Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Started reading Naruto, didn't know what else to read, and I wanted to go through the big three at some point anyway. Should I dread the inevitable power of friendship or isn't it that bad ?
It's not bad. It's WORSE. The fucking Uchiha take over the narrative and run with it, there's veery poor art in certain issues, and the Sasuke asshole has an inflated camera time due to being the author's favorite. The ending has a massive asspull because the writer got stuck in a corner that he couldn't get out of for a while.
 
Last edited:
I heard Ushio & Tora is really good too.
Yes and y'all should check it out. Do it for him.
1772743666876.png
 
Okay. Now did you pay attention to the rest of the ending? A flower is blossoming on his arm. Protagonist dies on his own but with a smile.
The flower doesn't blossom, a little gizmo on his prosthetic projects an image of a flower. Particularly, the one associated with the girl he tried to rescue and was ultimately only able to offer a mercy kill. If we're talking symbolism that's a significant difference. The idea I got there was that he was finding peace by reminding himself of why he did it all. It's been a while since I saw it but I didn't see much implication of humanity being reborn; putting aside themes and symbolism the city was the last remaining pocket of flesh-and-blood humans(I think?) and everybody there was either dead or had been converted into a pod person, slowly dying due to their mechanical bodies being out of power. The experiment to ensure human survival through forced evolution was a complete failure.

There was certainly a cathartic element to the protagonist dying on his own terms and being satisfied with his end but with a setting as inherently bleak as that there's just no way you're going to get anything that qualifies as a feel-good ending, at least not how I'd define it.
 
Started reading Naruto, didn't know what else to read, and I wanted to go through the big three at some point anyway. Should I dread the inevitable power of friendship or isn't it that bad ?
It's about the same as everything else. You're reading a manga aimed at little boys, they're all going to push friendship over being an anti-social sperg.

I think it peaked a little bit before the war but I still don't regret reading it. I never watched the anime but the soundtrack is very good, so I would check that out
 
The flower doesn't blossom, a little gizmo on his prosthetic projects an image of a flower. Particularly, the one associated with the girl he tried to rescue and was ultimately only able to offer a mercy kill. If we're talking symbolism that's a significant difference. The idea I got there was that he was finding peace by reminding himself of why he did it all. It's been a while since I saw it but I didn't see much implication of humanity being reborn; putting aside themes and symbolism the city was the last remaining pocket of flesh-and-blood humans(I think?) and everybody there was either dead or had been converted into a pod person, slowly dying due to their mechanical bodies being out of power. The experiment to ensure human survival through forced evolution was a complete failure.

There was certainly a cathartic element to the protagonist dying on his own terms and being satisfied with his end but with a setting as inherently bleak as that there's just no way you're going to get anything that qualifies as a feel-good ending, at least not how I'd define it.
How I interpret Texhnolyze is like an inversion of the Plato's Cave Allegory. The surface is somehow more depressing than the hellish underground and at the end he finds his own light or a reminder of what he did it for like you say. The blooming flower of the ending prior to the finale is symbolic of a few things to me. Played with a beautiful song by GACKT, and it's one of my favorite ending themes ever. The sages proclaim Lukuss aka Lux will be reborn, and while the show doesn't disprove them they are eventually killed. But they seem important enough for me to trust their word.

It takes from Mouse Utopia too a little. I find it to be a far more satisfying ending than Lain's ending in terms of closure, it definitely feels better to me. I'm the minority when it comes to Texhnolyze. A depressing tone doesn't have to mean it's a feel bad ending, maybe I'm crazy but it was heartwarming to me and a little sad. The characters all died according to their values and stuck by them to the end. It's pretty inspiring, while the world is bleak (some) people are still human.

What makes it satisfying for me is the way it ties everything together by the end for those who decided to stick with it. Most people wouldn't last a 10 episodes in. It's a very rewarding anime and there's no other that have made me feel multiple emotions about it all at once.

TLDR is the best way to define the show is "hauntingly beautiful". There is beauty and joy in some tales of sorrow. I rejoice in it.

This song among many other tracks in the show represent it best.

