NeoGAF & ResetERA - The Hilarious N̶e̶v̶e̶r̶e̶n̶d̶i̶n̶g̶ Splintering "Gaming" Forum Circus

It is like "I want the site to go back to its former glories, but the only tool I have is the ban-button".
There's no ban transparency, the mods are banning people and deleting their posts. It's gone back to gaf 2014, which was just REE before the split. But now there is a ree, so gaf is... nothing.

Were watching a website fail, for the second time, with the same owner, making the exact same mistakes. That's got to be an Internet first right?

Tyler 'elfy shower goblin' Tyler, forever known as the biggest loser in the history of gaming websites.
 
There's no ban transparency, the mods are banning people and deleting their posts. It's gone back to gaf 2014, which was just REE before the split. But now there is a ree, so gaf is... nothing.

Were watching a website fail, for the second time, with the same owner, making the exact same mistakes. That's got to be an Internet first right?

Tyler 'elfy shower goblin' Tyler, forever known as the biggest loser in the history of gaming websites.

Can confirm. It's bizarre. It's like a light switch has been flicked on in the Elf's head and he just randomly reverted back to pre-2019 tier loser-ville. You'd think that he would have learned from last time. I'm just glad that I got out relatively early.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: Begemot
There's no ban transparency, the mods are banning people and deleting their posts. It's gone back to gaf 2014, which was just REE before the split. But now there is a ree, so gaf is... nothing.

Were watching a website fail, for the second time, with the same owner, making the exact same mistakes. That's got to be an Internet first right?

Tyler 'elfy shower goblin' Tyler, forever known as the biggest loser in the history of gaming websites.
So basically banning the vaguely right of centre people who stood by him when the wokescolds left? Interesting. I wonder if, like resetera, we can see stats for neo-gaf?
 
Tyler 'elfy shower goblin' Tyler, forever known as the biggest loser in the history of gaming websites.
He's got competition.

Russ Pitts loudly "rescued" The Escapist from Hitler and his Nazis only to get cucked and mega-cancelled by fucking Chelsea van Valkenberg, causing him to resign and abandon the site.

At least Lord Virgin got to see a chick naked.
 
So basically banning the vaguely right of centre people who stood by him when the wokescolds left? Interesting. I wonder if, like resetera, we can see stats for neo-gaf?
Unfortunately wayback machine does not have anything cached as far as i can tell earlier than early 2000 or so,
but I looked at the traffic for third week of april and compared 2020 and 2021 and traffic had dropped from ~3500 posts a day to ~2500 posts a day in the gaming forum. That is a pretty bad drop, almost a third was lost.

Then for something fun, look at stats for january, I think it was around january 26 (+/- a few days, dont remember)
where suddenly about 10% of all posts just dissapeared from one dat to the other across the whole site.
So, the purge and "remove wrongthink" has been going on for a while.
When someone confronted him and asked about "why did 10% of all posts just get deleted?" He just responded "strange". lol.

EDIT: Actually, you do get stats in wayback machine prior to early 2020 too, you just have to look for www.neogaf.com/forum/ Sorry for me being retarded.

There's no ban transparency, the mods are banning people and deleting their posts. It's gone back to gaf 2014, which was just REE before the split. But now there is a ree, so gaf is... nothing.

Were watching a website fail, for the second time, with the same owner, making the exact same mistakes. That's got to be an Internet first right?

Tyler 'elfy shower goblin' Tyler, forever known as the biggest loser in the history of gaming websites.

I don't think it is the mods that are banning these people. His mods were often quite reasonable. I am certain that these perma-ban waves are Elf himself banning people, not the mods.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it is the mods that are banning these people. His mods were often quite reasonable. I am certain that these perma-ban waves are Elf himself banning people, not the mods.
If that's true then he's off the deep end.

Unfortunately wayback machine does not have anything cached as far as i can tell earlier than early 2000 or so,
but I looked at the traffic for third week of april and compared 2020 and 2021 and traffic had dropped from ~3500 posts a day to ~2500 posts a day in the gaming forum. That is a pretty bad drop, almost a third was lost.

Then for something fun, look at stats for january, I think it was around january 26 (+/- a few days, dont remember)
where suddenly about 10% of all posts just dissapeared from one dat to the other across the whole site.
So, the purge and "remove wrongthink" has been going on for a while.
When someone confronted him and asked about "why did 10% of all posts just get deleted?" He just responded "strange". lol.

EDIT: Actually, you do get stats in wayback machine prior to early 2020 too, you just have to look for www.neogaf.com/forum/ Sorry for me being retarded.
you can look at site traffic on Alexa. He used to post monthly stats of how well the site was doing. Back in January he had dropped to 17k.and today he's at 35k.

