Random Internet Person
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2019
4 is just what China’s going to be doing now. And they’ll pay hush money over Xinjaing (assuming the Taliban give a shit).It depends on how you define "war". The two of you might have to agree to disagree on this one, I think.
However, I'd offer a third take: we actually DID win the war, if by "we", we mean the people who got us into the war, and by "win", we mean accomplish those people's geo-strategic aims. We won the conventional war (obviously) and we also won the occupation war.
The Invasion of Afghanistan was never about regime change and establishing liberal democracy in the Middle East. It wasn't about going after Bin Laden, either, whom many in the intelligence community believed was either dead or elsewhere.
The Invasion of Afghanistan had four primary aims:
The Afghan War succeeded beyond anyone's expectations at (1) and (3). (2) was a success for twenty years, and we've still got so many bases overseas that a drawdown in Afghanistan is hardly noteworthy (except to journos and the public, who have been encouraged to learn about Afghanistan, and not, say, American involvement in the now sixty year long Moro war). (4) was largely successful, too - and while the glory days of Afghan poppy profits may be behind us, it'd be silly to call twenty years of successful plundering "a loss".
- the lend legitimacy to the War on Terror and what, at the time, was referred to as "the neoconservative agenda" - the establishment and growth of the national-security state (which was originally going to be used against Muslims, but as people at the time warned, has now grown to be used against Muslims, Christians, anarchists, white people. black people, shitposters, transphobes, and normies who only want to grill)
- to position American soldiers in what Halford Mackinder termed "the Heartland"; that geographic region between the three great power blocs of Europe, Russia, and China.
- to provide for the Military-Industrial complex an absolute windfall of profits, in the form of both weapons sales AND construction contracts. (get paid to blow up the country, get paid to rebuild.
- to secure and exploit Afghanistan's valuable natural resources, e.g. lithium, rare-earth elements, and heroin.
I mean, people have lost faith over the elections after 2020. All that needs is people thinking there’s going to be a return to 2020 rules.I think it's a matter of time when people realize they've lost the right to vote. "No Taxation Without Representation" is still a thing.