Blood Borne is a pay to win game
Hear me out alright? This is gonna be fucking retarded. But I've been thinking about it for awhile. Just buckle up.
Game play loops in other souls like is explore -> Optimize -> Bossfight. Which in terms of dark souls 1 was run around the map, find a shortcut, find the boss, and kill the boss. Bloodborne introduces a simple "grind" mechanic into this with blood vials and bullets, two things that are naturally going to be consumed through basic progress.
This fact is part A. There exist a grind mechanic that exists to disrupt the standard loop. The currency is echoes, which manifests as vials and bullets. For most people, they will naturally consume these, run out, and have to farm them. If you don't look up where to farm, for example if you try to farm vial drops and not souls, this takes up a shocking amount of time.
Part B is how those vials are treated. You are not told how many vials or bullets you have in stash, meaning you have no way of knowing when you are going to be thrown back into the grind. You can check at the echo store of course but only there. As far as I'm aware, no other resource works like this. This is a textbook case of
You are expected to spend echoes. You are expected to grind, When you get a new weapon, it goes to the shop where now you have to chose between a trick weapon, or 20 vials. Vial prices regularly increase throughout the game, meaning that unless you know what to anticipate and grind beforehand, there will be a continuous grinding process. Something to always push your towards ponying up the dough to get back to the incredible combat and cool cities and ugly things that yell at you.
So we have a basic comparison between a game say, making you wait, grind, spend resources, etcetera to do something that is otherwise skill based. The only thing stopping this from being, inexcusably ptw is the fact you can't buy souls
...
or can you?
The CUMPFFH or whatever dungeon will give you hundreds of thousands of souls with 0 effort. This is only available if you pay for playstation plus, and I secretly believe this little trick is the first thing many "Whales" (people who disagree with me) do in order to lessen the grind.
Thank you for listening to my ted talk.