fun I've had in an FPS.

Team Fortress 3, or maybe TF 2.5. TF2 was my favorite FPS for a long time, but it's really showing its age these days. Still fun, though.

A sequel to the THQ Space Marine game. I know they had story plans for a trilogy, and I kind of want to see how it would go even if the gameplay of the first one is just Gears of War with spess mehreens.
 
  • Agree
  • Winner
Reactions: Sundae and Bumblino
A really filthy competitive multiplayer game of some kind(MOBA or battle royale). It would be hugely popular because of the gameplay and people would just have to put up with the filth or install mods to tone it down but those will break with every new and frequent update and content patch. You can make a troon in the game but I think genitalia will be important in some way so they're completely useless. People will accept this because of the magical lore reasons. Anything homosexual will be considered team killing and gets you banned, for lore reasons, not just to further torture certain people. Trump is probably in it.

I wouldn't play it myself so I don't care, I don't like MOBAs or multiplayer, I just want a great game that tortures the audience yet they keep playing it. Maybe I'll call it Dead by Daylight 2.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Bumblino
Maratus volans said:
Planetside 3. Big fuckoff battles in early Planetside 2 were some of the most fun I've had in an FPS.
Click to expand...

Planetside 3 but the grinding is not retarded and it has more vehicles (maybe add sea/submarine stuff) and facilities you can build (although I dunno how this one would work I feel like it'd be cool if your faction could add facilities to controlled nodes).
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Maratus volans
Bumblino said:
Planetside 3 but the grinding is not retarded and it has more vehicles (maybe add sea/submarine stuff) and facilities you can build (although I dunno how this one would work I feel like it'd be cool if your faction could add facilities to controlled nodes).
Click to expand...
Honestly, I just wanted more stuff for vehicles to do. I haven't played Planetside 2 in a while, but around the time I stopped the devs were talking about adding control nodes that you can only cap with tanks / other vehicles to certain facilities, and I think that would have been awesome to have from the get-go. I loved tanking as Vanu but at most facilities your main value was getting into weird spots with good lines of sight to the spawn room and just emptying your magazines into anyone who poked their heads out. That, plus the wide-open spaces on a lot of maps, made tanks largely pointless when compared to air.

I think the main selling point of Planetside is that you can play a combined arms game with a huge group of other people, so my ideal remake of the game really would lean into that as hard as possible.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Bumblino
A team fighter like MvC but Loony Tunes.
Alternatively a true sequel to Ninja Gaiden Black with NG2s combat and NGBs world design.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sundae and Bumblino
Legend of Dragoon 2 with some kind of time warp plot element similar to chrono trigger. Some evil wingly wants bring back the past or something and sort of enslave a modern world. The modern world would be a continuation of the OG LoD with some (cliche) steampunk elements.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back