Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Is this season awful for anyone else? I got Demon Slayer pt2, Rust Eater Bisco, How a Realist Hero Rebuilt the Kingdom, and The Genius Prince's Guide to Raising a Nation Out of Debt every week and that's it.

Rust Eater Bisco I'm kind of 6/10 on but the offbeat setting gives me Dorohedoro vibes so it has my attention. Doctor main character is chronically boring though, and Mushroom Terrorist main character is generic shonen protagonist to the max.

Realist Hero is alright but it's eternally one stupid plot from getting dropped because it's an isekai where MCs power is paying attention in high school civics classes while the people in the world hold an idiot ball to make him look better.

Raising a Nation Out of Debt is basically the same anime as Realist Hero without being an isekai but his setting seems to be holding a much smaller idiot ball so it might work better. Hard to say 2 episodes in.
It's feeling like a worse-than-usual season to me. Realist Hero I avoid because it's the most reliant on idiot-ball-holding show known to man. Genius Prince has thus far been a vastly inferior adaptation compared to the manga.

Hakozome (Police Women) and Kuroitsu-san (Monster Development Department) are decent workplace comedies. Bisque Doll is pretty. Bisco I appreciate for its out-there setting. But outside of that and part 2s of some good shows, it's rather grim.
 
I am trying to remember the name of a manga about a guy who loves 80's idol songs and there is a girl who likes it too. what the fuck is the name of it?
 

Slow Motion Wo Mou Ichido; スローモーションをもう一度; Slow Motion Once More

Not sure which will get you more googleability
thanks, here a funny page
WOH85-14.jpg
 
Golden Kamuy is great and more people should watch it, obligatory post of the best OP/ED in the series and one of my favorite end themes for any anime:

Is this season awful for anyone else? I got Demon Slayer pt2, Rust Eater Bisco, How a Realist Hero Rebuilt the Kingdom, and The Genius Prince's Guide to Raising a Nation Out of Debt every week and that's it.

Rust Eater Bisco I'm kind of 6/10 on but the offbeat setting gives me Dorohedoro vibes so it has my attention. Doctor main character is chronically boring though, and Mushroom Terrorist main character is generic shonen protagonist to the max.
Golden Kamui is great. I'm glad it's getting another season. People joke about Jojo being homoerotic, but Kamui wins in that aspect thanks to all the jokes. The action is great, CGI bear notwithstanding. It's definitely an odd season. Orient seems fun, but you can't compare it to the budget Magi had. It looks cheap, despite the premise. I'll still watch it, but it's generic shonen. Fantasy Bishoujo is funny, but the premise will get old quick if the other characters such as the Kirito parody aren't as interesting. Bisco seems cool, but yeah the Panda doctor will just show Bisco how to be more empathetic and stopping his sister from wanting to kill him. I liked the use of animals as vehicles/weapons. Also, the hitmen wearing those bunny masks reminded me of the manga Doubt.

Slow Loop seems to fit the slice of life activity shows well, but it's a simple watch. Love of Kill seems interesting and the story is getting darker than the first episode. Need to watch Bisque Doll, Akebi-chan's first episode was okay, not sure if it'll catch my attention. Tokyo 24th Ward was interesting with its extended episode, but since it's a cloverworks original it'll probably change halfway through the season. World's End Harem is pointless to watch in its censored version. Police in a Pod's first episode didn't really catch my attention, but I'll give the second episode a try. Other than Princess Connect S2, Takagi San 3, Rankng of Kings, Demon Slayer... it's not that big of a season. How was the first season of Arifuerta?
 
Someone made a manga about Anna Comnena, no idea if there are more chapters planned or what they're even saying because I don't speak japanese.
cover.png
I just want a comfy manga about the Byzantine Empire.
 
Last edited:
I'm almost done S2 of Mushoku Tensei and I still like it. I see a lot of people talking about Golden Kamuy which I watched 1 episode of, laughed really hard at the CGI bear and dropped. The way you guys talk about it, it seems like maybe I should pick it back up. Would you say the anime is a good adaptation or is it one of those shows where the manga outclasses it by a country mile? I figured it'd be the latter due to CGI bear-kun but I'll pick the anime back up when I'm done Mushoku Tensei if you're telling me it's actually pretty good.
 
