Culture B.C. powwow organizers apologize after identity-based event rules spark outrage - First Nations attacked not by the government this time

Article | Archive




Organizers of a popular powwow in Kamloops, B.C. have issued their “sincerest apologies” after the event rules posted to their Facebook page sparked significant public outrage.

According to a Tuesday post, contestants in the 41st Annual Kamloopa Powwow must be “at least (1/4) Native Blood,” and proof of “tribal identification/status may be required.” The rules also stated that dancers must wear full regalia and “be of the correct gender for that category.”

The rules sparked immediate backlash, with some social media users accusing the Kamloopa Powwow Society (KPS) of enforcing colonial blood quantum, excluding gender diverse and two-spirit people, and upholding transphobia.

“My deepest sympathy to those who have been hurt and harmed in that posting,” said an organizer in a video posted to the group’s Facebook page on Wednesday. “The KPS board has been able to meet to discuss how we’re going to move forward and looking at those rules and making our wrong right.”

The KPS said Thursday it had no comment on the story as it prepared a formal press release.

READ MORE: Second annual convoy to Kamloops, B.C. honours the ‘lost souls’ of residential school
The term “blood quantum” refers to a colonial blood measurement practice used to determine who can obtain government-issued Indigenous status and who can pass it onto to their children. While not specifically referenced in Canadian legislation, the Indian Act lays out such criteria.

In a video viewed more than 154,000 times as of Wednesday, two-spirit Nakota Sioux TikToker Kairyn Potts said the Kamloopa Powwow is “enacting literal colonization tactics.” He further described the gender limitations as “heartbreaking” and a “step backwards for our community.”

“It is actively undoing a lot of the work that myself, and many, many, many other advocates for the two-spirit and Indigenous queer community are putting in so much work, and love and energy into,” he said.

Click to play video: 'Inside Pride: Two-spirited Sask. Indigenous girls inspire others to be themselves'


Inside Pride: Two-spirited Sask. Indigenous girls inspire others to be themselves – Jun 10, 2022
On Twitter, Cree lawyer and activist Tanya Kappo described the “blood quantum” and “correct gender” stipulations as “shameful.”

Stellat’en First Nation actor and model Shannon Baker tweeted, “Kamloopa powwow you should be ashamed of yourself! Blood quantum and being anti LGBTQ2S+ is colonial thinking.”

On Facebook, the Kamloops Pride Society said it has reached out to the Kamloopa Powwow Society to encourage a change in rules that intentionally includes two-spirit, trans and non-binary folks.

“Two-spirit people were historically celebrated and valued in Indigenous culture, and these decisions don’t align with that,” it wrote.

“Many of the voices we are hearing are echoing the sentiments of how these rules and decisions stem from the white colonialism, patriarchy, and systemic issues that still oppress these communities.”

READ MORE: Being Two-Spirit and trans in Canada: How colonization shaped the way we view gender diversity
In its own Facebook post, C&T Tabulating, a business that tabulates and measures powwow outcomes through a point system, said it was withdrawing its services from the Kamloops event.

“We support peoples choices, we support inclusivity and cannot in good conscious put ourselves in a situation where our two spirit youth within our family see us enforcing any of these rules (sic),” it wrote.

It was clear in the event organizers’ Wednesday apology that other dancers and individuals had withdrawn as well.

“I do not know how we’re going to recover from this,” the event organizer said in their video. “We respect your decisions and just know that we are here to relook at how we’ve been operating and how we can move forward in a good way so there is no room for hurt and harm to anyone.”

Click to play video: 'Emotional support workers preparing for Pope Francis’ visit to Maskwacis'

Emotional support workers preparing for Pope Francis’ visit to Maskwacis

According to the KPS, the now-controversial rules stemmed from a German participant in the powwow who won an event one year, upsetting some participants, and from an elder who once spoke about the need for the jingle dress category to be a women-only event.

“Today we’re more open to acknowledge our two-spirited,” the organizer said, “and even … Indigenous communities that it includes First Nations, Métis and the Inuit people.”

She herself was “hurting” as a result of the pain caused by the rules, she added. In its Facebook post, the KPS said the rules posted this week don’t reflect how it has run the last 19 powwows.

The Kamloopa Powwow takes place on Tk’emlúps te Secwe̓pemc territory, but the First Nation does not organize the event. Global News has reached out to its chief, Kúkpi7 Rosanne Casimir, for comment.
 
So wait, keeping white people out of Indian spaces is now colonialism?
I'm not surprised, white people with only tenuous connections to some form of native ancestry are usually the most vocal about their supposed tribal ancestry. It was only a matter of time before it became double-plus ungood for native groups to kick out the paleface LARPers.
 
I'm not surprised, white people with only tenuous connections to some form of native ancestry are usually the most vocal about their supposed tribal ancestry. It was only a matter of time before it became double-plus ungood for native groups to kick out the paleface LARPers.
Luckily DNA testing put a damper on it.

