The quota system is the only thing protecting Canadian farmers from being swallowed up by American milk which would put the majority of Canadian diary farmers out of business.
I was going to ask you why you believe that Canadian farms wouldn't be able to compete with the price of American dairy. However, after the following post, I assume your argument that it is an issue of scale?
Everybody hates factory farms if they put more restrictions on there ability to stupidly make the margins so thin for family farmers who treat there animals humanely and dont flood the market lowering the price of there product that will create a lot more high value careers that can support middle class families on both sides of the border,
I agree with this, but I don't understand why US dairy would be so cheap that it would put farmers out of business, considering the cost of transportation. If that was the case, then make the already existing tariff on foreign dairy higher.
It seems like quotas are just an artificial market that doesnt need to exist, that has become a billions of dollars asset for milk cartels. And, if there were no quota system, the milk that's getting dumped would be on the Canadian market pushing prices down. Again, I dont know anything about dairy, but when tobacco was still in full swing it was not unusual for farmers to have bales they were unable to sell due to quota and it would be degrading in storage (or sold on the grey market).
To be clear, Im not in favor of across the board free trade with any other country. I'm in favor of international protectionism and decreasing inter-provincial trade barriers. I'm in favor of developing domestic industry and decreasing our reliance on all foreign products. Nobody needs avocado toast, we arent going to die without it. I don't care if I have to buy greenhouse tomatoes for $0.50 more in the winter, rather than Chilean tomatoes.
If China can go from oxen plows to mag-lev trains, in my lifetime, Canada can at least bring our aerospace, tech, and heavy industry back to levels that existed in living memory. Why do we need to sell our lumber to anyone, when it could be used to build homes here? Theres no reason I can think of that doesn't have something to do with lines on a graph going up, which doesnt seem to benefit me, or any of my neighbors.
Maybe I've got this all wrong, I'm just a dumb hick, not some finance jew, but I'm old enough to remember when we exported CANDU reactors all over the world, and I heard enough about AVRO. We have enough arable land to feed everyone here. I'm old enough to remember when Canada was on the leading edge of telecommunications. There's no reason we can't create products that the rest of the world needs to buy. We have the resources, and hopefully, we haven't lost the capability.