I'm almost done S2 of Mushoku Tensei and I still like it. I see a lot of people talking about Golden Kamuy which I watched 1 episode of, laughed really hard at the CGI bear and dropped. The way you guys talk about it, it seems like maybe I should pick it back up. Would you say the anime is a good adaptation or is it one of those shows where the manga outclasses it by a country mile? I figured it'd be the latter due to CGI bear-kun but I'll pick the anime back up when I'm done Mushoku Tensei if you're telling me it's actually pretty good.
I think the cgi bear was honestly the best and worst thing in the anime.
Best because it filtered out a lot of anime only fags on /a/ and normie fags on Twitter so discussion didn't go to shit.
Worst because holy shit was it awful. Thankfully that's the only horrible CGI in season 1 and they switched to 2D bears in the later seasons.
 
I'm almost done S2 of Mushoku Tensei and I still like it. I see a lot of people talking about Golden Kamuy which I watched 1 episode of, laughed really hard at the CGI bear and dropped. The way you guys talk about it, it seems like maybe I should pick it back up. Would you say the anime is a good adaptation or is it one of those shows where the manga outclasses it by a country mile? I figured it'd be the latter due to CGI bear-kun but I'll pick the anime back up when I'm done Mushoku Tensei if you're telling me it's actually pretty good.
I love the anime. It's directed and voiced very well, especially Tsurumi (same guy as Sato from Ajin) but they also cut a lot non-crucial arcs, including a lot of Sugimoto's backstory, so I don't know if I should recommend it or not. I'm leaning towards "yes" but definitely try out the manga after to see what you missed. And if you read the manga first give the OPs and EDs a watch at some point even if you don't watch the whole anime.

The manga is in what's likely the final arc and killing it. I smiled ear to ear when some random bear survived the cow catcher at the end of the last chapter. It was the one thing this arc still needed. Every character is fighting on a runaway train and now there's a bear. We've reached peak Golden Kamuy.
 
I'm almost done S2 of Mushoku Tensei and I still like it. I see a lot of people talking about Golden Kamuy which I watched 1 episode of, laughed really hard at the CGI bear and dropped. The way you guys talk about it, it seems like maybe I should pick it back up. Would you say the anime is a good adaptation or is it one of those shows where the manga outclasses it by a country mile? I figured it'd be the latter due to CGI bear-kun but I'll pick the anime back up when I'm done Mushoku Tensei if you're telling me it's actually pretty good.
Yeah, the CGI is pretty damn wonky, especially in the first season, but Geno gradually improved in their use of it, and I think they were actually using it well by the time season 3 rolled around. I know they've been something of a budget studio and Brain's Base might do a better job, but I think Geno was hitting their stride. We'll see whenever season 4 comes out.

I can't speak to comparisons with the manga since I haven't gotten around to reading it yet (damn backlog), but the anime is a lot of fun. It's a unique setting (Hokkaido around 1910), great story, good balance of comedy and drama, tons of interesting characters, and a variety of plots that weave together. You also learn a lot about Ainu culture along the way, as well as the geopolitics surrounding the aftermath of the Russo-Japanese War. The downside is that, as I said, Geno is a more budget studio, and that budget shows in places. Panels I've seen from the manga have fantastic art, but it's sometimes not very well done in the anime. The art does improve though, and I think the other aspects are more than enough to make up for it.

Overall, it's great stuff, just get past the CGI bear and you'll be in for a hell of a good time.
 
Yeah, the CGI is pretty damn wonky, especially in the first season, but Geno gradually improved in their use of it, and I think they were actually using it well by the time season 3 rolled around. I know they've been something of a budget studio and Brain's Base might do a better job, but I think Geno was hitting their stride. We'll see whenever season 4 comes out.

I can't speak to comparisons with the manga since I haven't gotten around to reading it yet (damn backlog), but the anime is a lot of fun. It's a unique setting (Hokkaido around 1910), great story, good balance of comedy and drama, tons of interesting characters, and a variety of plots that weave together. You also learn a lot about Ainu culture along the way, as well as the geopolitics surrounding the aftermath of the Russo-Japanese War. The downside is that, as I said, Geno is a more budget studio, and that budget shows in places. Panels I've seen from the manga have fantastic art, but it's sometimes not very well done in the anime. The art does improve though, and I think the other aspects are more than enough to make up for it.