The average number of 'users online' has plummeted and there are hardly any reactions left.

This is the death throws for the site.
 
If that's true then he's off the deep end.


you can look at site traffic on Alexa. He used to post monthly stats of how well the site was doing. Back in January he had dropped to 17k.and today he's at 35k.

The average number of 'users online' has plummeted and there are hardly any reactions left.

This is the death throws for the site.

What can you say? He made a major bet and the market went in the opposite direction.
Elf : "I will fucking ban-button my way back to the top. What can go wrong?"
 
Can confirm. It's bizarre. It's like a light switch has been flicked on in the Elf's head and he just randomly reverted back to pre-2019 tier loser-ville. You'd think that he would have learned from last time. I'm just glad that I got out relatively early.
This kind of thing doesn't come out of nowhere.

It's almost certainly some kind of real life pressure, my guess would be he's trying to date a woman with touchy politics or is getting pressure from some kind of Sleeping Giants type of campaign behind the scenes.
 
This kind of thing doesn't come out of nowhere.

It's almost certainly some kind of real life pressure, my guess would be he's trying to date a woman with touchy politics or is getting pressure from some kind of Sleeping Giants type of campaign behind the scenes.


I agree, IMHO he definitely got spooked by something.

That's why I said I do not judge him. Every day I see rich/famous/accomplished people groveling and self-flagellating before the woke mob.

I am not expecting heroism from a video game forum owner.
 
I agree, IMHO he definitely got spooked by something.

That's why I said I do not judge him. Every day I see rich/famous/accomplished people groveling and self-flagellating before the woke mob.

I am not expecting heroism from a video game forum owner.

You know what spooked him? I think I know.
Thanks to wayback machine:
Stats on total number of visitors at ~2AM on a sunday, in whatever timezone Waybackmachine happens to be in:
2021 April 25 : 2276
2021 Jan 24 : 3173
2020 Apr 26 : 2964
2020 Jan 26 : 3387

Somewhat flat number of eyeballs across all of 2020. Then a brutal loss of eyeballs since his january sperg.
I assume there is a direct and linear correlation between eyeballs and ad revenue.
That is what fucking spooked him.

EDIT: he might have lost about a third of his income since january. That would spook anyone. Especially if your entire adult life has been about "running a faggot site" and you have no other marketable skills.
 
Last edited:
I agree, IMHO he definitely got spooked by something.

That's why I said I do not judge him. Every day I see rich/famous/accomplished people groveling and self-flagellating before the woke mob.

I am not expecting heroism from a video game forum owner.
Fuck him. He should kill himself.
 
I hope I'm not the only one who finds the recent rash of progressive asians trying desperately to build themselves a nice race card like the other minorities to be laughably pathetic.
I think my favourite moment was during the Democratic primaries when the news media was full of opinion pieces outraged that there were no POCs left in the race...when Andrew Yang was still running.

YOU DONT COUNT, YELLOW MAN.
 
View attachment 2116508
Whoever wrote this, you're either a terrible person or raised by terrible people.
Well I know I'm kinda late on this but the whole 'older sibling helps raise their younger sibling(s)' trope isn't anything new and it's not exclusive to Japanese media anyway as you can find plenty of Western media that are examples of this trope by the way.

Also, I guess ResetEra doesn't really understand the concept of dysfunctional families and orphans because in real life there are plenty of people out there that have to raise their younger sibling(s) and it's because either the parents are dead or the parents don't give that much of a shit that they have to take on that role then.
 
Last edited:
What can you say? He made a major bet and the market went in the opposite direction.
Elf : "I will fucking ban-button my way back to the top. What can go wrong?"
I wouldn't class it as a bet. I made a post in November last year, and again in December, saying what will happen with GAF (shit was already changing then), then he had his big sperg out in Jan and again in April.

He had a whole group of people telling him why he shouldn't sperg out like he did and he still did it. From April 2020, all he had to do was nothing and his website would have bounced back.

Now? He will be jobless by April 2022
 
  • Agree
Reactions: kuda
Did anyone get a screen grab of Soy_Sauce's final post? It's been deleted and scrubbed from the site. Gaf is down 17,000 places since the big ban spree after jan 6th. Good business model that
He archived the page on Webpage Archive and posted a link in his next post immediately which can be found here. EDIT: Complete version can be found here, which includes all the later posts.
It's a doozy.
Screengrab for just the post:
8kofZ1o.jpg

Coincidentally, I had also archived it on Wayback Machine here but it seems to have been removed? It was active last time when I visited just after Soy_Sauce's ban, not anymore. Can you request pages that are on a domain you own to be deleted from Wayback Machine?
 
Last edited:
Back