Culture B.C. powwow organizers apologize after identity-based event rules spark outrage - First Nations attacked not by the government this time

Article | Archive




Organizers of a popular powwow in Kamloops, B.C. have issued their “sincerest apologies” after the event rules posted to their Facebook page sparked significant public outrage.

According to a Tuesday post, contestants in the 41st Annual Kamloopa Powwow must be “at least (1/4) Native Blood,” and proof of “tribal identification/status may be required.” The rules also stated that dancers must wear full regalia and “be of the correct gender for that category.”

The rules sparked immediate backlash, with some social media users accusing the Kamloopa Powwow Society (KPS) of enforcing colonial blood quantum, excluding gender diverse and two-spirit people, and upholding transphobia.

“My deepest sympathy to those who have been hurt and harmed in that posting,” said an organizer in a video posted to the group’s Facebook page on Wednesday. “The KPS board has been able to meet to discuss how we’re going to move forward and looking at those rules and making our wrong right.”

The KPS said Thursday it had no comment on the story as it prepared a formal press release.

READ MORE: Second annual convoy to Kamloops, B.C. honours the ‘lost souls’ of residential school
The term “blood quantum” refers to a colonial blood measurement practice used to determine who can obtain government-issued Indigenous status and who can pass it onto to their children. While not specifically referenced in Canadian legislation, the Indian Act lays out such criteria.

In a video viewed more than 154,000 times as of Wednesday, two-spirit Nakota Sioux TikToker Kairyn Potts said the Kamloopa Powwow is “enacting literal colonization tactics.” He further described the gender limitations as “heartbreaking” and a “step backwards for our community.”

“It is actively undoing a lot of the work that myself, and many, many, many other advocates for the two-spirit and Indigenous queer community are putting in so much work, and love and energy into,” he said.

Click to play video: 'Inside Pride: Two-spirited Sask. Indigenous girls inspire others to be themselves'


Inside Pride: Two-spirited Sask. Indigenous girls inspire others to be themselves – Jun 10, 2022
On Twitter, Cree lawyer and activist Tanya Kappo described the “blood quantum” and “correct gender” stipulations as “shameful.”

Stellat’en First Nation actor and model Shannon Baker tweeted, “Kamloopa powwow you should be ashamed of yourself! Blood quantum and being anti LGBTQ2S+ is colonial thinking.”

On Facebook, the Kamloops Pride Society said it has reached out to the Kamloopa Powwow Society to encourage a change in rules that intentionally includes two-spirit, trans and non-binary folks.

“Two-spirit people were historically celebrated and valued in Indigenous culture, and these decisions don’t align with that,” it wrote.

“Many of the voices we are hearing are echoing the sentiments of how these rules and decisions stem from the white colonialism, patriarchy, and systemic issues that still oppress these communities.”

READ MORE: Being Two-Spirit and trans in Canada: How colonization shaped the way we view gender diversity
In its own Facebook post, C&T Tabulating, a business that tabulates and measures powwow outcomes through a point system, said it was withdrawing its services from the Kamloops event.

“We support peoples choices, we support inclusivity and cannot in good conscious put ourselves in a situation where our two spirit youth within our family see us enforcing any of these rules (sic),” it wrote.

It was clear in the event organizers’ Wednesday apology that other dancers and individuals had withdrawn as well.

“I do not know how we’re going to recover from this,” the event organizer said in their video. “We respect your decisions and just know that we are here to relook at how we’ve been operating and how we can move forward in a good way so there is no room for hurt and harm to anyone.”

Click to play video: 'Emotional support workers preparing for Pope Francis’ visit to Maskwacis'

Emotional support workers preparing for Pope Francis’ visit to Maskwacis

According to the KPS, the now-controversial rules stemmed from a German participant in the powwow who won an event one year, upsetting some participants, and from an elder who once spoke about the need for the jingle dress category to be a women-only event.

“Today we’re more open to acknowledge our two-spirited,” the organizer said, “and even … Indigenous communities that it includes First Nations, Métis and the Inuit people.”

She herself was “hurting” as a result of the pain caused by the rules, she added. In its Facebook post, the KPS said the rules posted this week don’t reflect how it has run the last 19 powwows.

The Kamloopa Powwow takes place on Tk’emlúps te Secwe̓pemc territory, but the First Nation does not organize the event. Global News has reached out to its chief, Kúkpi7 Rosanne Casimir, for comment.
 
More like "Well this person clearly isn't a man, so we're going to create a third category with its own special place in the tribe, and that special place in the tribe is going to involve sucking dick."
Such people also weren't allowed to hang around women or children and generally had to keep to themselves, unless there was a reason for them to interact with others.