Overall, it's great stuff, just get past the CGI bear and you'll be in for a hell of a good time.
What’s it actually about? Personally I’m not too into “realistic” historical fiction (which is the impression I got from it, I could be totally wrong) but I’ve heard a lot of good things about it so I may give it a shot.
 
I think the cgi bear was honestly the best and worst thing in the anime.
Best because it filtered out a lot of anime only fags on /a/ and normie fags on Twitter so discussion didn't go to shit.
Worst because holy shit was it awful. Thankfully that's the only horrible CGI in season 1 and they switched to 2D bears in the later seasons.
I actually dropped the anime adaption of Golden Kamuy because of the bears ngl. I'll give it another try but even then I'll probably still recommend the manga over the anime since the scanlations come with neat translator's notes about references.

Plus I'd imagine the anime misses the fun movie parody chapter cover pages.
 
What’s it actually about? Personally I’m not too into “realistic” historical fiction (which is the impression I got from it, I could be totally wrong) but I’ve heard a lot of good things about it so I may give it a shot.
Basic premise is a treasure hunt, where a criminal stashed away a pile of gold, tattooing parts of the map to the treasure on his fellow convicts. A bunch of different groups want the gold for their own purposes, which is where a lot of the conflict arises. But there are a bunch of other subplots mixed in that weave through the story, and while it starts off kind of simple, it quickly gets complicated as new characters show up and new truths are revealed.

I'd say it's not super "realistic," in that it's mostly grounded in reality but with a more stylized twist to it. It's ridiculous how many awesome commando-like characters you'll find. There are a couple real historical figures that come into the plot, but you don't need to know who they are to follow the story.
 
Basic premise is a treasure hunt, where a criminal stashed away a pile of gold, tattooing parts of the map to the treasure on his fellow convicts. A bunch of different groups want the gold for their own purposes, which is where a lot of the conflict arises. But there are a bunch of other subplots mixed in that weave through the story, and while it starts off kind of simple, it quickly gets complicated as new characters show up and new truths are revealed.

I'd say it's not super "realistic," in that it's mostly grounded in reality but with a more stylized twist to it. It's ridiculous how many awesome commando-like characters you'll find. There are a couple real historical figures that come into the plot, but you don't need to know who they are to follow the story.
Golden Kamui is literally a Western but with the proper nouns and settings changed to something appropriately Japanese (i.e. Ainu instead of Indians).
 
So, I finished the Chainsaw Man Manga (part1). I was pretty impressed with it!

Thought people were maybe overhyping it. But they weren't. Has great action, solid character development, bunch of WTF moments and good designs/artwork.

Was also actually happy with the ending. Which shocked me. Thought I was gonna hate it.

I'm happy the Author decided to take a break before rushing into part 2. Wish more Manga authors would take breaks and breathe some, just for their own sanity and wellbeing.
 
Last edited:
So, I finished the Chainsaw Man Manga (part1). I was pretty impressed with it!

Thought people were maybe overhyping it. But they weren't. Has great action, solid character development, bunch of WTF moments and good designs/artwork.

Was also actually happy with the ending. Which shocked me. Thought I was gonna hate it.

I'm happy the Author decided to take a break before rushing into part 2. Wish more Manga authors would take breaks and breathe some, just for their own sanity and wellbeing.
You know, it IS interesting how more manga don’t go the “multiple parts with discrete standalone storylines with no significant overarching plot” structure. Jojo is the only other major example I can think of off the top of my head. I guess it’s usually something you may see more with LN’s, Monogatari and Index/Railgun (the only two LN adaptations I’m familiar with) definitely share this structure, where the story doesn’t really have an overarching “end goal” it’s building towards, but rather just a series of mostly unrelated storylines with some vague thematic link.

Honestly, I think that’s a very sensible narrative format that doesn’t get enough attention in the realm of action/battle manga. Not only does it allow the author to take some time off between parts, it also takes some of the pressure off by reducing the overall impact of narrative blunders. Without a real overarching plot, a particularly shitty storyline can be easily ignored, instead of staining everything around it and ruining the whole story. Like, I thought Jojolion was shit, but I’m still excited for whatever Part 9 will bring because it’ll be its own standalone story that isn’t dragged down by Jojolion’s flaws.
 
Back
Top Bottom