I grew up being told there was injun blood but no, in fact I m like randy marsh I got that Neanderthal DNA.

You homos rapped my ancestors ree
 
I'm not surprised, white people with only tenuous connections to some form of native ancestry are usually the most vocal about their supposed tribal ancestry. It was only a matter of time before it became double-plus ungood for native groups to kick out the paleface LARPers.
In general, white LARPers aren't going to compete anyway. It takes a lot of time and money to make competition-worthy regalia (example: jingle dress, beaded leggins and other matching ornaments, otter skin hair ties, beaded fancy mocs, eagle feathers and fan, etc*) not to mention the time and money needed to go to the pow w ow. Dance competitions are for people with serious ties and commitment to their heritage and community, and deciding that based on blood quantum is some white government bullshit. It's foolish to not just require enrollment in a recognized tribe rather than add blood quantum to it, most white people who claim Native ancestry can't prove it and thus have no legit connection to/membership in a tribe.

1657927293437.png

(* Traditional, fancy, grass, and chicken dance take even more time and money for really outstanding regalia, women dancers get off easy.)
 
The term "Two-Spirit" was coined in the 1990s. It's a modern fad, not an ancient indigenous concept, and there's no reason to believe that such a concept would be shared across all North American indigenous groups (as people often pretend it is). Different societies probably had different terms used to describe homosexuals, masculine women, or feminine men, and such people were likely viewed differently in different societies.

Also, it's ironic that a bunch of young people are accusing elders of colonist thinking. The elders likely suffered a lot more under colonization.

According to the KPS, the now-controversial rules stemmed from a German participant in the powwow who won an event one year, upsetting some participants, and from an elder who once spoke about the need for the jingle dress category to be a women-only event.

The elder has a point. No one wants to see a big ass dude mixed in with the jingle dress dancers.

Also, I thought white people taking part in native cultural events was appropriation? Now not allowing it is colonization? What gives?
 
The term "Two-Spirit" was coined in the 1990s. It's a modern fad, not an ancient indigenous concept, and there's no reason to believe that such a concept would be shared across all North American indigenous groups (as people often pretend it is). Different societies probably had different terms used to describe homosexuals, masculine women, or feminine men, and such people were likely viewed differently in different societies.

Also, it's ironic that a bunch of young people are accusing elders of colonist thinking. The elders likely suffered a lot more under colonization.



The elder has a point. No one wants to see a big ass dude mixed in with the jingle dress dancers.

Also, I thought white people taking part in native cultural events was appropriation? Now not allowing it is colonization? What gives?
The real problem here was not allowing the tranny faggot shit, all that other crap was tacked on to make the initial accusation look worse. Tranny garbage has to be enforced with an iron grip because it has become the keystone to the modern progressive movement, if it is allowed to be questioned anywhere the whole thing will begin to fall apart. Hence the seemingly psychotic hypocrisy of a bunch of white dudes claiming to be oppressed by actually oppressed peoples.
 
Like it was said earlier, the made up two-spirit just so the Chief wouldn't feel gay when he buttfucked members of the tribe...both figuratively and literally.
It's a little more complicated than that.

More like "Well this person clearly isn't a man, so we're going to create a third category with its own special place in the tribe, and that special place in the tribe is going to involve sucking dick."
 
Two-Spirit is just cope so they can pretend it's not gay.
But this entire thing is hilarious, and shows just out of control clown world is in the land of the leafs. Like fuck off, let these people have their own thing.
That's literally what it was. Two-spirits existed because homosexuality didn't make sense to the native world view, so logically a man who liked it up the ass had to be a woman. There were even bisexual guys who stopped being two spirits when they decided the gay lifestyle wasn't for them.
 
"Two spirit"

Imagine being an actual indigenous tribe and getting btfo by a term created so a white oppresser could legitimize his degeneracy.

They tried to grift and used Whitey compassions to get gibs and now they are no longer the most important ones on totem poles, this is why i love accelerationism all these faggots get all their deserve,
 
The term "Two-Spirit" was coined in the 1990s. It's a modern fad, not an ancient indigenous concept, and there's no reason to believe that such a concept would be shared across all North American indigenous groups (as people often pretend it is). Different societies probably had different terms used to describe homosexuals, masculine women, or feminine men, and such people were likely viewed differently in different societies.

Also, it's ironic that a bunch of young people are accusing elders of colonist thinking. The elders likely suffered a lot more under colonization.



The elder has a point. No one wants to see a big ass dude mixed in with the jingle dress dancers.

Also, I thought white people taking part in native cultural events was appropriation? Now not allowing it is colonization? What gives?
For those who would like to know more: https://stoneageherbalist.substack.com/p/the-origin-of-two-spirit-and-the
 
Back