(Instrumental version I found)


(Normal version with lyrics)

For better Texhnolyze analysis there's Crit Bonus's old YouTube series on it. He finally uploaded another entry after like 7 years lol. And then there's this for faster reading:
 
Last edited:
TLDR is the best way to define the show is "hauntingly beautiful". There is beauty and joy in some tales of sorrow. I rejoice in it.
I largely agree with that. It's a dark show that uses its tone to make the few spots of brightness feel all the richer, and it concludes on exactly the note it logically should - the protagonist has suffered and seen the world slowly deteriorate from a dingy dystopia to a living hell that culminates in the apparent end of humanity, and the one goal that sustained him through the worst of it was in the end denied to him. Yet, there is a sense of peace; his journey is over and he can finally rest. It's a solemn, primal and utterly unforgettable. I wouldn't at all describe it as "feel bad"- I simply don't think it's in any way a "feel good" ending, nor should it be.

To me "feel good" means something tonally lighthearted. When I hear "feel good" I think of the kind of thing you watch when you just want to turn your brain off and enjoy some cheap dopamine, IE either SoL/CGDCT shows with no real conflict(something like K-On) or comedic shows where the conflict is largely there so funny things can happen(EG Delicious in Dungeon). An ending that fits that bill is only really going to work for a series that either isn't particularly dark to begin with or starts out dark but invests much of its runtime into a gradual tonal shift.
 
Ended up finding an anime called Usavich. It's a very weird 3d anime about a pair of prison escapee rabbits, their frog friend, and the mayhem they end up in.
Biggest sticking point, one of them is named Putin.
 
It's not bad. It's WORSE. The fucking Uchiha take over the narrative and run with it, there's veery poor art in certain issues, and the Sasuke asshole has an inflated camera time due to being the author's favorite. The ending has a massive asspull because the writer got stuck in a corner that he couldn't get out of for a while.
I just find it hilarious how both the narrative and retarded average fan dick ride Itachi for the same thing Danzo is condemned for
 
Ugh. Why the fuck am I reading and watching Apothecary Diaries? It's not like there's ever going to be good doujins from this, the main guy is a eunuch and the protagonist is flat-chested and has a background working for a brothel.

Naruto doesn't need to be read after volume 27.
Gaara Rescue still has Sakura and Chiyo vs Sasori. Plus there's everything to do with Pain up until the end of the Pain Invasion.
 
Ugh. Why the fuck am I reading and watching Apothecary Diaries? It's not like there's ever going to be good doujins from this, the main guy is a eunuch and the protagonist is flat-chested and has a background working for a brothel.
I am not sure what you expected. It's very obviously marketed to lonely, nerdy women. The "plain" protagonist that the royal man desperately wants, who is smarter than everyone around her and fixes issues nobody else is smart enough to, that even when she fails she succeeds, who works at a brothel but somehow doesn't end up sucking dirty dicks for money, and also all the prostitutes there have hearts of gold... It reeks of Mary Sue, romantasy wish fulfilment. It's the female equivalent of How Not To Train A Demon Lord.
 
It's very obviously marketed to lonely, nerdy women.
Most anime is marketed to lonely, nerdy men. Your avatar is from Youjo Senki, where the protagonist is a Mary Sue Nazi who also happens to be a fat guy in the body of a loli.

I expected the show to be a bunch of court drama and touchy feely stuff that I honestly enjoy. I just didn't expect it to also be narou as shit where the protagonist is a walking encyclopedia of factoids who starts off plain only to later be hiding their traditional attractiveness.
 
Most anime is marketed to lonely, nerdy men. Your avatar is from Youjo Senki, where the protagonist is a Mary Sue Nazi who also happens to be a fat guy in the body of a loli.

I expected the show to be a bunch of court drama and touchy feely stuff that I honestly enjoy. I just didn't expect it to also be narou as shit where the protagonist is a walking encyclopedia of factoids who starts off plain only to later be hiding their traditional attractiveness.
If you haven't seen the show, then do not lie about what the show is about. It's fine to not have seen the show, but don't be a retarded faggot about it.

Isn't that the trend a lot of female wish fulfillment follows? I thought it was pretty obvious it was going to be romantasy slop, but I can also get why people would have expected different. At least initially, it did present itself as a somewhat serious show.
 
Back
Top Bottom