Pretty much if you were a man that dressed like a woman you were considered a whore and treated as such.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TurdFondler
Canadian natives weren't utterly BTFO like the American ones were, so unfortunately, they still think they're special. They have been grudging for as long as I've been alive, and 16 year old tiktok red niggers pretending to care about their heritage is just the latest in a long line of people who think they're on equal standing with modern governments instead of just the people white men kept around as pets because they felt sorry for them.

I do, however, think it's hilarious that leftists are the biggest modern proponents of things like racial purity laws...
 
Lots of tribes are doing ancestry checks now, the media will spin it as good or bad at random.

There's been 3 or 4 high profile cases of people claiming indigenous heritage to build their careers. Heritage was self reported and being injun let you jump the queue so of course people did it.

The gender thing? Iunno. The backwoods natives are pretty conservative and it's usually urban off reservation natives that push the gender weird bullshit.
 
Lots of tribes are doing ancestry checks now, the media will spin it as good or bad at random.

There's been 3 or 4 high profile cases of people claiming indigenous heritage to build their careers. Heritage was self reported and being injun let you jump the queue so of course people did it.

The gender thing? Iunno. The backwoods natives are pretty conservative and it's usually urban off reservation natives that push the gender weird bullshit.
If native cultures are going to survive what is coming, they will need to become proactively insular and bigoted toward outsiders. For those bleeding hearts who like to depict themselves as speaking truth to power and helping the oppressed, understand that you must defend their freedom to practice values that are completely counter to your own and realize that you would find their society oppressive and abhorrent. This is the price of Otherness.
 
In general, white LARPers aren't going to compete anyway. It takes a lot of time and money to make competition-worthy regalia (example: jingle dress, beaded leggins and other matching ornaments, otter skin hair ties, beaded fancy mocs, eagle feathers and fan, etc*) not to mention the time and money needed to go to the pow w ow. Dance competitions are for people with serious ties and commitment to their heritage and community, and deciding that based on blood quantum is some white government bullshit. It's foolish to not just require enrollment in a recognized tribe rather than add blood quantum to it, most white people who claim Native ancestry can't prove it and thus have no legit connection to/membership in a tribe.

View attachment 3495606
(* Traditional, fancy, grass, and chicken dance take even more time and money for really outstanding regalia, women dancers get off easy.)

I know a college in America was able to pull it off.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: naaaaiiiiillllll!!!
There's been 3 or 4 high profile cases of people claiming indigenous heritage to build their careers. Heritage was self reported and being injun let you jump the queue so of course people did it.
Unsurprisingly, academia and activism are rife with it, and the more obnoxious someone - really, some woman, they're mostly women - was with their visible tribalism, the more likely they were faking. There were a bunch in 2019, I think, followed by one actual native estimating around 1 in 4 people in academia claiming native ancestry were LARPers.

Then you have Australia, where I believe by law you're not allowed to challenge someone if they claim aboriginal blood. Something to do with records being destroyed in the 60s - there was an article posted here about students abusing the system to save money on education.

Like we needed any more evidence that self-id being the only requirement to enter a protected class was a terrible, terrible idea...
 
Keeping out troons and larpers, and similarly mentally ill people, is surely a good thing, but what is good is instead a moral outrage to professional offence taking wokist.
 
Troons don't belong in jingle competitions. It's a women's dance. Just like women don't compete in grass dance. "Two spirits" need to shut the fuck up already.

But also note to self, don't go to Kamloops to dance jingle.

It's sad that they will ruin traditional gendered dances so some troon can rub it in the faces of the gender they are LARPing. With the blood requirements axed too it will be a lot of white troons who claim that their great great grandmother was a Cherokee princess or something.
 
It's sad that they will ruin traditional gendered dances so some troon can rub it in the faces of the gender they are LARPing. With the blood requirements axed too it will be a lot of white troons who claim that their great great grandmother was a Cherokee princess or something.
1657985496839.jpeg
Again, CWC was ahead of his time…
 
They should have just told them to fuck off. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that requirement.

The BC government, along with any NGO's or corporate sponsor's bankrolling them, likely threatened to cut them off if knees aren't immediately bent. They could have also gotten similar threats from their bank or any services they use.

In a world where ESG scores are controlling corporate behavior and who they can work with, you really need to be independent from basically everything to tell the they/them's to fuck off.
 
The BC government, along with any NGO's or corporate sponsor's bankrolling them, likely threatened to cut them off if knees aren't immediately bent. They could have also gotten similar threats from their bank or any services they use.
When the colonists support tribal independence but also condemn it because there are more "oppressed minorities" than them. This is like the land acknowledgements I hear at the beginning of some events; pure lip service that makes event organisers and attendees feel good but ultimately do nothing.
 
Back